No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Carl Ernst and Bruce Lawrence have drawn from their many years of research on Islamic mysticism to produce a groundbreaking work on Chishti Sufism in South Asia. The book examines the Chishtiyya in the subcontinent not simply in terms of its historical development and influence, but also as “a complex of spiritual practice, historical memory, and ethical models” that has been engaged in a continual process of evolution (p. 1). From this point of departure, the book seeks to dispel the hermeneutics that have long dominated the study of mystical Islam of a “golden age” of Sufism, its subsequent decline, and its contemporary revival.
As a corrective to most Western Orientalist research, which has concentrated on the 13th and 14th centuries as the “classical” period, Ernst and Lawrence use an expansive arsenal of sources dating from the 13th to the 20th century. Many of these sources have long been considered “spurious” and thus unworthy of serious academic investigation. However, adopting this approach has enabled the authors effectively to demonstrate several things. First, they illustrate some of the major disparities between Western Orientalist research and the Chishti literary tradition. While the former has tended to link the ebb and tide of Chishti development to the vicissitudes of Mughal political fortunes, the latter has suggested that Chishti Sufism continues to evolve and expand, remaining much more dynamic than most scholarship has conceded. Chapter 1 lays the foundation for this central argument, drawing from some of the very dialectical concepts found in Sufi thought and practice—fanā

and baqā

, love and knowledge; shari

a and ṭarīqa, the structure of the orders and the anti-structure represented by antinomian dervishes—to illustrate some of the contradictions inherent in characterizing the Sufi lineages and their representatives. Second, the authors reveal in chapter 2 how the Chishtiyya both embodies and transcends its Indian and Islamic identities, especially through ritual practices like samā

and dhikr. Third, they illustrate in chapters 3–6 that linear historicizations of the Chishti lineages, masters, and shrine cults have created a misleading picture of Sufism's development. Instead, the authors look to a variety of Chishti sources to devise a “synthetic portrait of the recurrent paradoxes of sainthood” (p. 71), despite the acknowledged difficulty of definitively assessing the shape and character of the Chishti literary tradition. Fourth, they illustrate some of the ways in which the Chishtiyya has remained responsive to the needs and concerns of the times. Chapter 7 takes up this subject by looking at how Chishtis today have appropriated technologies such as lithographic print, the Internet, sound recordings, television, and film to spread the influence of particular lineages and to promote ideals that are global in scope, such as the marriage of spirituality and science.
Ernst and Lawrence argue that the history of the Chishtiyya is better understood as a series of five cycles that represent a “comprehensive restaging of those major periods within which the patterns of piety and practice distinctive to them emerged” (p. 14). The first two cycles, which unfolded in the pre-Indian phase (7th–12th centuries), can only be reconstructed from fragmentary information contained in later literature and for this reason do not receive much attention. Rather, it is the last three cycles (12th–21st centuries), which occurred in the Indian subcontinent, that are the focus of this study. These three cycles are particularly important for understanding the multiple roles that genealogies have played in Chishti spirituality. For instance, they have operated as an organizing mechanism for Sufi lineages, as a means of authenticating the past and linking the present to it, as a way of (re)organizing the Islamic past and its meaning for particular lineages (since the genealogies often contain stories of Muslim exemplars who were not mystics), and as instructional and edificatory materials for those who pursued the Sufi path, sought to do so, or sympathized with those who did.
The book's exclusive reliance on texts obscures some important facts. For instance, several statements reinforce the perception that women are noteworthy only in their connections with major male saints (pp. 86, 90, 122). Much of the available information about saintly women is based on popular legends, and there is admittedly little written about them in Chishti literature. Yet those who do appear in such works as the Akhbar al-akhyar deserve more than a passing mention. Bibi Fatima Sam's shrine was frequented by many of the prominent Sufis of Delhi, such as Nizam al-Din Auliya. Besides in the Akhbar, she is mentioned in the collection of Nizam al-Din's discourses, Fawa

id al-fu

ad. Outside the Chishti literary tradition, evidence suggests that saintly women were sometimes considered de facto shaykhs. The biographical Mirat al-kaunain and the discourses of Sharafuddin Maneri, Khwan-i pur ni

mat (both Firdausi Sufi sources) mention women who were popularly referred to as shaykhs. And despite the authors' statement that women could not become khalifa (a type of successor) of shaykhs, some Chishti sources mention women who did. One notable example is Bibi Hafiz Jamal, Mu

in al-Din Chishti's daughter, who appears thus in the Dalil al-

arifin, composed in the 13th century by Mu

in al-Din's disciple Qutb al-Din; the Siyar al-aqtab, a 17th-century work by Allah Diya Chishti; and Bazm-i sufiya, the 1970 work by

Abdurrahman Sabah al-Din. Aside from this oversight, the book paints a rather homogeneous portrait of Wahhabi reformers that does not acknowledge the problematic nature of the term and its application or the fact that, among such reformers, there was never a consensus on the permissibility (from an Islamic legal point of view) of such practices as pilgrimage to the tombs of Sufi saints.
Undoubtedly, Sufi Martyrs of Love is the most important study of the Chishtiyya to emerge in recent years and should be part of the collection of serious scholars of Sufism. Particularly helpful is the list of death dates for saints important in the Chishti lineage, which appears in the appendix, and the extensive bibliography at the end of the book. Although this work is best suited for the specialist, graduate students and even upper-level undergraduate students will find it illuminating, and thus it should be part of the collection of research libraries.