Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:16:13.333Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Regimes of wettability-dependent and wettability-independent bouncing of a drop on a solid surface

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2020

Praveen K. Sharma
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Telangana 502285, India
Harish N. Dixit*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Telangana 502285, India
*
†Email address for correspondence: hdixit@mae.iith.ac.in

Abstract

Tiny drops of millimetre size are known to bounce on a solid surface if the surface is superhydrophobic. Recent experiments show that bouncing can occur even on hydrophilic surfaces under conditions where the drop is supported on a thin cushion of gas preventing it from making contact with the surface. We present a detailed insight into this observation by simulating bouncing dynamics of a drop on a flat solid surface using axisymmetric direct numerical simulations. The dynamics of drop motion is governed by three important dimensionless parameters, namely, Reynolds number, $Re$, Weber number, $We$, and capillary number, $Ca_g$. We generate a phase diagram in the $We\text {--}Re$ plane separating the wettability-independent (non-contact bouncing) and wettability-dependent (contact bouncing) regions. We show that $We=2.14$ is the optimum value of Weber number which can support a gas cushion for the widest range of Reynolds numbers. The phase diagram is further divided into five sub-regions based on the shape of the drop and the gas film beneath it. The simulations can reproduce experimentally reported gas films of ${\sim }1\ \mathrm {\mu }\textrm {m}$ with excellent agreement spatially and temporally. Simulations also reproduce well-known scaling laws for a variety of parameters characterising the gas film. New scaling laws for the radial extent of the gas film as well as time taken for impact are derived. For higher Weber and Reynolds numbers, a bouncing drop captures a gas bubble inside it consistent with simple experiments carried out for water drops bouncing on superhydrophobic surfaces.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic view of different types of drop–solid interaction found in the simulations: $(a)$ drop bounces from the surface without making contact with the solid supported on a thin and contiguous cushion of air; $(b)$ drop makes contact at its outer periphery; $(c)$ drop makes contact near the axis of symmetry.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Typical view of the adaptive quadtree grid employed in the simulations showing a high density of grids at the droplet interface (shown in red). The axis of symmetry is on the right side of the image.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Comparison of drop shapes during the bouncing process obtained from simulations with the images reported by de Ruiter et al. (2015c) for times 0, 2.3, 4, 7.5 and 9 ms. The yellow curves are the shapes obtained from the axisymmetric simulations. Dimensional parameters employed are identical to those in de Ruiter et al. (2015c): $R_0=1.03\ \textrm {mm}$, $H_0=3.61\ \textrm {mm}$, $\rho _l=996.9\ \textrm {kg}\,\textrm {m}^{-3}$, $\rho _g=1.225\ \textrm {kg}\,\textrm {m}^{-3}$, $\mu _l=0.001\ \textrm {Pa}\,\textrm {s}$, $\mu _g=1.81 \times 10^{-5}\ \textrm {Pa}\,\textrm {s}$, $\sigma =0.0646\ \textrm {N}\,\textrm {m}$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Time evolution of drop–gas interface profiles near the solid surface during its spreading phase obtained from simulations (dashed curves) overlaid on experimental profiles of de Ruiter et al. (2015a) for the following cases: $(a)$$We=0.83, Re = 233$, $(b)$$We=1.82, Re = 345$, $(c)$$We=3.19, Re = 457$. All other parameters are identical to those given in de Ruiter et al. (2015a). The finest grid size at the drop-gas interface is $\varDelta /R_0=1.77\times 10^{-3}$ in these simulation.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Same as figure 4 but with one higher level of refinement. The finest grid size at the drop-gas interface is $\varDelta /R_0 = 8.85\times 10^{-4}$. All other parameters remain unaltered. The simulation with resolution $\varDelta /R_0 = 4.425 \times 10^{-4}$ shows a very similar drop-gas interface profile and is included as supplementary figure available at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2020.773.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Phase diagram showing the transition from non-contact (wettability-independent or WI) to contact (wettability-dependent or WD) type of interaction with the solid surface. The boundary between the two regions is shown with a dashed-red curve for viscosity ratio $\lambda = 0.018$ (air–water case). Below the dashed-red curve, shown with ($\square$), lies the WI region where the drop is supported on a thin cushion of gas beneath it. The WD region is shown with ($\ast$) where the drop makes contact with the surface. The gas film approaches negligible thicknesses near the transition boundary and is expected to be grid-dependent. Vertical orange bars show the extent to which the transition boundary moves upwards in $Re$ with a decrease in grid size. Experimental studies of Richard & Quéré (2000) ($\bigstar$, orange), Kolinski et al. (2014) ($\blacklozenge$, limegreen) and de Ruiter et al. (2015c) ($\blacktriangle$, red) are also shown for comparison. A similar transition boundary was observed for a higher viscosity ratio, $\lambda =0.1$, shown with a blue curve. The symbols show the corresponding values of $Re$ and $We$ in the simulations and experiments.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Division of the phase diagram into five sub-regions, numbered 1–5, based on the shape of the drop and gas film beneath it. The typical shape of the drop in each region is shown in separate inset figures. In regions 3, 4, 5, the drop develops a large negative curvature on its upper surface which is largely absent in regions 1 and 2. The shape of the gas film in each of these regions differs significantly, shown over a small rectangular region close to the solid surface within each inset figure.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Time evolution of the drop–gas interface profile for a sample case in region 1 of figure 7 with $We=1.07$ and $Re=10.35$ during $(a)$ the spreading stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0$ to 0.81 and $(b)$ the receding stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0.9$ to 1.71 plotted in equal time intervals of $t/\tau =0.09$. Interface profile develops a single minima which gently spreads radially in time, reaches a global minima, $h_{min}$, before receding inwards and then eventually retreating from the solid surface. See supplementary movie 1 for the complete drop evolution.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Temporal evolution of drop–gas interface profile with $We=1.07$ and $Re=517.5$ contained in region 1 of the phase diagram for $(a)$ the spreading stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0$ to 0.81 and $(b)$ the receding stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0.9$ to 2.07 plotted in equal time intervals of $t/\tau =0.09$. Due to lower viscous damping, the receding stage exhibits localised bulges in the gas film prompted by strong oscillations on the outer surface of the drop. As a result, the receding motion of the outer kink is not monotonic in time. See supplementary movie 2 for the complete drop evolution.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Temporal evolution of the drop–gas interface profile with $We=1.07$ and $Re=1552.5$ contained in region 2 of the phase diagram for $(a)$ the spreading stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0$ to 0.54 and $(b)$ the receding stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0.63$ to 1.89 plotted in equal time intervals of $t/\tau =0.09$. The initially stable gas film ruptures at the outer kink forming a contact line. Due to the superhydrophobic nature of the solid surface, the drop recedes from the surface. Similar to the receding motion of the outer kink in figure 9, the contact line motion is highly non-monotonic in time.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Variation of drop shape and evolution of contact line motion for $We=0.53$ and $Re=1035$ during the receding stage. $(a)$ The drop shape at the onset of the receding stage ($(t-t_0)/\tau =1.02$) is shown in red while the blue coloured shape shows the drop at the onset of lift-off. $(b)$ Temporal evolution of the inner, $r_i$, and outer, $r_o$, contact lines during the receding stage. A schematic of the drop with both the contact lines is shown in the inset. Presence of an inner contact line reveals entrapment of a gas bubble. The oscillatory nature of the outer contact line motion, $r_o(t)$, is due to strong oscillations on the outer surface of the drop.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Temporal evolution of the drop–gas interface profile with $We=3.21$ and $Re=207$ contained in region 3 of the phase diagram for $(a)$ the spreading stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0$ to 0.72 and $(b)$ the receding stage from $(t-t_0)/\tau =0.78$ to 2.34 plotted in equal time intervals of $t/\tau =0.05$. The gas film flattens and can even develop a minima at a smaller radius.

Figure 12

Figure 13.$(a)$ Flow field in the bulk at the onset of the receding motion ($t/\tau =0.74$) for $We=3.21$ and $Re =310.5$. Though the overall drop begins receding after this time, the upper surface of the drop continues to descend indicated by downward velocity vectors near the axis of symmetry. Temporal evolution of drop shapes in advancing and receding stages for (b,c) $We=0.53$ and $Re =310.5$, and (d,e) $We=3.21$ and $Re =310.5$. In the advancing stage (b,d), drop shapes are coloured from red to blue and in the receding stage (c,e), drop shapes are coloured from blue to red. Panel (a) corresponds to the last/first curve in panels (d)/(e).

Figure 13

Figure 14.$(a)$ Vector flow field at the onset of touchdown for $We=3.21$ and $Re=724.5$ (region 4). The interface near the axis of symmetry descends down rapidly causing the bulk of the drop to spread radially outwards. This causes formation of a thin liquid film supported on a thin gas film. Zoomed view of interfaces and flow fields in a small rectangular region is shown in (b–d) for four different times. Strong shear in the gas film causes undulations at the interface (shown with red arrows) often followed by tiny vortices in the gas above the interface. The extensional flow in the thin liquid film further accentuates the rupture process (not shown here). $(a)$$t/\tau = 1.05652$. $(b)$$t/\tau = 1.05652$. $(c)$$t/\tau = 1.05704$. $(d)$$t/\tau = 1.05756$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Temporal evolution of the drop–gas interface profile for $We=3.21$ and $Re=517.5$ in region 4 where touchdown occurs at a much smaller radial location. $(a)$ Drop spreads radially and a kink is formed at its outer rim: $(t-t_0)/\tau =0$ to 0.78. $(b)$ Bulge near the axis of symmetry descends down and makes contact with the solid surface while the outer kink remains nearly stationary: $(t-t_0)/\tau =0.78$ to 0.98. This occurs due to a strong downward flow field shown in figure 14. $(c)$ Smaller ruptures emerge in the gas film near the axis of symmetry and the outer kink recedes inward: $(t-t_0)/\tau =1.09$ to 1.45. $(d)$ Coalescence of smaller gas bubbles leads to a larger gas bubble at the axis of symmetry the drop begins complete withdrawal from the surface: $(t-t_0)/\tau =1.51$ to 1.92. All the profiles are plotted at equal interface of $t/\tau =0.05$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Three-dimensional representation of drop shapes obtained by revolving the axisymmetric interface profiles. (a–d) Sample case from region 2 with $We=0.53$ and $Re=2070$ for $(t-t_0)/\tau = 0, 1.08, 1.212, 2.361$ for one complete bouncing event. Rupture of the gas film causes the formation of two axisymmetric contact lines. (e–h) Sample case from region 4 with $We=3.21$ and $Re=517.5$ for $(t-t_0)/\tau =0, 0.7817, 1.07, 1.14, 2.24$ for one complete bouncing event. Strong oscillations on the upper regions of the drop clearly causes entrainment of gas from above. This causes rupture of the drop–gas interface profile near the axis of symmetry (see figure 14 for vector field) and also traps a large bubble inside the drop consistent with experiments (see figure 18). Aesthetics guided the choice of orientation and scale for each panel. No effort was made to retain the same scale in the above images.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Interface shape for $We=3.21$ and $Re=517.5$ showing simultaneous ejection of a jet and bubble entrapment. As the jet is ejected at a very high speed, it break up into tiny droplets. Simultaneously a gas bubble is trapped inside the drop when the capillary waves collapse on the upper surface of the drop.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Bubble entrapment in a water drop surrounded by air impacting on a chemically treated superhydrophobic glass with $\theta =160.4^{\circ }$ for $Re=716$ and $We=6.1$. (a–d) Approximately correspond to various stages of a bouncing cycle (from left to right): $t=0.33\ \textrm {ms}$ after contact, $t=5.8\ \textrm {ms}$ at maximum spreading, $t=8.66\ \textrm {ms}$ showing bubble entrapment and $t=20.3\ \textrm {ms}$ showing drop in flight with the entrapped bubble. See supplementary movie 4.

Figure 18

Figure 19.$(a)$ Time evolution of the centreline height ($h_c$) and minimum height ($h_{min}$) of the drop-gas interface profile as the drop descends towards the surface. For $t \le t_0$, the drop remains spherical, hence, $h_c = h_{min}$ and non-dimensional surface energy, $E_S/E_{S0}$ (shown on right axis) is at its minimum. The drop begins its first deformation at time $t=t_0$ after its release from a height $H=H_0$ resulting in deviation between $h_c$ and $h_{min}$. Surface energy of the drop begins to increase at the same instant and is a useful measure for determining the time at which first deformation occurs. The blue vertical line shows the time, $t=t_0$, at which the first drop deformation occurs at height $H_d$ as measured from the bottom surface. $(b)$ Scaling of $H_d$ for various Weber numbers shows that $H_d \sim Ca_g^{1/2}$, a scaling obtained by balance of capillary pressure in the drop and lubrication pressure in gas film. Solid symbols are from the current study and open symbols are taken from the following experiments: ($\lozenge$) are bubble impact experiments of Hendrix et al. (2012) and Manica et al. (2013, 2014), ($\Box$) are mercury drops in water impacting a mica surface by Connor & Horn (2003) and ($\bigcirc$) are ethanol drops impacting on glass by Bouwhuis et al. (2012).

Figure 19

Figure 20.Comparison of the motion of the outer kink ($h=h_2 = h_{min}$) with experiments reported in figure 11(c) of de Ruiter et al. (2015b). Looping indicates that receding motion is non-monotonic and is seen both in experiments and simulations.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Scaling for minimum height in the drop-gas interface profile for cases in region 1 of the phase diagram. Solid symbols correspond to the current study whereas open symbols correspond to experiments reported by de Ruiter et al. (2015a). Theoretical scaling by Mandre et al. (2009) () and experimental fit of de Ruiter et al. (2015a) ($- - -$) is also shown. Thickness values shown in figure 8 of de Ruiter et al. (2015a) ($\triangle ,\bigcirc ,\Box$) correspond to the inner kink whereas outer kink values ($h_2$) are extracted from their figure 6 shown with (, blue) symbol.

Figure 21

Figure 22.Scaling relationships with varying Weber number for radial location of the outer kink, $r_k:(\nabla , \text {blue}; \lhd , \text {blue};$, blue), radial location of the first rupture for parameters in region 2, $r_{ir}:(\Box , \text {red}; \triangle , \text {red};$, red; $\lozenge , \text {red}; \bigcirc , \text {red})$ and radial extent of drop deformation, $x = (R_{max}-R_0):({\ast , \text {pinegreen}; \lozenge , \text {pinegreen}; \blacksquare, \text {pinegreen}})$. Experimental data for radial position of outer kink, $h=h_2$, extracted from figure 4(c) of de Ruiter et al. (2015a) is also shown ($\blacksquare$) and found to be in excellent agreement with the $We^{1/4}$ scaling. Maximum deformation of the drop (see inset schematic) follows the scaling derived by Richard & Quéré (2000) valid for bouncing on superhydrophobic surfaces, $x \sim We^{1/2}$.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Scaled rupture time of the gas film (or contact time), $t_r/\tau$. Simulation data shows distinct scaling behaviour for cases belonging to region 2 and region 4 of the parameter space. In region 2 (orange open symbol) we have $t_r/\tau \sim St^{-1/2}$ whereas in region 4 (solid black symbols), $t_r \approx \tau$.

Figure 23

Figure 24.Phase diagram showing the transition from non-contact (similar to WI region) to contact (similar to WD) type of interaction with a free-slip boundary condition on the impact surface. The impact surface is akin to a surface of symmetry and the simulation mimics the head-on collision of two identical drops. Open symbols ($\square$) show simulation points where a thin gas layer prevents the drop from making contact with the gas surface. The drop bounces back without contact, hence, we refer to this region as the ‘bouncing region’. Above the transition boundary (orange line), the drop makes contact with the surface and simulations were stopped after the first contact. Vertical ‘error’ bars show that the transition boundary is grid-dependent similar to the phase diagram given in figure 6.

Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 1

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 965.1 KB

Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 2

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 929 KB

Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 3

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 3(Video)
Video 255.1 KB

Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 4

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary movie 4(Video)
Video 2.8 MB
Supplementary material: File

Sharma and Dixit supplementary figure

See pdf file for figure caption

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary figure(File)
File 277.2 KB
Supplementary material: PDF

Sharma and Dixit supplementary material

Captions for movies 1-4 and supplementary figure 1

Download Sharma and Dixit supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 71.4 KB