Fortune Tellers is a book about economic forecasting in 1920s and 1930s America as told through the stories of seven prominent forecasters. The reader is introduced to Wall Street insiders like Robert Babson, an early technical analyst, and John Moody, who applied measurement and data to assessing the health of corporate firms and the securities they issued. We meet academics in the form of Irving Fisher, one of the first mathematical economists who sought to uncover the deeper theoretical determinants of business cycles and made his forecasts accordingly, and Wesley Mitchell, who sought to better understand the American business cycle through careful study. The Harvard Economic Service of Charles J. Bullock and Warren Persons made their forecasts in a purely academic setting as well, using an empirical model formulated through intense analysis of scarce data using primitive methods of computation. Also profiled is Herbert Hoover, who transformed the Department of Commerce from little more than a supervisor of lighthouses to a powerful agency in charge of collecting extensive statistics about the American economy.
The stock market crash of October 1929 and the ensuing Depression naturally loom large in Fortune Tellers, as success or failure in predicting the downturn could make or break forecasters’ careers. After the hubris of the 1920s, viewed by many at the time as a “New Era” of permanent prosperity, the American economy would, like Icarus, plunge calamitously down to earth. While these Delphic Oracles offered up their divinations in this Greek tragedy, they largely did not predict the calamitous denouement. Indeed, Fisher's infamous 1929 prediction that stocks had reached “a permanently higher plateau” would define his career as a forecaster for posterity. The Harvard Economic Service had predicted the downturn of 1920–1921, which gave them a great deal of credibility. However, the purely empirical approaches of Moody and the Harvard Economic Service did not predict either the downturn in either the stock market or the broader economy during the Depression, though both services claimed ex post that their models showed some signs of reversal before 1929, which were not believed by the forecaster. Herbert Hoover had improved data collection in government as Secretary of Commerce during the Harding and Coolidge administrations and had campaigned on his record at Commerce during the 1928 election. He promised more prosperous years thanks to scientific management guided by statistics that were collected in concert between government technocrats and business leaders. He failed miserably to deliver on this promise as president. Hoover's persistently rosy predictions of recovery “just around the corner” became increasingly absurd and cruel as the Depression worsened throughout his presidency. Ironically, the forecaster who was best able to predict the October 1929 Crash was the forecaster with the model which relied the least on empirics or economic theory. Babson's forecast relied on the run-up in stock prices between 1926 and 1929 to predict that a correction was coming soon. However, Babson's model would predict a speedy recovery in 1930 and 1931 when the economy was “due” for an upward correction, which did diminish his reputation somewhat.
The reader will learn about much more than just forecasting in Fortune Tellers. The optimistic view of science and technology to solve societal problems pervades both the zeitgeist of the 1920s and the forecasters of that era. Many of the social movements of the 1920s are discussed such as Prohibition and eugenics, two movements which both Fisher and Babson supported enthusiastically. The interlude in the middle of the book with several forecasting charts was a treat, showing the importance of charts in conveying forecasts and giving more insight into the way forecasts were made at the time. Chart making was greatly advanced by the forecasters of the time, especially by the iconic Babsonchart and Harvard's ABC chart.
The major historical events of the early twentieth century figure prominently in the book, and major economists make cameo appearances throughout the book, including Joseph Schumpeter, Stanley Jevons, Simon Kuznets, Nikolai Kondratiev, Oskar Morgenstern, Friedrich Hayek, and John M. Keynes. The philosophical implications of forecasting are discussed throughout including the relative importance of empirics and theory in constructing forecasting models, as well as the efficient-markets and behavioral theories of equity prices. Many central economic concepts were developed directly and indirectly by these forecasters, like the Equation of Exchange, aggregate price levels, and price-to-earnings ratios. Fortune Tellers also discusses competing theories of business cycles extensively, including those intended to better understand business cycles to mitigate them (as in the case of Moody and Keynes) and those that saw business cycles as natural phenomena better left free of government meddling (as with Wallace Donham of the Harvard forecasting group and Schumpeter). Fortune Tellers does spends time discussing the large-scale Keynesian forecasting models that became dominant after World War II, but a brief discussion about the current state of forecasting, which does not even receive much of a mention, would have improved the book.
The most prominent book of this year would have to be Thomas Piketty's Capital in the Twenty-First Century (Cambridge: Belknap/Harvard University Press, 2014), a major tome of about 700 pages with mountains of archival data and grand theories of capitalism, which requires many hours of careful reading to digest. Fortune Tellers is not Capital, and neither is it your standard biography which delves into the life of a single individual. But while one can get indigestion from these ponderous works, Fortune Tellers serves up several courses of light tapas which together form a hearty meal. There is no opportunity to get bogged down with any one individual or topic, and the series of short biographies make for a pleasant and engaging read. If you are interested in economic forecasting or in the economic history of interwar America, I can confidently forecast that this book will be well worth your time.
