In January 1969, a full-page screed by the radical group Up Against the Wall Motherfucker—the Motherfuckers for short—appeared in Rat Subterranean News, an underground newspaper published on New York's Lower East Side.Footnote 1 “The Reclaiming Project,” as the piece was called, concerned a conflict between the Motherfuckers and Bill Graham, impresario of the Fillmore East, the Lower East Side's most important rock venue. Since September 1968, the Motherfuckers had confronted Graham repeatedly to demand that he grant “the Community” free access to the Fillmore.Footnote 2 Negotiations culminated in violence on 26 December 1968, when one of the Motherfuckers’ sympathizers slashed Graham's face with a bicycle chain as Graham attempted to block the Fillmore's entrance during a performance by Michigan's MC5.Footnote 3 In “The Reclaiming Project,” the Motherfuckers justified their actions:
Out of our experiences emerge A CULTURE / A PEOPLE / A VISION / Which have attracted the media / the money / A New Business is born: the business of stripping life from our culture and selling the husk / And they try to tell us the husk is the whole fruit and now the musicians who used to play for us play for them and money and plastic week-enders. Spaces where we found each other, danced stoned, dug lights, and moved now turned to ‘Music Palaces’ where the dead sit specticalized [sic]. WE WANT IT ALL BACK.
The Motherfuckers concluded with a vague threat: “WE WILL TAKE WHATEVER IT TAKES TO STRENGTHEN OUR COMMUNITY IN ITS STRUGGLE / THE RECLAIMING PROJECT SPREADS TILL LIFE ITSELF IS OURS.”
The Motherfuckers found defining their terms unnecessary, but readers today might wonder: whose “Community”? Who were “we”? Although the Motherfuckers’ “Community” was, in the broadest sense, the counterculture of the mid-to-late 1960s, “The Reclaiming Project” refers more locally and literally to the Lower East Side's community of recently arrived young bohemians. During this period, several urban districts in the United States populated by marginalized ethnic groups—San Francisco's Haight-Ashbury and Detroit's Warren-Forest, for example—witnessed an influx of white middle-class youth who attempted to remake society and themselves against a backdrop of inner-city grit and decay.Footnote 4 Rock, as the form of expressive culture most central to these communities, became a signifier not simply of countercultural values, but more precisely of the experience of living in such urban neighborhoods, often called slums. In rejecting outsiders who commodified and consumed rock, the Motherfuckers’ “Reclaiming Project” also argued for the authenticity of the counterculture's presence in a marginalized neighborhood.
In this article, I focus on the Lower East Side and the Fugs, one of the neighborhood's most influential bands, to explore the role of bohemian slumming in the creation and reception of 1960s rock. First, however, it bears noting that slumming was associated with a divergent range of musical approaches across the United States. White bohemian rock musicians in San Francisco and Detroit, for example, identified to varying degrees with African American urban culture, developed musical styles that drew heavily on black music from blues to soul to avant-garde jazz, and linked their musical tastes (if sometimes naively) to black political movements. San Francisco's Jefferson Airplane paid tribute to the Black Panther Party by posting a sign on the front of their Haight-Ashbury house reading “Eldridge Cleaver Welcome Here.”Footnote 5 John Sinclair, manager of the MC5, argued that “we ourselves are developing a culture that has as its most exciting aspect … its commonness with the blues culture, black culture, in that our music at its best is a direct expression of the people who make the music, first, and of the whole people out of which the musicians emerge.”Footnote 6 Lower East Side rock musicians, in contrast, drew little overt musical influence from their neighborhood's ethnic communities, which included eastern Europeans, Puerto Ricans, and African Americans. Rather, Lower East Side musicians were fascinated with the concept of the slum itself as a more abstract signifier of authenticity, adventure, and nonconformity. This conception of the slum enabled bohemian musicians to pursue what Barry Shank, in his influential work on the Austin rock scene, calls “the performance of new, sometimes temporary but nevertheless significant, identities.”Footnote 7
The notion of a poor or working-class neighborhood as a stage upon which the more privileged can craft a new identity has a long history. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the verb “slum” was first used as early as 1860 to mean “to go into, or frequent, slums for discreditable purposes.” The noun “slumming,” defined as “the visitation of slums, esp. for charitable or philanthropic purposes,” appeared in 1884. As these competing definitions suggest, slumming has long been an ambiguous practice that combines titillation, condescension, and moral uplift. Several recent studies of slumming examine this ambiguity. Historian Seth Koven, who addresses Victorian London, uses the word “to refer to activities undertaken by people of wealth, social standing, or education in urban spaces inhabited by the poor.” As he points out, however, “slumming,” like “slum” itself, had no commonly accepted meaning and served various political and cultural agendas during the Victorian era: “charity and philanthropy mingle with immoral pursuits and voyeuristic curiosity in these definitions, which refuse to be definitive.”Footnote 8 Koven argues that for Victorian philanthropists, slums served as “stages upon which they enacted emancipatory experiments in reimagining themselves.”Footnote 9 Literature scholar Robert M. Dowling identifies a similar desire for self-transformation among slummers in New York between 1880 and 1930. Drawing on the work of Chicago School sociologist Robert E. Park, Dowling describes slums as “‘moral regions,’ definable areas that the larger society imagines are characterized by deviant social behavior.”Footnote 10 Such regions attracted privileged but disenchanted elites who hoped to make a break with mainstream society. The values of mainstream society are tenacious, however, as Chad Heap demonstrates in his work on slumming in early twentieth-century New York and Chicago.Footnote 11 “White middle- and upper-class New Yorkers and Chicagoans began to embrace slumming,” he writes, “not only as a means to ground the changing popular conceptualization of race and sexuality in particular urban spaces but also as an opportunity to shore up their own superior standing in the shifting racial and sexual hierarchies by juxtaposing themselves with the women and men they encountered on their slumming expeditions.”Footnote 12 In other words, slumming paradoxically broke down barriers of race, class, and sexuality while also reinforcing the notion of a fundamental moral and cultural difference between privileged white slummers and debased slum-dwellers. This body of scholarship suggests that slumming, whatever its motivation, normally reveals more about slummers than about the so-called slum itself.
We might be inclined to call participants in the 1960s counterculture bohemians rather than slummers—after all, they lived and often worked in impoverished urban neighborhoods rather than occasionally dropping in for a glimpse at how the other half lived. The line between bohemianism and slumming, however, is often more blurry than self-styled bohemians would like to admit. As Heap points out, early twentieth-century bohemians’ “excursions to the cities’ red-light districts and slums often differed little from those undertaken by more obvious slummers”; moreover, the literature and art that bohemians produced “further stimulated popular interest in slumming.”Footnote 13 The result was that bohemians both practiced and publicized slumming and themselves became objects of other slummers’ interest, as wealthy urbanites “exchanged the rough-and-tumble atmosphere of the cities’ working-class amusements for the more fanciful, if still ramshackle, basement and alleyway nightspots of bohemia.”Footnote 14 Urban bohemians of the 1960s contended with a similarly nebulous role as newcomers aspiring to fit in as authentic locals rather than mere tourists. Rock became an important medium through which the counterculture examined and negotiated the ambiguous relationship between bohemianism and slumming.
I propose that a “slum aesthetic” was central to the creation and reception of rock music on the Lower East Side. By focusing on slumming and taking the Fugs as a case study, I intend to shed new light on the broader question of rock's vexed relationship to politics. As the Lower East Side's musicians sought both radical social change and a large audience, they represented their neighborhood in ways that combined thoughtful engagement with broad caricature, a contradiction that inspired both musical creativity and social tension.
We Are Our Music: The Lower East Side Rock Scene
By 1966, recently arrived participants in the counterculture had transformed the Lower East Side (or the “East Village,” as its northern section was increasingly called) into what journalist John Gruen termed a “New Bohemia.”Footnote 15 Some of the new arrivals opened psychedelic shops, bookstores, and coffeehouses. They also founded underground newspapers including the East Village Other (or EVO) and Rat Subterranean News, whose title suggests its reporters’ fascination with urban squalor. A lively music scene flourished in the neighborhood throughout the mid-to-late 1960s, including avant-garde jazz clubs such as Slug's (or Slugs) Saloon (which began featuring jazz in 1966); rock clubs such as the Electric Circus (opened 1967) and the Dom (opened ca. 1964); and eventually larger rock venues, among them the Anderson Theatre (which began featuring rock in 1968) and the Fillmore East (opened 1968).Footnote 16 A significant, if less formal, music venue was Tompkins Square Park, where bohemians hung out and played guitars and hand drums. The park also featured occasional rock concerts.Footnote 17
The Lower East Side's cheap rents exerted a strong pull on the counterculture. Ed Sanders, poet and co-founder of the Fugs, recalls that “living expenses were tantalizingly low during those years when the World War II rent controls were still firmly in place, so a person could become obsessed with a creative project for a couple of weeks, then surface to scrounge for rent and electricity for a few days, succeed, then dive back to the art.”Footnote 18 Just as significantly, the Lower East Side's image as “the symbolic antithesis of postwar suburban society” drew bohemians.Footnote 19 The neighborhood's reputation “as both marginal and (perversely) alluring” dated to the turn of the twentieth century, when photographer Jacob Riis exposed the filth of its tenements and writer Hutchins Hapgood celebrated “the everyday culture of immigrants.”Footnote 20 Sanders was attracted to the neighborhood's longstanding tolerance of nonconformity. The Lower East Side, he writes, “had been discovered over and over for two hundred years by the beaten-down, the broken, the rebellious, the radicals, the socialists, the anarcho-syndicalists, the suffragettes and feminists, the Trotskyites, and in our time by the bards and pot-heads, the jazz hips, those into psychedelics, and those just passing through on the way to the gold-paved streets of the American Dream.”Footnote 21 Sanders hoped to help make the neighborhood what he called “Goof City, a city of freedom for all to relax, where poverty was banished and wealth truly shared.”Footnote 22 This sense of possibility encouraged bohemians to endure the less romantic aspects of the neighborhood. Sanders writes that “the Lower East Side in the 1960s, before the ultra high rents and the gentrification, WAS a slum, with garbage-strewn sidewalks, apartments without adequate heat, and certain blocks you learned not to walk down day or night. There was police corruption, and plenty of junkies trying to break into pads.”Footnote 23
Bohemians of the 1960s often argued that they were simply the next wave in the Lower East Side's long history of immigration. Allan Katzman, editor of the East Village Other, wrote in 1966 that the neighborhood was “a slum occupied by divergent groups: Puerto Rican, Negro, Ukranian [sic], Russian, Polish, Hassidim, Beatnik, Artist, Creep, Bar Fly, Bum and Policeman.” Its newest arrivals, the bohemians, sought refuge “from the New World of broken lives, broken homes and broken myths.”Footnote 24 In 1967, EVO writer Lionel Mitchell conflated the backgrounds and motivations of the neighborhood's disparate residents: “People are here in the East Village because they could no longer make it in Harlem or Poland or Russia or Eastern Europe or Suburbia or Puerto Rico or what have you.”Footnote 25Rat reporter Margie Stamberg explained in 1968 that the Lower East Side housed four main groups of “ghetto-ized people”: “Puerto Ricans, Blacks, Hippies, and Ukrainians.”Footnote 26 In another article Stamberg claimed dramatically that “the Lower East Side is a jungle. And if you live down here, you are an outlaw, baby.”Footnote 27 The solidarity between bohemians and other local communities implied by such rhetoric was occasionally realized at such events as the Tompkins Square Smoke-In, a pro-marijuana rally that attracted a “mixed group of hippies, Puerto Ricans, Negroes, and straights” on 23 July 1967.Footnote 28 Sanders remembers that although “every group tended to leave other groups alone. … there was great cross-cultural mingling of groups in the many bars of the Lower East Side during the 1960s. The Ukrainians of course had a church, and a big presence on, say, East 7th between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. I used to wear flowered Ukrainian shirts at early Fugs shows I had made by an Ukrainian seamstress in the L.E.S.”Footnote 29 In 1968: A History in Verse, Sanders describes Tompkins Square Park as a place “where all the races, cultures and factions came together / There was very little open strife.”Footnote 30
In contrast, art historian Rosalyn Deutsche has argued that the “democratic public sphere” is rooted in “conflict, division, and instability,” and that “the very notion of an undivided social space is irremediably deceptive, constituted by disavowing plurality and conflict.”Footnote 31 Other accounts of relations between bohemians and other locals contradict Sanders's description of a placid, tolerant neighborhood. Sanders's own memories also include “a kind of Puerto Rican street gang on East Tenth near my bookstore. I had friction with one member because I refused to allow use of my tools to repair a zip-gun.”Footnote 32 Sociologist Christopher Mele writes that “despite the ‘Gentle People’s’ platitudes of inclusiveness and identification with the Lower East Side locals, differences between the old-timers and newcomers were apparent.”Footnote 33 In Mele's account, Tompkins Square Park was divided into segregated sections by “hippies, white ethnics, and Latinos” and thus represented not peaceful coexistence but rather “a microcosm of the neighborhood that clearly signified the social and cultural distance between the three dominant groups.”Footnote 34 In 1967, the New York Times quoted a coffee shop cashier who “sighed deeply and said: ‘This park is last thing we needed. This was such quiet neighborhood before. Calm, quiet. Polish, you know.’”Footnote 35 Concerns over control of the park led to violence on 1 June 1967, when “a melee broke out between the hippies and a crowd of Puerto Ricans and Negroes who hurled bottles and debris on the hippies and sought to strip one young woman of her clothes.”Footnote 36 In his first-hand account, novelist Ronald Sukenick claims that a disagreement over music sparked the conflict: “I was in Tompkins Square Park listening to some live music from the bandshell when a hip-rock group came on and started playing. Right away the Puerto Ricans in the crowd clutched their heads and started yelling bloody murder. Wha kina noise's this? They call this music? Pretty soon a few bottles hit the stage. Local conga drums struck up a loud counterpoint. The kids pulled up several oil drums and started pounding on them with sticks to drown out the musicians.”Footnote 37 Police reinforcements were called in to quell the incipient riot, a teenager was arrested, and a thrown bottle injured a policeman.Footnote 38 Divergent feelings toward bohemians sometimes led to unpredictable ethnic alliances. The Times reported that “it seems … many Negroes don't mind the white, hirsute bongo drummers in Tompkins Square Park, and some Lower East Side Slavs side with Puerto Ricans in harassing hippies.”Footnote 39
Some bohemians hurt by such hostile reactions to their cultural expressions and their very presence in the neighborhood declared themselves more authentic Lower East Siders than longer-standing residents. Emmett Grogan, best known as a founder of San Francisco activist group the Diggers, describes a Lower East Side community meeting at which hippies complained that “Puerto Ricans and blacks were prejudiced against them solely because of their long hair and life-style, making them the country's ‘new niggers.’”Footnote 40 Such presumptuous claims of oppression offended the hippies’ neighbors, who often resented middle-class, predominantly white bohemians for assuming “voluntary poverty” in what historians have called a “fantasy ghetto.”Footnote 41 Grogan writes that “the sight of a pair of well-fed hippies walking through the neighborhood, panhandling change against a backdrop of desperate bleakness may have appeared farcical to strangers, but to the people who lived their entire lives in the area, grew up there, it was a mockery, a derisive imitation of their existence and it got them angry.”Footnote 42 In his 1968 book The Hippie Trip, sociologist Lewis Yablonsky quoted a “non-hippie cab driver who lived in the neighborhood” as saying “We have to live in this shit. They don’t. I don't understand these young punks.”Footnote 43
The counterculture sometimes attempted to defend their legitimacy as Lower East Siders by glorifying their preferred music, rock, as a genuine expression of the streets. This claim may seem surprising because, as the so-called “Tompkins Square Riot” revealed, many locals actively disliked rock. Bohemians pointed out, however, that rock performances often pitted neighborhood residents against unsympathetic city authorities. At a 1966 Fugs concert in Tompkins Square Park, for example, police cited noise complaints and then a purported bomb threat in order to make the band stop playing and submit to a search.Footnote 44 In a more abstract sense, the counterculture saw rock as an authentic cultural expression that belonged to them in the same way that jazz or blues belonged to African Americans. Michigan's John Sinclair, for example, argued that blacks had shown white radicals “how music can be a first term in people's lives … how a whole culture can be built up on a strong musical foundation, and how the music can sustain a whole people and keep the [sic] together under the most oppressive conditions, as the blues and its later variations had sustained black people all those years.”Footnote 45 In New York, this belief was expressed most dramatically by the Motherfuckers, who published a series of manifestos in Rat insisting that rock was a form of folk culture rather than a commodity. One such statement declared that “music is in the people / & the people are in the streets / Move to the natural rythms [sic] / Move to the rythms inside / WE ARE OUR MUSIC.”Footnote 46 In an advertisement for a free “COMMUNITY FREAK OUT” at Fillmore East scheduled for 9 October 1968, the Motherfuckers proclaimed that “THE SEATS BELONG TO THE PEOPLE” and added that “IT SHLD BE FOR FREE ALWAYS FOREVER AND EVER BUT FOR NOW WE’LL TAKE ONE NITE.”Footnote 47 On October 22, the Motherfuckers disrupted events at the Fillmore by bringing their mimeograph machine on stage and printing a flyer asserting that “Bill Graham, hippie entrepreneur … may tonite have been a little liberated, or he may not” and demanding “One Nite a Week [of free admission for “the community”] or the Sky's the Limit.”Footnote 48
This rhetoric paralleled that of contemporaneous black critics such as Amiri Baraka, who argued that African American music and culture had been appropriated and marketed by whites.Footnote 49 As Peter Doggett points out, “the sky's the limit” was a phrase borrowed from the Black Panthers, who employed it as a threat during their “Free Huey Newton” campaign.Footnote 50 The distinctions between an African American musical heritage rooted in a long history of oppression and the culture of a self-selected community of disaffected, mainly white youth rarely entered into the rhetoric of the Motherfuckers or their supporters. Rat reporter Ken Pitchford, for example, wrote: “as quoted by the New York Times, Graham previously considered us Lower East Siders to be ‘pus.’ Now he talks about the ideals of a new generation and tries to imply that he thought we were beautiful all along. This is precisely the same change in tone that came over whites when they first discovered that blacks meant business—from nigger to Negro overnight.”Footnote 51 Nor did the Motherfuckers address the uncomfortable fact that the rock musicians prized by the counterculture were often the same musicians accused of theft and inauthenticity by Baraka and other black commentators. In his influential 1966 essay “The Changing Same (R&B and New Black Music),” Baraka asked “finally, what is the difference between Beatles, Stones, etc., and Minstrelsey [sic]. Minstrels never convinced anybody they were Black either” and dismissed the Fugs and other groups as “white kids playing around.”Footnote 52 Emulating the seriousness and intensity of black protest demanded that the Motherfuckers overlook or conceal such contradictions. Drawing on a romantic identification with black political rhetoric, the Motherfuckers and their allies argued that rock was the expression of an entire culture and thus belonged collectively to all members of that culture, so that its marketing was a form of theft.
Perhaps what bohemians found most threatening about rock venues as visible as the Fillmore East, however, was that they threatened to make the counterculture itself the object of slumming. The Motherfuckers neatly summed up this concern with accusations leveled at the police, whom they personified as the “cop-pig”: “He successfully defends the uptown freaks, their tourist buses, the stores they spend their money in, and their cars. The fat tourists come down fondeling [sic] their fantasies and we give them the finger. They are in our space. We live here.”Footnote 53 Comparatively high ticket prices at the Fillmore made many Lower East Side residents feel excluded. EVO critic Jules Freemond complained in April 1968 that “the audience at the Fillmore is looking more and more like an upper-Eastside shopping tour.”Footnote 54 The Electric Circus, which even the far-from-hip Life magazine described as “Non-Toxic Psychedelia for Squares,” was a particular target for scorn.Footnote 55 According to the Village Voice, antipathy toward the club began on its opening night, when “several hundred locals—hippies and East Europeans—stood behind police barriers” as “a variety of Beautiful People types who probably never had to stand on line for anything before in their lives” were admitted into the club for the high price of $15 each (the evening was a benefit for the Children's Recreation Foundation).Footnote 56 In 1969, Liberation News Service reporter Mark Kramer exhorted readers to “walk down St. Marks Place in the East Village and dig the crowd on either side of the velvet rope which separates those with the bread ($10 a couple) to get into the Electric Circus from those who beg spare change to buy a knish.” Kramer argued that “street people … made the culture which the rich fops imitate.”Footnote 57
Although such rhetoric implied a clear distinction between the counterculture and the so-called “hip capitalists” who marketed rock on the Lower East Side, more reflective bohemians sometimes questioned their role in the neighborhood. The Motherfuckers’ violent Fillmore East protest spurred soul-searching and accusations in the underground press. Several observers noted that the counterculture was only one part of the greater Lower East Side community. An East Village Other editorial asserted that “it is time the community at large, which the Motherfuckers claim to speak for, make their own lifestyles felt. I propose a board representing various members of the community; from Negroes to Puerto Ricans, to Ukrainians, to Hippies, Yippies and Motherfuckers. … Let them run the free nights at the Fillmore East.”Footnote 58 The Motherfuckers responded in a letter: “what the hell has EVO ever done for the Ukes, the P.R.s, and the Negroes on the Lower East Side?”Footnote 59 In an impassioned letter to John Sinclair, poet Marilyn Lowen Fletcher wrote that she “was following closely the happenings at the fillmore, etc.” and explained:
the lower east side is an exploited community. the resident blacks and puerto ricans used to despise the hippies—those voluntary poor folk who always seemed to get let off by local police supt. SGT. Fink for little things like grass while the tercer mundo brothers were getting their heads opened by Sgt. Fink's boys for walking the streets they were born and grew up on. Naturally, the natives are pissed when out of town white musicians who are MAKING it come into their territory that they have struggled and yes BLED for without wanting to join with them or understand them—only to ENTERTAIN them.Footnote 60
These discussions reveal that many Lower East Side bohemians recognized that the utopian dreams of such groups as the Motherfuckers, like the rock culture represented by the Fillmore East, held little relevance for many of their neighbors. Such arguments remained largely confined to the bohemian community, however, and EVO's vision of a multicultural advisory board for the Fillmore East was never realized.
Although the Lower East Side's musicians were famous for political activism, they tended to focus on nationally significant issues including the Vietnam War and drug legalization, and the local concerns they addressed emphasized the interests of the counterculture. The Fugs, probably the most politically engaged Lower East Side rock band, are a case in point. Members of the group served on the advisory committee of the New York City League for Sexual Freedom and the steering committee of LEMAR, the New York Committee to Legalize Marijuana.Footnote 61 Between 1967 and 1969, the band played benefits for local countercultural causes including the Community Defense Fund, the Community Breast (which raised money for the pro-marijuana group the Provos and other organizations), listener-supported radio stations WFMU and WBAI, the New York Free Press, and the New York High School Student Union.Footnote 62 In August 1967, the band concluded a performance in Tompkins Square Park by marching with the audience to the West Street House of Detention to protest the arrest and beating of Provo Dana Beal earlier that day.Footnote 63 Occasionally, the Fugs took on problems that affected the entire neighborhood. Drummer Ken Weaver, for example, reportedly mailed his sooty snot to Consolidated Edison each morning to protest the pollution from its nearby power plant.Footnote 64 In general, however, bohemian protests did not target the condition of the Lower East Side as a whole.
The Fugs, Dirt, and Amateurism
As dedicated and widely publicized promoters of the Lower East Side, the Fugs provide a useful case study in an examination of slumming in 1960s rock. Their “slum aesthetic,” I argue, comprised three interrelated facets: first, a strongly (if sometimes ironically) stated pride in their neighborhood; second, a fascination with dirtiness, both literal and metaphorical; and third, an unapologetically amateurish approach to musical performance. As these traits were profitably marketed, a contradiction arose in which the band's commercial success seemed to run counter to the slum aesthetic that had inspired their work.
The Fugs, who derived their name from the euphemism for “fuck” that Norman Mailer's publisher required him to use in his 1948 novel The Naked and the Dead, were founded in December 1964 by poets Ed Sanders and Tuli Kupferberg.Footnote 65 Sanders, who grew up near Kansas City and moved to New York to attend New York University in 1959, had already become a key figure in the Lower East Side's literary scene through his “offbeat local entrepreneurship,” to borrow a phrase from art historian Reva Wolf.Footnote 66 From 1962 to 1965, Sanders edited, mimeographed, and distributed a literary journal entitled Fuck You / A Magazine of the Arts, which published his own work and that of many up-and-coming Lower East Side writers as well as better-known figures including Allen Ginsberg and LeRoi Jones (later Amiri Baraka).Footnote 67 Sanders's open defiance of censorship and his dedication to what literary historian Daniel Kane labels “a very serious if entertaining vision of a libertarian pansexualism” led to his arrest on obscenity charges in a well-publicized 1966 bust.Footnote 68 Sanders also contributed to the literary community as the proprietor of the Peace Eye Bookstore. The store sold poetry, underground comics, and books on drugs, sex, music, vegetarianism, politics, and religion; it also contained a “Marijuana Research Library,” a gallery that presented the work of local painters and sculptors, and a “leaflet production center” where local organizations (including the Motherfuckers) could use mimeograph machines.Footnote 69 During 1967, Sanders opened the bookstore to “the ‘community’,” some of whom set up a “Mattress Meadow” on the floor and used it as a nightly “space to crash.”Footnote 70
Tuli Kupferberg, born in 1923, was a generation older than many of the Lower East Side's “New Bohemians” and recalled that his political awareness began during the Great Depression when he witnessed unemployed New Yorkers living in “shanty-towns” in Central Park.Footnote 71 Sanders, born in 1939, remembers that he already “knew Tuli as a Beat hero” when they first met in 1962.Footnote 72 Kupferberg, who lived “in the building next to the Peace Eye Bookstore, above the Lifschutz wholesale egg market,” became a regular contributor to Fuck You beginning with a 1962 issue in which he presaged the Fugs’ intertwined themes of sex and politics with the satirical poem “Pacifist Primer” and the openly erotic “6996th Psalm.”Footnote 73 The Fugs soon added a third member, drummer Ken Weaver, an Air Force veteran from El Campo, Texas who had recently moved to the Lower East Side and met Sanders after hearing that he needed help collating and stapling Fuck You.Footnote 74 Sanders, Kupferberg and Weaver, working with a shifting lineup of backing musicians, comprised the core of the Fugs until the group disbanded in 1969.Footnote 75
The Fugs made their debut at the Peace Eye Bookstore's “grand opening” on 24 February 1965.Footnote 76 For almost three years thereafter, the band were fixtures of the lower Manhattan rock scene, performing regularly at such venues as the Bridge Theatre, the Café Au Go Go, the Astor Place Playhouse, and the Players Theatre on MacDougal Street, where they appeared frequently from the summer of 1966 to the end of 1967.Footnote 77 During this period, they released three albums on local independent labels: The Village Fugs Sing Ballads of Contemporary Protest, Point of Views, and General Dissatisfaction (Broadside, 1965), The Fugs (ESP-Disk, 1966), and Virgin Fugs (ESP-Disk, 1967). In 1967, Sanders appeared on the 17 February cover of Life magazine with a caption describing him as “a leader of New York's Other Culture,” and early the next year the Fugs released Tenderness Junction, their first album on the major label Reprise. Later Reprise albums included It Crawled into My Hand, Honest (1968), The Belle of Avenue A (1969), and Golden Filth (recorded in 1968 at the Fillmore East and released in 1970).Footnote 78
The Fugs were proud Lower East Siders who celebrated their neighborhood in compositions dating from “Slum Goddess,” the first track on their first album, to the title song of The Belle of Avenue A.Footnote 79 The band's publicity materials commonly drew attention to their residence. A Fugs press release from around 1966 touts Sanders as “a captain of Lower East Side industry” and proclaims that Kupferberg “commenced extra-uternic existence in New York City's Lower East Side.”Footnote 80 Another press release from around the same time explains that “THE FUGS are an emanation or projection of the culture of New York's lower east side, utilizing its literary and artistic heritage combined with the energy of the civil rights and peace movements.”Footnote 81 Critics and reporters drew similar connections between band and neighborhood. In 1967, the fan magazine Freak Out, U.S.A. reported that Ken Weaver “has written a number of the boisterous, expressive songs that most vividly project the slumy [sic], lower-echelon, creepy culture of New York's East Side, including such immortal tunes as Slum Goddess.”Footnote 82 A 1968 feature on the Fugs in the magazine Avant-Garde claimed dramatically that “home for the Fugs is lower Manhattan's East Village, the ghetto that Eddie Cantor, Jimmy Durante, and Lucky Luciano left for other climes over 50 years ago and that now is inhabited by cockroaches, rats, hippies, and immigrants who never made it to Park Avenue.”Footnote 83 It is clear from these sources that the Fugs were widely understood as representatives of their neighborhood as a whole.
Given the Lower East Side's long history as a center for Yiddish (and often left-wing) theater and music, it is perhaps surprising that the Fugs did not emphasize Kupferberg's Jewish heritage to a greater extent.Footnote 84 Kupferberg had grown up on the Lower East Side when it was a cultural center not only for its Jewish residents but also more generally for the Jewish population of the New York metropolitan area.Footnote 85 Other than an occasional sly reference, however, as in a fan club newsletter declaring September 28 “the glorious anniversary of the day Tuli Kupferberg refused to be Bar Mitzvahed,” the Fugs drew little overt attention to Kupferberg's ethnicity.Footnote 86 Kupferberg compositions such as “The Ten Commandments” and “Nothing,” however, sometimes drew on eastern European Jewish tradition; Sanders later credited him with bringing “the shtetls, the keening sensitivities of Hasidic music” to the group.Footnote 87 “Nothing” takes its melody and the form of its text from the Yiddish song “Bulbes,” the lament of a narrator whose diet consists entirely of potatoes.Footnote 88 Kupferberg's original text, however, is an enigmatic meditation on nothingness that seems to question the value and perhaps the existence of such cultural touchstones as scholarly disciplines, Beat poets, and even the days of the week. Sanders suggests that the song may have been influenced by the nihilistic pronouncements of Louis Aragon's “Manifesto of the Dada Movement.”Footnote 89 “The Ten Commandments” seems to parody both Jewish cantorial singing and the grandeur of Elmer Bernstein's score for Cecil B. DeMille's hugely popular 1956 film of the same name.Footnote 90 Another song that nods toward eastern European (if not specifically Jewish) influence is “Morning, Morning,” which according to critic Richie Unterberger is “adapted from the folk song ‘Morgen, Morgen’”; the precise source is probably “Morgen,” which, recorded in German by the Croatian singer Ivo Robić, reached no. 13 on Billboard's U.S. pop chart in 1959.Footnote 91 Although the two songs are distinct in form and melody, “Morning, Morning” begins with a melodic phrase almost identical to the opening of “Morgen.”
The press sometimes depicted Kupferberg through the lens of Jewish stereotypes. In the New York Review of Books, Elizabeth Hardwick claimed that he “look[ed] like some obscene Yeshiva student,” while Cavalier's Jack Goddard typecast Kupferberg as a man “whose doleful beard and moanful baritone evoke every wailing Jew in history.”Footnote 92 (The photograph of Kupferberg accompanying Goddard's article, however, shows him smiling exuberantly at the camera.) In Rolling Stone, Robert Greenberg wrote that the Fugs’ recording of “Hare Krishna” “displays the sextet's uncanny ability to make every chant sound like a Jewish cantor.”Footnote 93
Rather than emphasize their ethnic connection to the Lower East Side, however, the Fugs focused instead on the neighborhood's reputation as filthy and seedy. Publicity photos showed them standing on piles of rubble or leaning against walls covered with graffiti, and the cover of their album Golden Filth depicts an alley full of overturned trashcans.Footnote 94 These images, like Weaver's Con Ed protest, demonstrate a simultaneous fascination with and repulsion toward dirt and grime that has long been a feature of slumming. (Seth Koven describes Victorian philanthropists for whom “immersing themselves in the dirtiness of the slums was a literal and symbolic act of independence and adventure.”Footnote 95) The Fugs often presented themselves as literally dirty, with hair that was unkempt and clothes that were ragged even by bohemian standards. Hardwick, reviewing a 1966 performance at the Players Theater, wrote that “Ed Sanders in dirty black cotton pants, a horrible white plastic vest, dirty red scarf, matted hair, holding a mike with a cord, is some sort of parody of all the MC's of history.”Footnote 96
Another connotation of “dirty” is “obscene,” and the Fugs’ songs often employed profane and openly sexual language. The Fugs were well known for gleefully lewd songs including “Coca Cola Douche” and “Wet Dream” that led critics to compare them favorably to taboo-smashing comedian Lenny Bruce and also triggered a secret obscenity investigation conducted by the Department of Justice and the FBI.Footnote 97 By 1968, Sanders's stage patter had become a surreal parody of pornography. Introducing “Slum Goddess” at a 1968 Fillmore East concert, Sanders described the title character as “lying down in viscid, skooshy strands of cherry Jell-O, buttocks popping in arpeggios of lust. … She is as horny as a heathen. Her dildo is made out of a petrified tapir snout.”Footnote 98 During the Fugs’ heyday, even self-consciously hip, unflappable listeners felt obliged to comment on the band's obscenity, if only to proclaim their own comfort with it. A 1970 Rolling Stone cartoon responding to the exceptionally crude Golden Filth (which includes the version of “Slum Goddess” just cited) showed a crowd of disgusted hippies with their backs turned to the band, captioned “really, kids, didn't we know it all along. … the Fugs are just plain dirty!”Footnote 99
The Fugs’ obscenities were intended to amuse and shock, but they also served a deeply felt political agenda. Like many members of the counterculture, the Fugs believed that sexual repression and other social evils were linked and that by freeing their bodies people could also free their hearts and minds. Ken Weaver explained in 1968 that “we cut out the hypocrisy,” and Sanders added, “we could sing double-entendre songs, the kind disc jockeys play all over the country…We could make a quick fortune that way. But that's compromise. Fucking is fucking, and that's what we call it.”Footnote 100 Kupferberg, who was influenced by radical Freudian Wilhelm Reich and taught “courses on the sexual revolution” at the Free University of New York, published essays and poems in EVO arguing that “the [Vietnam] war is pathology. … & the Pathology is Sexual Pathology! … THOSE WHO WILL NOT LOVE WILL KILL.”Footnote 101 According to Hardwick, the Fugs’ performances illustrated that “to be clean and well-dressed and concerned about homosexuality or four-letter words: that is the real madness. It is not free sex, but free speech they celebrate: dirty words, dirty feet, laughter.”Footnote 102 In 1966, Fugs fan Shelly Rosenzweig wrote a letter to EVO explaining that “I always thought that foul language (be that as it may) was only for the gutter, but through EVO, and the Fugs and Allen Ginsberg, I have found that the use of ‘loose language’ can also serve a needed purpose in getting across a very important or hard to get across point.”Footnote 103
The Fugs’ “loose language,” as Rosenzweig suggests, tied them to a longer tradition of bohemian New York poets that stretched back through Allen Ginsberg and the Beats all the way to Walt Whitman, whose frank treatment of sexuality led to censorship and accusations of “intolerable coarseness.”Footnote 104 Ginsberg was a particular inspiration for the Fugs, who condensed Howl, his famous evocation of urban angst, into the incongruously upbeat “I Saw the Best Minds of My Generation Rock.”Footnote 105 (Kupferberg is mentioned in Howl as the person “who jumped off the Brooklyn Bridge” and survived.)Footnote 106 In his liner notes for the Fugs’ second album, Ginsberg proclaimed that “the United States is split down the middle. On one side are everybody who make love with their eyes open, maybe smoke pot & maybe take LSD & look inside their heads to find the Self-God Walt Whitman prophesied for America. … People in there think sex body loves are bad—I say make love to them. They need it most.”Footnote 107 Ginsberg later performed “Hare Krishna” with the Fugs on Tenderness Junction. The band's close connection to Ginsberg reflected a shared commitment to glorifying human sexuality and pushing the boundaries of publicly acceptable expression.Footnote 108
Unlike Ginsberg, who was known for celebrating gay male sexuality, the Fugs promoted an ideal of sexual freedom that was at times contradicted by sexist objectification of women. “Supergirl” (1965), for example, describes the ideal woman largely in terms of the services she can provide for the narrator, as a “girl” who can “fuck like an angel” and “cook like the devil.”Footnote 109 Introducing the song at the Fillmore East in 1968, Sanders reduced the “supergirl” to a collection of body parts and sexual talents: “She has the mouth power of an industrial vacuum cleaner. She's able to break brass bolts with her vaginal scrunch. … Who is she? She is supergirl, supergash, supervulva.”Footnote 110 The Fugs’ dirtiness was underpinned in part by a naïve idealism that failed to account for the gender politics of sexual freedom. Contemporaneous critics sometimes noted the inconsistency between such rhetoric and the gentle utopianism of much of the Fugs’ music. Reporter Martin Cohen wrote in 1968 that Sanders was “strangely bothered when I note that the Fugs seem to ridicule women.” Sanders responded “sometimes it seems that way … but we’re not tearing women down. I think what we are trying to do is take them off the sexual pedestal. On the overall, I have a holy view of the woman thing. As a matter of fact, I believe in a feminine universe.”Footnote 111 Although this explanation is unconvincing, it suggests that, among other objectives, Sanders sought to undermine a double standard that typecast women as asexual. Daniel Kane, discussing the obscene and often sexist language in Sanders's journal Fuck You, argues that Sanders's work exhibits “inherently liberatory and satirical impulses behind what might otherwise be received as typically sexist or oppressive.”Footnote 112 Sanders himself has since renounced the sexist values of “lazy hippie slobs and useless louts who viewed women as hookers, lookers and cookers,” and wrote recently that although the Fugs’ songs “were true to the testosterone-crazed era in which they were created,” “we might not now write them in quite the same way.”Footnote 113
Although the Fugs’ obscenity and sexism were products of their era, they sprang more specifically from a Lower East Side bohemia that included such groups as the Motherfuckers, whose name “could not be spoken in polite company,” and for whom the neighborhood served as a dirty backdrop for male fantasies of license and excess, sexual and otherwise.Footnote 114 As early as 1965, folk music promoter Israel Young described the Fugs as “deeply versed in the psycho-sexual ethos of Lower Manhattan's extreme East Side,” suggesting that open discussion of sexual preoccupations was a distinguishing characteristic of the neighborhood's culture.Footnote 115 In an unsparing recent memoir of his exploits as a Motherfucker, Osha Neumann (then “Tom Motherfucker”) describes an obsession with bodily taboos that he attributes to his repressive upbringing in a family of bourgeois intellectuals.Footnote 116 Neumann writes “for me, the Lower East Side was the anti-suburb…The streets were all stains and clutter. They smelled of piss, mildew, roach powder, and rotting garbage. Refuse and filth blanketed the empty lots.”Footnote 117 The Motherfuckers provided a way to turn dirtiness into a way of life: “Treating ‘no-trespass’ signs as invitations, shoplifting from supermarkets, turning over garbage cans, hurling muck and rocks and invective, I became a human dirt ball.”Footnote 118 Neumann's fixations informed his political activism and sexual identity in ways that disturbed him: “I worried … about the cruelty of my fantasies in which violence, including sexual violence, anger, and shit were identified with the forces of liberation.”Footnote 119 The Fugs differed from the Motherfuckers in important ways—they employed sly humor rather than angry invective, and they were explicitly opposed to violence—but their song texts and public statements reflect a similar notion of the slum as a place where obscenity might lead to liberation, political and personal.
The Fugs’ disheveled appearance and obscene rhetoric were mirrored by what could be called a “dirty” musical style. The band was, at least at first, brashly amateurish and seemed to demonstrate indifference to conventional notions of competence. Although there were, of course, many willfully unrefined folk singers in the Greenwich Village area during this era, the Fugs drew special attention for what Freak Out, U.S.A. approvingly called “crudity and nonconformity and an ‘anything goes’ philosophy,” a description that applies to the band's musical approach as well as the subjects they addressed.Footnote 120 In their celebration of unpolished cacophony, the Fugs participated in a larger movement in Lower East Side rock that included the shambolic performances of David Peel, the Godz, and the Holy Modal Rounders as well as the noisy avant-gardism of the early Velvet Underground.Footnote 121
The Fugs’ first album includes original songs on countercultural themes such as “Carpe Diem” and “I Couldn't Get High” as well as settings of poems by William Blake and Algernon Swinburne, most backed by straightforward melodies and chord progressions drawn from 1950s rock and roll, country music, and urban folk. Although the band demonstrates some basic musical proficiency, they are distinguished primarily by their amateurism. “Slum Goddess” features a notably out-of-tune electric guitar. “Carpe Diem” is marked by a more fundamental discrepancy in pitch: during the verse, the vocal harmonies oscillate between E major and A major, but the guitar plays a repeated E major–A minor progression. “Nothing” similarly juxtaposes a harmonica in E major with a vocal melody in E minor. Uncertain or badly timed vocal entrances are common. Sanders audibly hums to find his pitch before he begins singing “Ah, Sunflower Weary of Time.” Weaver begins the second verse of “I Couldn't Get High” two beats early, forcing the guitar and bass to alter the chord progression temporarily in order to catch up. Moreover, the instrumentalists themselves often play shaky grooves that fail to cohere rhythmically. Throughout “Supergirl,” for example, the band re-enters tentatively after the breaks separating verses from choruses and vice versa, as if they need to renegotiate the downbeat each time it returns.
The Fugs’ displays of amateurism sometimes seem intentionally humorous, as in “My Baby Done Left Me,” a raucous spoof of country music, and “Swinburne Stomp,” during which the band makes goofy sounds with a slide whistle and harmonica as Sanders recites from Swinburne's Atalanta in Calydon. Just as often, however, the Fugs simply sound under-rehearsed. The simplicity of the production, which involves no obvious overdubbing or other studio manipulations, adds to this effect, making much of the album sound as though it had been recorded informally in someone's apartment, or perhaps at a rehearsal by an interesting band not quite ready to perform in public. Sanders remembered: “we did one take only, as wild young men looking at each other. We didn't know that you were supposed to face the microphone.”Footnote 122 Spoken asides suggest that sloppiness was a point of perverse pride with the band. At the end of “I Couldn't Get High,” Weaver mutters “Well … blew that one.” In an outtake included in CD reissues of the first album, Sanders instructs the band “From now on, nothing holds us back. Cacophony forever.”Footnote 123 Sanders, looking back in 1993, argued that “the fact that Tuli and I, and later Ken Weaver, had not been educated at the Juilliard School of Music did not create any problems, because we had already been fully trained in that very informal but exacting institution one could call the Beatnik Academy of the Outlandish Spectacle, and we harnessed our aimless frenzy beneath the inspiration of folk music, jazz, Cantor singing, Stravinsky/Varèse/Cage, Left Wing union tunes, rock and roll, and the milieu of the Civil Rights and peace movements.”Footnote 124
By pulling this jumble of influences into messy, haphazard performances of songs that celebrated the Lower East Side and its countercultural ethos, the Fugs musically signified both the dirt and disorder supposedly characteristic of the slum and its residents’ ostensible resistance to professional standards. I have argued elsewhere that the “radical incompetence” displayed by the Fugs’ Lower East Side contemporaries the Godz reflected an important “facet of the 1960s’ counterculture: suspicion toward conventional values of technique and expertise.”Footnote 125 More specifically, “the Godz formed at a moment when New York's downtown bohemian scene cast itself as an authentic alternative to the glossy standards of commercial popular culture and the midtown entertainment industry.”Footnote 126 Like that of the Godz, the Fugs’ amateurish music rejected traditional conceptions of both show business and the bourgeois work ethic, highlighting instead playfulness and an apparent rejection of (or apathy toward) commercial concerns. Undisciplined performances evoked and celebrated the supposedly slovenly, squalid, but liberated and fun lives of slum-dwelling performers.
The Fugs’ amateurism was immediately attractive to the Lower East Side counterculture and its sympathizers. Peter Stampfel of the Holy Modal Rounders, who played fiddle at the Fugs’ first recording session, recalled: “that's one of the things that attracted me to them: the idea that they had no ability whatsoever, and it didn't matter.”Footnote 127 Writing in 1966, Jack Goddard claimed that at the band's first gig a year earlier, “as singers they made the most appalling noise since old Samson brought down the temple.”Footnote 128 The Fugs, rather than object to such portrayals, played them up with a humorous blend of self-deprecation and mock hubris. Sanders, advertising the band's debut performance in Fuck You, proclaimed that “these creeps barf from an unbelievable bag. There has never been any thing like the FUGS in the history of western civilization!!”Footnote 129 Goddard, although he acknowledged that the band had improved technically since 1965, maintained that “at its best Fugsound always had a doleful, amateur-night quality, and this people liked. It belonged with those loony lyrics. And it was one more way of flipping a big Fug finger at technically slick but shallow mass culture sounds.”Footnote 130 Many of the Fugs’ fans shared this view. Australian admirer Howard Greenberg wrote to the band that “your lack of professionalism and technical brilliance is compensated for a million times by the message gear [sic] you get out.”Footnote 131
Even as they drew bohemian audiences, the Fugs’ outlandish, messy performances also appealed to slummers seeking a titillating evening out, and the band's increasing popularity endangered their supposedly authentic connection to Lower East Side bohemia. As early as 1966, Israel Young worried that the band's message was getting lost. Young argued that the Fugs “claim to be a rebellion against our Puritan society, but they’re becoming a part of it. … This new audience they’re after is mostly kids so middle class they can't be reached deeply—kids who make a lot of noise about sexual or political rebellion but don't really do anything about it. For them the Fugs are just one more form of vicariousness, like beer busts or panty raids.”Footnote 132 The band appealed to this broader audience in part because, even as their words remained crude, their music was becoming more polished and professional. As Richie Unterberger points out, “the Fugs … were never dogmatic musical purists, rising to an appreciably higher level of sophistication and tautness than they’ve usually been given credit for, onstage and in the studio.”Footnote 133 Sanders realized that a tight, exciting rock group had the potential to reach a much larger audience than did poetry or more conventional folk music. In 1966, he told critic Richard Goldstein that “this is a rock generation. … We wanted to investigate the possibility of presenting radical philosophical ideas to adolescents before they have rigidified. That's why we’re in rock ’n’ roll.”Footnote 134 As early as 1965, Sanders fired guitarist Steve Weber (also of the Holy Modal Rounders) for unprofessional behavior during live performances, and by 1967 the band had adopted a set of “semisatiric rules for performances” including “6. performers should be prepared to play precisely at the minute scheduled for the show to begin, in tune, & on the stage” and “8. Perfection should be worshipped. Arrangements should … proceed thru slight & ever-improving modifications toward the Absolute Arrangement.”Footnote 135 “By the spring of ’68,” Sanders remembers, “the Fugs finally put together a stable and excellent band / I wanted an ensemble that / could play outdoors / in front of thousands / and deliver thrills.”Footnote 136
Sanders aspired to a similar level of discipline in the recording studio. By the time of their second album, the Fugs “wanted to get beyond tribal primitive in our recording techniques.”Footnote 137 Their later albums for Reprise took advantage of sophisticated production techniques and sometimes skilled session musicians. Tenderness Junction (1967) features gifted lead guitarist Ken Pine and carefully arranged and recorded performances. Its successor, It Crawled into My Hand, Honest (1968), runs a remarkable gamut of styles from Nashville country, complete with a string section (“Ramses II Is Dead, My Love”), to pseudo-medieval polyphony (“Marijuana,” a choral arrangement by jazz singer Bob Dorough). Although the Fugs’ music remained eccentric, it was no longer amateurish.
Sanders's desire to attract a large audience was, as Reva Wolf writes, “fairly common among ‘underground’ figures of the 1960s” and “had at its roots two distinct objectives: changing the world and achieving fame. These objectives, the one altruistic and the other self-centered, are seldom mutually exclusive, as both Sanders and [Andy] Warhol well understood.”Footnote 138 The tension between these competing objectives is fundamental to bohemianism, which since its beginnings in nineteenth-century Paris has involved what historian Jerrold Seigel terms “simultaneous repudiation of and hunger for wealth and the comforts of bourgeois life.”Footnote 139 Purists uncomfortable with such ambivalence about art's role in the marketplace took a negative view of the Fugs’ commercial success and visibility in the media. In 1967, Israel Young complained that the band seemed to be buckling to the profit-minded approaches of the corporate music industry:
I liked the Fugs better when they were just plain lousy as far as music was concerned and outrageous in all other matters. Now that they have a music director and set arrangements for songs, etc., they find themselves in the same class as the New Christy Minstrels, say, who also have to get new musicians every week and have to consider them as human beings. A studio drummer is replacing Ken Weaver on the recording session but guess whose face will be on the album cover. The cover will feature the founders of the group and not the musicians who made it possible for them to reach into new markets. This is normal for America but it shouldn't be so for avowedly anarchistic-like groups.Footnote 140
The ever-zealous Motherfuckers, Sanders recalls, were “mean to me, one of them accusing me at an early Yippie meeting of having a Swiss Bank account!”Footnote 141 A 1968 letter to the editor of EVO satirized both Sanders and his detractors: “The other day I duly swear by the Bible and by the memory of my mother (who was a saint) that I did see Ed Sanders with his white suede shoes get into a taxi on the corner of Ave. A and 14th St. … How dare he get into a taxi-cab!—being a pseudo-leftist, anti-bourgeoise [sic], anti-establishment, avant-garde, hippie, cool (he made the cover of LIFE), labor lover patron of the afflicted, patron of the arts, poet, writer, martyr, singer, musician, and everything else. How dare he take a cab?”Footnote 142 Sanders himself recalls an odd mismatch between his very recent show-business successes and the grimy Lower East Side: “with our second album on the charts and our shows sold out, we were treated to the eerie sensation of sudden fame. Though I lived in an apartment in a slum building, fans located it and hovered outside near the incredibly dingy ash cans and their squashed lids connected by chains to the cans.”Footnote 143
Ostensibly non- or anti-commercial musicians such as the Fugs walked a thin line between an authentic stance directed at a limited audience and mass popularity that threatened to undermine their original motivations. The Fugs managed this balance by maintaining a scatological, satirical tone even as their music grew increasingly professional throughout the 1960s. Their status as spokespeople for the Lower East Side counterculture eventually waned, however, even as the neighborhood itself entered a period of economic decline following the sensational coverage of the brutal 1967 murders of young bohemians Linda Fitzpatrick and James “Groovy” Hutchinson that established the neighborhood's notoriety as a “predatory ghetto” unsafe for middle-class whites.Footnote 144 It was not until the early 1980s that a new generation of bohemian artists and musicians dedicated to “transform[ing] poverty and ‘urban decay’ into the ingredients of a romantic bohemia” helped to spark a wave of gentrification that significantly altered the demographics and character of the neighborhood.Footnote 145
Considering the Fugs and the Lower East Side rock scene more broadly suggests that the narrow border supposedly separating slummers and bohemians during the 1960s was a site of creative energy as well as a battleground over issues of class, commerce and professionalism. If rock musicians and their bohemian audiences were rarely heroic representatives of the urban underclass, neither were they mere voyeurs who sought sleazy thrills in a disadvantaged neighborhood. Rather, they negotiated shifting positions between these extremes as they performed and experienced music. Understanding the enthusiastic amateurism, willful obscenity, and political engagement of 1960s rock challenges us to think more deeply about the very particular, local connections between popular music and cities. To listen for the slum aesthetic is to uncover the crucial ways in which the sound of rock reflects and informs the concerns of urban life.
