Despite North Korea's almost hermetic closure to the outside world, the proliferation of books on the “hermit kingdom” seems unstoppable: the two books reviewed here represent highly welcomed contributions, since they offer us innumerable tools to analyze this “unintelligible” country from perspectives that too often remain behind the scenes in scholarly and journalistic works.
Victor Cha's most recent work, The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future, is the ideal synopsis of North Korea, serving as an introduction for novices and as a critical in-depth analysis for scholars. Promoted as “the definitive account of North Korea,” and named one of the Best Books on Asia and the Pacific of 2012 by Foreign Affairs, this book is an authoritative and prodigiously long volume of more than 500 pages, but very easily readable despite the extreme weightiness of its contents. Widely renowned as one of the preeminent specialists on North Korea worldwide, Cha is a professor at Georgetown's School of Foreign Service and a senior advisor at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, and served as the National Security Council director of Asian affairs from 2004 to 2007, during George W. Bush's presidential mandate. In that period, he was deputy head of the American delegation at the Six-Party Talks, the negotiations aimed at persuading Pyongyang to yield up its nuclear weapons. In sum, those who work on the same topic can disagree with Cha's argumentations and perspectives but it is absolutely unimaginable not to encounter his works.
The adjective chosen by the author for the title of this book is of particular relevance here: “impossible”; in fact, this state—North Korea—is ruled by a dynasty that, after the collapse of the Soviet Union and the recent political turmoil in the Middle East, is anachronistically refusing any change or possibility to negotiate. The first part of this book is devoted to a wide spectrum of issues, from the historical reconstruction of the “hermit kingdom's glorious” past to the nuclear weapons program, from the brief experiments with a market economy to the accurate delineation of the members of the Kim family, including the new leader Kim Jong-un, who faces the double challenge of keeping the troubled regime alive and successfully leading it. The North Korean regime's survival, in fact, is threatened from different perspectives—economic and political—and, in Cha's opinion, the new leader “needs reform to survive, but the process of opening up will undeniably lead to the end of his political control” (p. 105). The response is embodied in the notion of neojuch'e revivalism, a sort of resurgence of the juch'e ideology (usually translated as “self-reliance”) through which the North may relive its past glory. In order to sustain itself, in sum, the regime tries to mold the future in its past experiences.
The central part of the book, mercilessly entitled “The Worst Place on Earth,” is a vivid depiction of the 1990s famine, one of the most difficult periods for North Korea, which brought the country to the verge of collapse. In addition, Cha gives a clear account of North Korea's dreadful human-rights record, repeatedly praising Bush's commitment to the improvement of human-rights conditions in the country and the president's meetings at the White House with defectors. Unfortunately, it seems that the author here is unable to effectively show the gravity of the situation and, above all, does not elaborate on the difficulties North Korean defectors seem to experience in being admitted to the United States. Since Bush signed into law the now almost moribund North Korea Human Rights Act at the end of 2004, only a limited number of North Korean refugees have found refuge in the United States, despite the oppression to which they have been subjected in their country. According to the Migration Information Source, in 2011 only 122 refugees from North Korea had been admitted and only an estimated 25 had received political asylum. Major obstacles block their admission to the United States, unlike a few European countries and Canada, but Cha remains almost silent on this issue.
After having discussed the degree of uncertainty that the presence of North Korea—and its relations with the neighbors—creates in the region, Cha closes this book with a chapter entitled “The End Is Near,” which is perhaps more an auspice of the author who, in the wake of Kim Jong-il's death, wrote that “North Korea as we know it is over. Whether it comes apart in the next few weeks or over several months.”Footnote 22 This statement, directly dependent on the old and always abused “collapse theory,” should have been more cautious because at this juncture we have no evidence showing substantial chinks opening in the wall of the regime. In addition, Cha rides the wave of the moment, taking into account the revolts sparked off in the Middle East and North African regions, usually labeled as the Arab Spring, and wondering if this earthquake could eventually shake the basis of the North Korean regime. Even though the author notes that many times the collapse of authoritarian regimes has not been predicted, and so this might well be the case with North Korea, it seems highly unlikely that Pyongyang could retrace the Arab Spring experience: the differences are considerable.
In the end, two elements emerge from Cha's analysis in this book: the genuine appreciation of Bush's North Korea policy—the “Complete Verifiable and Irreversible Dismantlement” approach, for which the author reserves a chapter—and North Korea's intrinsic “bad nature.” However, this position makes Cha forget that Bush bears much of the responsibility for the frustration of the efforts—aimed at creating a cooperative environment—made until that moment by the previous American administration together with the South Korean President Kim Dae-jung. A couple of things, however, should be dealt with in a more appropriate way: the first is to look in depth and without ideological preclusions at the message North Korea is transmitting, while the second regards sanctions imposed on Pyongyang. As for the message, it should be understood that the North's “belligerent” behavior is highly likely to be dictated by the need to normalize diplomatic ties with Washington. As for the sanctions, it must be clearly said that they are ineffective, limited, and counterproductive. Sanctions have not prevented Pyongyang from launching missiles, conducting nuclear tests, constructing a light-water reactor, and improving its nuclear program; sanctions' immediate result has been Pyongyang's escalation of its confrontational attitude.
In the end, The Impossible State is a product that perfectly fits in the scenario of works on North Korea recently requested by publishers, characterized by the co-presence of informed reconstructions, scientific analysis, and personal anecdotes that make this kind of volume more marketable and appealing to the general public. However, Kim Jong-il's death, in mid-December 2011, has probably accelerated the publisher's need to put this book on libraries' shelves, resulting in continuous and frustrating repetitions throughout the volume. It also seems anomalous that this voluminous and instructive book barely takes into account Korean-language sources, while it relies a great deal on English-language sources, thus reinforcing the perception that this book conveys an American-centric perspective.
The second volume, entitled North Korea: Beyond Charismatic Politics, is the outcome of a collaborative effort by two scholars, Heonik Kwon, professorial senior research fellow at Trinity College, University of Cambridge, and Byung-Ho Chung, professor of cultural anthropology and director of the Institute for Globalization and Multicultural Studies at Hanyang University in Korea. This multifaceted book focuses on one of the most disputed assumptions regarding the North Korean regime: its persistency and surprising stability. The two authors discuss the astute use of rituals by the members of the Kim family that has allowed them to perpetuate their charismatic role by successfully transforming the country into a “theater state.”
A starting point in the delineation of the theoretical framework is the “routinization of the charismatic authority,” a topic of much discussion in the literature of social sciences since its introduction by the German sociologist Max Weber. The routinization of charisma, although referring to a critical phenomenon, is largely undefined in the sociological literature, and in particular the “mechanisms” of routinization have inspired an endless discussion among scholars. Charisma, one of the three forms of political authority—the others being traditional and rational-legal—is generally recognized as ephemeral and transitory; it exists in “pure form” only in the moment of its appearance. Therefore, it is inherently transitional and incorporates a fundamental dilemma: it must change to survive but in changing it erodes its own essential qualities. This, of course, is central to the understanding of the North Korean political order, depicted by the South Korean anthropologist Lee Moon-woong as a “family-state” (p. 18), where the relationship between the Great Leader and the masses was almost paroxysmic. The concept of family-state can be better understood when related to one of the theoretical architraves for the authors of this book, the notion of “partisan state,” borrowed from the work of Wada Haruki, an important historian of North Korea. Basically, the authors refer to that group of actors, led by Kim Il-sung, who chose to fight against the Japanese in Manchuria and who were in large part “responsible” for the foundation of the North Korean state soon after the end of the Japanese colonization. This essential step in the process of nation building is the foundation of the “boundless love of the nation”—in Sonia Ryang's words—for their supreme hero (p. 16).
In the process of political succession to Kim Jong-il, however, “symbolic and theatrical means to demonstrate the power and authority of political succession” (p. 44) became more accentuated. In order to explain the “supremacy of symbols and metaphors in the contemporary North Korean political process” (p. 45), the authors refer to the work of Clifford Geertz, a symbolic anthropologist who gave prime attention to the role of symbols in constructing public meaning and was widely known for his extensive research in Indonesia and Morocco. Discussing the “theater state” model developed by Geertz, the authors describe the importance of “power display” (p. 45)—rituals and spectacles of different forms: mass games, mass parades, and theatrical plays—as a means to create a sense of political loyalty in the North Korean masses to the Manchurian partisans and Kim Jong-il himself. This process of “sanctification” of Manchurian partisans—with special reference to Kim Il-sung and his first wife and partisan fighter, Kim Jong-suk—has been essential in the practice of the so-defined “legacy politics,” an indispensable element in the routinization of charismatic authority. Other evidence of this kind is found in the theorization of the Sŏn'gun politics: that the origin of the military-first politics, according to some late sources, may be found in the 1930s anticolonial resistance and that the idea was born from an assiduous interaction between Kim Il-sung and Kim Jong-il legitimize the perpetuation of the Manchurian partisan tradition. The two authors also emphasize that “moral economy” is one of the main components of North Korea's theater state, where “general reciprocity” is essential and selfishness is condemned. Gifts are to be seen in a double perspective: from the Great Leader to the people of the country and from the peoples of the world to the Great Leader. Either way is absolutely unavoidable: for Kim Il-sung the act of giving to his people was a sign of paternal benevolence, while receiving from people in other parts of the world represented the universal love toward the Great Leader that eventually went beyond physical borders.
Even though this book has been regarded as essentially reserved for those who have an academic interest in North Korea, it is undoubtedly a major contribution to the field of North Korean studies, from a cultural and anthropological perspective. Kwon and Chung give us one of the most mature contributions that has appeared in the last few years in the field of North Korean studies: a vivid and uncommon picture of North Korea that describes the value of theatrical ideology to the maintenance of the North Korean regime. By employing this line of reasoning, however, the authors imply that the control imposed on society is a secondary factor. However, different methods of social control place severe constraints on social groups and their activities. The most important tool is Sŏngbun, the system of political classification of people according to their family background, ideological orientation, and loyalty to the regime and leadership. Sŏngbun becomes even more effective when conjugated with yŏngoje, the family purge. Underpinning this elaborate system of political classification and family purge is the ubiquity of government intelligence agencies, such as the State Security Department. This is a perverse system that has nothing to do with the “theater state.” Another factor that cannot be easily explained by the concept of “theater state” is the rituals of political institutions. As has been evident since Kim Jong-il's death, representative institutions have been constantly at work, showing that the regime's authority is not merely dependent on the charisma of the leadership. In the end, North Korea: Beyond Charismatic Politics remains a meticulously researched book, lucidly argued and clearly interconnected in its parts despite the complexity of its theoretical approach.
