This fascinating book makes an important contribution to our understanding of the role and functioning of Sufism and Sufi communities in Ottoman life—a topic that is still little understood even though the ubiquity and importance of Sufism in Ottoman society is commonly noted. For this reviewer, the comparative insights that Curry promises to provide—be they about movements of religious purification, affinities between challenges to early modern Sufi communities and the emergence of the Reformation in Europe, or “transitions in the early modern period of world history” (p. 292)—are negligible. Where this book shines is in its lively, in-depth, solidly grounded analysis of how Ottoman Sufi communities functioned in their local, and particularly provincial, settings. This analysis is made possible, in turn, by the author's close, critical reading of a wealth of published and unpublished 16th- and 17th-century materials, including doctrinal and devotional treatises, Sufi genealogies (silsiles), and especially hagiographic literature.
The focus of Curry's analysis is the history and literary production of one Halveti sub-branch, the Şaʿbaniye, based in Kastamonu in north-central Anatolia. He reconstructs the history of the Şaʿbaniye from its origins in the chaotic environment of Azerbaijan and Anatolia during the Timurid depredations of the turn of the 15th century, through the career of the eponymous founder Şaʿban-ı Veli Efendi (d. 1569), to the institutionalization brought about by the “second founder,” ʿÖmer el-Fuʾadi (d. 1636). Masterfully reading and interpreting the treasure trove of anecdotal materials in sources such as Fuʾadi's hagiography (Menakib) of Şaʿban-ı Veli or his account of the construction of Şaʿban's tomb-complex in the Türbename (“Tract on the Tomb”), the author weaves together a highly nuanced and illuminating picture. We get glimpses into how the legitimacy of an “outsider” shaykh is bolstered through encounters with, and through the testimonials of, the Prophetic figure Hızır, or how a shaykh conveys mystical ideas in a simple and direct language accessible to his provincial audience. We witness newly minted Anatolian shaykhs traveling and working in groups of two, with a lower-ranking “assistant” gaining experience at the side of a more seasoned partner before receiving his own assignment. We learn how shaykhs negotiated thorny environments involving “pseudo Sufis” and their magical and doctrinally suspect practices on the one hand and the ever-watchful guardians of “proper” Islamic practice on the other. A set of anecdotes shows a shaykh acting as a lender of last resort, redirecting to needy followers the charity offered by wealthier visitors to his lodge. Another depicts how a eulogy at a shaykh's funeral drove followers into a state of uncontrollable fervor, leading them to grab relics such as pieces of the matting upon which the shaykh had sat or to try to capture bits of spilt water used in washing his corpse. Yet another illustrates how a shaykh's tomb-complex was built through the cumulative material support and physical labor of local communities. Altogether we gain a highly textured understanding of how a Sufi order and its leaders, among other things, engaged committed disciples and a larger following, built a reputation, and faced detractors.
A secondary, narrower focus of this study is the “unsung hero” (p. 197) of the Şaʿbaniye, ʿÖmer el-Fuʾadi, whom both later devotees of the order and scholars of Ottoman Sufism have generally neglected. Curry demonstrates how Fuʾadi was pivotal to the order, having codified its history in the Menakib and orchestrated the building of Şaʿban-ı Veli's tomb complex in Kastamonu, thereby inscribing the eponym and his branch into the local landscape. He also composed numerous tracts that helped define, circulate, and defend the order's tradition, providing access to its teachings to a new and unprecedentedly diverse audience. Through these activities, Fuʾadi substituted the individual charisma of the eponym with an institutional framework. In this respect, he reminds us of more than one “second founder” in the history of the Sufi orders and helps us form, via Curry's deft analysis, a nuanced understanding of the workings of Sufi communities and orders and of sainthood and saint veneration.
The author is perhaps on shakier ground in his attempt to characterize Fuʾadi as representing a broader transformation in both Muslim mystical thought and Ottoman culture. Fuʾadi's time was one of increasingly forceful criticism of Sufi devotional practice—even before the appearance of those who would be labeled Kadızadelis. He was clearly driven by a sense of urgency and attuned to the challenge of defending the Halveti tradition in the face of aggressive critics while at the same time competing in the “marketplace of regional holy figures” (p. 210). Similar to some of his contemporaries, he made a bid to reach a newly diverse audience by writing on mysticism in Turkish and by crafting accessible narratives. But it is quite a leap to infer from this that Fuʾadi's activities “suggest the tip of a broader populist trend that was taking shape in the religious culture of Ottoman society from the eleventh/seventeenth century onward”—or that he was responding to “increased scrutiny [of the Sufi orders] by new generations of religious thinkers who sought to rationalize and circumscribe the diversity of practice that had marked the post-Mongol formation of the Ottoman enterprise” (p. 259).
Ultimately it is Curry's treatment of the extensive hagiographical materials (composed by Fuʾadi and others) on which this book relies that is most valuable. Through painstaking reading and analysis of the sources, often page by page, he seeks to capture (and check against other sources) both those bits of historical reality that they convey and their retroactive reconstructions of the history of the order in the service of later needs. The result is a rich historical canvas and the kind of critical evaluation of hagiographic materials that, until now, we have come to expect from scholars of South and Central Asian Sufism more than from Ottomanists. Curry thus brings to Ottoman Sufi studies a new level of engagement with the hagiographic literature; at the same time he joins scholars working on other historical settings in putting to rest old doubts about the utility of Muslim hagiographic sources and in providing a model for how to read them. Similarly, through his careful attention to the historical evolution of the Şaʿbaniye branch and to successive transformations in its ideas, practices, and responses to changing realities, he joins another recent scholarly and critical endeavor—this one seeking to revise old paradigms that assumed the immutability of diverse Islamic institutions.
This book will be indispensable to scholars and students of both Ottoman history and the history of Sufism. I highly recommend it for its analytical and methodological approaches, its engaging narrative, and its ability to open a window to still poorly appreciated social and religious dynamics in the early modern period of Islamic history.
