Disease is political. It is not possible to separate disease and politics. Add race to the story and the result is a disturbing illustration of the disparities of health both within and between countries. Samuel Kelton Roberts offers a fascinating history of how tuberculosis, racial politics and ideologies combined with fear and cultural stereotypes of race to shape the story of Baltimore's public health in early twentieth-century America. He describes the indisputable links between racial segregation of housing and the high death rates amongst African Americans in a New South city. Whereas many stories of tuberculosis emphasize the importance of antimicrobial therapies in eradicating the disease, Roberts argues that in Baltimore slum clearance was more important. To illustrate this point, Roberts highlights the importance of place when analysing the health history of African Americans, particularly urban space and racial ghettoization. Integral to the tuberculosis story is the politics of Jim Crow public health and medicine, namely racism.
Roberts begins his story with an excellent chapter explaining the historical epidemiology of tuberculosis, as well as how black populations have interacted with the disease. Within this, racial science dominated the direction and conclusions of tuberculosis researchers. He then skilfully entwines racial science within the context of tuberculosis epidemiology and politics in Jim Crow America, highlighting the importance of political change in shifting the engrained racist emphasis of public-health officials. Next, Roberts analyses the importance of place in producing certain health conditions and social relations. He demonstrates how the rapid industrialization of the late nineteenth century intensified certain population densities. This, in turn, created huge areas of poverty, overcrowding, poor sanitation, and the associated factors that contributed to high disease rates in these areas. This, in turn, became the lens through which politicians and public-health officials viewed the problem. The political and economic geography of Baltimore created a “lung block,” which became the environmental paradigm that influenced a public-health policy of surveillance and institutional care, as well as the public-health rationale for slum clearance. Political decision-making and public-health policy surrounding the “white plague” was underpinned by racial stereotyping, especially assumptions of black ignorance, and ignored black leaders' arguments for housing reform. During the twentieth century, the friction between black and white leaders over housing issues increased, despite some progress and cooperation in public-health education efforts. Eventually, Baltimore politicians and public-health officials realized that segregation would not work and that it impacted the city's public health. They finally began demolishing poor neighbourhoods in 1929, with more demolitions to follow. Yet it was 1940 before the city began building replacement low-rent housing. Meanwhile, throughout this entire period, those who suffered from tuberculosis, as either victims, relatives or neighbours, constantly and quietly adjusted their lives to cope with the effects of the disease.
Complete with illustrations, figures, maps and tables, Roberts's well-researched monograph provides a solid contribution to research on health disparities. It provides another chapter in the story of racial politics and health alongside Keith Wailoo's Dying in the City of the Blues: Sickle Cell Anemia and the Politics of Race and Health. While some readers might find the numerous statistical descriptions of racial differences within Baltimore hard going, and, indeed, tables might have strengthened the statistical analysis, Roberts tells an important story. Furthermore, he highlights how the historical roots of health disparities need further investigation as past narratives could benefit future public-health policy.
