One might say without exaggeration that when Thomas Betterton died in April 1710, a generation passed away. He grew up in a city in which theatre was illegal, yet in 1710 London supported two functioning theatres, one of which had just been appropriated for Italian opera, and a third theatre was being remodeled. Betterton had performed in all of them, usually as both a leading actor and a comanager, during a fifty-year career that stretched nearly to the end of the Stuart dynasty. Just as preparations were already underway for a Hanoverian to succeed the ailing Queen Anne, so too a younger generation had recently taken charge of the theatre, though Betterton continued to perform occasionally to within fifteen days of his death. His influence over the medium shows in the provision for spectacle in plays and in English operas: he built the first permanent theatre fully equipped with Italianate machinery, out of whose legacy pantomime evolved. He encouraged many aspiring playwrights, some of them female, creating over 130 roles and playing more than 50 in older plays. He taught actors and public speakers.
Nevertheless, personalia are very scarce, as is new information. David Roberts has found one letter previously unknown, and electronic search has led him to a number of fugitive references, mostly from the eighteenth century. Conventional biography being impossible, he offers an account of how Betterton's “public profile was rooted in the particulars of his personal life” and seeks “to reconsider Betterton's significance for Restoration London” (4). Roberts acknowledges that “While this study is organised according to phases in its subject's life, … chronology often defers to themes” (4). Thus late events in the life or memories recorded posthumously may come up early in the book, and early developments are taken to have effects later than has been recognized. Context becomes more than usually important. At his best, Roberts is able to develop enough context around a few fragments of information to generate convincing speculations as to what they meant in some larger picture.
For example, Betterton's father was an “under-cook” (41) in the royal household: the future actor was born into what was once a comfortable niche in the mercantile support of monarchy, which he watched civil war disrupt. The experience is seen as instilling loyalty to the crown, but also caution. Betterton was informally apprenticed to a bookseller/publisher and later issued a few works under his own name. His background equipped him with firsthand knowledge of business, ideal for the head of an unsubsidized theatre. His fine and durable voice allowed him to become a key actor early. He wisely invested in the remodeling of a tennis court as a theatre, so that in addition to his salary he received a small “rent” for every performance done there. Not all his colleagues showed such fiscal discipline. Betterton's prudence comes to be his defining characteristic in all regards, whether performance style (he was said to underplay rather than overplay), marriage (to an actress, who would understand schedule pressures), or investments (money should be reinvested in the business). Roberts builds a contrast between Betterton's steadiness and what little we know of the more flamboyant behavior, onstage and off, of his comanagers Henry Harris and, later, William Smith. The Roberts Betterton is always aware that he only acts noble or royal characters and is careful not to aspire above his station. Mary Betterton is her husband's consultant and business partner, not a mere rib. At a time when actors, male and female, were often stigmatized as whores, the Bettertons were respectable enough to be invited to teach noble and royal children to perform in the last Stuart court masque, John Crowne's Calisto (1675).
Alternative versions of these stories might be suggested, but on the whole Roberts makes plausible arguments for his interpretations of such facts as we have about Betterton's career. The early chapters, in which he is establishing his Betterton, are perhaps more successful than the later ones, where more might have been said about the context of succession and retirement plans and about the broader economic climate during the morass of lawsuits into which new owners plunged the theatre from the 1690s through the rest of Betterton's career. Circa 1692, when William Mountfort was murdered, the Bettertons could well have been thinking of him as a future acting manager, but not as a groom for their ward Anne Bracegirdle (157), because in 1686 he had married Susanna Percival (subsequently Verbruggen). The new owners, Sir Thomas Skipwith and his man of business Christopher Rich, were both speculators whose emphasis on cost cutting and profits nearly wrecked the theatre company they had bought. Comparison with past investors, such as the scions of the Davenant and Killigrew families, might have provided some perspective. Roberts finishes with an elaborate discussion of the sale of the Chandos portrait of Shakespeare, now in the National Portrait Gallery, which Betterton had allegedly bought from Sir William Davenant.
Two quibbles: The Life of Mr Thomas Betterton was the first acting guide published in English, although it is largely a pastiche from French rhetoric manuals with passages from English plays inserted. The book is problematic in several regards, but its attribution (5) is not in doubt: the preface is signed by Charles Gildon in a press correction included in the 1970 Garland edition. My second quibble is a favorite quotation not included: in the preface to The Force of Friendship (1710), Charles Johnson reported that Betterton, for whom the prologue had been intended, “confessed but very lately” that at the age of seventy-five “he was yet learning to be an Actor.” I find Joseph Roach's surrogation argument in Cities of the Dead more plausible when applied to Colley Cibber's Betterton than to Richard Steele's. Roberts is concerned with the gradual accumulation of the professional profile that Cibber looked back to, and he serves the shadowy figure of Betterton well.
