Ioan Grillo, a veteran Mexico-based reporter on organised crime, provides an in-depth look at gun trafficking in and from the United States. Engagingly written, thoughtful in tone, and stunning in its breadth, Blood Gun Money: How America Arms Gangs and Cartels is perhaps his most ambitious book yet. It examines how the illicit weapons trade developed, how it fuels criminal violence in the Americas, and why law enforcement has struggled to contain it. This is fundamentally a story about gun trafficking – its sources and methods, its economics, its regulations and policing. But Grillo's quest to understand firearms violence, and its ramifications and its solutions, also leads him to explore how it touches the lives of perpetrators and victims. The twelve-chapter book takes readers on a journey to Europe, the United States, Mexico, Honduras and Colombia. Drawing on dozens of interviews with smugglers, dealers, agents, activists and survivors, it illuminates different angles of the black market in guns: technology, industry, drugs, conflict, enforcement and culture.
A crucial part of the volume concerns the perplexing politics of US gun culture, which has helped forge the country's labyrinthine firearms legislation. The loopholes and restrictions in the laws allow an illicit weapons trade to flourish. Key to the debate is the Second Amendment to the US Constitution, which protects the right to keep and bear arms. The clause has been variously interpreted as applying either to a regulated militia or to everybody. Grillo scrupulously discusses the arguments for and against stricter weapons control. Both gun safety advocates and gun rights supporters include moderate and extreme elements. Reformers range from those championing simple measures that keep firearms away from killers to those that seek the repeal of the Second Amendment. The gun rights movement, on the other hand, unites people desiring weapons as a pastime, for sport, for self-defence or due to political beliefs. Those who hold radical positions, and dominate the politics of gun culture, include the grassroots and the National Rifle Association. What began as a post-US Civil War club of hobbyists practising marksmanship has, since the 1970s, transformed into a militant group that resists any gun laws and promotes a ‘gun lifestyle’ in the media. As Grillo's fascinating portrait of the NRA reveals, the lobby's tremendous influence also stems from its committed membership: dedicated single-issue voters who will punish gun reform-minded politicians.
A central concern animating the book is the role of firearms in criminal violence, particularly the resolution of disputes in illicit drug markets. The author illustrates this relationship with a visit to Baltimore, a homicide hotspot and established centre for street-level drug sales. The city's open-air drug market constitutes a striking contrast to the heavily policed narcotics trade in Mexico and further south. Grillo explains how local dealers, operating out of Baltimore's many impoverished neighbourhoods, obtain and use guns to enforce their drug profits. The broader discussion addresses the measurement and reduction of violence, although it might have appraised more explicitly the challenges in such efforts. The journalist recognises that murders are but one important indicator of violence and that in a city as racially segregated as Baltimore it is low-income districts, particularly their young, male residents, which are especially vulnerable to violent deaths. Two ideas would have been worth exploring, however, in respect of the Latin American context: one relates to gang truces and other negotiated agreements that may ease law enforcement pressure and provide a temporary respite in violence, without diminishing the insecurity and terror associated with the presence of armed groups; the other concerns community activism and the work of former gangsters-turned-peacemakers. Grillo considers these violence prevention workers as playing an essential part in helping end the bloodshed. He cites the Los Angeles-based non-governmental organisation Homies Unidos, directed by a former MS-13 gang member, as one prominent example. Individuals with ‘street knowledge’ are often deeply committed and uniquely suited to assisting others in staying out of violence and drugs. But they may lack legitimacy among police officers and face stigma and rejection in societies loath to give resocialised offenders a second chance.
Mexico, it seems, has borne the brunt of the violence that illegal firearms trafficking enables. In a terrible irony, army soldiers tasked with stopping criminals can be found selling weapons to them. As well as documenting corruption in the security forces, the writer trains his gaze on the country's ongoing drug war. The militarised strategy aimed at dismantling the drug cartels prompted the latter to diversify their criminal portfolios, going as far as to incorporate the smuggling and kidnapping of irregular migrants. The painful account of this ongoing offensive focuses on its human cost: the thousands of murders and disappearances that have been committed with impunity, and a justice system that is so broken that the families of the missing take it upon themselves to locate them. Grillo notes that the militarisation has progressively increased. However, he makes little of the political point-scoring that these symbolically powerful deployments permit nor of the half-baked attempts at police reform that justify the continued military participation in the fight against organised crime. In Honduras, where street gang violence is hurting, killing or displacing people in marginalised urban areas, the journalist interviews a sicario (hitman) about his victims and modus operandi. The minutiae of shootings and decapitations make for the most distressing section in the book, but they reveal the depth of the violence engulfing much of Latin America as well as the perpetrators’ own traumas.
Blood Gun Money can be read as a tribute to the victims of actual or threatened gun violence. It concludes by identifying modest measures that would stem firearms trafficking, recommending drug policy reform (based on the principle of harm reduction), and insisting on social work to steer disenfranchised youths away from the gangster life. Grillo is aware of the political obstacles but believes that sustained collective action can make these ambitions a reality. He has produced a formidable, hugely insightful book that should prove of interest to researchers, policymakers and lay readers interested in crime and violence in the Americas.
