This is an ambitious book. It aspires to give an account of virtually all aspects of David Ricardo’s work as well as the political and economic background to his writings, personal influences, the changing reception of his ideas, and the relevant secondary literature. The inclusion of background influences is to be welcomed, as is the depiction of Ricardo as an intensely practical political economist whose work was motivated by a desire to engage with the political and economic problems of the time. Also to be commended are King’s recognition of the failure of Ricardo’s work to gain widespread support after his death, and his treatment of Ricardo’s “monetary” writings and his social and ideological orientations. In other respects, however, the book suffers from doctrinal partiality, reluctance to engage with central interpretative issues, mistaken attributions, and a level of exposition that would render some topics, such as the treatment of “value,” incomprehensible to readers who are not already apprised of the issues.
King’s interpretation follows the established “Sraffian” line that the early Ricardo analyzed distribution in terms of a single-product “corn model.” Untroubled by the fact that there is not a single surviving example of this “model” in Ricardo’s extant writings, as attested by Piero Sraffa himself, King declares confidently, “For the most part … in his early work Ricardo used the ‘corn model’ to evade the question of value” (p. 73), as if there cannot be any serious doubt on the matter (cf. pp. 59, 210). Granted, the existence of some dissenting literature is mentioned, but it seems to be only the “evidence” adduced by King and other “Sraffians” that merits detailed consideration (see pp. 206–208). Any appearance of “balance” is an illusion.
No less of an illusion is the notion that Ricardo’s Essay on Profits of 1815 contains a “corn model”: as stated by Ricardo, half the capital employed by an individual at the outset of the analysis is said to consist of “fixed capital, such as buildings, implements, &c.” (Works IV, p. 10). Yet, according to King, who is perhaps mesmerized by Ricardo’s valuation of agricultural capital in terms of corn, the Essay contains “tantalizing indirect allusions to the corn model” (p. 206). Indeed, so taken is King with his own perception of the Essay that his account of Ricardo’s theory of distribution is based on “the clearest model that [Ricardo] ever produced of his economic system as a whole” (p. 61): not the “model” in the Principles, as one might reasonably expect, but, remarkably, the one tabulated in the Essay on Profits. However, for all of Ricardo’s “clarity” in the Essay, it then transpires that he was “not consistent in his use of terms” and that his tabular analysis “is not fully specified.” Helpfully, King is on hand “to make some additional assumptions in order to present a complete and consistent version of his [sic] model” (p. 62): a model in which Ricardo’s own valuation procedures are tendentiously erased and in which King imposes his own, entirely gratuitous interpretation of what Ricardo meant by an “increase of capital” (far from being “silent on this question,” as King asserts, Ricardo states explicitly that an “increase of capital” means an increase in the wheat/corn value of using “more labourers, horses &c.” [Works IV, p. 13]).
With Ricardo’s “model” of distribution now identified with King’s wheat-denominated tabular creation, it comes as no surprise to find the labor theory of value accorded an almost cursory treatment. Indeed, having convinced himself of Ricardo’s belief in the precedence of “distribution” over “value,” King finds himself at a loss to explain why “On Value” should have been Ricardo’s first chapter (pp. 72–73): a bizarre pseudo-puzzle that serves as a fitting reductio ad absurdum to his own interpretation. Then, in spite of an earlier promise to point out “some very significant revisions” to the third edition of Ricardo’s Principles, King chooses to omit any discussion of the extensive changers to the chapter “On Value,” instead basing his account entirely on the version in the third edition. By adopting this strategy, he deprives the reader of insights to a remarkable episode in Ricardo’s intellectual journey, to the central place that the labor theory occupied in Ricardo’s theoretical system, as well as to the profound influence that Robert Malthus had on the evolution of Ricardo’s thought (something that Sraffians seem loath to acknowledge, perhaps because it might detract from Ricardo’s iconic status). To make matters worse, in one instance where Malthus is singled out for attention, he is unaccountably confused by King with John McCulloch (p. 79; the reference should be to Works IX, pp. 103–104, not pp. 393–394). Ricardo did not end up criticising Malthus “for advocating a simple labour theory,” and to claim otherwise is to betray a radical incomprehension of the subject matter.
Other problems with King’s interpretation include an inability to determine if Ricardo held an “optimistic” or “pessimistic” view of Britain’s economic prospects (King vacillates between both positions); a failure to notice Ricardo’s misunderstanding of Adam Smith (on the meaning of “utility” and the “real measure of exchangeable value,” for example); a statement of Ricardo’s trade analysis that treats “the monetary advantages of international trade” as separate from “comparative advantage” (it is only through the pursuit of absolute monetary advantage that the benefits of comparative advantage are realized); an endorsement of the erroneous view that Ricardo neglected the “compensation effects” on labor employment from the introduction of machinery; the curious representation of John Stuart Mill’s treatment of Ricardo as some kind of “precursor” to later “neoclassical” (mis-)interpretations; and, admittedly of far lesser importance, the depiction of this reviewer as an erstwhile supporter of Sraffa’s interpretation (in a 1981 review), who was “soon to change his mind on these matters” (p. 206): a quite startling revelation, entirely without foundation.
There may well be a case for publishing a book that gives a balanced account of Ricardo’s life and is accessible “to students of economics and the interested layperson” (as stated on the back cover). But this is not that book. Granted, King does at least alert the reader to the existence of non-Sraffian interpretations but, in the end, his account is decidedly partisan. Students and interested laypersons should beware.
