Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T16:40:27.322Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Embodying Musical Heritage in a New–Old Profession: American Jewish Cantorial Schools, 1904–1939

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2017

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Current scholarship on music in Jewish life generally views American cantorial training as a postwar process of transplantation, translating a culture decimated by the Holocaust into a higher education program in the United States. Recently available digital repositories of historical materials, however, show at least five organized efforts to establish American cantorial schools between 1904 and 1939. I closely examine these efforts here, which reveal during this period a complicated and active negotiation surrounding the role of the cantor—and music more generally—in American Jewish life. Organizers of these schools engaged in active dialogue with cantorial colleagues in central and eastern Europe, subsequently creating institutional training models that imbued the cantor with a character, history, musical repertoire, and professional lifecycle compatible with the United States’ religious marketplace. Understanding the urge to establish these schools in the first half of the twentieth century, and the tendency to forget or minimize these efforts after World War II, offers insight into the flexibility of musical tradition as it sought to reassert itself on American soil.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2017 
Figure 0

Table 1.Cantorial schools in the United States, 1904–1940.

Figure 1

Example 1.German-style liturgical music. Theodore Guinsburg, “The Lord Reigneth” [opening measures] for choir and organ. In Anthems, Hymns, and Responses for the Union Prayer Book (New York: n.p., 1894).

Figure 2

Example 2.Eastern European–style cantorial music. Yossele Rosenblatt, “Adoshem Moloch” (Hebrew equivalent of “The Lord Reigneth”). Recitative transcription (beginning). In Josef Rosenblatt, Tefiloth Yosef: Selected Recitatives (New York: Metro Music, 1927), 2.

Figure 3

Example 3a.Salomon Sulzer, “Barechu” (call to prayer) for the Friday night service.

a. Original version, from Schir Zion, volume 2 (Vienna, 1865) arranged for cantor and unaccompanied choir of men and boys
Figure 4

Example 3b.Salomon Sulzer, “Barechu” (call to prayer) for the Friday night service.

b. 1904 Society of American Cantors arrangement for cantor, mixed choir, and organ.
Figure 5

Table 2.Program for a concert by the Society for American Cantors to publicize the effort to create a “Cantors Seminary of America,” 1 March 1911. New York Tribune, 26 February 1911, C3. *=Non-liturgical selection.

Figure 6

Figure 1.Lyre figure representing Asher Chassin's organizational ambitions for the cantorial ecosystem. “The N[ew]. E[ducational]. M[usic]. Idea.” New York: Cantors Seminary, 1930.