Despite manifest differences in personality styles, modes of thought, and behavior—and the articulation and evaluation of subjective experience across cultures and historical periods—psychological anthropology and comparative psychology have remained at the margins of their respective disciplines. In part, this marginalization reflects the often crude methodologies, simplistic theories, and reductive generalizations, edging on stereotypy, that have characterized many studies. There have, nevertheless, been several more refined studies that now fall (if by word magic) under the rubric of cultural psychology: an ill-defined field of diverse theoretical orientations, which studies patterns of psychological development, attachments, values, identities, and pathologies within a particular culture. Although cultural psychologists have not especially focused on the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), there have been a surprising number of psychological studies in the area both by Western and MENA scholars. Gary S. Gregg, a personality psychologist who spent five years doing ethnographic and life-historical research among Moroccan Berbers, presents us in his careful overview of such studies a perceptive portrayal of the cultural psychology of the MENA peoples, one that is not insensitive to the individual and his or her situation.
Recognizing the dangers of stereotypy, Gregg begins his work with an illuminating discussion of MENA stereotypes and is careful throughout his text to avoid such typifications. After considering MENA as a viable culture area—one characterized by Islam and an honor–modesty constellation of values, he organizes the remainder of his book in psychological developmental terms, along the lines of Erik Erikson, the Whitings, Robert Levine, and Dan McAdams, and not those of Piaget and his followers. Indeed, he is quite resistant to cognitive studies, in part because little research has been done in these terms in the MENA area. Gregg is careful to explain clearly each of these approaches, as he is the psychological studies he refers to and their ethnographic background. His book is certainly the most comprehensive cultural psychological study of any area of the world, as well as an impressive ethnographic introduction to MENA. It will certainly become standard reading in any course on the area.
Gregg's work is, of course, limited by the quality and range of the studies carried out in the area, and although he reads these studies critically, he is at times caught within their framework. (I would argue, for example, that his stress on honor and modesty and Islam leads him to underplay other formative features of MENA “personality” such as attitudes toward language, emotional display, and tolerance toward ambiguity.) Sometimes, as when he makes comparisons with Japan, India, and Africa, he relies too heavily on problematic substantive conversions. His emphasis on the developmental cycle from infancy to the mature adult appears at times, despite his caveats, to overprivilege psychological determinants and suggests experiential continuities that are, in my view, questionable. Gregg himself is anxious not to overemphasize hybridity and discontinuity, as trenchant as they may be, at the expense of developmental continuities related not just to child-rearing practices and other common experiences. His discussion of different developmental periods is divided between traditional and modernizing, essentially urban patterns, the latter in tension with the former. Following Levine, he distinguishes between pediatric and pedagogic models of infant care; that is between constant mothering, nursing on demand, and dampening excitement purportedly characteristic of traditional societies, and face-to-face interaction, proto-conversation, and the eliciting of excitement prevalent in industrial societies and conducive to achievement motivation. He recognizes here and in other life stages tensions between traditional and modernizing practices but, owing perhaps to the absence of studies, is reluctant to describe these intermediate situations. He does stress the effect of the often tragic discrepancy between aspirations—dreams—people have and structural impediments to their fulfillment. Happily, he notes that MENA peoples, like others, “develop multiple self-conceptions that are called into play in different contexts” (p. 323). How these self-conceptions relate to conflict, contradiction, and paradox has yet to be determined.
Gregg discusses the effects and the conflicting demands of underdevelopment, political subjugation, and terrorism primarily in terms of adults. He focuses particular attention on the work of Lebanese psychotherapist Mustafa Hijazi, who looks at how tyranny undermines the basic sense of security, efficacy, and self-regard and instills fear and anxiety—a sense of emasculation (Hijazi's male basis is clear) that seeks at times remediation through both outer and inner directed violence, with women often its target. More cautious than Hijazi, Gregg recognizes that we know little of the effect of tyranny and terrorism on the individual, but along with Hijazi, Ali Zayrour, and Kanan Makiya, he acknowledges the insidious effect of subjugation and terror on the family and, thereby, on the development of the individual. One wishes that Gregg had given greater attention to fear, anxiety, fragmentation, and dissolution at all levels of development.
