The edited essays of this volume dedicated to J. Walters (emeritus of Boston University) developed out of two conference sessions held in Vienna at the 2014 International meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature. The essays are divided into three parts: ‘Structures’, ‘Spaces’ and ‘Objects’, after a helpful ‘Introduction’ by D. Schowalter (1–8). Most of the essay authors first review previous scholarship about their topics and then suggest new interpretations, based upon the most recent archaeological excavations at the site of Ephesos and alternative interpretive frameworks. Only some of the most significant results of this new research for understanding religion in Ephesos can be mentioned here, along with some questions stimulated by the essays.
S. Ladstätter, Director of Excavations at Ephesos, opens Part 1, ‘Structures’, with a succinct history of research on ‘the so-called Imperial Cult Temple for Domitian’ (11–40). Though epigraphic evidence supports the assumption that the sanctuary located to the west of the Upper Agora of Ephesos was dedicated to the Flavian imperial house, the results of archaeological excavations and research upon the temple conducted since 1930 have not conclusively clarified to whom the temple was dedicated. T. Schulz (41–61) summarises the history of archaeological research on ‘the so-called Serapeion’, a building near the lower Agora of Ephesos, to the east of the harbour. Research conducted since 2011 supports the hypothesis that the temple was dedicated to the worship of Egyptian deities, and may have included initiations. R. Pillinger (62–72) reviews research done from 1996–2010 on the so-called cave of St Paul, located approximately 80 m above sea level on the northern slope of Bülbüldag. The article focuses on the larger cave on the right side of the installation, which contains several frescoes, including a late fifth-century c.e. painting of Thekla, her mother Theokleia and St Paul, a unique artistic evocation of a scene described in the Acts of St Paul and Thekla, in which Thekla was supposed to have sat at a window in the house of Onesiphoros, listening to the word of the virgin life spoken by Paul. A. Pülz (73–89) presents examples of archaeological evidence for Christianity among the inhabitants of the city. The collected body of evidence, according to Pülz, shows the many ways in which Christian iconography permeated public and private spaces in late antique Ephesos. The questions of who put up the public Christian symbols and what the contexts were in which they were created are far harder to answer.
Part 2, ‘Spaces’, begins with D. Steuernagel's re-evaluation (93–107) of the creation of the so-called Upper Agora of Ephesos, in light of the conclusion that the peripteral temple on the longitudinal axis of the Agora discovered in 1970 was not the starting point of a comprehensive replanning of the Upper Agora but was added as a late element within a more lengthy formative process. Steuernagel suggests that the Upper Agora was perhaps the result of heterogenous influences and competition among socially stratified factions within the city. The implications of this intriguing conclusion have yet to be elaborated. A. Sokolicek (108–22) summarises recent archaeological and architectural investigations of the ‘Magnesian Gate’ at the south-east corner of the urban fortifications of Ephesos. Sokolicek argues that that the gate, now dated to c. 100 b.c.e., functioned as a conduit between the city and the countryside, and was articulated both as a station to regulate traffic and as a sacred space in processions between the Artemision and the city.
M. Steskal (123–34) offers a fascinating overview of burial practices in Ephesos from the late Hellenistic into the Byzantine period. During the Roman period Ephesos had at least 90 ha of densely used extra-urban burial land with more than 1,200 individual burial sites. Steskal concludes that the community of (deceased) individuals became a landscape of identity. H. Thür (135–57) reviews the spaces associated with Dionysos in Ephesos and contextualises the house of Gaius Flavius Furius Aptus (Unit 6 of Terrace House 2), along with other buildings that are interpreted as club houses for Dionysiac associations. Thür's review allows us to understand the residence of Aptus not only as an object for enhancing the reputation of a member of the Ephesian upper class (as in the past), but also as the meeting place and clubhouse of a Dionysian association. The activities of mystai at Ephesos (and elsewhere) were not just an extra-urban phenomenon.
L. Zabrana (158–70) rightly asserts that the Temple of Artemis and its sanctuary are both known and unknown. The reason for this is that heretofore our knowledge about the sacred district of Artemis has been based more convincingly upon scattered ancient literary references than upon the scientifically problematic early excavations carried out by J. T. Wood (1869–74). That situation has been changed due to the research of A. Bammer (from 1965), U. Muss (1989) and now Zabrana (2009–11), who has reexamined Wood's original documentation, including references to other buildings, and inscriptions, proving that there was an Augusteum within the precinct. Zabrana's research has in fact clarified that a dense construction of different buildings existed in the immediate vicinity of the temple in Roman times. The more official, public buildings (Odeion, Augusteum, building with Doric entablature) were situated south of the temple, while the north and north-eastern area consisted of residential architecture. This division of space allows us to locate (provisionally) accommodations for priests, cult-specific employees, as well as shelter for persons officially granted asylum in this area. The Temple of Artemis can now be understood as part of a complex of buildings that corresponded to the multi-dimensional character of this ancient, extra-urban sanctuary in the Roman period.
In an imaginative and stimulating essay, C. Thomas (171–91) addresses the invisibility of Christ worshippers in Ephesos (and elsewhere) during the first two centuries c.e. by investigating the shared urban landscape and built environment. Relying on the results of geoarchaeological work at Ephesos, and recent geophysical surveys of the site conducted between 2000 and 2006, Thomas argues that the likely urban landscape of the ‘invisible’ early Christians was the Roman-era harbour area of the city, where artisanal workshops may have been located. This area of the city was an emporion and a more likely ‘peripheral’ location for Paul and the early worshippers of Jesus than areas of the city characterised by monumental structures, including government offices, temples of traditional gods and opulent private houses.
In Part 3, ‘Objects’, F. Kirbihler (195–210) re-thinks the origins and development of municipal and provincial imperial cults at Ephesos. He argues that Octavian's interventions in 30/29 b.c.e. (Cass. Dio 51.20.6–7) were not the beginning of the imperial cult at Ephesos, but rather modified an older cult, disassociating it from Marc Antony, and associating it with Octavian's adoptive father Iulius Caesar. N. Zimmermann (211–29) presents a masterful survey of the evidence for private worship and domestic religion in the seven peristyle houses that comprise the insula of Terrace House 2 in Ephesos. The material attests a wide range of religious phenomena, including the veneration of Greek, Roman and Egyptian deities, the presence of agathos daimon as a snake, the maintenance of ancestor cults and the practice of sacrifices during construction. Finally, E. Rathmayr (230–51) reviews the use and function of terracotta figurines found in the seven residences of Terrace House 2 and the domus of Terrace House 1. Terracottas found in the excavations of the houses date from the Hellenistic period until the second century c.e., and their numbers declined over that time span. Although some of the terracotta figurines seem to have been used as toys or for decorative purposes, Rathmayr argues convincingly that the majority should be understood within the context of domestic worship.
This well-organised and beautifully illustrated volume is an advertisement for the benefits of using newer archaeological techniques and technologies, and interpretive frameworks, to help us achieve a more accurate and nuanced understanding of religion and religious change in one of the largest and most important cities of the Graeco-Roman world. The volume does not give readers a comprehensive view of religion in the city over time, but it allows us to understand better the history of some of the major religious buildings, spaces and objects in the city, at times with broader implications for Graeco-Roman civilisation, and stimulates fresh questions.
