Steven Michels begins his thoughtful book on Sinclair Lewis with the observation that “there is considerable disagreement about what to make of Lewis and even whether he is worth reading at all” (ix). Indeed, although Lewis produced influential accounts of American life in Main Street, Babbit, and Elmer Gantry, and even won a Nobel Prize in Literature in 1930, his reputation waned through the remainder of the twentieth century. Was the decline in Lewis's popularity unwarranted? Might he be worth another look, especially by those interested in the fundamental tendencies of democracy?
Michels answers in the affirmative, arguing that Lewis's “voice is needed somewhat desperately” (vii). He groups Lewis's works thematically in nine chapters, exploring the novelist's views on everything from democratic freedom to ambition to nationalism. Michels begins each chapter with a summary of what various great thinkers, from Plato to Nietzsche, have written on the subject at hand. He then devotes several pages to each of several novels bearing on the chapter's theme, before summing up and discussing the wider implications of Lewis's ideas.
Michels reads Lewis carefully and sympathetically, resurrecting Lewis's best ideas and explicitly connecting them to centuries-old debates about democracy. Lewis thus becomes a participant in a broader dialogue about fundamental political questions, rather than a time-bound author of 1920s America. In addressing topics such as love and religious belief, Michels provides a helpful reminder of how a regime's effects spread far beyond institutional structures. Narrative fiction, through the use of detailed description and stories about particular people, is well suited to capturing these effects.
Michels's strongest chapters are—not surprisingly—those that deal with Lewis's strongest works. The opening chapter, for example, provides an excellent discussion of Arrowsmith—a novel about the competing demands of scientific inquiry and democratic politics—with frequent references to Plato and Aristotle. The chapter on American business mentality, focusing on Babbitt, probes the limitations of a work ethic that has no place for higher culture or genuine leisure, while Elmer Gantry is employed in chapter 4 to illustrate the “readiness on the part of the religious to accept the authority of supposed leaders” (68).
The timeliest chapter is the third, which centers on It Can't Happen Here, Lewis's cautionary tale about the possibility of European-style fascism in America. Given the widespread anxiety surrounding the 2016 election, this novel has rocketed up the bestseller lists. Whether Michels originally drafted this chapter with Donald Trump in mind is unclear, but in the final version he makes the connection explicit: “it's difficult to read It Can't Happen Here and not see similarities between [President] Windrip and the fascist positions and rhetoric of Donald Trump” (54).
Read in 2017, Lewis's Main Street—prominently featured in chapter 7—also takes on new meaning. Carol Kennicott, the disillusioned newcomer to Gopher Prairie, ruthlessly criticizes her town's dullness and dreadful taste. Her language resembles the rhetoric leveled at current-day small-town America from coastal and urban enclaves. Michels makes a shrewd observation here about the balance of power in American politics, brought so clearly into focus in the recent election: “These small towns have no influence or will of their own, but taken as a whole, the sheer force of their number cannot be denied” (124). The sea of red surrounding blue cities on the 2016 electoral map is testament to the lasting power of small towns, considered in the aggregate.
In reading Lewis, Michels believes the choice should not be seen as urban society versus rural society. Rather, we should seek “more society,” so long as we “pick our places carefully and not stay there for too long” (130). Michels tells us that Lewis wrote of democratic community as potentially flourishing in a variety of contexts, from theater troupes (77) to road trips (119). Unfortunately, most examples of “democracy” in Lewis's works receive bitter satirical treatment. Should we really be hopeful about the prospects for healthy democracy if Lewis sees it occurring only as the exception to the rule?
While most of Michels's chapters provide interesting accounts of Lewis's thought, connected where relevant to larger debates in political philosophy, there are places where the material is thin. One wonders if Michels might have been better off focusing on one major work per chapter, rather than including so many subchapters on minor works. The overall effect is a kind of dilution, in which Lewis's best narratives have to share space and attention with works of lesser quality.
There are also some missed opportunities for further analysis. Michels observes, for example, that Lewis and Alexis de Tocqueville disagree on whether a proliferation of religious sects is healthy for a democracy (72–73). This difference is noted, but not really explored. Is Lewis right, or is Tocqueville? At another point, Michels writes that Lewis and Aristotle disagree on the value of small communities (130). Assuming there is such a disagreement—which is not well established in the text—what should we make of it? Does Lewis see something Aristotle misses? Then, in the chapter entitled “Love, Family, and Friendship,” Michels argues that Lewis would reject Tolstoy's view of unhappy families each having a unique source of unhappiness. Is it really plausible that “unhappy families are all alike,” as Michels describes Lewis's opinion on the matter (93)? Without knowing more about any of these disagreements—particularly how the other authors might respond to Lewis—it is difficult to conclude that Lewis is more insightful than those formidable thinkers.
More broadly, I found myself wondering about the significance of Lewis's contribution to political philosophy. At times, Michels praises Lewis enthusiastically, if somewhat curiously: “His is a unique voice in that it combines a full range of ancient, modern, and even post-modern perspectives” (xv). The novelist is portrayed as going toe-to-toe with great philosophers and even anticipating by twenty years George Orwell's work on language and politics (43). But then scattered throughout the book are apologetic statements about Lewis's work. Of Elmer Gantry Michels writes, “Lewis preaches with a sledgehammer, giving us an image of religion that's both petty and elitist and more about knocking faith than giving it its due” (71). Lewis is “less playful” than Kurt Vonnegut, the implication being that he is therefore “heavy-handed” (162). Whereas Mark Twain's “humor allowed his satire to be deeper and more biting,” Lewis's satire does not generally achieve that level of effectiveness (163). Might we, then, be better off reading Vonnegut and Twain, who cover much of the same ground with greater skill?
In the end, although Lewis may not give us as rich an account of democracy as, say, Tocqueville does, his perspective is nonetheless an important one. Lewis himself would appreciate Michels's careful analysis, and readers of Sinclair Lewis and American Democracy will likely be convinced that Lewis is, in fact, “worth reading” again.
