This is a challenging study which argues for the contingency of looking as a condition of the ways in which meaning is produced in theatrical spectatorship. Bleeker argues that vision must be acknowledged as ‘visuality’, a situated experience that complicates the fiction of a biological, transhistorical experience of vision, in the theatre and beyond. By addressing the theme of visuality, she sets out to address a lacuna in theatre studies, namely the frequent absenting of accounting for vision in writing about theatre. For Bleeker, theatre points to the contingent relationship between a seeing subject and the event it sees. The curious absence of a theory of vision in the theatre relates to the persistent assumption of presence and immediacy, and the traditional subjugation of visuality to textuality.
The book's major contribution is to use theories of vision to track the mid-twentieth-century shift from the avant-garde sublation of art and the everyday to a postmodern, deconstructive method. Bleeker shows that ‘new strategies of seeing leave space for subjective aspects of vision’ (p. 65), by staging the need to read vision as a particularized experience. Following Mieke Bal, this particularity is dependent upon ‘focalization’ (p. 33), a specifically physical positioning of one's body in relation to the thing given to be seen, and also by race, class, gender and other subjective orientations. Bleeker describes this as a movement from politics to semiotics, and argues that this transformation coincides with the historical development of postdramatic theatre in the same moment.
Throughout, her readings are burdened by dense elaborations of the work of theorists such as Hubert Damisch, Roland Barthes or Jacques Lacan. She works through these and other theorists in detail, to the extent that her implicit argument is that an arbitrary set of performances may help to illustrate and synthesize a history of European approaches to the problem of vision and visuality. Her focus is ‘the inevitable discursivity of our ways of seeing’ (p. 81) in the theatre, and this leads her to difficult synopses of diverse topics, towards a theory of ‘the body as the locus of our looking’ (p. 147), yet the tangents rarely elucidate her explanations of specific events or clarify her descriptions of the reciprocity of the subject and the seen/scene. Her opacity is compounded by theoretical solecisms, such as the statement that ‘Constative gestures are always performative in the sense that they are acts of making meaning’ (p. 149), which conflates the founding opposition of Austinian linguistics. Nevertheless, Visuality in the Theatre will be of interest to scholars of Continental theory, and is a step towards addressing a curious oversight in theatre and performance studies: the absence of a convincing account of what we do when we look at events in the theatre. I found myself wondering about how readers might apply her readings to one's own experience of looking at bodies in the theatre.
