Time magazine's 1955 review of André Bazin's seminal work on the western scoffed at European admiration for the genre, wondering at the fact that “many a longhaired Frenchman believes that the western film is Hollywood's finest achievement, a kind of national folklore in the making.” Pippin, who would certainly endorse this view of the western's mythic centrality, is an American philosopher able to view these films’ distinctively national characteristics in a geographically wider intellectual frame – often a German or French one. It is an achievement of this book that Nietzsche does not look too incongruous alongside John Wayne.
Hollywood Westerns consists of three extended readings of films which Pippin identifies as particularly rewarding of interpretation and which, almost incidentally, he proposes as part of a subgenre: Howard Hawks's Red River (1948), John Ford's The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962) and Ford's The Searchers (1956). The chapters were originally part of a lecture series, which might account for a slight repetitiousness in places, and are contextualized by examples of earlier and later films in the introduction and conclusion. At the outset, Pippin highlights the congruence of the concerns of the western and the preoccupations of modern political philosophy. Matters of justice, citizenship, self-determination, and the attempt to comprehend the ramifications of power are to an extent generic questions of the discipline, especially in its liberally inflected variants. Pippin is not the first to notice these parallels, but he draws attention to the way citizenship is an oddly overdetermined idea in American art and in “the American imaginary” in general. Abstractions like equality, precisely as abstractions, somehow become the subject of America's self-expressions in a peculiar way.
The book could be approached simply as a set of compelling accounts of certain films. Pippin wants to illuminate the sheer complexity of the cultural position westerns occupy – as skeptical, anxious, ambivalent, reflexive, even modernist – but he is also a champion of “naive reading,” the practice of pursuing a subjective response to a work of art in its own terms. He takes as established that others have blazed the necessary trail for the commercial products of Hollywood to be treated seriously by philosophers. For him, though, these films are not philosophizing as such, but rather doing something “messier.” He credits their directors with making sophisticated aesthetic choices, and film as a form with providing a space for the exploration of the experiential and the passionate. Political psychology is a key concept in the book, and it opens into wider issues Pippin wants to raise about the limits of self-knowledge in relation to political theory, and the limits of idealization in national mythology. In his climactic essay on The Searchers, in which a trope of blindness and insight is related to the film's famous inside and outside shots, this becomes an explicit opportunity for critique.
The note of warning is gently but firmly introduced. Keeping sympathy with the films, and the world they depict, whilst unpacking some of what is generated around and informs them, is a delicate job. A reader interested solely in westerns would find plenty of interest, with only one or two strained analogies. But like The Searchers itself, Pippin hopes his readings might also bring into the light elements occluded from more conventional approaches to political philosophy. The book wears its references lightly (the densest allusions to Hegel, Rawls, or Schmitt occur in the notes), but the broad intention of the collection is to complicate the liberal picture. Pippin intends the issues he raises to be live ones. One of his tasks is the identification of fantasies and delusions, as distinct from allegories. Another is to provide an oblique angle on contemporary debates around liberalism and communitarianism. Significantly, though, there are no clear wearers of black and white stetsons. No one gets a moral pass in a world where true desires, commitments, and motives are so murky.
