For All of Humanity is a book about epidemic diseases, pregnant bodies, and the attempts by the Spanish colonial state at controlling them in eighteenth-century Central America. In Few's able hands, however, this seemingly straightforward history is merely the background for a rich examination of the encounter between a number of Mesoamerican ‘gendered, ethnic, and hybridized knowledges’ (p. 18) and Western medicine as articulated through the enlightened apparatus of eighteenth-century Spanish imperial policies. Few's book demonstrates how different ‘complex New World cultures’ present in eighteenth-century Mesoamerica created, engaged with and put in practice ‘medical knowledges, technologies, and practices’ of multifarious origins in the region (p. 12). Few shows how a variegated group of historical actors from all Atlantic origins became immersed in complex processes of exchange, circulation and adaptation of medical practices and knowledge to distinctively fashion eighteenth-century Guatemalan public health policies. These dynamics, Few argues, cannot be easily analysed under old models of centre–periphery – a conclusion that fits squarely within the results of the revisionist historiography of global histories of science and medicine that has come of age in the past two decades. Thoroughly researched, For All of Humanity uses a large documentary array – that includes medical manuals and registers, ecclesiastical sources, criminal trials and newspapers, among others – to examine a series of ‘informal settings’ for health practices outside traditional medical spaces. Few's multi-layered analysis allows her to uncover processes of exchange and knowledge-making that spanned the local, the imperial and the global and where historical actors easily jumped across the supposed divide between medical/scientific and religious practices and beliefs.
Few acutely shows the multiple ways in which ‘indigenous, religious, gendered, and local medical cultures’ (p. 16) influenced and shaped metropolitan European medical beliefs and practices in the Atlantic. Besides that of books, pamphlets (many of them produced regionally) and manuscripts, Few shows that it was the movement of material culture, human beings and other biota, through unexpected sylvan, terrestrial and oceanic routes that allowed for the articulation of the specific type of medicine that came to define eighteenth-century health practices in the region. More to the point – and herein lies Few's main contribution – For All of Humanity shows that the modelling of health practices and policies in Central America occurred on the basis of a type of relationality that had long been in place in Spanish colonial spaces by the eighteenth century. Such linkages were framed around bodily and spiritual networks that channelled disparate interactions between ‘male and female Spanish, casta, black, and indigenous scientists, physicians, healers, and lay persons’ (p. 13) in Mesoamerican cities defined by their ethnic pluralism and in highland Maya towns.
Starting in the sixteenth century, For All of Humanity begins with an examination of the history of epidemic disease in Mesoamerica, and the impact that pestilence had on everyday life, relationships and societal structure – particularly in indigenous groups. Chapter 2 explores the interactions, mostly acrimonious, between colonial medical officials and local communities during medical campaigns to eradicate pestilence. In the following chapter, one that – it must be said – is not fully articulated with the epidemic diseases-centred narrative of the rest of the book, Few expertly analyses the introduction of legislation requiring post-mortem caesarean sections for all deceased pregnant women in the Audience of Guatemala in 1785. Few uses this evidence to highlight the gendered links between bodily control, disease and violence in Spanish colonial spaces in the Americas. The penultimate chapter focuses on smallpox outbreaks in the late 1790s in southern New Spain and Guatemala and the response of colonial anti-smallpox officials. In this section, Few describes how colonial administrators and medical officials engaged and negotiated with indigenous communities and their leaders in the midst of epidemic-control campaigns marked by forced inoculation, extensive quarantines and the enacting of militarily enforced boundaries. The final chapter examines the arrival in Central America of Edward Jenner's vaccine in the famous Spanish Royal Maritime Vaccination Expedition. More to the point, Few shows how, besides the central vaccine Junta, a diverse array of health practitioners, including lay ‘aficionados’, used human smallpox, cowpox and similar pustular materials to engage with experimentation and contribute to that massive vaccination effort. Vaccination campaigns, Few shows, were marked by a continued significant mistrust among local indigenous communities, places where strong native medical cultures were still present and thriving by the eighteenth century.
I have only two minor complaints about Few's excellent book. First, I would have expected a more explicit engagement with a growing scholarship on the history of health practices in colonial Latin America that has been interested in similar processes of encounter between Western medicine and indigenous or African groups in the Caribbean, New Spain, Peru and the New Kingdom of Granada, among others. Second, in her use of methodologies firmly rooted in cultural and post-colonial histories from South Asia and Oceania, Few can sometimes miss the nuances of the multiple identities and complex labelling of colonial actors in Latin America. This is not necessarily Few's fault, and is, rather, a reflection of the relative under-theorisation of the field of medical and scientific histories in the region during the colonial period. For instance, the fascinating case study of the ‘sacred geography’ of Maya caves she explores in Chapter 2 could have been richly examined using methodologies developed by scholars who during the past decade have reframed histories of knowledge production on the basis of Amerindian ontologies from Central and South America.
In conclusion, Martha Few's For All of Humanity is a solidly researched and rich contribution to the history of global health practices, and the history of colonial Latin America. This book vividly reminds us that to fully understand the multiple cultures of modernity arriving in Spanish colonial spaces we need to pay close attention to the bodily vicissitudes of the occupants of these lands. Few proves that is no longer possible to elucidate the interrelationship between colonial medicine and the politics of global health without first paying close attention to the myriad ways in which indigenous communities locally shaped the practices of medicine and colonialism.
