Transposition of the great arteries (TGA) is a CHD with an incidence of 0.02% per birth, Reference Villafane, Lantin-Hermoso and Bhatt1 while congenitally corrected TGA (cc-TGA) has a lower incidence of 0.003% per birth. Reference Wallis, Debich-Spicer and Anderson2 Until the 1980s, the Senning and Mustard procedures were commonly performed for atrial switch, leaving a systemic right ventricular prone to dysfunction. From the late 1980s and early 1990s onwards, TGA has been managed instead by arterial switch operations in which the ventriculoarterial discordance is rectified. Reference Shah, Gupta and Ahmad3 Patients with uncorrected cc-TGA also have the systemic circulation supported by the morphological right ventricle, thereby rendering these patients to an increased risk for heart failure events. Reference Filippov, Del Nido and Vasilyev4
Several theories have been postulated for the progressive dysfunction of the systemic right ventricle, which include the solely longitudinal arrangement of the cardiomyocytes in the right ventricle versus the predominantly circumferential with the radial and longitudinal patterns of the left ventricle, Reference Lopez, Cohen and Anderson5 an increase in myocardial fibrosis due to right ventricle pressure overload and hypertrophy Reference Weber and Brilla6 and a decrease in coronary flow reserve. Reference Hauser, Bengel and Hager7 – Reference Hauser, Meierhofer, Schwaiger, Vogt, Kaemmerer and Kuehn9
Failure of the systemic right ventricle could be resolved by anatomic repair either in Senning and Mustard patients (conversion to switch operation) or in cc-TGA (double-switch operation). However, right ventricle dysfunction usually remains sub-clinical for decades and typically manifests during fourth and fifth decades of life, when surgery is no longer a successful option, leaving heart transplantation as the only long-term solution. Reference Said, Burkhart, Schaff and Dearani10
The cardiopulmonary exercise test is a powerful predictor of mortality in heart failure patients and is used as the standard criterion for the need for heart transplantation, Reference Mehra, Canter and Hannan11 with peak oxygen consumption (pVO2) and the relation between ventilation and CO2 production (VE/VCO2 slope) as the most used risk assessment tools. Reference Butler, Khadim and Paul12 Several cardiopulmonary exercise test studies had previously shown that adult CHD patients have reduced exercise capacity similar to non-congenital heart failure patients Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko13 – Reference Mantegazza, Apostolo and Hager15 and that cardiopulmonary exercise test can be used to stratify the risk of heart failure events in adults with CHD similar to the heart failure patients. In the Diller study, Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko13 CHD patients with a pVO2 lower than 15.5 ml/kg/min had a 2-year event rate of 50% regarding death or heart failure hospitalisation, whereas those with a pVO2 superior to 27 ml/kg/min had a 2-year event rate of only 3%.
The aim of this study was to evaluate several cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters for stratifying the risk of heart failure events in TGA or cc-TGA patients with systemic right ventricle. We hypothesised that cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters may provide optimal prognostic information on midterm heart failure events in this population.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to address the use of cardiopulmonary exercise test to stratify the risk of heart failure events in solely TGA or cc-TGA patients with systemic right ventricle without mixing other CHD and is one of the first studies to compare several different cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters in only one type of adult CHD.
Methods
The investigation conforms to the principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki. The institutional ethics committee approved the study protocol and all patients provided consent for the use of the collected information.
Patient population and study protocol
The study included a single tertiary centre retrospective analysis of 44 consecutive adult TGA patients with systemic circulation supported by the morphological right ventricle (TGA patients with Senning or Mustard procedure and cc-TGA patients), referred for cardiopulmonary exercise test as part of their clinical evaluation between January 2010 and December 2017. Cardiopulmonary exercise test is requested in our TGA patients with systemic right ventricle at intervals from 3 to 5 years, even in asymptomatic patients to detect early changes in exercise capacity. If one patient performed more than one cardiopulmonary exercise test during the time of evaluation, the last one was used for the analysis. Clinical, laboratorial, and echocardiographic information were also collected at the time of cardiopulmonary exercise test when available.
Patients were considered cyanotic if they had an oxygen saturation lower than 90% at rest.
Follow-up and endpoint
In order to stratify the risk of heart failure events in TGA patients using cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters, all patients were followed up for at least 12 months from the date of completion of the cardiopulmonary exercise test. The primary endpoint was a composite of cardiac death or heart failure hospitalisation. Data were obtained from the outpatient clinic visits and medical charts review and were complemented with a standardised telephone interview to all patients at the end of follow-up. Information regarding all-cause mortality and hospitalisation for other cardiac reasons were also gathered.
Cardiopulmonary exercise test
A maximal symptom-limited treadmill cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using the modified Bruce protocol (GE Marquette Series 2000 treadmill, Marquette Medical Systems, Inc., Milwaukee, WI, United States of America). Gas analysis was preceded by calibration of the equipment. Minute ventilation, oxygen uptake, and carbon dioxide production were acquired breath-by-breath, using a SensorMedics Vmax 229 gas analyser (SensorMedics Corporation, Yorba Linda, CA, United States of America). Patients were encouraged to perform exercise until the respiratory exchange ratio was ≥1.10.
Heart rate was measured by continuous electrocardiogram, blood pressure was obtained manually with a sphygmomanometer, and oxygen saturation was monitored by pulse oximetry. Standard spirometry was not available in all patients.
Cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters
The pVO2 was defined as the highest 30-second average achieved during exercise and was normalised for body mass. Percentage predicted pVO2 (pVO2 predicted (%)) was calculated from the Wasserman equations. Reference Guazzi, Arena, Halle, Piepoli, Myers and Lavie16 The VE/VCO2 slope was calculated by least squares linear regression, using data acquired throughout the whole exercise. Reference Clark, Poole-Wilson and Coats17
The cardiorespiratory optimal point of ventilation was measured as the minimum value of the ventilatory equivalent for oxygen (VE/VO2 minimum), corresponding to the moment during the incremental exercise in which there is less ventilation for a litre of oxygen to be consumed. Reference Ramos, Ricardo and Araujo18
The anaerobic threshold was determined by combining the standard methods (V-slope preferentially and ventilatory equivalents). Reference Wasserman, Stringer, Casaburi, Koike and Cooper19
Partial pressure of end-tidal carbon dioxide (PETCO2) was reported before exercise, at anaerobic threshold and at peak exercise in mmHg units. Reference Balady, Arena and Sietsema20 Since the increase during exercise until the anaerobic threshold is achieved (PETCO2 at anaerobic threshold – PETCO2 at rest) has prognostic importance in heart failure patients, this parameter was also calculated. Reference Guazzi, Arena, Halle, Piepoli, Myers and Lavie16
Heart rate reserve was calculated as the difference between the maximal heart rate achieved with exercise and the resting heart rate. Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko21 Heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise was defined as the difference between the maximal heart rate achieved with exercise and the heart rate 1 minute into recovery. Reference Guazzi, Arena, Halle, Piepoli, Myers and Lavie16
Chronotropic incompetence patients were defined as those with a peak heart rate at exercise lower than 80% of the estimated maximal heart rate (220 – age), or lower than 62% of the estimated maximal heart rate if the patients were prescribed with negative chronotropic agents. Reference Khan, Pothier and Lauer22
Statistical analysis
Baseline characteristics were summarised as frequencies (percentages) for categorical variables, as means and standard deviations for continuous variables when normality was verified, and as median and interquartile range when normality was not verified by the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test. The Student’s t-test for independent samples or the Mann–Whitney test when normality was not verified was used for the analysis of the variables.
Univariable Cox proportional hazards models were applied, with p-values for time-to-event analyses being based on log-rank tests, and hazard ratios for treatment effects and 95% confidence intervals presented to study the combined endpoint considering the follow-up time for the different cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters.
The predictive power of several cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters was analysed for the highest area under the curve in the follow-up. Reference Heagerty, Lumley and Pepe23 Cut-off values for variables were determined from the receiver operating characteristics curves so that the sum of sensitivity and specificity was maximised. Reference Bewick, Cheek and Ball24 Hanley and McNeil test was used to compare two correlated receiver operating characteristics curves. Reference Hanley and McNeil25
Statistical differences with a p-value <0.05 were considered significant.
Results
Overview of TGA patients
A total of 44 patients were enrolled in the study, 36 (81.8%) TGA patients previously submitted to a Senning/Mustard procedure and 8 (18.2%) cc-TGA patients. The baseline characteristics are presented in Table 1.
Baseline characteristics.
cc-TGA = corrected transposition of the great arteries; TGA = transposition of the great arteries; BNP = brain natriuretic peptide; VE = ventilation.
Values are mean ± standard deviation (normal distribution in all characteristics).
The mean age was 35.1 ± 8.5 years, with a higher percentage of males (72.7%) in the population. Regarding clinical data, the vast majority of the population were in NYHA class I or II (29.5 and 47.7%, respectively), with eight (18.2%) cyanotic patients. Medication with negative chronotropic agents was presented in nine (20.5%) patients, all of them using beta-blockers. There were only four patients treated with angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor or angiotensin receptor blockers (9%). There were 11 patients (20%) on diuretic treatment.
A previous pacemaker implantation was performed with four VVIR and three DDDR pacemaker’s systems in seven (15.9%) patients. The four VVIR system carriers were the only patients in atrial fibrillation during cardiopulmonary exercise test.
Other cardiac anomalies associated with TGA not fully corrected at the time of the cardiopulmonary exercise test included ventricular septal defects (29.5%), pulmonary stenosis (20.5%), atrial septal defects (6.8%), and atrioventricular septal defect (2.3%). Regarding previous surgeries, 25 (69.4%) and 11 (30.6%) of the TGA patients had a Senning and Mustard procedure, respectively. In cc-TGA patients, only one had one previous surgery for an atrioventricular septal defect correction.
Laboratorial data showed no patient with a glomerular filtration rate lower than 30 ml/min as well as no patient with anaemia. Brain natriuretic peptide values were highly variable between patients (a median value of 68 (41–421) pg/ml).
With respect to echocardiographic data, tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion was lower than 16 mm in 26 (68.4%) patients, with 9 (20.5%) patients with at least moderate A-V systemic regurgitation and no patient with sub-pulmonary ventricle dysfunction.
Primary outcome
All patients were followed up for at least 12 months from the date of completion of the cardiopulmonary exercise test, with a mean ± standard deviation follow-up time of 36.7 ± 26.8 months. The primary endpoint, a composite of cardiac death or heart failure hospitalisation, occurred in 10 (22.7%) patients (one death and nine heart failure hospitalisations). No patient was lost to follow-up.
Relationship between cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters and primary outcome
A maximal symptom-limited treadmill cardiopulmonary exercise test was performed using the modified Bruce protocol in all patients, revealing a pVO2 predicted (%) lower than 50% in 16 (36.3%) patients. Anaerobic threshold was achieved by 42 (95.5%) patients, but the respiratory exchange ratio was lower than 1.05 and 1.10 in 40.9 and 59.1%, respectively, despite patients were encouraged to perform exercise until the respiratory exchange ratio ≥1.10. There were no complications during the cardiopulmonary exercise test exam, and the patients finished exercising because of fatigue (59.1%) or dyspnea (40.9%). Chronotropic incompetence was presented in 24 (54.5%) patients.
The univariate predictors of the primary outcome by cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters are represented in Table 2, showing that pVO2, pVO2 (%) predicted, VE/VCO2 slope, PETCO2 at peak exercise, heart rate at anaerobic threshold, time until anaerobic threshold, VO2 at anaerobic threshold, HHR, O2 saturation at peak, and chronotropic index were all predictors of the primary outcome (p < 0.05 for all).
Univariate Cox predictors of the primary outcome.
AT = anaerobic threshold; HR = heart rate; VE = ventilation.
Only cardiorespiratory optimal point, heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise, and the difference between PETCO2 at anaerobic threshold and rest did not achieve significant statistical difference (p between 0.05 and 0.10).
In addition to the Cox analysis, these cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters were analysed for the highest area under the curve in the follow-up period (Table 3).
AUC analysis.
AUC = area under the curve; VE = ventilation.
Heart rate at anaerobic threshold had the highest area under the curve value (0.864), followed by pVO2 (0.838) and O2 saturation at peak exercise (0.830). With the exception of heart rate recovery in the firstt minute after exercise (0.675), all parameters analysed had an area under the curve value higher than 0.700.
Since four (9.1%) patients were in atrial fibrillation, a sub-analysis was performed only with patients in sinus rhythm without an increase in the area under the curve value of heart rate at anaerobic threshold (0.853).
Since pVO2 prognosis power had been related to the need to perform a truly maximum cardiopulmonary exercise test, as assessed by a respiratory exchange ratio >1.05, Reference Balady, Arena and Sietsema20 a sub-analysis was performed showing an area under the curve value of 0.829 (CI 0.608–1.000) in patients with a respiratory exchange ratio >1.05.
Another sub-analysis was performed regarding VE/VCO2 slope excluding cyanotic patients, since previous studies have shown a lack of correlation between VE/VCO2 slope and prognosis in this group of patients, Reference Dimopoulos, Okonko and Diller26 , Reference Khan, Paridon and Kim27 without a significant decrease in the AUC value.
Cut-off values for variables were determined from the ROC curves so that the sum of sensitivity and specificity was maximised and are presented in Table 4.
Sensitivity and specificity results.
AT = anaerobic threshold; VE = ventilation.
Reaching anaerobic threshold before the 7 minute of exercise and a VO2 at anaerobic threshold ≤15 ml/kg/min had a sensitivity of 87.5% and a specificity of 83.5% for the primary outcome. The most used cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters regarding prognosis in heart failure had a sensitivity of 80.0 and 87.5% and a specificity of 76.5 and 67.6%, respectively, for pVO2 ≤20 ml/kg/min and VE/VCO2 slope >37.0, slightly lower than the values achieved with anaerobic threshold time, heart rate at anaerobic threshold, and VO2 at anaerobic threshold. No differences were found in the analysis excluding atrial fibrillation patients.
The Hanley and McNeil test was applied for comparing each area under the curve parameters, with no statistically significant difference found.
Discussion
In a group of adult TGA patients with systemic circulation supported by the morphological right ventricle and evidence of limitation in their exercise capacity, as shown by baseline mean values of pVO2 predicted (%) of 55.8 ± 13.4%, several cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters were predictors of the primary outcome of cardiac death or heart failure hospitalisation, including pVO2, pVO2 (%) predicted, VE/VCO2 slope, PETCO2 at peak exercise, heart rate at anaerobic threshold, time until anaerobic threshold, VO2 at anaerobic threshold, heart rate reserve, O2 saturation at peak, and chronotropic index (all with a p < 0.05), while cardiorespiratory optimal point, heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise, and the difference between PETCO2 at anaerobic threshold and rest did not achieve statistical significance (p between 0.05 and 0.10).
In heart failure patients, cardiopulmonary exercise test is a powerful predictor of mortality and is used as the standard criterion for the need for heart transplantation, Reference Mehra, Canter and Hannan11 with pVO2 and VE/VCO2 slope as the most used risk assessment tools. Reference Butler, Khadim and Paul12 Several trials had tried a similar approach to predict survival in CHD patients, showing that pVO2 and VE/VCO2 slope are related to midterm survival in this patients. Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko13 , Reference Inuzuka, Diller and Borgia14
In a previous investigation, VE/VCO2 slope was the most powerful exercise predictor of mortality on non-cyanotic adult CHD patients. Reference Dimopoulos, Okonko and Diller26 However, some studies had not shown the same prognostic prediction with VE/VCO2 slope in cyanotic patients, Reference Inuzuka, Diller and Borgia14 , Reference Dimopoulos, Okonko and Diller26 , Reference Khan, Paridon and Kim27 suggesting that cyanosis is associated with raised VE/VCO2 slope, but these higher values should not be extrapolated alone to predict a worse prognosis. In our study, despite being a univariate predictor of the primary outcome (p = 0.010), VE/VCO2 slope only achieved an area under the curve value of 0.713, numerically lower than other analysed parameters like pVO2 (0.838) and heart rate at anaerobic threshold (0.864). Since 18.2% of the patients were cyanotic, a sub-analysis was performed in non-cyanotic patients, without an increase in the area under the curve value (0.703).
Of all the parameters analysed, pVO2 had the second highest area under the curve value (0.838), with a value lower than 20 ml/kg/min achieving a sensitivity of 80.0% and a specificity of 76.5% for the primary outcome. As well as other cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters, pVO2 had been related to the need to perform a truly maximum cardiopulmonary exercise test, as assessed by a respiratory exchange ratio > 1.05. Reference Balady, Arena and Sietsema20 However, in our population, respiratory exchange ratio was lower than 1.05 in 40.9%, so we performed a sub-analysis for pVO2 in patients with respiratory exchange ratio > 1.05 which showed an area under the curve value of 0.829, numerically lower than the 0.838 achieved with all patients.
Anaerobic threshold represents the moment where anaerobic metabolism becomes relevant for the production of the amount of energy demanded by exercise. Reference Wasserman, Stringer, Casaburi, Koike and Cooper19 Previous studies in CHD patients have shown that VO2 at anaerobic threshold values is below normal (45–65% of the pVO2), Reference Reybrouck, Rogers and Weymans28 and some may fail to achieve anaerobic threshold in a way similar to heart failure patients. Reference Kadish, Nademanee and Volosin29 In our trial, VO2 at anaerobic threshold values was 55.8 ± 13.4% of the pVO2, and only two (4.5%) patients failed to achieve anaerobic threshold, a lower percentage than previous trials with all types of CHD.
Parameters related to anaerobic threshold (anaerobic threshold time < 7 minute of exercise, heart rate at anaerobic threshold < 95 bpm, and VO2 at anaerobic threshold <15.0 ml/kg/min) reached the highest values of sensitivity (87.5%) and specificity (82.4–83.5%) for the prediction of the primary outcome, suggesting that they should be used in the routine evaluation of these patients to stratify the risk of cardiac death or heart failure hospitalisation.
Chronotropic incompetence was previously related to mortality in adult CHD patients Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko21 and is common in this group patients (30–60% of the patients Reference Khan, Paridon and Kim27 ), since they usually have a blunted heart response to exercise related to autonomic dysfunction, cardiac arrhythmias, and high use of chronotropic negative medication, like beta-blockers. Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko21 , Reference Reybrouck, Vangesselen and Gewillig30 However, some trials have shown that beta-blockers have beneficial effects in systemic right ventricular dysfunction, Reference Bouallal, Godart, Francart, Richard, Foucher-Hossein and Lions31 , Reference Doughan, McConnell and Book32 being the medication with the most supportive data for TGA patients with systemic right ventricle dysfunction. Medication with beta-blockers was presented in nine (20.5%) patients, which may be explained by a mean tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion of 14.6 ± 2.8 mm, and there was no relationship regarding the use of beta-blockers to the primary outcome. Additionally, a previous pacemaker implantation was performed in seven (15.9%) patients; however, all of them had a rate responsive function.
In our study, chronotropic incompetence was present in 24 (54.4%) patients, with a mean chronotropic index of 72.0 ± 20.6%. Chronotropic index had an area under the curve value of 0.802, with a value lower than 78% with high sensitivity (88.9%) but lower specificity (62.5%) for the primary outcome.
Other heart rate-related parameters (heart rate reserve; heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise) had shown prognostic importance in CHD patients. Reference Inuzuka, Diller and Borgia14 , Reference Mantegazza, Apostolo and Hager15 In our trial, heart rate reserve as opposed to heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise was a significant predictor of the primary outcome (p = 0.003 versus p = 0.053). Other parameters had higher values of sensitivity and specificity than heart rate reserve and heart rate recovery in the first minute after exercise, which could be explained by the confound effect of patients doing beta-blockers and with previous pacemaker implantation. Few patients (9.1%) were in atrial fibrillation.
Despite a previous trial showing that cardiorespiratory optimal point is a good predictor of all-cause mortality in adults, Reference Ramos and Araujo33 in our trial cardiorespiratory optimal point did not achieve statistical significance for the prediction of the outcome (p = 0.092). Likewise, the increase in PETCO2 until the anaerobic threshold is achieved (PETCO2 at anaerobic threshold – PETCO2 at rest), which was previously shown to have prognostic importance in heart failure patients Reference Guazzi, Arena, Halle, Piepoli, Myers and Lavie16 did not achieve statistical significance neither (p = 0.089). To the best of our knowledge, this was the first time that cardiorespiratory optimal point was assessed in a CHD population.
Uncertainty remains about managing systemic right ventricular failure Reference Winter, Bouma and Groenink8 and heart transplantation currently remains the only long-term life-saving procedure. Reference Filippov, Del Nido and Vasilyev4 Despite a number of confounders that are less relevant in heart failure, cardiopulmonary exercise test was able to predict heart failure events in this TGA population with systemic right ventricle. These confounders include a high number of patients with a respiratory exchange ratio lower than 1.05 (40.9%), which may favour the use of sub-maximal exercise parameters such as VO2 at anaerobic threshold rather than maximal effort-dependent parameters such as pVO2. However, when the Hanley and McNeil test was applied for comparing each area under the curve parameters, no statistically significant difference was found, which is not surprising since previous studies have already shown that the usual benchmarks for interpretation of respiratory exchange ratio may not have the same meaning in patients with CHD. Reference Glaser, Opitz and Bauer34
Study limitations
There are limitations to our study that should be referred when interpreting our results. This was a single-centre retrospective experience with only 44 patients, and therefore, the results can reflect local practice and might not represent other adult CHD centres. Despite being a small study, to the best of our knowledge, it is the first study addressing the use of cardiopulmonary exercise test to stratify the risk of heart failure events in TGA patients with systemic right ventricle alone without mixing other CHD and showed promising results for the use of cardiopulmonary exercise test to predict heart failure events in this population.
Mustard/Senning physiology and response to exercise may not be completely similar to cc-TGA patients despite having a systemic right ventricle, since atrial baffles cause a relative preload reduction during exercise when compared to cc-TGA patients. Reference Fratz, Hager and Busch35 However, the results would be similar if we only analysed the 36 atrial switch operation patients.
The primary outcome was a composite of cardiac death and heart failure hospitalisation. Although heart failure hospitalisation is not as important as cardiac death for the prognosis of the patients, heart failure hospitalisation is a major hazard for adult CHD patients and is associated with substantial costs and an amplified risk of subsequent mortality, Reference Diller, Dimopoulos and Okonko13 , Reference Moons, Siebens, De Geest, Abraham, Budts and Gewillig36 , Reference Kaemmerer, Fratz and Bauer37 so we used it to increase the percentage of the primary outcome since cardiac mortality was low in the mean 3-year follow-up (2.3%).
Each cardiopulmonary exercise test parameter was analysed for the area under the curve and the cut-off value so that the sum of sensitivity and specificity was maximised. However, some interaction between cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters cannot be excluded, and the results cannot be interpreted as if each cardiopulmonary exercise test parameter has a prognosis power that can be added to the predictive power of other cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters.
Several cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters had been related to the need to perform a truly maximum cardiopulmonary exercise test, as assessed by a respiratory exchange ratio >1.05. Reference Balady, Arena and Sietsema20 However, in our population, the respiratory exchange ratio was lower to 1.05 in 40.9%, so we decided to perform a sub-analysis for pVO2 in patients with a respiratory exchange ratio >1.05 which showed an area under the curve value of 0.829, no higher than the 0.838 achieved with all patients. Additionally, we used several parameters (VE/VCO2 slope, cardiorespiratory optimal point, and PETCO2 at anaerobic threshold – PETCO2 at rest) that do not need a maximal exercise cardiopulmonary exercise test to have prognostic power. Reference Guazzi, Arena, Halle, Piepoli, Myers and Lavie16
In a similar way, another sub-analysis was performed regarding VE/VCO2 slope excluding cyanotic patients, since previous studies have shown a lack of correlation between VE/VCO2 slope and prognosis in this group of patients, Reference Dimopoulos, Okonko and Diller26 , Reference Khan, Paridon and Kim27 with an area under the curve value of 0.703, no higher than the 0.713 achieved with all patients.
Conclusions
Patients with both TGA previously submitted to a Senning/Mustard procedure and cc-TGA have right ventricle working against systemic pressures, thereby rendering these patients to an increased risk for heart failure events. Heart rate at anaerobic threshold had the highest predictive power of all cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters analysed, with a value ≤95 bpm achieving a sensitivity of 87.5% and a specificity of 82.4% for the primary outcome. Additionally, in a way similar to heart failure patients, several cardiopulmonary exercise test parameters were able to provide prognostic information regarding heart failure events, suggesting that cardiopulmonary exercise test should be used in the routine evaluation of these patients as a prognostic tool.
Acknowledgements
We sincerely thank Centro Hospitalar Universitário Lisboa Central for the opportunity to perform this study.
Financial Support
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Conflicts of Interest
None
