Until Kim “Howard” Johnson's The Funniest One in the Room: The Lives and Legends of Del Close, the closest thing to a biography of the improvisation guru was a series of DC comic books he coauthored in the late 1980s entitled Wasteland. As one of the three major theorists of contemporary improv alongside Viola Spolin and Keith Johnstone, Close was associated for years with Chicago's Second City and ImprovOlympic theatres. His ideas and teachings were integral to the development of long-form improv as a popular form of theatre that has now spread from Chicago throughout the United States. Kim Johnson, a coauthor with Close and Charna Halpern on Truth in Comedy, the manual for long-form improvisation, presents a detailed narrative of Close's life rich with the anecdotes that helped to create the legend behind “The Funniest One in the Room.”
Taking a chronological approach, Johnson uses Close's Kansas childhood to set the contrast for his eventual embracing of the counterculture in the early 1950s. Close spent time as a fire-eater, a performer in traveling horror shows, a stand-up comedian, and a subject in Air Force LSD experiments. He started in improvisation in earnest with the St. Louis version of Chicago's Compass Players alongside Elaine May, Mike Nichols, and Ted Flicker, among others. It was here in 1957 that the three basic rules of improv became codified by the group: never deny reality, take the active choice, and justify everything that happens. Close maintained throughout his lifetime that these rules, in moving away from Spolin's conception of improvisation, allowed it to become an art form in itself rather than only a tool to create other works. The manifestation of Close's ideas was the Harold, a long-form improvisation developed in between stints at Second City while he was a performer and director with the Committee in San Francisco in 1967. Through the years, when Close directed at the Second City, producer Bernie Sahlins maintained doubts about the commercial viability of Close's style of improv and kept his theory relegated to workshops rather than integrated into the revues. After the eventual severing of ties with Second City, his collaboration with Charna Halpern permitted the Harold to develop into a performable structure at the ImprovOlympic theatre in the 1980s and sparked the rejuvenation of Chicago's improvisation culture.
Johnson weaves together Close's growing status as an improvisation artist with his increasing identification with the American counterculture as an invitation to see Close even more so as the anti-Spolin. His heavy drug use and drinking, while fueling some of the stories that magnified his legend, were also promoted as causes for his frequent inability to see projects through to completion and for his several dismissals from Second City. The author does a good job of moderating some of the stories that Close allowed to grow over the years, particularly those of his father's suicide and Close's disagreements with Mike Nichols. Along these lines, Johnson tries to temper Close's noted disdain of women and children, either through psychological speculation or by offering personal instances that reports of his misogyny were not universal. Johnson generally treats his friend kindly throughout the book and accepts Close's eccentricities as part of the trappings of genius.
In historical scope, Johnson's book works well in conjunction with Janet Coleman's The Compass, Jeffrey Sweet's Something Wonderful Right Away, and Rob Kozlowski's The Art of Chicago Improv in rounding out the Chicago improvisation movement of the past half century. The appendix details the various projects with which Close was involved, including the Second City and ImprovOlympic shows he directed. Reflecting the limited writing on contemporary improv, the bibliography comprises only six books. Staying true to the biographical nature, Johnson does not delve into larger critical issues, like Amy E. Seham's Whose Improv Is It Anyway? did with gender in the improvisation community. However, Johnson's book does compile much-needed first-wave research in the field, and it is unique in its focus on one particular improviser rather than on a theatre or on the improv community as a whole.
Johnson fills in quite a few of the holes in his subject's past through interviews of many of the people who knew Close, as well as access to his notebooks and personal effects, but admits that the timeline is disputable and that some of the facts are lost to fuzzy memories. The book has a much wider biographical scope than Guru by Jeff Griggs, which focused on a more personal level about Griggs's relationship with Close during his last years, but did provide a better glimpse at Close's teaching techniques. Though Johnson's book only briefly compares Close's theories to other improvisation theories, it is a thoroughly researched, well-written biography that should be read by anyone interested in contemporary popular improv and is a valuable addition to the research on American comedy.
