Policing is a topic largely absent from political science and perhaps for that reason also from initial studies of democratisation processes in Latin America. Police institutions in most countries in Latin America have now come to be recognised as being in urgent need of reform, since policing practices characterised by the illegal use of violence, endemic corruption, and the highly selective provision of security are seen as seriously undermining democratic citizenship. Mercedes S. Hinton's book on policing in Argentina and Brazil swells the increasing number of publications dedicated to this thorny issue. The title is somewhat misleading, since the book does not in fact deal with Argentina and Brazil, but with one city in each – Buenos Aires and Rio de Janeiro.
Following a general introduction on policing in Latin America, the book is divided into two parts, the first analysing Buenos Aires and the second Rio de Janeiro. Both of these two parts usefully follow the same pattern, each being divided into five sections. The author first sketches the security situation in each city, then turns, secondly, to a description of policing practices, goes on, thirdly, to present reform projects introduced in the 1990s and intended to enhance the quality of policing, before, fourthly, considering the reasons commonly adduced for the lack of progress in reforming the police – reasons she considers insufficient to explain the halting progress of reform. Finally, the concluding chapter in each of the two parts is devoted to an analysis of what Hinton terms the ‘political game’ in Argentina and Brazil. It is here, in the unwritten rules of politics, that she locates the explanations for the dismal record of police reform in both cities – in the lack of accountability that characterises not only the police, but also other state institutions; in the ubiquity of corruption, and in the fragmentation of civil society, to name some of the most salient factors. A brief concluding chapter draws together the main arguments, sketches more recent developments, and offers some general reflections on policing throughout Latin America.
Two aspects of this study deserve special mention. First, the author is conversant with central issues in police research and does a good job, in the introductory chapter and throughout the book, of linking her analysis to the insights of police research carried out in established democracies such as the USA and Great Britain. In a liberal state committed to uphold civil rights, the very function of the police as the exercisers of the state's coercive power towards its own citizens is an uncomfortable one, as she reminds us. Throughout, her analysis is informed by an awareness of the contradictions and tensions inherent to the role of the police in a democratic society. She thus avoids the fallacy that seems to ensnare a good many political scientists venturing into what, to them, is the virgin territory of policing in new democracies and that consists in a facile and unhelpful juxtaposition of policing within the law in established democracies with ‘undemocratic’ policing in newly-established democracies. Secondly, she places her analysis in the context of broader socioeconomic developments in both countries, discussing how statehood has been undermined by the exigencies of international lending institutions (this applies particularly to Argentina) and showing how policing practices are both conditioned by and reinforce the pervasive breach between rich and poor.
Hinton's study is brief – some seventy pages serve to cover Buenos Aires and ninety Rio. Given this brevity, the analysis is necessarily somewhat summary and short on detail. One has the impression that the author is anxious to condemn the police reforms at the centre of her analysis as ineffective in order to press on to her wider analysis of the ‘political game’. Yet more nuanced studies of some of these reforms (such as the abolition of the notorious police edicts in Buenos Aires, or the effects of computerisation in Rio de Janeiro) suggest that, despite their problems, they have made a significant impact on either the legality or the effectiveness (or both) of policing in these two cities; the pertinent bibliography is not referenced. This is a pity, since the effective reform of policing practices will probably always only be possible through a cautious and incremental approach; in this field more than in others, the devil, but also the hope, lies in the detail. Part of the problem here may lie in the fact that Hinton's field research was largely conducted in 2000–2001 and only a comparatively small part of the bibliography she cites is of a later date; relevant research published after 2001 appears not to have been systematically consulted.
One disappointment is the rather meagre use of interview material. The author tells us that she conducted 165 interviews with ‘police officers, military officers, legislators, NGO representatives, directors of trade associations, owners of private security companies, prostitutes, members of the clergy and unions, community organizers and residents, intellectuals, academics, judges, lawyers, and economists’ (p. 206) and suplemmented these with visits to shanty towns, police training institutions, social outreach programmes and the like (p. 11, p. 207). The heavy reliance on interviews and observation leads one to expect – indeed, to hope for – an ethnographic approach to the subject matter, and yet the fruits of this very considerable labour are scarcely evident in the finished product, in which interview material is rather used to provide soundbites than to build a fleshed-out picture of the subjective worldviews of these protagonists (or victims) of public security policy. Evidently the author must still be sitting on a goldmine of field research material and one hopes that these riches may find more extensive use in future publications.
Despite these reservations, this book offers a very good introduction to the problems of policing and police reform in Latin America. The style is clear and succint throughout. If many issues are treated in a rather cursory fashion, leaving the reader hungry for greater detail, Hinton's study undoubtedly does an excellent job of contextualising problems of policing in Latin America.
