Amitai Etzioni has written something of a pocket guide for public intellectuals, proffering hard-won lessons from his own time in the trenches. I wish that I had read his primer before I tried to break into the club. And I hope that PS readers seeking to be PI players read his guide with the right mix of humor, curiosity, and skepticism about the rules of success that Etzioni evinces.
As someone who, like Etzioni, has been granted the “father” moniker for PI grunt work (better than “godfather”!), I can relate to the double-edged nature of the sobriquet. In my case, the label came as a result of my advocacy for the so-called “public option,” the idea of creating a Medicare-like public insurance plan to compete with private insurance that became a central issue in the recent health care debate. As the “father of the public option,” I was featured in a none-too-friendly YouTube video purporting to uncover my covert agenda for total government takeover of American medicine. (Simultaneously, I was attacked by critics on the left for having given comfort to the private-sector enemy by advocating a public plan that would compete with private insurance, rather than a single public plan.) Needless to say, in these years of Tea Party outrage, I have received more than a few e-mails and phone calls helpfully pointing out that I should be—among other things—“ashamed,” “shipped to Gitmo,” and made to “pay for [my] treason.”
I do not know if Etzioni has some letters of this sort that he pulls out whenever he wants to remind himself why academic solitude is not all bad. But he is correct to emphasize that anyone who wants to push their ideas into public discourse should also be prepared to receive the slings and arrows of American politics.
* * *
On the other hand, Etzioni is rather quiet on the question of why. Why should political scientists leave the relative comfort of engaging other political scientists to take on the occasionally rewarding but often bruising—and, in scholarly circles, generally unappreciated—challenge of shaping public debate? In Etzioni's account, public intellectualism is portrayed as some kind of primal urge. “If you want to be a PI,” he seems to say, “here is what you need to keep in mind.” But why should you want to engage in public intellectualism in the first place?
The question really has two parts. The first is personal: Why should you want to engage in public intellectualism? Is this a calling that you can and should heed? Like Etzioni, I prefer to think of “being a PI” as more of a process than a role. Aspiring to be a PI is a recipe for frustration, not least because the identity is not self-chosen but bestowed on us by the informal but effective network of gatekeepers who determine access to the public sphere: editors, journalists, advocates, think tanks, political staff, television producers, politicians, and so on. Yet many of us can do the things that PIs do. The question is whether we should desire to.
We all know those “you might be a redneck” jokes made famous by the comedian Jeff Foxworthy. (Clue: “Chiggers are included on your list of top five hygiene concerns.”) In my version of the list, “you might be a PI” if you meet the following three criteria: First, your research centers on substantively important issues about which others care. Second, you have the ability to convey your ideas using clear and persuasive language, both written and spoken. And, third, you have enough interest in getting others to agree with or learn from you that you are willing to devote a good deal of time to the challenge. These characteristics certainly do not describe all political scientists, and indeed they probably describe a decreasing share of political scientists as the discipline becomes more specialized (Mead Reference Mead2010). But they surely describe a fair number more than the handful who actively take up the charge.
Why do so many political scientists who might be PIs not act as PIs? Part of the reason, no doubt, is the ingrained idea that the “intellectual” in the PI moniker is just for show—that many people who are called PIs are simply smooth talkers or facile writers spouting conventional wisdom or personal opinions without serious research to back them up (Posner Reference Posner2001). No doubt such folks are out there. But dismissing the mission of public intellectualism on the grounds that the field contains some substandard practitioners is like dismissing the mission of academic scholarship on the grounds that some academics do work that is shoddy or without impact. The best public intellectuals ground their advocacy in true expertise. They bring substantial learning and hard-won knowledge to bear on contemporary issues. They take carefully derived, sometimes highly technical research findings and translate them into insights that can guide public policy and public discussion. They understand that making their insights accessible or linking them to larger issues is not “dumbing them down,” but scaling them up.
* * *
Which brings us to the second part of the question: Why should political scientists, in particular, engage in public intellectualism? To put the question more pointedly: why does political science appear to be so underrepresented among the upper ranks of PIs? After all, some fields—history, law, and economics come immediately to mind—tend to produce many more PIs than does political science. Is there some reason why political scientists are not prominent in the roster of contemporary PIs? Should political science be more prominent?
To be sure, we all know (or know of) great political scientists with serious PI credentials. But clearly the list is not as long as the discipline's subject matter would suggest it should be. Political scientists, after all, study politics and public affairs. The discipline's roots lie in the very public intellectualism of the Founding Fathers. The discipline's own founding fathers—Wilson, Bryce, Merriam, Lasswell, and others of similar stature—were, almost without exception, deeply involved in public life as politicians, advocates, and advisers. What has changed? Is this a change for the worse or the better?
I can only speak from my own perspective, of course. But there is a strong case to be made that the lack of a substantial PI presence in contemporary political science is not just paradoxical, but lamentable and avoidable. As a discipline uniquely well-suited to support public engagement, political science suffers when public affairs cease to be an abiding concern of its practitioners. The costs include unhealthy disciplinary self-preoccupation, a fascination with trivial but technically tractable questions, supreme indifference to the stakes of politics—i.e., what government actually does—and a related lack of appreciation outside the discipline for the insights that political science can offer, made vivid by Republican Senator Tom Coburn's thankfully unsuccessful effort to cut off National Science Foundation funding for political science research. (“Theories on political behavior,” Coburn opined, “are best left to CNN, pollsters, pundits, historians, candidates, political parties, and the voters” [quoted in Tucker Reference Tucker2009].)
The highly technical quality of much research in the top political science outlets cannot be the core problem, since economics has this tendency in spades and yet has produced a steady stream of PIs. The core problem, it seems to me, is that political science today—unlike political science of previous generations, and unlike many subfields of economics today—is simply not all that interested in the substantive activities of governance (that is, policy). In American politics research and, to a lesser but growing extent, other empirical subfields, the great bulk of research centers on public opinion and political behavior, on the one hand, and models of basic decision making, such as roll-call votes, on the other. The struggle to use the levers of public authority to change the economy and society in durable ways is almost entirely missing from the discipline.
Now, it is certainly possible to have a discipline that studies public policy and produces no PIs. My coauthor Paul Pierson and I have argued for greater integration of substantive public policy into political science on the grounds that it will improve the scientific quality of the discipline (Hacker and Pierson Reference Hacker and Pierson2009). A political science that ignores policy, we argue, is a poor political science, a political science that fails to capture extremely important aspects of the phenomena under study. Nonetheless, there does seem to be an elective affinity between research that engages with what government does and research that stems from a desire and willingness to wade into policy discussions. A discipline concerned with how policy is made and how it reshapes the economy, society, and polity is simply much better poised to produce scholars equipped to speak to fundamental questions about the allocation and use of public authority.
* * *
As Etzioni's commentary suggests, one should not take up the PI banner with visions of easy success in mind. Nor—given where the discipline is right now—should one do so with illusions about winning the minds of fellow political scientists along with the hearts of the people. Political scientists do not all frown on public engagement, but there is no question that a strong current of skepticism and even hostility toward the PI path runs through the discipline. Certainly, this suspicion has some salutary effects—among other virtues, it encourages scholars to build a strong foundation of research on which to base their policy and political advice. Yet it also carries a major, mostly unacknowledged cost. The message sent to members of the profession is that they should feel free to do what they want in their own spare time, but they should not let these other activities get in the way of their real mission of scholastic achievement. Informed attempts to shape public debate based on serious research are, in this perspective, something like a hobby in which one can indulge occasionally and privately—and which others might frown on if they found out about it. No wonder so few political scientists are PIs.
Yet speaking truth to power is not a hobby. It is, as Etzioni puts it, “a calling or public service” (655). As a profession dedicated to the understanding of how societies resolve collective problems, allocate resources, and manage—or fail to manage—conflicts with sometimes life-or-death stakes, political science has a special ability and, yes, a special obligation to seek to influence the direction of governance when it can offer real guidance. It would be good for neither the discipline nor its practitioners if every political scientist started to fixate on the New York Times op-ed page. But it would be good, at least in this political scientist's view, if many more integrated the study of public policy into their research. And it would be even better if at least a modestly larger number felt willing to take up the PI mantle when they believed their research had clear implications for the construction of a better society.
