Introduction
In this Article, I argue that there is inconsistency and confusion at the heart of UN policy on use of deadly force by peacekeepers and that this lack of clarity has resulted in deaths and injuries to people that pose no threat to UN forces or anybody else and have not engaged in any violent activities or indeed in any type of crime. Such deaths and injuries are likely to recur if the United Nations continues to use the same rules of engagement for law enforcement operations as it does for operations aimed at curtailing violence by parties to an armed conflict. The problem would be greatly mitigated if the United Nations were to formally commit to applying customary international human rights law standards on use of force in all circumstances except those to which international humanitarian law applies.
This Article draws on research that I undertook in Haiti on use of deadly force by the UN Stabilisation Mission in Haiti, funded by the British Academy (UK) and the Arts and Humanities Research Council (UK). As part of my research in Haiti I coproduced and codirected a film It Stays with You: Use of Force by UN Peacekeepers in Haiti (50 minutes, 2017) which presents testimonies of survivors and is available for streaming from the project's website.Footnote 1
Authorization to Use Force Under the UN Charter, International Humanitarian Law, and International Human Rights Law
Peacekeepers today are routinely expected to conduct law enforcement operations and assist host state governments maintain law and order for example through providing security so that elections can take place—arresting spoilers and controlling riots.Footnote 2 However, UN rules of engagement and policy documents have not kept pace with the expansion of UN peacekeeping to encompass its extensive role in law enforcement and security.
Most peacekeeping missions today have a Chapter VII mandate. This means that the mission may use force to carry out its mandate without risking violating the prohibition on use of force set out in the UN Charter. However, the UN Charter deals with use of force in the inter-relations between states, sometimes referred to as the jus ad bellum: it does not deal with use of force against human beings. The jus in bello, more commonly referred to today as international humanitarian law (IHL), regulates how states must conduct operations in an armed conflict context and includes rules governing who can be targeted and in what circumstances. Law enforcement operations—which would include all state operations involving use of force outside of a hostilities-in-armed-conflict context—are governed by international human rights law (IHRL).Footnote 3
In 1999, the United Nations formally acknowledged that peacekeepers must comply with core rules of international humanitarian law when they are engaged as combatants in an armed conflict.Footnote 4 The United Nations has not published any formal statement as to the legal framework governing peacekeepers’ use of force when they are not engaged as combatants in an armed conflict.
Under the secretary general's Bulletin on Observance by United Nations Forces of International Humanitarian Law, UN peacekeepers must comply with at least the fundamental rules and principles of IHL set out in the Bulletin “when in situations of armed conflict they are actively engaged therein as combatants, to the extent and for the duration of their engagement.”Footnote 5 The intensity threshold for meeting this criterion is high and therefore for most missions international humanitarian law applies only in exceptional circumstances.Footnote 6 Even where the intensity threshold is met and peacekeepers find themselves engaged in fierce fighting, IHL will not become applicable unless the fighting takes place in a situation of armed conflict against members of the armed forces of a party to the conflict or civilians directly participating in the conflict. This is because “lawful use of armed force” against people that are not directly participating in an armed conflict—e.g. criminals, rioters, civilian perpetrators of war crimes—is “a matter of law enforcement or defense of self or others” and hence is not governed by IHL.Footnote 7
Applicability of International Human Rights Law
There is no agreement on the extent of the formal applicability of international human rights law to UN peacekeeping largely because of disputes over the meaning and scope of jurisdiction. But the UN accepts that it must comply with human rights law norms regardless of whether they are formally applicable. The UN's Human Rights Up Front initiative, adopted in 2013, commits the UN to entrenching human rights norms into all aspects of its missions.Footnote 8 The High-Level Independent Panel on Peace Operations has recommended that the “entire United Nations system commits to the full implementation of the Human Rights Up Front initiative.”Footnote 9
It is a fundamental principle of law and of morality that all human beings have an equal right to life, in particular an equal right not to be deprived of their life. Outside of hostilities in an armed conflict the only circumstances in which it is permissible to intentionally kill someone is if it is the only means of preventing an attack on someone's life or preventing serious injury. Even then any use of deadly force must be proportionate to the aim of protecting life.Footnote 10 These norms are widely regarded as peremptory norms and hence are binding on the United Nations.Footnote 11 But even if they are not peremptory norms, they are certainly norms that the United Nations has promulgated and committed to uphold.Footnote 12
Despite the United Nations commitment to upholding IHRL, it has not formally acknowledged that peacekeepers that are engaged in armed operations outside an armed conflict context should comply with international human rights law standards. Although IHL is seldom applicable to UN peacekeeping operations, rules of engagement for UN peacekeepers remain heavily shaped by it. There is no mention of IHRL in the United Nations Guidelines for the Development of Rules of Engagement for the UN Department of Peacekeeping or in the model rules of engagement attached to those Guidelines.Footnote 13
Peacekeeping missions are routinely mandated to undertake operations to assist host state governments maintain security and law and order. If these operations were conducted by host state forces, they would be required to comply with IHRL under standards promulgated by the United Nations.Footnote 14 However, the United Nations currently does not require its own forces to comply with these standards.
Consequences of the UN's Failure to Apply International Human Rights Law Standards
The film It Stays with You: Use of Force by UN Peacekeepers in Haiti documents extremely high levels of force used by the UN peacekeeping mission MINUSTAH to neutralize armed gangs in Cité Soleil to control gang crime in Cité Soleil and other marginalized communities. MINUSTAH’s rules of engagement authorize the mission to use force “up to and including deadly force in order to put a stop to acts of civil unrest.” Civil unrest is defined in the rules of engagement as “the commission, perpetration, or instigation of acts of violence that effect public peace and order.” There is no requirement in that definition that the violence effecting public peace and order must pose an imminent threat to life that could not be averted in any other way. It is hardly surprising given this broad authority to use deadly force and heavy pressure from international and local elites to control gang crime that the UN used force far beyond what is permitted under international human rights law standards.
According to the UN's own records, on July 6 2005, the mission fired 22,700 bullets, seventy-eight grenades, and five mortars in a densely populated neighborhood where most people live in shacks made of salvaged bits of corrugated metal.Footnote 15 In another operation in the same neighborhood on December 21, 2006 the UN fired 10,000 bullets.Footnote 16 Witnesses state that MINUSTAH fired from helicopters and the bullets penetrated the roofs of the houses and killed people in their beds including several children.Footnote 17 The bullet holes have since been repaired with patches of scrap metal but are still clearly visible.Footnote 18 Witnesses also state that MINUSTAH fired from heavy machine guns mounted on armored personnel vehicles, destroyed scores of houses, and killed several families.Footnote 19 No one in Haiti other than the UN mission has helicopters. No one in Haiti other than the UN mission has heavy machine guns mounted on armored vehicles. The doctors we interviewed said that they received phone calls from people injured but they were unable to reach them for twenty-four hours because the UN would not allow anyone in or out.Footnote 20
Everyone that we interviewed said that no one from the UN or from the state had visited them after the raids to inquire as to whether there were any casualties. One woman, Evelyne, said “it makes you feel worthless.”Footnote 21 Another person, Sorel, said: “A massacre happens and no one comes to find out how many people were killed, how many people were lost, how many cases there are. It stays with you, you know what you know.”Footnote 22
Recommendations
The UN Department of Peacekeeping has not responded to my requests for information regarding its investigations into these operations, nor to my request on behalf of the participants in the film, that it authorize an independent and transparent investigation into what happened.
In addition to authorizing an independent investigation into peacekeepers’ use of force in Haiti, the United Nations should put in place policies and procedures to ensure that they do not happen again. The United Nations should explicitly affirm its commitment to comply with international human rights law standards on the right to life in all circumstances in which troops use deadly force against persons that are not parties to an armed conflict or civilians participating in one. This would require troops to assess so-called “collateral damage” with much greater care and ensure that any operations in which deadly force is likely to be used are planned so as to ensure that any use of deadly force is proportionate to the aim of protecting life.
