No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The Culture of Islam: Changing Aspects of Contemporary Muslim Life explores the shifting social, political, and cultural concepts of a contemporary North African Muslim community, extrapolating it to the rest of the Arab/Islamic world. Rosen uses for the most part his ethnographic experience, which goes back more than three decades in the Middle Atlas town of Sefrou as well as in other Moroccan environments. Stuck in his old paradigm of the “negotiating situated individual,” he reshelves his data, remaps it to include contemporary themes, and restructures “his” Moroccan society, with Sefrou still as its microcosm.
The Culture of Islam: Changing Aspects of Contemporary Muslim Life explores the shifting social, political, and cultural concepts of a contemporary North African Muslim community, extrapolating it to the rest of the Arab/Islamic world. Rosen uses for the most part his ethnographic experience, which goes back more than three decades in the Middle Atlas town of Sefrou as well as in other Moroccan environments. Stuck in his old paradigm of the “negotiating situated individual,” he reshelves his data, remaps it to include contemporary themes, and restructures “his” Moroccan society, with Sefrou still as its microcosm.
In the aftermath of 11 September 2001, Rosen's book adds to the intensive literature that tries to make sense not only of the character of Muslim societies but also of the nature of relationships that involve Muslims. Although the book was not written with the terrorists' attacks in mind, Rosen attempts to provide some answers to Western readers about the Muslim world, using “his Morocco” as an example of the general Arab Islamic context. In fact, in a 24 February 2003 interview with Princeton Weekly Bulletin, Rosen confirmed that since 11 September, the United States has not been playing the negotiating game of Arabs/Muslims. While in Sefrou people negotiate their relationship in the market, politics, culture, family, and law, the United States does not engage itself in this bargaining of or for ideas. Instead, it looks to the Arabs as a de-localized and de-centered superpower that can “do anything to anybody.” For Rosen, the “constant focus, then, is on the situations, the contexts in which persons interact with others and on the particular ways they have played out their possibilities to create their own social situatedness…. In a sense, then, what is at work is a ‘great game,’ a constant series of moves aimed at securing oneself in an uncertain world.” (xii).
After three decades, Rosen is still faithful to his doctrine of “connections and negotiations,” where individuals, depending on their skills, engage in striking deals, bargaining, and networking. Once again, the group is put aside in the margin of Rosen's “world order.” In this world, Moroccans as individuals still “bargain” and “negotiate” their relationships. Unlike what Gellner, Hart, and others have maintained, the group—that is, the lineage, the tribe, the neighborhood, and, if we may say, the state—are there only in case the individual needs help. The dyadic characteristic of social relations, the basis of Bargaining for Reality, is still central not only to Sefrouis but also to all Moroccans and the Arab world. The negotiation is everywhere: it is in the market, religion, law, economics, politics, family—above all, in “culture.” Simply put, in Rosen's epistemological construction of “Arab/Muslim societies,” the foundation of these societies is the individual caught in a web of intermittently shifting relationships.
Throughout the three sections and the ten chapters of the book, Rosen crosscuts themes such as memory, sainthood, faith, doubt, corruption, tribalism, Salman Rushdie's challenge to Islam, and the developing forms of Islam in European communities. Part 1, “Ambivalence Culture,” revisits the concept of ambivalence previously discussed in Bargaining for Reality and other works on the Jews of Morocco. For Rosen, whether it is in gender, political authority, or saintly legitimacy, there is an ambivalent feeling toward power seen in many cultural forms in the Arab/Islamic world, and through which Westerners can make sense of many contradictory reactions toward power as experienced in the daily lives of Muslims.
Part 2, “Memory Worlds, Plausible Worlds,” provides some ethnographic stories about peoples' memories of past events. The three chapters of this part—“Contesting Memory,” “Memory in Morocco,” and “Have the Arabs Changed Their Minds?”—raise some of the central themes of this book. The part begins with a chapter on memory in which Rosen looks at whether memory in Morocco is continuously reconstructed. Rosen uses an example of a Moroccan city whose inhabitants came to realize that their traditionally visited Muslim saint might be Jewish. In this context, Rosen discusses how memory alters over the decades. Furthermore, faithful to his theory of the situated person who adapts himself to different webs of relationships, Rosen poses a central question in his book about “whether cultural ideas have so changed in the past generations that the very terms by which the same people capture past events now are different from the way they did so when [he] first encountered them several decades ago” (p. xiv). One of the most important theoretical features of this work is this comparative anthropological diagnosis of a Moroccan society over the years. Yet despite the large number of examples and details, Rosen's analysis sometimes fails to be comprehensive and convincing. His obsession with individual capacity continues to affect the analytical prisms through which he reconstructs Arab/Islamic society.
Consistent with his theory, Rosen also concludes that his observation of Moroccan society points to “an open ended-approach” to social, political, and cultural concepts. This makes it very difficult for any individual to promote his or her policies or the agenda of his or her group. Of course, this is consistent with Rosen's “system,” where the individual, as the molecular unit from which society is built, is in a continuous process of negotiating his space and social networks. For these reasons, Rosen makes it clear that, as cultural anthropologists, we should be conservative in our analyses because the “world is more disorderly than our theories about it.” In other words, Rosen's “cultural anthropological conservatism” is about interpretive theory. What we can do in this disorderly Arab/Islamic world is use the symbols and signs it provides and reconstruct our own anthropological view without looking at the historical, ideological, and economic factors that influence Muslims' decisions.
Part 3, “Shifting Concepts, Discerning Change,” adds something new to Rosen's description of the changing Arab/Islamic cultural and religious landscapes. Although some sections of this part reminds us of Rosen's The Anthropology of Justice: Law as Culture in Islamic Society, also based on Sefrou, this chapter takes us outside Morocco's border to discuss the challenges that Muslim minorities in Europe as well as in the United States, and Salman Rushdie's Satanic Verses, pose to Muslims/Arabs.
It remains to be said that Rosen is an excellent writer. The book's synthetic power resides in its ability to bring together three decades of ethnographic experience. Its clear and detailed style makes it an enjoyable read. Rosen gets credit for raising some of the questions at the heart of Muslim societies. Today, the Arab/Muslim world is undergoing a social, political, and economic paralysis. Rosen has raised some of the central issues in this dilemma where Muslims are struggling to find the convenient road to a better modernity. For this reason, I strongly recommend this book to audiences within and outside academe.