What constitutes a ‘code of conduct’?
The term ‘code of conduct’ is hereby used to refer to documents that, albeit different in length and form, contain at their core lists of rules and responsibilities that armed groups' hierarchies set out for their members. These rules aim to regulate both the members' internal behaviour and their relations outside the group. As one author in this edition of the Review remarks, rules contained in a code of conduct may repeat existing obligations of international humanitarian law (IHL), fall short of it, or extend beyond it.Footnote 9 Codes of conduct rarely specify whether a particular rule is derived from a certain branch of law – such as IHL or human rights law – or whether they stem from other ethical or social norms. The content of these documents demonstrates the acceptance of the included norms, rather than their concrete foundations in law.
Codes of conduct are not the only documents that include behavioural norms adopted by armed groups: agreements between parties to a non-international armed conflict (NIAC), unilateral declarations, and statements are examples of other such documents. The present collection, however, focuses on codes of conduct in order to shed light on this relatively little explored category of documents.Footnote 10
The legal significance of codes of conduct
The choice of an armed group to adopt a code of conduct including rules of IHL does not affect the applicability of IHL to an armed group involved in an NIAC. As a party to the conflict, the said group will be bound by the relevant rules of NIAC (Common Article 3 to the Geneva Conventions, customary IHL, and Additional Protocol II, where applicable), regardless of the content of its own code of conduct.
Furthermore, the adoption of codes of conduct should not be assumed to guarantee compliance with IHL by armed groups. As previously discussed, such an adoption presents one way for armed groups to indicate their willingness to be bound by a norm in an international legal environment that does not allow them to sign or ratify treaties.
While the practice of organized armed groups may contain evidence of the acceptance of certain rules in NIAC, the ICRC Customary Law Study has considered the legal significance of such practice to be unclear.Footnote 11 It has been argued that the practice of armed groups (through their acts or omissions) should also be considered as contributing to the formation of customary rules on NIAC.Footnote 12 At present, it is uncertain to what extent this role would be accepted by states or international courts and tribunals.
Codes of conduct as tools for respecting the law
The potential of codes of conduct to increase respect for the law cannot be overlooked. As described in the ICRC Study, ‘codes of conduct that are consistent with IHL provide a concrete mechanism for persons to respect the law’.Footnote 13 First, codes of conduct have the advantage of being short and simple texts. If integrated properly, IHL rules can be stated in a way that is easy to understand and to be followed by members of the armed group. Complex legal texts are unlikely to capture the attention of fighters.
Second, discussions on, and the drafting of, codes of conduct may cause groups to reflect on IHL and on their behaviour in comparison to it. In some cases, the inclusion of norms of IHL in codes of conduct may mean that the leadership of an armed group expresses its willingness to recognize IHL as the applicable law. Even when an armed group chooses to do so purely for reasons of propaganda, the passing of a code of conduct can represent a first step towards the group's improved ‘ownership’ of rules originally created by states, and towards ensuring respect for the mentioned provisions of IHL.Footnote 14
Acceptance of a code of conduct containing IHL norms may lead to further preventative steps within the group, such as the dissemination of the code itself or the instruction and training of the members in its rules. It is to be hoped that a better overall knowledge of the rules of IHL will induce better compliance with IHL.
Finally, the potential of these instruments lies in the reality that armed actors who commit violations in NIACs are not acting completely autonomously. They are usually part of a hierarchical structure, and their actions depend, at least in part, on orders and rules passed on by the hierarchy. As an expression of such rules, codes of conduct can be a powerful tool for compliance. In many instances, the perceived deterrent value of punishment for violations of rules stipulated by the group itself may be greater than the threat of international prosecution for violations of IHL.
Codes of conduct as tools for humanitarian actors
External actors such as humanitarian workers and academics can benefit from studying the adoption of codes of conduct by armed groups. These documents can provide an entry point for substantive dialogue on the law, and a basis for engaging armed groups in addressing violations.Footnote 15 Additionally, the content of these documents can reveal the views of armed groups on humanitarian standards. As will be discussed later in this issue with regard to, for example, rules on the treatment of prisoners, the practice of armed groups as reflected in their codes and agreements with other parties can highlight their equivalence to or disparity with IHL.Footnote 16 The rules chosen to be included and the discussions surrounding the adoption of these documents can provide further insight into the reasons why armed groups decide to respect, or not, certain rules.Footnote 17
CODES OF CONDUCT
Workers' and Peasants' Red Army / People's Liberation Army (PLA) – China
The PLA was first formed in 1927 as the Red Army. With the founding of the People's Republic of China in 1949, the PLA became the national armed forces.
The ‘Three Main Rules of Discipline and the Eight Points for Attention’ were drawn up by Mao Zedong and others during the Second Revolutionary Civil War (1927–37). Although at times different units had varying versions, in 1947 a standard version was issued and is now the principal set of disciplinary regulations and basic code of conduct for every member of the PLA.
Three Main Rules of Discipline:
1. Obey orders in all your actions.
2. Do not take a single needle or piece of thread from the masses.
3. Turn in everything captured.
Eight Points for Attention:
1. Speak politely.
2. Pay fairly for what you buy.
3. Return everything you borrow.
4. Pay for anything you damage.
5. Do not hit or swear at people.
6. Do not damage crops.
7. Do not take liberties with women.
8. Do not maltreat captives.
In 1928, four policies for the lenient treatment of captives were also laid down. They were:
1. Do not hit, swear at, kill, or maltreat captives.
2. Do not search captives' pockets.
3. Give medical treatment to wounded captives.
4. Let captives stay or set them free at their own will.
These rules were later developed into Five Policies for Lenient Treatment of Captives:
1. Do not kill or injure captives.
2. Do not hit, swear at, maltreat, or insult captives.
3. Do not confiscate the private property of captives.
4. Give medical treatment to sick and wounded captives.
5. Set the captives free.
In 1937, three main principles for political work were put forward; among them was a mandate to give lenient treatment to captives. In October 1947, Mao Zedong said in the Manifesto of the CPLA that ‘our army will not kill nor insult any of the Guomingdang soldiers and officers who have laid down their arms. We will collect those who are willing to stay and repatriate those who are willing to leave’.Footnote 18
New People's Army (NPA) – Philippines
The New People's Army was formed in 1969. Their ‘Basic Rules’ were issued in the same year and also include the ‘Three Rules and Eight Principles’, following the example of the Chinese PLA.Footnote 19
PRINCIPLE IV – Discipline
Point 1. The discipline of all officers and men of the New People's Army is a conscious discipline guided by Marxism-Leninism-Mao Zedong Thought, the Communist Party of the Philippines and the organizational principle of democratic centralism. The Party committees in the army shall see to it that the line, policies and decisions of the Party are implemented by the military command at all levels.
Point 2. The New People's Army adheres to the following discipline:
a. An individual is subordinate to the whole army;
b. The minority is subordinate to the majority;
c. The lower level is subordinate to the higher level;
d. All members are subordinate to the Military Commission and the Central Committee.
Point 3. All officers and men are prohibited from committing the slightest damage against the interest of the masses and they are always subject to the Three Main Rules of Discipline and the Eight Points of Attention of Comrade Mao Zedong so as to always advance their revolutionary integrity.
A. The Three Main Rules of Discipline are:
1) Obey orders in all actions.
2) Do not take even a single needle or thread from the masses.
3) Turn over everything confiscated to the proper body.
B. The Eight Points of Attention are:
1) Be polite in speech.
2) Pay all purchases with the appropriate amount.
3) Return everything borrowed.
4) Compensate all damages.
5) Do not hurt or curse anybody.
6) Do not destroy the people's crops.
7) Do not take liberties with women.
8) Do not be cruel to captives.
Point 4. All officers are strictly prohibited from using bourgeois and feudal ways in dealing with the fighters and the masses.
Point 5. All officers and men are strictly prohibited from gambling and drunkenness.
Point 6. The Party committee in the army in the appropriate level or the military court that can be created by it shall conduct the trial and shall decide on the cases filed against officers and men at the level where the error or crime was committed. The following penalties shall be meted out based on the gravity of the crime:
a. Strong warning
b. Strong warning and transfer to another area of work
c. Demotion
d. Suspension
e. Expulsion
f. Expulsion and death
Point 7. In all types of penalties, except for expulsion, and expulsion and death, the erring individual or group shall be re-educated for a definite period of time and shall also apologize to the aggrieved party in public.
Point 8. The most severe punishment of expulsion and death shall be imposed on those proven to have committed treachery, capitulation, abandonment of post, espionage, sabotage, mutiny, incitement to rebellion, murder, theft, rape, arson and severe malversation of people's funds.
Point 9. All cases shall be thoroughly investigated and all accused shall be given a just trial.
National Liberation Army (ELN) – Colombia
The National Liberation Army (Ejército de Liberación Nacional, ELN) came into existence in 1964 and is still active in Colombia. The exact date of this code of conduct is unknown.
Code of warFootnote 20
…
Respect for the civilian population
Civilians shall not be used as human shields during combat.
When the enemy takes civilians hostage in its movements, efforts shall be made to avoid harming them during attacks on enemy forces.
Military operations shall be carried out against enemy forces in such a way as to avoid indiscriminate attacks.
Efforts shall be made to avoid damage to civilian property and installations resulting from military operations and to make reparations where possible.
The civilian population shall be informed of the location of mined areas.
No acts shall be undertaken with the sole purpose of spreading terror among the population.
There shall be no forced displacement of the civilian population from combat zones.
Those under the age of 15 shall not be recruited into the permanent military force. They may be involved in revolutionary activities other than participation in hostilities.
Individuals who join paramilitary groups and their possessions shall cease to be seen as civilians and civilian property.
The organization holds certain persons captive for political reasons, with the aim of making their demands known. Such persons shall be treated with due respect and their families shall be informed of their situation.
Limits on the methods and means of warfare
When carrying out acts of sabotage, our forces shall not target installations more useful to the community than the enemy.
Acts of sabotage shall, as far as possible, avoid causing environmental damage.
Religious sites, cultural objects, and installations containing dangerous forces such as dams or nuclear material shall not be attacked.
Poisonous gases shall not be used and water supplies shall not be poisoned.
In combat zones, vehicles and facilities bearing the Red Cross emblem shall be respected. It is forbidden for our forces to use this emblem to mislead the enemy.
Our commanders shall prevent looting and pillaging once the enemy surrenders its position. They shall arrange for the retrieval of objects needed by our forces.
Dignified treatment of prisoners
It is prohibited to kill or injure an adversary who has surrendered or is hors de combat.
Prisoners of war shall be treated humanely and receive medical assistance. Their belongings shall be confiscated.
Information about the rank and name of those captured shall be made public.
Efforts shall be made to hand prisoners over to the Red Cross after a brief period of captivity.
Neither mercenaries nor spies shall be granted the protection guaranteed to prisoners of war. They shall be treated humanely.
Executions
The death penalty shall be applied to those responsible for war crimes.
Those accused of war crimes shall be guaranteed due process.
Minors, pregnant women, and mothers with young children shall not be sentenced to death.
Executions shall be carried out in such a way as to avoid unnecessary suffering.
Efforts shall be made to inform family members of the location of the remains.
War taxes
To fund the war of liberation and help to establish popular power, the ELN imposes war taxes and social taxes, the latter used to promote development in the areas under its influence.
These taxes and other demands made shall be focused on transnational companies with local monopolies and individuals who have made themselves rich through corruption and violating the people's interests. They shall also be imposed on those who collaborate unconditionally with the armed forces of the government and paramilitary forces.
Capital invested in development in areas under guerrilla influence shall be respected and these areas shall be subject to a contribution stipulated by common agreement.
Through its governing bodies the ELN takes responsibility for the rational, collective use of the resources generated from the collection of these taxes, which shall be centralized under the authority of the National Directorate.
In order to pressurize them into paying these taxes and meeting other demands, the ELN shall temporarily hold captive individuals representing the aforementioned sectors. The latter shall be immediately released once the amount demanded by the ELN has been paid.
Captives shall be treated humanely and their families kept informed of their situation.
The ELN shall try to avoid holding pregnant women, minors, elderly people, and those in delicate health in captivity.
As part of its policy of categorically disassociating itself from the drug-trafficking mafia, the ELN shall not impose any kind of taxes or demands on this sector for their activities. The ELN shall not permit the growing of crops, creation of laboratories, or building of landing strips related to this sector in the areas under its control. The trade in drugs shall also be banned.
Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, People's Army (FARC-EP) and ELN – ColombiaFootnote 21
The message below containing rules of conduct was signed and sent to their militants by the FARC Secretary of Central Staff and by the ELN Central Command in 2009.
Rules of conduct with the masses
In the belief that we should embody new men and women, setting a revolutionary example to our people while behaving in an unassuming way, in order to rally them to our cause, the commanders of the Simon Bolivar Guerilla Coordinating Board [Coordinadora Guerrillera Simón Bolívar, CGSB], gathered at its first ‘Jacobo Arenas’ summit, call upon Bolivarian combatants to abide by the following rules of conduct with the masses.
1. Our daily behaviour, and the purpose underlying our activities, should be borne in the people's interests.
2. We should respect the political, philosophical, and religious ideas and attitudes of the population, and in particular the culture and autonomy of indigenous communities and other ethnic minorities.
3. We should not prevent people from exercising their right to vote, nor force people to vote.
4. The safety of working people and their homes and property should be taken into account when planning and executing political and military activities, and in our daily movements.
5. We should respect the various measures taken by collaborators to keep their links to us secret.
6. Care should be taken to maintain internal discipline when working with the masses, in order to protect innocent people and those friendly to our cause, ensuring that our mistakes or failures do not make them a target of terrorism and hatred at the hands of the official army and its paramilitary forces.
7. Wherever and whenever the masses are under attack from the official army and its paramilitary forces, subjected to bombardment and the destruction of their property, we must actively denounce and counter these terrorist activities so that the people feel supported by us.
8. Murder and any kind of proven outrages committed against the population should be seen as a crime.
9. We should not impose on the masses. We should try to ensure that they see our weapons as their own.
10. Accusations made by communities about attacks by combatants and other individuals should be investigated exhaustively with input from the community.
11. Leaders and combatants should study and comply with the rules of international humanitarian law that are applicable to our revolutionary war.
12. If it should prove necessary to detain a militant or supporter of a sister organization for alleged or proven wrongdoing, the case and, if possible, the individual should be handed over to the said organization.
13. Our founding principle in all circumstances is respect for the right to life.
14. Leaders and combatants should bear in mind that executions may only be carried out for very serious crimes committed by enemies of the people and with the express authorization in each case of each organization's senior governing body. In all such cases, evidence must be examined and decisions taken collectively. The leadership must produce a written record setting out the evidence.
15. Alcoholism, drug addiction, theft, and dishonesty are counterrevolutionary vices that damage people's trust in us.
16. We must avoid abusing people's trust and generosity. We must not demand goods and property for our personal gain.
National Redemption Army (NRA) – Uganda
The National Redemption Army was founded in 1981 and became the national armed forces of Uganda in 1986.
The National Resistance Army Code of ConductFootnote 22
[abridged]
A. Dealing with the Public
1. Never abuse, insult, shout at or beat any member of the public.
2. Never take anything in the form of money or property from any members of the public, not even somebody's sweet bananas or sugar-cane on the grounds that it's mere sugar-cane, without paying for the same.
3. Pay promptly for anything you take and in cash.
4. Never kill any member of the public or any captured prisoners, as the guns should only be reserved for armed enemies or opponents.
5. Return anything you borrow from the public.
6. Offer help to the members of the public who may be in the territory of your unit.
7. Offer medical treatment to the members of the public who may be in the territory of your unit.
8. Never develop illegitimate relations with any woman because there are no women as such waiting for passing soldiers yet many women are wives, or daughters of somebody somewhere. Any illegitimate relationship is bound to harm our good relations with the public.
9. There should be no consumption of alcohol until the end of the war. Drunken soldiers are bound to misuse the guns which are given to them for the defence of the people.
B. Relationships among the Soldiers
1. The lower echelons of the army must obey the higher ones and the higher echelons must respect the lower ones.
2. In decision making, we should use a method of democratic centralism where there is democratic participation as well as central control.
3. Every officer, cadre or militant must strive to master military science in order to gain more capability so that we are in a position to defend the people more efficiently.
4. The following tendencies can be injurious to the cohesion of the army and are prohibited:
a) Quest for cheap popularity: on the part of officers or cadres by tolerating of wrongs in order to be popular with soldiers.
b) Liberalism: which entails weak leadership and tolerating of wrongs and mistakes. In case of liberalism, the person in authority knows what is right and what is wrong, but due to weak leadership, he does not stand firmly on the side of right.
c) Intrigue and double talk: this can cause artificial confusion even when there is no objective basis for confusion.
5. The following methods should be used in correcting mistakes within the army:
a) Open criticism of mistakes instead of subterranean grumbling which is favoured by reactionaries.
b) The holding of regular meetings at which all complaints are heard and settled.
c) A distinction should always be made between errors due to indiscipline, corruption or subversion and treatment of each should be different.
6. All commanders should ensure that all soldiers, depending on particular circumstances, should at any one particular time either be fighting, studying military science or undertaking self-improvement in academic work, taking part in recreational activities, or resting. There should be no idleness whatsoever which breeds mischief.
7. Political education should be mandatory every day so that the cadres and militants can understand the reasons for the war as well as the dynamics of the world we live in. ‘Conscious discipline is better than mechanical discipline’.
8. Formation of cliques in the army is not allowed, at the same time the principle of compartmentalization should be strictly adhered to and understood. We should adhere to the principle of the ‘need to know’ and avoid the mistake of soliciting information for its own sake. The strategy of the NRA and the regular tactics should be known to all officers, cadres, and combatants. But operational matters should be known to those who need to know.
9.
(i) There shall be a High Command consisting of the Commander-in-Chief, who shall be Chairman, and eight other members to be appointed by the Commander-in-Chief.
(ii) All members of the High Command shall be members of the Army Council.
(iii) The High Command shall perform such functions as may be conferred upon it by any law in force in Uganda; or as the President may direct.
10.
(i) There shall be a General Court-Martial, which shall be the supreme trial organ under this Code.
(ii) This General Court-Martial shall consist of:
a) a Chairman;
b) two senior officers;
c) two junior officers;
d) one Political Commissar; and
e) one non-commissioned officer.
11.
(i) There shall be a Unit Disciplinary Committee for each Army Unit which shall consist of:
a) the Second in Command who shall be the Chairman;
b) the Administration Officer of the Unit;
c) the Political Commissar of the Unit;
d) the Regimental Sergeant-Major or Company Sergeant-Major of the Unit;
e) two junior officers;
f) one private.
(ii) The Unit Disciplinary Committee shall have powers to try all combatants below the rank of Provisional Junior Officer II for all offences except the following:
a) murder;
b) manslaughter;
c) robbery;
d) rape;
e) treason;
f) terrorism;
g) disobedience of lawful orders resulting in loss of life.
(iii) A Unit Disciplinary Committee may refer any case in which its opinion is of a particularly complex nature to the General Court-Martial.
Revolutionary United Front (RUF) – Sierra Leone
The RUF was involved in the conflict in Sierra Leone from 1991 until 2002. The ‘Eight Codes of Conduct’ govern the RUF fighters' interactions with civilians.
The Codes provided in part:
- To speak politely to masses.
- To pay fairly for all [that] you buy.
- To return everything that you borrow.
- To pay for everything that you demand or damage.
- Do not damage crops.
- Do not take liberty from women.
- Do not ill-treat captives.
- Do not hate or swear [sic] people.Footnote 23
National Transition Council (NTC) – Libya
The National Transition Council was formed in February 2011, with the National Liberation Army as their military arm. At the time of writing, the NTC is in the process of forming a government, and the National Liberation Army is expected to become the national armed forces. The documents below are a set of guidelines issued by the NTC.Footnote 24
Rules on the treatment of detainees
Detainees must receive humane treatment AT ALL TIMES, from the moment of capture. DO respect detainees and protect them from harm
Rules on targeting and the use of violence
- ONLY target Qadhafi forces and others using force against you. Permissible targets include fighters, buildings, facilities and means of transportation being used or could be used for a military purpose.
- DO NOT allow persons who are less than 18 years of age to fight, even if they have volunteered to do so.
- AVOID as far as possible any effect on civilians of an attack against Qadhafi forces.
- DO NOT target fighters who are surrendering or are no longer fighting.
- DO NOT target civilians or places where there are only civilians.
- DO NOT target medical personnel, facilities, transports or equipment. These may be searched if you need to verify they are genuine, but REMEMBER that medical personnel are allowed by law to carry small arms to protect their patients.
- DO NOT target religious personnel.
- DO NOT target UN/ICRC/Red Crescent personnel or facilities.
- DO NOT harm cultural, educational and religious buildings and historic sites unless Qadhafi forces are using them for hostile purposes, and such harm is absolutely necessary.
- ONLY use the Red Crescent symbol to indicate medical personnel, facilities and transport and under direction of the competent authorities.
REMEMBER!
FIGHT ONLY FIGHTERS.
ATTACK ONLY MILITARY
TARGETS. SPARE CIVILIANS.
Protections of detainees
Summary of requirements to be observed by the detaining authority
REMEMBER!
THE PURPOSE OF DETENTION IS NOT TO PUNISH BUT TO PREVENT FROM FIGHTING
Source – adapted from: http://ehl.redcross.org/curriculum/module5/downloads/M5_Exp5C_re1.pdf
Procedure in the case of suspected breaches of the rules set out in these guidelines
Anyone who wishes to complain about a suspected violation of these rules, and in particular the mistreatment of detainees or the use of fighters who are less than 18 years of age, should be told the name and contact details of the person who has been designated to deal with complaints.
The complaints will be made in confidence. The person providing the information will be informed before being called as a witness.
Complaints must be investigated promptly, thoroughly, and in an impartial manner by an independent body.
