The governments of Kiribati and Fiji “should make every effort to minimise the difficulties of and inconveniences to this community which finds itself under two jurisdictions.”Footnote 1
Our younger generation have been taught that they also have another home. There are still two homes. That's their roots. That's where they belong.Footnote 2
1. Introduction
This article addresses an unexplored aspect of Pacific colonial history that has surprising, but important, implications for contemporary policy making: the legal consequences of cross-border community relocation. In 1945, the small Banaban community from Ocean Island in the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony (present-day Kiribati) was relocated to Rabi Island in Fiji. The community was granted considerable local autonomy within Fiji, and also retained special rights of entry, residence, and parliamentary representation in Kiribati, even if they were not citizens of that country.
The story is important for its own sake, but also for the lessons it provides about cross-border relocation generally.Footnote 3 It speaks to a rapidly growing body of research on mobility in the context of climate change and disasters, specifically on planned relocation as a form of adaptation to climate change.Footnote 4 It also forms part of the literature on the historiography of law in the Pacific,Footnote 5 and contributes to scholarship on Pacific colonial and transnational history.Footnote 6
The significance of the Banaban case study is that it reveals innovative responses to complex questions relating to legal status, in particular nationality and citizenship; access to and rights over land; and self-determination and governance. It enables a rethinking of the concepts of sovereignty, citizenship, and minority protection. It shows that although elaborate legal safeguards can help to ameliorate concerns about loss of identity, land, and control, they are unlikely to overcome them.Footnote 7 This is why relocation remains such a fraught option to this day.
There is a reluctant recognition in low-lying Pacific island states that at some point in time, international movement may be a necessary adaptation strategy to avoid the long-term impacts of natural disasters and climate change. Although the media has often portrayed this as requiring the mass relocation of whole populations, it is more likely that people will move gradually, and through regular migration channels where possible.Footnote 8 This is for several reasons: the absence of “spare” land for group relocation, differing perspectives on when movement is necessary or desirable, and the immense legal and practical challenges of re-establishing a whole community in another country.
Whether people migrate (at an individual or household level) or are relocated (with the intervention of the state), some common legal issues arise. Among these are nationality and citizenship,Footnote 9 and the extent to which the community can exercise a degree of self-determination and self-governance in the new location. The latter is particularly pertinent if a community is relocated from one place to another, but may also be relevant if large numbers of migrants co-locate in the new country (or join an ethnic community already established there).
To the extent that the long-term habitability of low-lying island states has been critically examined in international discussions on migration, the focus has often been on the need to secure alternative land elsewhere: for food and water security initially, and for migration in due course.Footnote 10 There has been a tendency to overlook important legal issues that migration scholars have noted from the start: that although land is obviously important, it offers no solution unless affected communities also have the right to enter and reside in the other country, enjoy their full range of human rights (including the right to work), and not be subject to expulsion.Footnote 11
This has been reiterated in recent intergovernmental consultations with affected Pacific communities. They regard relocation as an option of last resort precisely because of concerns that it would permanently rupture conceptions of home, land, and identity, and impact negatively on nationhood, sovereignty, control over land and sea resources, culture, and livelihoods.Footnote 12 For this reason, they have stressed that any relocation should: 1) define the legal status of the relocated community within the new state, 2) help communities adapt to local customs and laws, 3) include consultation with potential host communities, and 4) contain measures to facilitate the diaspora community maintaining cultural ties, such as allowing dual citizenship.Footnote 13
Mindful of these concerns, this article takes a historical approach to these matters by examining the unique governance and citizenship arrangements that were constructed in both Fiji and Kiribati for the Banaban community. Although the use of special statusesFootnote 14 and the “rule of difference”Footnote 15 were characteristic of British imperialism, the Banaban safeguards in the Kiribati Constitution were unprecedented in their protection of non-residents’ and (potentially) non-citizens’ rights to entry, land, and parliamentary representation. Similarly, the local autonomy granted to the Banabans within Fiji, especially during a period of fierce debate about Fijian paramountcy, was very significant.Footnote 16
It should be emphasized that the Banaban case provides an unusually “pure” example of cross-border community relocation because it involved the movement of almost the entire Banaban population, to an uninhabited island in another country (which meant they did not have to integrate with a pre-existing community).Footnote 17 By contrast, any future relocations are likely to involve partial movements to inhabited areas, and in most cases within countries, rather than across international borders. This is why the focus of most research and international discussions is on internal relocation; cross-border relocation is regarded as exceptional and highly complex. The particular legal safeguards that were created for the Banabans in Fiji and Kiribati, especially in relation to self-governance, were arguably possible because relocation was undertaken en masse to a relatively isolated location.
The article is structured in two main parts, centered on Fiji and Kiribati respectively. Part I provides a brief overview of the Banabans’ relocation to Rabi in Fiji. It then examines the governance structures that were established on Rabi to give the Banabans a degree of internal autonomy within Fiji, and the Banabans’ legal status in Fiji, including questions of citizenship. Part II shifts the focus to Kiribati, to examine the unique constitutional safeguards that were created to entrench the Banabans’ rights of entry to stay and parliamentary representation in Kiribati, including a right to dual citizenship. The final section of the article reflects upon the meaning of formal, “legal” identities vis-à-vis personal understandings of belonging and attachment, and what this may mean for relocated communities.
2. Methodology and Approach
This article is the first scholarly attempt to paint a comprehensive picture of the legal frameworks devised to protect the rights of the relocated Banaban community in both their old and new countries of residence. Although there is literature on the cultural, social, and economic dimensions of cross-border relocations,Footnote 18 little attention has been paid to these legal questions.Footnote 19
The analysis draws largely on the examination of official records housed in the national archives of Kiribati, Fiji, Australia, and the United Kingdom; the Papers of Henry Evans and Honor Courtney Maude, 1904–99 at the Barr Smith Library, University of Adelaide; and the colonial records of the Western Pacific High Commission (the British colonial authority responsible for Fiji and the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony, inter alia) held in New Zealand. These documents span the period 1900–86.Footnote 20 The archival records contain correspondence between the local Pacific colonial administrations (primarily the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony and Fiji), the Colonial Office in London, and the governments of Australia and New Zealand. They also include correspondence from Banaban representatives. The article also draws on parliamentary debates in the United Kingdom and Australia between 1908 and 1994.
In addition, the article reflects findings from 38 interviews conducted by the author in Fiji and Kiribati in 2012 and 2013. Interviewees in Fiji were members of the Banaban community living on Rabi or in Suva, including present and past political and community leaders. The youngest interviewee was 18; the oldest were Banabans in their 90s who had been part of the original relocation in 1945. In Kiribati, interviewees were past or present government officials. The article also draws on the sparse secondary literature relevant to the study, in particular the 1985 review of the Banaban provisions in the Constitution of Kiribati, which provides the only detailed analysis on that subject.
3. The Banaban Relocation to Fiji
A Background
The Banabans were the original inhabitants of Ocean Island (or Banaba), a tiny South Pacific island in present-day Kiribati. Ocean Island is located approximately 400 kilometers from the nearest island in Kiribati, and 300 kilometers from Nauru. This isolated high, coral island was discovered by the British ship Ocean in 1804 (from which it derives its English name). In 1892, the British proclaimed the Gilbert and Ellice Islands as a protectorate,Footnote 21 but did not include Ocean Island. However, when the British discovered high-grade phosphate on Ocean Island in 1900, they incorporated the island into the boundaries of the protectorate, and granted the Pacific Islands CompanyFootnote 22 the exclusive right to occupy the land to collect and export phosphate.Footnote 23 When the protectorate became the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony in 1915, Ocean Island was annexed. A subsequent Order in Council of January 27, 1916 formally included Ocean Island within the colony's boundaries.Footnote 24 Lucrative mining operations commenced on the island in 1900, and by 1909, the mining company was agitating for the Banabans’ removal.Footnote 25 Without an indigenous population (albeit only 476 people as of January 1, 1909),Footnote 26 phosphate resources could be exploited to the full.
The story of the Banaban relocation has been told in detail elsewhere.Footnote 27 For present purposes, it suffices to note the following. The British government was initially far more circumspect about the prospect of relocation than the mining company (or, indeed, colonial officials in the region). It stressed that the Banabans had a right to remain in their traditional homeland, and that any move would have to “operate entirely by way of inducement and not by compulsion.”Footnote 28 However, imperial interests ultimately won out: Ocean Island's extensive phosphate resources, which could produce high-quality fertilizers to stimulate agriculture and thus produce food for the Empire, took priority.Footnote 29 An article published in the Sydney Morning Herald in 1912 encapsulated the prevailing sentiment: “it is inconceivable that less than 500 Ocean Island-born natives can be allowed to prevent the mining and export of a produc[t] of such immense value to all the rest of mankind.”Footnote 30
In 1913, a trust fund, known as the Banaban Fund, was established “for the general benefit of Ocean Island natives, always having in view the purchase of another island in the Gilbert Group and the ultimate transfer of the natives to that island.”Footnote 31 In 1931, the Banaban Provident Fund was also established (from a portion of the royalty on exported phosphate) “for the purpose of the eventual purchase of a new island home for the Banabans.”Footnote 32
In a letter to the Colonial Secretary in London in 1919, Britain's resident High Commissioner for the Western Pacific, Cecil Hunter Rodwell, opined:
Is it better for them that they should be encouraged to remain where they are, utilising only the surface of their land, regarded—rightly or wrongly—as obstacles in the way of developing the wealth below it, surrounded by an advancing tide of scientific enterprise, and subjected probably to influences not conducive either to their social or to their moral welfare; or that some other place should be found for them, no less desirable save perhaps, on sentinmental [sic] ground than their present habitation, where their presence will be welcome and where they may profess unmolested and, subject to proper administrative control, on their own lines?Footnote 33
In March 1942, the British authorities purchased the freehold title of Rabi Island in Fiji on behalf of the Banabans, who became the beneficial owners.Footnote 34 Rabi had been owned by Lever Bros, an Australian company which ran a coconut plantation there. Officials noted that it would “probably be many years before the Banabans will be ready to migrate to Rabi Island,” and that “by that time different counsels might prevail and the migration might never take place at all.”Footnote 35 However, in December 1945, 703 Banabans (185 men, 200 women, and 318 children), accompanied by 300 Gilbertese friends and relatives,Footnote 36 were relocated to Rabi.Footnote 37
The Banabans characterize their relocation as “forced,”Footnote 38 likening their “exile” to the biblical exodus from Israel.Footnote 39 They did, however, raise the possibility of relocation themselves on two occasions: in 1920 and again in 1940.Footnote 40 They felt that they had a responsibility to secure land for the future “against the time when the phosphate deposits in that island [Ocean Island] will have been worked out and the island will, in consequence, have become largely uninhabitable,”Footnote 41 However, they stipulated a condition—accepted by the colonial authorities at the time—that “no sudden or wholesale removal would be resorted to at any period.”Footnote 42 Furthermore, any new location “was not to be regarded as a replacement for Ocean Island but rather as a second home.”Footnote 43
Ostensibly, the relocation in December 1945 was prompted by irretrievable damage done to Ocean Island when it was occupied by the Japanese during the Second World War (who deported most of the Banabans to other parts of the colony).Footnote 44 Rather than return the Banabans to an apparently uninhabitable island,Footnote 45 the British authorities encouraged a wholesale move to Rabi.Footnote 46 Having long regarded the Banabans as an “awkward obstacle” to the full exploitation of Ocean Island's phosphate resources,Footnote 47 it seems very likely that the postwar circumstances provided the colonial authorities with a convenient excuse to relocate them. They were told that their transportation, the cost of establishing their temporary camp on Rabi, and one month's rations would be paid for by the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony. If they chose to return after a two year trial period, then the colonial government would also cover the costs of transport back to Ocean Island.Footnote 48 Standard immigration, quarantine, and customs requirements were waived.Footnote 49
According to Banaban accounts, they were misled into thinking that they were moving to an established town with roads, cars, and two storey houses, where life would be easier than on Ocean Island.Footnote 50 On December 14, 1945, when the ship Triona arrived at Rabi, the women got “all dressed up: gold earrings, gold bangles, bracelets,” in anticipation of their disembarkation at a bustling town.Footnote 51 On arrival, however, they found no town and very few inhabitants, apart from some Solomon Islanders who had stayed behind to work on the old coconut plantations. “When we got here there was no proper housing, they were temporary shelters, not what we were promised,” explained Naomi Christopher, who was 15 years old at the time.Footnote 52 “It was nothing compared to what we were told,” said Tebwebwe Teai, who was then a child.Footnote 53 The Banabans had to live in canvas tents beside the beach, with only two months’ rations and little knowledge of how to cultivate the island and become self-sufficient.Footnote 54 Colonial documents from the period described Rabi as “a refugee camp,”Footnote 55 and in later years, the United Kingdom authorities admitted that the early conditions on Rabi were unsatisfactory with “inadequate housing and poor medical and educational facilities.”Footnote 56
B A Part of Fiji or Apart from Fiji?
In 1944, when relocation was mooted but no concrete scheme was yet in place, the High Commissioner for the Western Pacific noted that “[i]f the Banabans come to live in Fiji it must be as ‘Fijians’ and not as a foreign settlement.”Footnote 57 This revealed an expectation that the Banabans would integrate and not maintain a separatist enclave: “There has never been any idea on our part of any ‘extraterritoriality’ in connexion with this proposed Banaban settlement in Fiji—once we have transported them to the island and settled them in, our concern with them will cease; and they will immediately on arrival pass under Fiji jurisdiction. I do not know whether the Banabans think otherwise, but I propose that this point be made perfectly clear to them when the matter is reopened with them.”Footnote 58
However, a different attitude prevailed a year later when the relocation was being planned. Major Donald Kennedy, who was to brief and accompany the group (at their request) and become the first Banaban adviser, recommended that contact between the Banabans and the existing Fiji population should be “carefully watched.” He surmised that the Banabans would “probably wish to maintain a certain degree of aloofness or segregation of their own community until the Elders have had time to adjust themselves to a new environment and, if this should prove to be the case, they should be assured of Government co-operation in preventing indiscriminate contacts.”Footnote 59
The Colonial Secretary wrote to Fiji's Attorney-General intimating that the officers handling the Banaban relocation “had a vague sort of idea that the Banabans, by purchasing the freehold, had ‘annexed’ part of Fiji and would live there as a separate community.”Footnote 60 He noted that although it was “clearly desirable” to establish a Banaban local authority, Kennedy's recommendations could not be facilitated without an ordinance of some kind.Footnote 61 He also queried whether it was currently lawful for Rabi to operate as a “sort of closed area” on which only Banabans or certified persons could land.Footnote 62
A month prior to the Banabans’ arrival, Fiji's District Commissioner Northern noted that on a recent visit to Rabi and Taveuni (a neighboring island), he had been asked many questions about the Banabans’ pending relocation. One of the points on which he wanted more information was the “[r]elations between Fijian and others.”Footnote 63 Although he thought it appropriate to let the Banabans travel to other islands in Fiji, he proposed that such movement should be controlled by a system of travel permits.Footnote 64 Other officials thought it a mistake to impose such controls, especially because legally, the Banabans were “as free as any other resident of Fiji to roam from island to island at will.”Footnote 65 Harold Cooper, the chief of the Government Information Office for the Fiji Islands, argued that the Banabans needed to view Rabi “as a home and not a prison.” He thought it important for their longer-term integration that they be enabled to mingle with others living in Fiji: “They cannot remain forever a separate community, wrapped in a sort of geographical cellophane, and if they are to become happy and useful inhabitants of this Colony they must get to know, and to understand, the people who are to be their neighbours.”Footnote 66
In 1946, Harry Maude, at that time the Acting Resident Commissioner of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony, argued that a recent visit to Rabi had given him the distinct impression “that the fact that [the Banabans] were being compulsorily cloistered from the outside world, like the lepers on Makogai, was one of the principal factors behind their growing dislike of the place.”Footnote 67 He thought that in their own interests, they should be treated “in precisely the same manner as any other race in Fiji,” and for this reason, should have no special privileges either (such as having their repatriation to Rabi paid out of Banaban trust funds if a Banaban were stranded outside Rabi).Footnote 68 Such privileges would enable a Banaban “to evade the responsibilities of a citizen.”Footnote 69
Some media commentary within Fiji at the time cast doubt on the desirability of the Banaban settlement altogether. An article in the Fiji Times and Herald thought it “quite possible” that the resettlement scheme would fail. Detecting the Banabans’ apparent desire for isolation on Rabi, the author noted that although such wishes would be respected, they seemed to trump the wishes of the Fijians themselves: “If the Fijian people as a whole could be consulted they might say that they do not want the Banabans here at all.”Footnote 70 At the heart of this was the concern that Banabans—along with other migrants—were destabilizing employment opportunities and economic conditions for local Fijians. Allegedly, some Banabans had already made their way to Suva as early as 1946, following a longstanding general pattern of movement from outer islands to the urban center in search of work.
Although the Banabans generally welcomed local Fijians to Rabi, they resented those who came with the sole intent of stealing foodstuffs and bush materials.Footnote 71 The Secretary for Fijian Affairs warned the local chief of the area that he would be grateful if he would tell his people to cease this practice, noting that he would “appreciate that the Fijians themselves would naturally object to strangers trespassing on their land for the purpose of taking things away without permission.”Footnote 72 Immediately prior to the Banabans’ arrival in December 1945, he had written to the chief to say that consideration needed to be given to whether the reefs adjoining Rabi should be “made available to the Banabans for their own exclusive use,” and that in the interim, Fijians should not use them.Footnote 73 The right of indigenous Fijians to fish in the waters off Rabi remains a source of tension to this day.Footnote 74
The next section explores the governance arrangements established on Rabi that enabled the Banabans to establish a degree of autonomy within Fiji. The article then turns to the issue of citizenship and formal “belonging” within Fiji.
C Governance Structures on Rabi
The Banaban relocation to Fiji was initially for a trial period of 2 years. The Secretary of the Western Pacific High Commission thought it “very doubtful” that the Banabans would agree to remain on Rabi permanently, noting that their willingness to do so would “depend upon their treatment there and whether they get to like the place sufficiently during their enforced sojourn in the island.”Footnote 75 This was a key factor in the decision to grant the Banabans a degree of autonomy in managing their own affairs.
For this reason it is important that the proposed legislation should give them as nearly as possible the same Government organization and powers of self-Government as they enjoyed and were used to in Ocean Island. It must be borne in mind that they are intensely suspicious of anything the Government may do to get them away from Ocean Island; and if they think that their new constitution is going to take any powers or privileges away from them which they have enjoyed in Ocean Island, it is going to influence them in their decision whether they remain permanently in Rambi or not.Footnote 76
In the months preceding the relocation, Major Kennedy was asked to outline a scheme for resettlement. He proposed that the new settlement “be arranged to function in the same manner as a Banaban village on Ocean Island,” with a native government, under an administrative officer's guidance, appointing camp officers to exercise customary controls.Footnote 77 Kennedy recommended that the native government
should be permitted, from the outset to exercise all the legal functions and powers it possessed under the laws of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony. To permit of this being done, it will be necessary to grant a special authority and dispensation within the territory of Fiji pending the enactment, at a later date, of suitable legislation to provide for the special needs of the Banaban community.Footnote 78
Harry Maude, the Acting Resident Commissioner of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony, discussed this matter with the Secretary for Fijian Affairs and Fiji's Acting Solicitor-General. The Secretary gave his in-principle agreement that the Banabans “should be permitted to retain as much of their system of Local Government as was practicable under the circumstances and undertook to consider favourably any legislation drafted with this end in view.”Footnote 79 The Acting Solicitor-General offered the assistance of the government's Legal Department to draft the necessary legislation should he be instructed to do so by the Fiji government. The Secretary of the Western Pacific High Commission requested that Fiji's Legal Department be asked to draft a bill, which, based on the views of the Acting Solicitor-General, might be in the form of either
1. A short Bill empowering the Governor-in-Council to enact Regulations to provide for the Local Government of Rambi Island; or, in more general form, to enable Regulations to be enacted to provide for the Local Government of any such homogenous communities; or
2. A longer Bill adapting suitable sections of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony Native Governments Ordinance 1941 for application in Rambi Island. This Ordinance supersedes the Native Laws Ordinance 1917, and, while it has not yet been applied to Ocean Island owing to the war, it is considered to form the more appropriate model for basing any Fiji enactment.Footnote 80
In December 1945, the first of three ordinances governing Banaban affairs on Rabi was drafted. The Banaban Settlement Ordinance established the local governance framework for the island.Footnote 81 This included the Rabi Island Council (which, among other things, regulated the system of land tenure and inheritance), the Rabi Island Court, and the Rabi Island Fund. Section 3 authorized the Governor in Council to “make regulations to provide for the peace order and good government of the Banaban community,” but the Rabi Island Council could submit recommendations to him. Section 5 empowered the Rabi Island Council to make island regulations on the following subjects (subject to the prior approval of the Governor): island cleanliness and public health; maintenance of peace, order and public safety; social and economic betterment of the population; performance of communal works/activities; controlling livestock; prevention/removal of public nuisances; care of children and aged persons; conservation of food supplies; fishing and fishing rights; hospitals, prisons and schools; and “the promotion of the general welfare of the native inhabitants.” Importantly, section 5(4) prescribed that island regulations published “in such manner as is customary in the Banaban community” would “thereupon be of full force and effect,” notwithstanding any other laws that might be in force.
At a meeting on January 26, 1946, the heads of 153 family groups on Rabi met to devise a structure for the Rabi Island Council. They accepted a proposal put forward by Major Kennedy to instate ten Council members and a Chairman. Seven plus the Chairman would be elected annually at the general meeting of elders, and three would be nominated by the Chairman in consultation with the District Commissioner.Footnote 82 There was some discussion about precisely what a “family group” consisted of, but Kennedy suggested that for political purposes on Rabi, “those people who eat over one fire form an economic family group.” Footnote 83 As a colonial construct, the Council effectively assumed the authority previously wielded by the Banaban elders, who became “an unelected but customary advisory board for the Council.”Footnote 84 Rotan Tito, who had been the chief leader of Banaban affairs for the past 15 years on Ocean Island (and who was later to lead the Banabans’ movement for independence), was unanimously elected as the first Chairman. The first task of the Council was to formulate the island regulations to be made pursuant to section 5 of the ordinance.Footnote 85
Although the Rabi Council is subject to the ultimate control of the Fiji government,Footnote 86 in practice it “has maintained a large degree of autonomy and has acquired freedom from supervision in [its] affairs.”Footnote 87 It has a higher status than other island councils in Fiji, being able to levy taxes and make its own regulations.Footnote 88 A councillor described it as
a governing body which looks after the affairs of the Banabans in terms of, okay, economic developments, and at the same time, it tries to find ways of uplifting or upgrading the living standards of our people, and at the same time, we tend to, sort of, promote the idea to the younger generation that we, as Banabans, we come from an island of itself, right now it's under the Kiribati government, that is Ocean Island. We try to maintain the idea that the youngsters, when they grow up, they should maintain their identity as Banabans, and also to know the history; where do they come from and what type of island that they come from.Footnote 89
In practical terms, there has been much financial mismanagement and corruption within the Council over the years. In the early 1990s, it was placed under administration by a panel appointed by the Prime Minister of Fiji.Footnote 90 In mid-2013, an interim administrator was again appointed by the Prime Minister's office because the Council had failed to meet targets set by the government in relation to works to be carried out on Rabi.Footnote 91 According to one interviewee, “we always say that a Council is going to create an atmosphere or environment that will bring in honey, milk and honey, you know, but we haven't seen any honey or anything and now all we are seeing is just poverty.”Footnote 92
D Permanent Settlement
On May 13, 1947, a referendum was held on Rabi for the Banabans to determine whether or not they would make Rabi their permanent home.Footnote 93 By 270 to 48 votes, they decided to remain,Footnote 94 based on the conditions set out in the 1947 Statement of Intentions of Government. This was a document signed by the Banabans and the colonial administrations of Fiji and the Gilbert and Ellice Islands, “cast in the form of a statement of proposed Government policy vis-à-vis the Banabans.”Footnote 95 It was based on a draft Memorandum of Agreement prepared by Maude, who doubted that it would have any legal validity.Footnote 96 The Statement of Intentions subsequently became the basis for the Banabans’ entrenched rights in the Constitution of Kiribati.
In essence, the Statement of Intentions provided that the Banabans’ decision to remain on Rabi would not affect their rights to lands on Ocean Island; that they retain an inalienable right to return to Ocean Island; that the title to worked-out phosphate lands there, which had or might come into the possession of the Crown, should revert to the Banabans; that ownership of Rabi was to be vested in the Rabi Island Council, except for a Crown reserve of 50 acres;Footnote 97 and that the stock, tools, houses, and other assets of the copra estate on Rabi were also to vest in the Council. The Council would legislate for the division of lands on Rabi, and for the system of land tenure and inheritance.Footnote 98 At this time, the question of citizenship did not arise, because Fiji, like the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony, was a Crown colony and its inhabitants were citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies.Footnote 99
The Banabans were formally brought under the jurisdiction of the Governor of Fiji on January 1, 1950.Footnote 100 In addition to the Banaban Settlement Ordinance, two further legislative instruments were drafted to govern the affairs of the Banaban community on Rabi. First, the Banaban Funds Ordinance established the Banaban Trust Funds Board, to administer the proceeds received from phosphate mining on Ocean Island.Footnote 101
Second, the Banaban Lands Ordinance vested the freehold title of Rabi in the Rabi Island Council in trust for the Banaban community.Footnote 102 The 50 acre Crown reserve that had not been part of the original sale was transferred as freehold in 1948.Footnote 103 Although in land law terms the Banabans “owned” Rabi and Ocean Island, in international and constitutional law terms, those islands remained within the territory of Fiji and the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony respectively (for which the United Kingdom government was responsible internationally).Footnote 104
Land title had been deliberately omitted from the earlier Banaban Settlement Ordinance because the Secretary for the Western Pacific High Commission wanted to retain it “as a bargaining lever in connexion with the necessary renunciation by the Banabans of their interests in Ocean Island.”Footnote 105 He thought it “most unwise to vest the Rambi Island lands in the Banabans before they agree[d] to exchange their rights to the lands in Ocean Island for those in Rambi.”Footnote 106 Fiji's Attorney-General explained that the Secretary was not in a position to offer Rabi to the Banabans in exchange for them relinquishing their rights to Ocean because Rabi was held by the Western Pacific High Commission on trust for the Banaban community, and “it would be an abuse of the High Commissioner's powers as trustee to make the carrying out of the trust dependent upon such a condition.”Footnote 107
On Fiji's independence in 1970, the Banaban Funds Ordinance was repealed and the remaining two ordinances became the Banaban Settlement Act and Banaban Lands Act respectively. Until 2013, they were entrenched in successive Fiji Constitutions, which meant they could not be repealed or amended without a special parliamentary majority.Footnote 108 The 1970 Constitution required at least a three-quarter majority in Parliament.Footnote 109 The 1990 Constitution required a simple majority in the lower house, plus at least 18 of the 24 members of the Great Council of Chiefs (Bose Levu Vakaturaga) in the Senate.Footnote 110 The 1997 Constitution required that any bill to amend the Banaban statutes be read three times in each house of Parliament, and that it receive the support of at least 9 of the 14 members of the Senate appointed by the President on the advice of the Great Council of Chiefs before it could be approved.Footnote 111
The 2013 Constitution removed the legal safeguards for the Banabans, ostensibly as part of a new national policy to enhance unity in ethnically diverse Fiji.Footnote 112 The Banaban statutes could now be amended or repealed just like any other Act.Footnote 113 The Prime Minister of Fiji claimed that the new Constitution provided “greater protection and security for … Banaban land than ever before.”Footnote 114 However, it is difficult to reconcile this view with section 28(5) of the 2013 Constitution, which provides that the “ownership of all Banaban land shall remain with the customary owners of that land and Banaban land shall not be permanently alienated, whether by sale, grant, transfer or exchange, except to the State in accordance with Section 27.”Footnote 115 The term “customary owners” is not defined, and although it may have been an error incurred by hasty drafting,Footnote 116 it is clear that the provision offers no protection against the Fiji government compulsorily acquiring Banaban land for a “public purpose.”Footnote 117 It essentially makes the Banabans tenants-at-will of the state. The President of Kiribati referred his concerns about the provision to his Attorney-General for further investigation, noting that: “I think the wording of the new Constitution really opens the possibility that they may lose that land. … It remains native land and may revert back.”Footnote 118
E The Legal Status of Banabans in Fiji: Citizenship Entitlements
On relocation from Ocean Island to Rabi, the Banabans retained their pre-existing legal status as citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies by birth, as both islands formed parts of British colonies. They also acquired “belonger” status in Fiji, which exempted them from immigration control.Footnote 119
In preparation for Fiji's independence from the United Kingdom in 1970, there were extensive deliberations about what legal status the Banabans should have once Fiji was no longer a British colony. Officials at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) detailed a number of possible options, citing precedents from other Commonwealth countries.Footnote 120 A key question was whether the Banabans should retain citizenship of the United Kingdom and Colonies.
The British government was eager to divest itself of responsibility for the Banabans, concerned that they would become a national embarrassment.Footnote 121 It was determined to avoid the possibility of an “enclave” of United Kingdom citizens living on their “own private estate in an independent Commonwealth country, pressing us for development and budgetary assistance, to be administrated under their own control, to enable them to sustain their present standard of living.”Footnote 122 The British were also determined not to replicate their experience in other decolonization contexts, noting that “we risk a little East Africa in Rabi.”Footnote 123 Nevertheless, they recognized that they could not renege on their undertaking in the 1947 Statement of Intentions that the Banabans could return to and reside on Ocean Island at any time. Although they might seek to argue that the situation had changed radically on Fiji's independence, FCO officials noted that “this would scarcely find favour with our critics in the United Nations and elsewhere.”Footnote 124
Over the longer term, the British government wanted to avoid potential problems for a future Gilbertese State (namely, Kiribati). If the Banabans retained their citizenship of the United Kingdom and Colonies on Fiji's independence, they would acquire Gilbertese (I-Kiribati) citizenship when the Gilbert Islands became independent.Footnote 125 The British government considered that a newly independent Gilbertese state would not welcome responsibility for a large diaspora community (noting that in addition to the Banabans on Rabi, there were already more than 1,000 Gilbertese emigrants in the British Solomon Islands ProtectorateFootnote 126) and “might require cash compensation to take account of this responsibility.”Footnote 127 The British, therefore, wanted “to leave a tidy situation.”Footnote 128
However, the FCO acknowledged that unless and until the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony became independent, it would be wrong to assume “that if the Banabans take up Fiji citizenship they will cease permanently to be our problem.”Footnote 129 This was because “under the U.K. reacquisition legislation [they] will always have the right to reacquire U.K. citizenship whenever they should wish to do so.”Footnote 130 This would not give them a right of entry to the United Kingdom, but they would retain a right to entry and residence in the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony if they were born there, or if they were the minor children of, or married to, someone born there.Footnote 131 It was also noted that if the Fiji government were to alter the rights attaching to “belonger” status, it could possibly expel Banabans who did not become Fiji nationals.Footnote 132
Considering that the best way to safeguard the Banabans’ future was for them to integrate into Fiji's economic and social life,Footnote 133 British officials sought to convince the Banabans that their future lay in Fiji.Footnote 134 Confidential memoranda prepared by the British government revealed strategies “to encourage the Banabans to identify themselves with Fiji, adopt Fiji citizenship and abandon separatist tendencies”; “to encourage the Fijians to treat the Banabans as citizens of Fiji, to help them integrate into the Fiji community and to develop Rabi as their home”; and to ensure that the Fiji Constitution would “provide protection of Banaban custom, particularly land tenure.”Footnote 135 They also reiterated that the Banabans had declined to return to Ocean Island en masse, and that therefore, they had “really no alternative but to accept that their future lies in Fiji.”Footnote 136
The government of the United Kingdom anticipated that there would be Banaban resistance given their longstanding desire for independence,Footnote 137 and the fact that they already enjoyed “virtual autonomy locally under the various Fiji ordinances.”Footnote 138 Officials were, therefore, very surprised when the Banabans readily accepted that they would become citizens of Fiji, and, moreover, requested that they automatically become so on independence.Footnote 139 This represented a “material change” in their attitude.Footnote 140
Fiji refused to confer automatic citizenship on all Banabans, because it would have meant treating them differently from other minority groups in the country; however, it agreed to grant citizenship automatically to Banabans who had been born in FijiFootnote 141—approximately three quarters of the 2,000 Banabans in Fiji at independence.Footnote 142 The British were reluctant to agitate for further special arrangements, because “Fiji's attitude to its nationality legislation will be governed by its big Indian problem, not by its ‘little’ Banaban problem.”Footnote 143
Therefore, section 19 of Fiji's independence Constitution provided that anyone born in Fiji prior to October 10, 1970 who was a citizen of the United Kingdom and Colonies would automatically become a citizen of Fiji on that date, whereas section 21 provided that those born after independence would be Fiji citizens by birth (and citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies by descentFootnote 144). They could remain dual nationals up to the age of 21, but would have to renounce their citizenship of the United Kingdom and Colonies before they turned 22 if they wanted to retain their Fiji citizenship.Footnote 145 Such a provision was common in the decolonization context.Footnote 146 It was not until 2009 that Fiji permitted dual citizenship.Footnote 147
On Fiji's independence in 1970, Banabans born on Ocean Island but living on Rabi retained citizenship of the United Kingdom and Colonies and “belonger” status in Fiji.Footnote 148 They could apply for Fiji citizenship within two years of independence, but to do so they had to have resided in Fiji for at least seven years and have renounced any other citizenship if they were older than 21.Footnote 149 The FCO was justifiably concerned that this latter requirement would dissuade Banabans from acquiring Fiji citizenship, as experience elsewhere suggested that “immigrant races do not voluntary [sic] surrender their UK citizenship to acquire local citizenship.”Footnote 150 In particular, the FCO feared that the Banabans’ emotional attachment to Ocean Island, still part of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony, might galvanize them to retain their United Kingdom links.Footnote 151
Eight years after Fiji's independence, only one such Banaban had renounced his United Kingdom citizenship.Footnote 152 Of the Banabans living on Rabi, it was estimated that 854 were citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies only, whereas 1,440 were citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies and Fiji (permitted up to the age of 21). It was noted that these figures would increase/decrease respectively by 46 per year if people did not renounce their United Kingdom and Colonies citizenship before turning 22.Footnote 153 Other Banabans older than 22 had ceased to be Fiji citizens (14% of the population), or, by virtue of their birth outside Fiji, had never acquired Fiji citizenship (23%).Footnote 154 Only a handful of Banabans were citizens of Fiji only: second generation Banabans born on Rabi (and the man who renounced his United Kingdom and Colonies citizenship).Footnote 155
Therefore, for one generation after independence, a large proportion of Banabans remained citizens of the United Kingdom alone (by birth or descent).Footnote 156 This gave them continued enjoyment of “the conventional avenue of appeal to British MPs and government departments” via the British High Commissioner,Footnote 157 a mechanism they utilized extensively as they again sought autonomy in the lead-up to the Gilbert and Ellice Islands Colony's independence in the late 1970s.
4. The Banabans’ Rights and Legal Status in Kiribati
The safeguards are very satisfactory and unusually extensive.Footnote 158
A Introduction
It will be recalled that the 1947 Statement of Intentions guaranteed the Banabans’ rights to land on Ocean Island and their inalienable right to return there. Therefore, when the process of decolonization began in the Gilbert and Ellice Islands in the mid-1970s, the ongoing legal status of the Banabans also came into sharp focus.Footnote 159 The Banabans’ own bids for independence intensified, and although unsuccessful, they were highly relevant to the special provisions inserted into the Constitution of Kiribati to safeguard their rights of access, land, and political representation in that country.
As early as March 23, 1975, the Gilbert Islands had agreed that the Banabans’ rights in the 1947 Statement of Intentions should be enshrined in the independence Constitution.Footnote 160 In discussions in June 1975, the chief minister of the Gilbert Islands offered the Banabans a number of constitutional guarantees if they renounced their claims to independence.Footnote 161 Known as the “Fifteen Points” these included:
• An enshrined right of return to Ocean Island
• “Belonger” status in the Gilbert Islands (pre-independence), and then the right to citizenship (post-independence), “irrespective of the fact that they may also be citizens of Fiji”
• A dedicated parliamentary seat, and
• A suggestion that these rights could be embodied in “a formal agreement for registration with the United Nations” and that the United Kingdom and Fiji governments could be asked “to stand as guarantors of the agreement.”Footnote 162
It was no secret that both sides had a vested interest in maintaining control over Banaba on account of the vast income generated by its phosphate resources.Footnote 163 For the Banabans, this was intimately bound up with questions of identity and home.Footnote 164 For the Gilbertese, the issue was primarily about territorial integrity. As the Chief Minister of the Gilbert Islands recorded in a secret document presented to his Council of Ministers:
There can be no question of conceding the Banaban claim to independence since the House of Assembly has resolved that Ocean Island is an integral part of the Gilbert Islands and there can therefore be no change in our position without reference back to the House. Similarly we must protect our phosphate income by every means possible. I nevertheless believe that there could be considerable advantage in our making an offer to the Banabans in sufficiently generous terms to ensure that if it was rejected it became clear that it was they who were being totally unreasonable and not this Government.Footnote 165
Nevertheless, the Banabans rejected the “Fifteen Points,” and maintained their claim to full independence.
Two-and-a-half years later, in November 1977, the Gilbert Islands government and the Rabi Council of Leaders did reach a compromise. They jointly approved the “Bairiki Resolutions,” which provided that “a referendum to decide on the separation of Banaba from the Gilbert Islands should be held on all islands of the Gilbert Islands and, with the prior approval of the Government of Fiji, on Rabi also,” and that the government of the United Kingdom must honor the outcome “when deciding on the question of independence at the forthcoming constitutional conference.”Footnote 166 If the result was that Banaba should remain part of the Gilbert Islands, then it was agreed that the Banabans would be “allowed to commute freely between Rabi in Fiji and Banaba and any other Gilbert Islands,” and that “subject to the concurrence of the Fiji Government,” the Banabans would be “conferred dual citizenship by the Gilbert Islands Government upon application.”Footnote 167 The Banabans believed that they had support from the outer islands for separation from the Gilberts, although the British doubted that separation was likelyFootnote 168 (and expressed doubt that the agreement to hold a referendum would “stick,” as leader Tebuke Rotan was not involved).Footnote 169
In the end, the referendum did not proceed, because elections in the Gilbert Islands and on Rabi led to different leadership in both places,Footnote 170 and the Banabans withdrew from the agreement before a vote could be held.Footnote 171 They reverted to their earlier demand for Banaban independence.
The process for securing Gilbertese independence continued nonetheless. A constitutional conference for the Gilbert Islands was convened in London from November 21 to December 7, 1978.Footnote 172 Although the Banabans were permitted to send representatives to the meeting, they were apparently unhappy that they were not full delegates,Footnote 173 and they walked out when the British made clear that they would not support Banaban secession. British officials said that there were inadequate grounds to justify any departure from the “long-established and widely accepted policy” followed by successive British governments that “the principle of territorial integrity” and “the wishes of the people as a whole within the existing boundaries [of the Gilbert Islands Colony] should be the main guide.”Footnote 174 Notwithstanding the Banabans’ claim that the very annexation of Ocean Island was illegitimate, the island had come to be considered part of the territory of the Gilbert Islands, a situation that “has existed for at least 60 years and … the situation with which we have to deal.”Footnote 175
Nevertheless, British officials stressed the importance of protecting the Banabans’ “special interests and concerns,” which should be “safeguarded to the fullest extent possible within the sovereignty of the Gilbert Islands State.”Footnote 176 They welcomed an offer by the Gilbert Islands delegation to provide a “specially privileged constitutional status for Banaba and the Banabans, within a sovereign independent Gilbert Islands State.”Footnote 177 This would give effect to the safeguards set out in the 1947 Statement of Intentions by protecting the Banabans’ rights to land, entry, and residence on Ocean Island.Footnote 178
As a sign of good faith, the Gilbertese delegation expressed its willingness to discuss a novel proposal by the Rabi Council: a treaty between Fiji and Kiribati that would enable the Banabans to make representations to either government if they felt their constitutional rights were being infringed.Footnote 179 However, when the Banabans withdrew from the London constitutional conference, this idea was not developed any further.
B The Constitutional Safeguards
The remaining delegations at the constitutional conference did, however, draft constitutional safeguards for the Banabans, which to my knowledge are unique in their protection of non-resident and non-citizen rights.Footnote 180 The Banabans did not formally accept the provisions, stating that they were “thrust down our throats.”Footnote 181 They later acknowledged that many of them replicated parts of the pre-independence Constitution.Footnote 182
The safeguards are contained in Chapter IX of the Constitution, entitled “Banaba and the Banabans,” and Chapter III, which governs citizenship. Although Chapter III does not refer expressly to the Banabans, it entitles them, as persons of I-Kiribati descent,Footnote 183 to acquire citizenship by registrationFootnote 184 and to hold dual nationality.Footnote 185 The Constitution also establishes a right of appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council from any decision of the High Court involving the interpretation of the Constitution that might negatively impact the rights or interests of any Banaban or the Rabi Council.Footnote 186
At the time of drafting, a number of United Kingdom parliamentarians doubted that the Banaban safeguards would remain secure after independence.Footnote 187 Many Gilbertese found this insulting. As “Pacific islanders practising the Pacific way,” explained Lord Goronwy-Roberts in the House of Lords, they “not only intend but insist on treating the Banaban Islanders as their brothers, which they truly are.”Footnote 188 Any agreement would be “held as binding on all generations to come.”Footnote 189 It was noted that in “the whole history of the islands there has not been an example of an edict being repealed without the full consent of all the Members [of Parliament].”Footnote 190 The constitutional safeguards do remain in place today, notwithstanding claims that many I-Kiribati dislike them.Footnote 191
The following section explains the constitutional safeguards. It incorporates analysis from an independent Commission of Inquiry that reviewed the provisions in 1985, which remains the only in-depth treatment of them.Footnote 192
(i) Chapter IX: land rights, entry, and residence
Chapter IX of the Kiribati Constitution secures the Banabans’ land rights and interests on Ocean Island and preserves their right to enter and reside there.Footnote 193 Accordingly, provisions relating to restrictions on the movement, residence, exclusion, or expulsion of non-citizens do not apply to Banabans vis-à-vis Ocean Island.Footnote 194
Section 19 of the Constitution provides that anyone of “I-Kiribati descent shall have an inalienable right to enter and reside in Kiribati and on Independence Day shall as hereinafter provided, become or have and continue to have thereafter the right to become a citizen of Kiribati.” Because Banabans are defined as being of “I-Kiribati descent” (see subsequent description), Chapter IX guarantees do not restrict Banaban movement to Ocean Island alone.Footnote 195
Conversely, however, legislative restrictions may be placed on the movement of non-Banabans to Ocean Island, even citizens of Kiribati.Footnote 196 Although the Kiribati government sought to have this provision repealed, the 1985 Commission of Inquiry believed it was an essential safeguard for the Banabans, in part because the Banabans claimed that “Banaba can support only a limited population and the entry of non-Banabans would hinder their own resettlement.”Footnote 197
As far as practicalities are concerned, any Banaban wishing to enter Kiribati is issued a letter from the Rabi Council stating that: “This person is of Banaban descent, was born in Fiji and is visiting for that purpose.”Footnote 198 As a Kiribati government official explained, “they are allowed under our Constitution, to travel on a one-way ticket and live as long as they wish in Kiribati.”Footnote 199 According to a former President of Kiribati, Teburoro Tito, “I arranged for the one-way ticket. Before they were required to have a two-way ticket. I arranged that the visa and things would be relaxed between the two sides, Fiji and Kiribati.”Footnote 200 Individuals must fund their own travel; there is “no provision for repatriation at official expense.”Footnote 201
(ii) Chapter IX: internal governance on Banaba
Section 121 establishes the Banaba Island Council to give the residents of Banaba some autonomy in administering their affairs, and to deal with the central Kiribati government on their behalf.Footnote 202 At the time of the 1985 review, the Council had not yet been established, which “adversely affected development planning for Banaba as well as consultations between the Banabans and the government.”Footnote 203 The Banabans wanted more extensive powers than an ordinary island council, and believed it should be composed of the same members as the Rabi Council. Under the Local Government Act, however, a Kiribati island council's members had to be elected by the island's residents, and this would not be the case if Banabans from Rabi were to form the Banaba Island Council.Footnote 204 Notwithstanding the Commission of Inquiry's sympathy toward a single representative body, given that the Rabi Council already had the de facto authority to speak for the Banabans of both Rabi and Banaba, it concluded that a separate council on Banaba was important for two reasons: to represent the interests of any non-Banaban who might reside there, and to preserve a right of direct representation in the event that the Banabans on Ocean Island might develop interests distinct from the Banabans on Rabi. For these reasons, the Commission suggested that a majority of the Banaba Island Council should be composed of nominees of the Rabi Council, with the remainder elected by the residents of Banaba.Footnote 205
(iii) Chapter IX: parliamentary representation in Kiribati
The Kiribati Constitution provides for two elected parliamentary representatives to safeguard the Banabans’ interests. They do not have to be citizens of Kiribati.Footnote 206 One is the “elected member” of the electoral district “comprising or including Banaba,”Footnote 207 who may be either “a citizen of Kiribati or a Banaban.”Footnote 208 That person is elected by citizens of Kiribati or Banabans over the age of 18 who reside within the electorate.Footnote 209
The other is the “nominated representative of the Banaban community,” selected by the Rabi Council (and presumably a resident of Rabi, although this is not expressly stipulated).Footnote 210 This person must be “Banaban,” defined in section 125(1) of the Constitution as “the former indigenous inhabitants of Banaba and such other persons one of whose ancestors was born in Kiribati before 1900 as may now or hereafter be accepted as members of the Banaban community in accordance with custom.”Footnote 211 In practice, if there is any doubt as to a person's Banaban status, the Rabi Council makes a ruling on it. The High Court of Kiribati has jurisdiction over any disputes as to whether the nominated member has been validly declared,Footnote 212 even though the selection is undertaken by the Rabi Council within Fiji.
The two Banaban members have the right to veto proposed amendments to the Banaban constitutional safeguards.Footnote 213 If the nominated member is not present at the time of voting on the second reading of the bill, then the bill's consideration must be deferred. If the nominated member votes against the bill at that later time, then the bill must not be passed. In that sense, the nominated member (from Rabi) has special privileges not enjoyed by the elected member (from Ocean Island).
During the 1985 review, the Rabi Council suggested that the elected Banaban member's veto should be removed, because the Rabi Council's nominated member was “the rightful spokesman for the Banabans; and that there was danger that the nominated and the elected members might speak with different voices.”Footnote 214 However, the Commission of Inquiry was not persuaded. It did, however, recommend that Banaba be designated as an electorate on its own, rather than combined with any other part of Kiribati, given its special needs and interests, a position that the Kiribati government accepted during the hearings.Footnote 215 Evidence to the Commission of Inquiry showed that although there had been a separate elected member for Banaba since 1978, it had never been a Banaban because the Banabans had refused to participate in elections.Footnote 216
The Constitution requires all members of Parliament to take an oath of allegiance to Kiribati,Footnote 217 except the nominated member from Rabi. This creates an inherent tension for any elected Banaban member with Fiji citizenship.Footnote 218 From a constitutional perspective, there is no concern: section 56(3) notes that no one shall be disqualified by this section “by reason only that he possesses the nationality of a state other than Kiribati” (an obvious carve-out for the Banabans).Footnote 219 However, as the 1985 Commission of Inquiry noted, under Fiji law, a Banaban member who was a citizen of Fiji could potentially lose that citizenship if such an oath were taken.Footnote 220 Although the Commission was told that the Fiji authorities tended “to turn a blind eye to rights and procedures concerning the Banabans,”Footnote 221 it did not consider this a satisfactory solution. Instead, it suggested that if the government of Fiji were not willing to relax its laws, then perhaps the Kiribati government could exempt any Banaban with Fiji nationality from the oath of allegiance.Footnote 222
(iv) Chapter III: citizenship
Chapter III of the Constitution concerns matters of citizenship. That chapter provides that a person of “I-Kiribati descent” has “an inalienable right to enter and reside in Kiribati,”Footnote 223 the right “to become a citizen of Kiribati” (if not automatically so by virtue of other provisions),Footnote 224 and the right not to be deprived of that citizenship.Footnote 225 Dual nationality is permitted for persons of I-Kiribati descent.Footnote 226
Although the Banabans are not expressly mentioned in Chapter III, these provisions apply to them. A person of “I-Kiribati descent” is “a person one of whose ancestors was born in Kiribati before 1900.”Footnote 227 Section 125 of the Constitution defines “Banabans” as “the former indigenous inhabitants of Banaba and such other persons one of whose ancestors was born in Kiribati before 1900 as may now or hereafter be accepted as members of the Banaban community in accordance with custom.”Footnote 228 From a political perspective, it is significant that the very provision that safeguards Banaban rights in Kiribati depends upon Ocean Island being described as part of Kiribati, which was the central dispute by the Banabans in their claims for independence.
This definition is different from the definition of “Banaban community” in Fiji's Banaban Settlement Act, which does not refer to Kiribati at all. At the time of Fiji's independence (and still when the Constitution of Kiribati was drafted), it provided that “unless the context otherwise require[d],” the ‘Banaban community’ comprised “the former indigenous inhabitants of Ocean Island and such other persons as may now or hereafter be accepted as members of the Banaban community in accordance with Banaban custom; and includes any member of a race indigenous to Micronesia and Polynesia who is ordinarily resident on Rabi Island.”Footnote 229
In 1996, this definition was changed to “the former indigenous inhabitants of Banaba and their descendants,”Footnote 230 which had the effect of limiting who could vote on Rabi, curtailing, for example, the rights of non-Banaban spouses.Footnote 231 According to John Teaiwa, the trigger was rampant corruption by a non-Banaban Council Chairman, Rongorongo, who was “Banaban” by adoption rather than blood.Footnote 232 Katerina Teaiwa writes that this led to the Banaban Council of Elders recommending that a tighter definition be adopted for the purposes of local elections.Footnote 233
During the 1985 review, the Rabi Council proposed that the definition in Kiribati's Constitution be harmonized with the Fiji statute “to avoid confusion as well as a situation where a person is a Banaban for the purposes of one legislation and not for another, or is a Banaban in one country but not another.”Footnote 234 The Commission of Inquiry rejected this proposal because it regarded the two instruments as having different purposes: whereas the Act broadly regulates the Banabans on Rabi, Chapter IX of the Constitution specifies fundamental constitutional rights for people with special ties to Kiribati, and as such, a definition removing the express link to Kiribati would be inappropriate.Footnote 235
C Dual Citizenship
Although the Kiribati Constitution permits dual citizenship for Banabans, this “generous treatment” was for a long time “somewhat illusory in practice” because Fiji did not permit dual citizenship until 2009.Footnote 236 Banabans who wanted to take up citizenship of Kiribati had to renounce their Fiji citizenship first. Because approximately 90% of all Banabans resided on Rabi at the time of Kiribati's independenceFootnote 237—and most wanted to retain the citizenship of their country of residence, namely, Fiji—they were “effectively prevented from claiming their citizenship rights under the Constitution of Kiribati.”Footnote 238
Sir Bernard Braine, a Conservative member of Parliament in the United Kingdom and staunch Banaban supporter, wanted assurances that “a Banaban, who is a Fijian subject, will be able not merely to live on Rabi, which is agreed, but will be able to work on Rabi and, having lived and worked on Ocean Island, will be free to go back to live and to work on Rabi.” He argued that without a bilateral agreement between Fiji and Kiribati “to have some arrangement for dual citizenship,”Footnote 239 complete freedom of movement would be impossible.Footnote 240
The predominant view in the United Kingdom's Parliament was that this was a matter beyond its control, because it was “a restriction imposed by a sovereign Government, the Fijian Government.”Footnote 241 Although officials in the United Kingdom agreed to raise the issue with the Fiji Prime Minister, the United Kingdom could not interfere.Footnote 242 The concerns of most members of Parliament were assuaged by Fiji's tolerant approach in practice. “Whatever Fiji law may say, the Fiji Government allow Banabans to move freely to and from Banaba. They treat all Banabans as if they were Fiji citizens, and draw no distinction between those who were or were not citizens. I see no reason to expect the Fiji Government to change their practice in that respect. It is for the Fiji Government to decide, but I can see no reason to expect a change.”Footnote 243
However, Lord Hylton recognized that Banabans who were Fiji citizens would “be faced with a very difficult choice of citizenship if they wish[ed] to return to Ocean Island.”Footnote 244 Lord Somers expressed it this way: “If they want to come back to Banaba—and many of them do—they will of course have to face the problem of either retaining their Fijian citizenship, and so remaining for political purposes foreigners in their own country, or they will have to reject their Fijian citizenship and take on that of the Gilbert Islands, which is the last thing on earth that they want to do.”Footnote 245 In a confidential Cabinet memorandum, it was noted that by virtue of their Gilbertese descent, they would have the right to enter and reside in Kiribati irrespective of their formal nationality.Footnote 246
In anticipation of possible accusations that the British government was “unjustifiably infringing the human rights of the Banabans,” the FCO argued that it “would clearly be helpful if the Fiji government were prepared to make special provisions for Banabans living on Rabi to acquire or regain Fiji citizenship” at that time.Footnote 247 It was suggested that the Fiji government could either draft new legislation to restore citizenship to Banabans who had lost it, and grant it to those who had never acquired it (e.g., Banabans born on Ocean Island), or it could amend the Fiji Citizenship Act to enable the Banabans to hold dual citizenship and to pass it on to their descendants.Footnote 248
When the Commission of Inquiry reviewed the Kiribati Constitution in 1985, it found that no Banaban had either sought to register as a citizen of Kiribati or to renounce Kiribati citizenship. Neither the Kiribati government nor the Banabans raised the issue as one of concern.Footnote 249 The Commission of Inquiry noted, however, that although non-Kiribati-citizen Banabans still had the right to enter and reside in Kiribati, they were at risk of losing their Fiji citizenship if they remained in Kiribati for five years or sought to exercise certain political entitlements there.Footnote 250 Even though the Fiji government seemed to exercise considerable tolerance toward Banabans returning to Banaba,Footnote 251 the Commission was concerned about the precariousness of the situation. It recommended that the Kiribati government request that Fiji permit dual citizenship for Banabans to enable them “to fully exercise their rights in Kiribati as Kiribati citizens, without risk of jeopardizing rights as Fijians.”Footnote 252
It was not until April 2009 that Fiji law finally permitted dual citizenship.Footnote 253 A primary motivation was to open up opportunities for investment,Footnote 254 rather than to respond to Banaban concerns. This relatively recent legislative change might partially explain the confusion among many Banabans on Rabi today as to their legal status in Kiribati. Some believe that they are citizens of Fiji and Kiribati, others are adamant that they cannot be citizens of both, and some assume that they are citizens of Kiribati because they have the right under its Constitution to enter and reside there.Footnote 255
Finally, it is important to note that in 2005, Fiji offered a three month grace period to permit 500–600 Banabans on Rabi without Fiji nationality to acquire it, waiving the usual fee.Footnote 256 These were people who had arrived in subsequent migrations to Rabi (between 1975–77, and 1981–83 after the 1979 closure of the phosphate mines), whose presence had been tolerated by the Fiji authorities but not yet formalized.Footnote 257
D Reviews of the Constitutional Safeguards
The difficult situation in which the Banabans and the Kiribati government find themselves is not of their own making. The situation has been created by the former colonial authority; they are both equally the victims of it. … The inequities of the colonial legacy become the responsibilities of the newly independent people.Footnote 258
(i) 1985 Commission of Inquiry
Reference has already been made to the independent review of the Banaban constitutional safeguards, which took place in 1985. The Constitution itself provided that such a review would be held three years after independence (i.e., in 1982), and there were some discussions to that end between the Rabi Council and the Kiribati government in 1981 and 1982. However, the Kiribati government did not have sufficient funds to instigate a review at that time. When the government did move to establish a Commission of Inquiry in 1985, it inadvertently failed to consult the Rabi Council, which therefore had no say in the membership, venue, or other arrangements of the review. Nevertheless, the Rabi Council expressed confidence in the impartiality of the Commission's members: the Honorable Sir Darnley Alexander GCON, CFR, CBE from Nigeria (Chair), Professor Yash Ghai from Kenya, and Angoea Tadabe from Papua New Guinea.Footnote 259
At the time of the 1985 review, the majority of Banabans (approximately 4,000) resided on Rabi and were Fiji citizens, either by naturalization or birth.Footnote 260 The Commission noted their unique circumstances and the challenges of being subject to two different jurisdictions. This required flexibility among all concerned and the willingness “to explore, and if necessary adopt, unconventional procedures and solutions.”Footnote 261 In general, the Commission believed that the Banabans’ ownership of Rabi and their special internal governance arrangements there had enabled them “to preserve a sense of community and traditions’, and the Rabi Council, through its legal powers in Rabi and its concern for Banaba, had “helped the community to cope with problems of divided jurisdiction while maintaining unity within itself.”Footnote 262
With respect to the special Banaban provisions in the Kiribati Constitution, the Commission found that few had in fact been implemented. This was mainly because the Banabans had refused to accept the legitimacy of the Constitution and, therefore, had not cooperated to make it work.Footnote 263 Nevertheless, over the years, the Rabi Council and the Kiribati government had consulted with each other, albeit sometimes outside the constitutional framework,Footnote 264 and the Commission detected a new determination to enable the constitutional provisions to operate effectively.Footnote 265
The Commission's overarching conclusion was that the Kiribati Constitution provided sufficient safeguards to meet the Banabans’ needs. Any problems thus far had stemmed from the provisions not being fully utilized, rather than from deficiencies in the provisions themselves.Footnote 266 It made a number of recommendations, of which the most pertinent for present purposes were that:
• The government of Kiribati should enter into discussions with Fiji about possible changes to the law of Fiji to permit dual nationality for the Banabans, and acceptable procedures and documents to identify Banabans travelling in Kiribati (Chapter III)
• If Fiji were unwilling to relax its citizenship laws, the Kiribati government should consider ways of exempting the nominated or elected member of Parliament from the oath of allegiance, which would jeopardize his or her Fiji citizenship (section 117)
• Banaba should be a stand-alone electorate (section 118)
• A majority of the Banaba Island Council should be councillors or nominees of the Rabi Council, with the rest elected by the residents of Banaba, and the council's powers should be those set out in the Local Government Act (section 121)
• The Banaban elected member should retain the power of veto (section 124)
• Section 125(a) be amended to clarify that the relevant “custom” is Banaban custom
• The definition of “Banaban” in section 125(a) otherwise remain unchanged.Footnote 267
No constitutional amendments were made following the 1985 review, and the Banaban safeguards remain as originally drafted.
(ii) 1996 constitutional review and the future of the constitutional safeguards
In November 1994, a Select Committee of the Kiribati Parliament conducted a general review of the Kiribati Constitution.Footnote 268 Its findings were published in March 1996 and tabled in the May–June 1996 session of Parliament. Despite my best efforts to obtain a copy of the report, no one in the national archives, government, or parliamentary library of Kiribati was able to locate it for me. Former President Tito tracked down his personal copy of the minutes of the constitutional conference (in Gilbertese) and translated a number of select passages for me, but none revealed any pertinent discussion of the Banaban provisions,Footnote 269 other than the member for Banaba stating that “the laws that are here before us reflect our greatest need and we really need them to be in place and we trust that this will be maintained and further developed by the government.”Footnote 270
Given the Banaban right of veto, the process to amend or repeal the Chapter IX provisions is the most stringent of the whole Constitution. Former President Tito recalled that the Banabans argued strongly that the safeguards should be maintained.
They were saying that they've been moved out of their homeland, they're in a position in Fiji where they're not even counted as equal to the Fijians, they are substandard in Fiji, and they needed the sympathy and understanding of the Kiribati people. They asked that these provisions should be kept as they were. … I remember in Cabinet we had the view that we should start amending those provisions. Then we knew that it would still require a Banaban to say yes, and we could not guarantee that.Footnote 271
According to Tito, the Cabinet's initial rationale for amending the safeguards was that they “wanted everybody to feel equal, feel uniform. We wanted to do away with the argument that the Banabans were a different race, different language. They were not. … They're just part of our people, they're just part of us. We are part of them and they are part of us.”Footnote 272
The Magistrate on Rabi similarly recalled the discord among the Kiribati members of Parliament about Banaba's “higher” status in the Constitution. “Now all the islands in Kiribati, they all in any chapter, but Chapter IX is only for the Banabans. They asked ‘why?’, and then the President, he called the Attorney-General, and then all the people voted for amending the Constitution, or the Chapter IX. But the Attorney-General and the President, they stood up and responded to them. Those who agree to amend this Chapter IX: that is the Banabans only.”Footnote 273
In the end, it was agreed that there would be no change to the Banaban safeguards.Footnote 274 Nevertheless, Tito believes that they remain unpopular among the Kiribati population because they afford “special treatment.” He anticipates that they will eventually be changed “[o]nce the Banabans feel they're comfortable with us.” “I'm sure changes that would happen would ensure that they have free access to the island, in and out.”Footnote 275
In interviews with I-Kiribati officials, one gets the sense that there is considerable frustration at the government's inability to progress initiatives on Ocean Island (such as rehabilitation of the landFootnote 276) because of the veto entrenched by the constitutional safeguards. According to the Kiribati opposition leader, “we want to amend [the Banaba provisions] so that we will be able to do a lot more for Banaba, for Rabi and Ocean Island. Of course it's difficult as it is now. They can just veto anything if they don't agree on it.”Footnote 277
There are apparently also tensions with the small population on Banaba,Footnote 278 who are wary of the model of “external” governance from Rabi.Footnote 279 One government official suggested that the Rabi Council's attitude toward the Banaban “caretakers” on Ocean Island was along the following lines. “Why are you on Banaba to make decisions when there's only maybe 100 of you, and the rest of us are here. So we have more people and we've got the authority. You just look after the island. That's all you do.”Footnote 280
Similarly, as a Kiribati government official in Fiji explained, there were “lots of problems now” because the Banabans on Rabi often have different views from those on Ocean Island. The Rabi Council had prevented certain activities being undertaken on Ocean Island, despite the fact that the Banaban MP from Ocean Island had requested them. Banabans on Rabi “have overarching, sort of more control.”Footnote 281
5. Identity and Belonging
The ideology of Banabans is within us.Footnote 282
We sometimes sit and talk about Banaba, even now. We want to keep the memory alive, it is still our home.Footnote 283
Because of the fact that we are now on our new settlement place of Rabi Island in the Fiji Group, we had no other practical choice in the circumstances but to become citizens of Fiji.Footnote 284
As other scholars have found in the Pacific context, the legal status of social groups, and immigrant groups in particular, can have long-term effects on their present situation.Footnote 285 This is the case for the Banaban community, where the deep, intergenerational consequences of planned relocation are still apparent.
Most Banabans I interviewed felt that being a Fiji citizen was important, a finding that resonated with a small survey conducted by Teresia Teaiwa in 1999, in which 32 out of 33 respondents shared this view.Footnote 286 However, formal citizenship does not necessarily equate with personal understandings of identity and belonging. A recurring theme in my interviews with Banabans on Rabi was: “I am Banaban. Because I am in Fiji I am Fijian, but I am Banaban.”Footnote 287 Another interviewee explained: “Yes, a Fijian citizen, but we can't do anything about it. It's the government's idea. We can't do anything.”Footnote 288
In his 2012 submission to the Fiji Constitutional Commission, a former nominated Banaban member, David Christopher (later also a member of Parliament in the Fiji government), explained that he could not identify as “Fijian,” despite being a citizen of Fiji. “[T]he word Fijian is associated with race, with the race of the indigenous community of Fiji. Banaba is an island in the central Pacific Ocean. The indigenous community on Banaba are called the Banabans. I am a descendant of the indigenous community on Banaba and I call myself a Banaban. I find it difficult and most uncomfortable to call myself a Fijian as I was not a Fijian and will never be a Fijian.”Footnote 289
The strong sense of Banaban identity is pervasive,Footnote 290 and there is a determination for it to remain so. One member of the Rabi Council explained that “if we do not keep on telling the younger generation that we are Banabans, they come from an island, the limestone island in the Kiribati group, they will just grow up as Fiji citizens.”Footnote 291 He has even proposed the construction of a new Banaban language to preserve the group's cohesion and distinctiveness.Footnote 292 In part, this stems from a longstanding insistence that the Banabans are a unique ethnic group. But it also feeds into, and from, the sense that the Banabans are still outsiders in Fiji,Footnote 293 notwithstanding generally good relations with the Fiji government.Footnote 294 Teresia Teaiwa describes what she terms mutual “peripheralities”: “Fiji” exists on the periphery for the Banabans, whereas the Banabans and Rabi exist on the periphery in Fiji national consciousness.Footnote 295 This is despite the fact that there is a large amount of intermarriage between the Banabans and other Pacific islanders (including from Fiji), a fact that also predated relocation, which, however, is still perceived by many as a “threat” to Banaban culture and identity.Footnote 296
Some argue that relocation has actually “reinforced the separate identity of the Banaban people.”Footnote 297 Pacific scholar, John Connell, suggests that this is commonplace in the Pacific, where relocations (predominantly internal) have “enhanced rather than diminished the retention of island identities in the face of difference.”Footnote 298 Arguably, the experience of dislocation—the physical severance of the link to place and home—intensifies the desire to preserve (and forge) a collective identity.Footnote 299 In the Banaban case, the existence of “an opposing ethnic group,” in this case Fijians, may also have stimulated the desire to maintain a distinct identity.Footnote 300 However, the fact that the Banabans were relocated en masse, and that those living on Ocean Island today are “caretakers” sent from Rabi rather than a remaining indigenous community, distinguishes them from diasporic communities whose identities are articulated “against a still-present ‘home’ culture.”Footnote 301
The complexity of identity (and governance) in the Banaban context is revealed by the invariable response Teresia Teaiwa received when she asked her survey participants about their perceptions of government: “which government?”.Footnote 302 For Banabans on Rabi, it may mean the Rabi Council, the Fiji government, the Kiribati government, or even the British government. As Katerina Teaiwa explains, “Banabans, like many Pacific Islanders, have plural, situational identifications,”Footnote 303 which means that trying to isolate a single “identity” is artificial.
There is anecdotal evidence that a sizeable number of Banabans are now returning to Kiribati to access social benefits, such as government scholarships for education and old-age pensions.Footnote 304 Indications are that this has more to do with economic and social incentives rather than a sense of belonging.Footnote 305 This may reflect what anthropologist Martin Silverman described as the Banabans’ “have your cake and eat it too” approach—“an attempt to get the best (or at least something) of all worlds.”Footnote 306 Accurate statistics on return migration are not available because the Kiribati Immigration Ministry has not maintained systematic records.Footnote 307 The last Kiribati census (2010) showed that there were 295 residents of Ocean Island (of whom 165 were Banabans), representing only 0.3% of Kiribati's total population, with negative growth (-0.4%).Footnote 308 Because this number has remained fairly consistent since 1990,Footnote 309 it suggests that most Banabans who are moving to Kiribati are not returning to Banaba. The Kiribati government says that in terms of access to Kiribati: “We are trying to encourage them. We don't want to create barriers.”Footnote 310
From a governance perspective, the Kiribati government continues to monitor the Banabans’ situation in Fiji.Footnote 311 As former President Teburoro Tito told me, he always made a point of meeting with Fiji's President or Prime Minister whenever he visited Fiji in order to discuss the Banabans: “It would always be on my agenda, the Rabi people, ways and means of assisting them in their unique position.”Footnote 312
6. Conclusion
I think if you mention the moving of people, a group of people, set in ways, like us, if you are thinking of moving them to another place, the good thing is they'll be able to live maybe better … but at the same time, I think they should be really careful because once they are relocated to a certain place, they may not be able to enjoy the privileges that they want—they had—because where they are staying now, because that is a different place, a different government is going to govern them, and there will also be a chance of integration.Footnote 313
The Banaban story is simultaneously unique and emblematic. It reflects a broader historical narrative about colonization, exploitation, and dispossession.Footnote 314 At the same time, any “metanarrative of colonialism” must be resisted.Footnote 315 As with any relocation, the Banaban case must be understood on its own terms, with its own complexities and anomalies, within a particular historical context. It is precisely the rich historical detail presented in this article that provides the key to understanding the ramifications of this particular planned relocation, from which lessons can be extracted for the contemporary context.
The necessity, desirability, and political feasibility of future relocation by Pacific island communities remains contested, not least because of these past experiences.Footnote 316 Furthermore, the legal “solutions” created for the Banaban context cannot simply be extrapolated to contemporary examples. They were contingent on the resolution of larger questions relating to Banaban self-determination and identity, which were the subject of lengthy and hotly contested negotiations between the Banabans and the governments of Britain, the Gilbert Islands, and Fiji. Nevertheless, the Banaban case study merits closer analysis if relocation across international borders is ever to be considered as a possible adaptive response to the impacts of climate change. It provides an example of how states have created special statuses for relocated groups in the past, which may help to inform thinking about matters such as dual nationality, land rights, and the maintenance of distinct, self-governing communities, if groups are relocated across borders in the future.
