Nanotechnologies are the European Union’s spearhead of global competitiveness, as evidenced by the earlier framework programmes and, currently, the Horizon 2020 programme. Ehnert’s study tells of the origins of today’s regulatory state of play in this field, tapping into fundamental questions of EU political legitimacy. It intriguingly unveils the EU executive branch’s techniques for minimising parliamentary or public “interference” with the designing of nano policy (see sections IV and V below). The book provides an excellent example of the power of interdisciplinary research.
Their overwhelming economic significance makes nanotechnologies one of the most salient areas of risk regulation in our times. Well-defined prospects of benefits grapple with scientifically uncertain risks to health and the environment. This uncertainty makes it almost impossible to assess conclusively regulatory efforts’ conformity to primary EU law (avoiding over- or under-regulation), thus curtailing the latter’s capacity to inform appropriate legislation. Ehnert’s key argument is that this deficiency renders the standards of effectiveness for nano regulation particularly “subjective in nature” (pp xxxi, 7), making the “Where, by whom and how [.] decisions [are] taken” (p xxx) the litmus test of legitimacy. Consequently, her research question amounts to: “How does the EU confront the emergence of nanotechnologies?” (p xxxiv). In addressing it, the author seeks to paradigmatically explore broader questions of “the creation of legitimate regulation in modern societies” (p xxxiv). Methodologically, the study employs legal analysis, and empirical analysis of decision-making processes including qualitative interviews, and it draws from political and legal theory.
I The study’s structure
Chapter 1 introduces the regulatory challenge posed by nanotechnologies. Chapters 2–3 develop the study’s theoretical account of political legitimacy and discuss the Union’s overall approach to “good governance”. They draft criteria of legitimacy and of regulatory capacity for the purposes of Ehnert’s subjective approach, and some working definitions of key terms. Chapters 4–5 then put the preceding groundwork into practice. Two case studies in the fields of foods and chemicals survey the nanotech regulatory landscape and trace the latter’s coming into being. Empirical findings are then assessed for compliance with the criteria of regulatory capacity. The final chapter elaborates the study’s conclusion and the outlook for EU reforms.
II Author’s point of departure
In her initial chapter Ehnert provides an overview of how the EU has been tackling scientific uncertainty about adverse effects of nanotechnologies. The EU’s “incremental approach” (pp 7–9) is revealed: existing legislative frameworks are kept intact but amendments are made as soon as the specifics of nanotechnologies suggest them. However, Ehnert notes a divide between the Commission and the Parliament as to the extent to which nano-related risks are considered to be already covered. In 2009, the Parliament deemed current legislation unable to address these risks (pp 7–11). This conflict drives a lot of what is to come later in the case studies.
III Theoretical foundations
The second chapter first seeks to show that the issue of nanotechnologies is paradigmatic of “fundamental transformations in modern societies, namely those of globalisation, functional differentiation and the rise of the risk society” (p 14). Ehnert points out that globalisation does not affect every societal subsystem equally. The economic and scientific systems transcend territorial boundaries with ease, whereas systems like culture and health tend to remain interlocked with the nation-state. This mismatch adds to the intersystemic friction already existing due to operational closure in a Luhmannian sense. A thus ever-loosening grip of democratically accountable individual regulators then gets weakened even more when uncertainty comes into play (pp 15–20). Nanotechnologies embody all of these concerns: tremendous benefits spur innovative efforts in the economic system transnationally. Just as little, however, does environmentally-released nanomaterial stop at political borders. And scientific uncertainty subverts substantive justification of any regulatory effort.
In a nutshell, Ehnert’s subsequent proposal on how to make the best of this convoluted situation is to strive for maximum inclusion, replacing substantive criteria of legitimacy with proceduralisation. In order to provide a theoretical foundation, she has recourse to the Habermasian “ideal speech situation” and brings to mind the associated discursive conditions: full inclusion of all actors, equality, sincerity of the participants’ input, and non-coercion. Deliberative democracy should materialise, firstly, within the public sphere itself and, secondly, through responsive political institutions (pp 20–23). Habermas’ rejoinder to critics who question his account’s applicability to an EU still lacking a full-fledged public sphere is briefly discussed (p 23, and again at pp 61–62, 220). Additionally, Ehnert calls into service Teubner’s reflexive and pluralistic account of law, which she interprets as an attempt to salvage law’s societal role in face of increasing intersystemic friction (pp 23–26). Though designed to accommodate partly different purposes – political legitimacy versus the effectiveness of law – both Habermas’ and Teubner’s accounts end up proposing a procedural understanding of law-making (p 26).
The book then proceeds to delineate the EU’s own take on the pivotal transformations in a global society. While acknowledging the crisis of legitimacy and envisaging “better involvement”, the Commission, as Ehnert notes, falls way short of truly committing itself to deliberative democracy.Footnote 1 When it comes to risk regulation in particular, the Commission favours a solely science-infused precautionary principle over proceduralisation as the dominant policy-designing scheme. This downbeat finding has, Ehnert adds, prompted academic efforts to conceptualise new modes of governance all the more. She cites characteristics of such modes as identified by de Búrca and ScottFootnote 2 (eg participation, transparency and policy learning). These characteristics serve, so Ehnert implies, descriptive or normative purposes alternately, with the line between the two accounts being little reflected upon (pp 28–33).
The subsequent chapter first discusses the vagueness of concepts like “law”, “governance” and “regulation”. Ehnert resents using the former two in her study. “Law” is deemed to be unfit to accommodate for interdisciplinary research and to be oscillating between state-centered and pluralistic accounts. “Governance” is – somewhat quickly – dismissed as being too normatively charged in recent discussions. She chooses to go ahead with ‘regulation’, a concept understood as “the intentional attempt to alter the behaviour of others according to defined standards or purposes”Footnote 3 (p 44). In light of the executive branch’s resorting to non-binding regulatory instruments, as is depicted in the upcoming chapters, the broadness of this definition seems quite appropriate (pp 40–45).
Effective regulation has as a prerequisite sufficient regulatory capacity on the part of the regulator. Ehnert views “mastering knowledge” and “ensuring legitimacy” as key elements of regulatory capacity. “Knowledge”, she suggests, is a social construct. Though not expressly discussed in the book, this assumption seemingly connotes Habermasian consensus theory of truth: the outcome of a discourse in an ideal speech situation amounts to “the truth”. This does reconcile with Ehnert’s further claim that there are many truths (pp 50–51), for those “individual” truths can be seen as mere infusions (the “sincere input” mentioned above) into the ideal discourse that will eventually provide the “final” truth (keeping in mind that an ideal speech situation is only to be approximated and never actually attained). It also sits very well with her subjective take on nano regulation: scientific uncertainty obscuring the objective truth amounts to essentially the same effect on the regulator as does the absence of an objective truth whatsoever, the latter being implied by Habermas’ rejection of the correspondence theory of truth.
A requirement of broad participation in any decision-making process presents itself as a natural consequence of this account of “knowledge” (p 51). The following section introduces “Impact assessment” as the Union’s own means of gathering knowledge, which does allow for some participatory or consultative tools.
As for the second key element of regulatory capacity, “legitimacy”, Ehnert adopts the common distinction of input and output legitimacy. She also mentions the two fundamentally different routes to tackling legitimacy in political philosophy (pp 57–59): descriptive accounts, most notably Max Weber’s, ask why people may believe government to be legitimate, whereas normative accounts discuss substantive reasons of legitimacy resulting in a duty to obey. This issue is, however, not further explored, having Ehnert’s instant siding with the normative route (pp xxxvi, 199) come across as an axiomatic starting point.
The next sections examine how to generally achieve input and output legitimacy of nano regulation in particular. Now here is where Ehnert’s subjective take kicks in neatly. Output legitimacy usually rests upon “effective problem-solving” (p 58), ie upon a policy truly promoting the common good. However, as Ehnert rightfully points out, the existence of scientific uncertainty frustrates identifying a policy that would actually do so. Therefore, she suggests, output legitimacy should instead be achieved through ensuring ex-post-accountability of the regulator. Specifically, with the “proper” policy remaining unbeknownst due to scientific uncertainty, the regulator is to be held to account for how knowledge had been gathered prior to the decision-making, and how participation in the decision-making process, ie the ensuring of input legitimacy, was organised (pp 57–59, 118). With gathering knowledge in mind as being dependent on participation, too, “output legitimacy” for Ehnert supposedly means, in short, an ability to verify adherence to proper participatory procedures. Thus, her conception of legitimacy nicely ties together all aspects of regulatory capacity as defined in her study.
The remainder of the chapter elaborates on various modes of participation and accountability (political, administrative, legal and social). Participation is, most notably, achieved through representative democracy and through the involvement of affected actors in any decision-making process. Procedures should provide for “objective and subjective actor identification” (p 61; ie identification by discrete criteria or self-identification) in order to ensure full inclusion. Accountability may, for instance, be achieved through judicial review or the European Ombudsman (pp 59–71).
IV The case studies
The case study on the food sector (chapter 4) starts with an introduction to the risks and benefits of nanotechnologies and to the EU regulatory frameworks. Initial uncertainty as to the applicability of the Novel Food Regulation (EC) No 258/97 to nanofoods is revealed. Ehnert names the prior lack of a legal definition of nanomaterials as the likely cause, mostly owed to disagreement between Commission and Parliament. She then depicts the continuing struggle between the two institutions when it came to negotiating a revision (resulting in Regulation 2015/2283). She identifies a de facto moratorium on the commercialisation of nanofoods that was pursued by the Parliament. However, the only amendments that made it into the final text concern a nano-specific food category and a definition of engineered nano material (pp 73–82). In contrast, the Parliament was able to place a nano-specific – if cautious – provision in the Food Additives Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 (Article 12) early on. Finally, the Food Contact Materials (FCM) Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004 delegates the implementation of authorisation requirements to the Commission without calling for due regard to the specifics of nanomaterials (pp 83–85).
Ehnert infers dilatoriness of the Commission’s incremental approach as well as inconsistency among legal frameworks. The Commission favours administrative activity over legislation. Specifically, Ehnert identifies three different measures designed to handle the nano issue: implementing acts under the FCM Regulation, the mandating of an EFSA guidance document for the risk assessment of nanotechnological applications in food and feed, and a recommendation targeted at eliminating definitional confusion over nanomaterial (pp 85–86).
The chapter proceeds to meticulously examine whether the key elements of regulatory capacity – “mastering knowledge” and “ensuring input/output legitimacy” – were properly present in the devising of these measures. As for “mastering knowledge”, key findings concern a limited and blurry scope of application of the impact assessment procedure. Other procedures in place lacked transparency and inclusion. In essence, Ehnert laments an “empty procedural net” (p 106) created by the Commission. Basically the same holds for “ensuring input legitimacy”. Reluctance towards legislative action makes Parliament involvement – and hence input legitimacy through political participation – scarce overall. Administrative participation did not make up for that, which Ehnert calls paradoxical (p 118). Procedures in place are deemed limited or blurry in scope, opaque, or non-inclusive. For instance, online consultations launched by the Commission and the Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks (SCENIHR) used questionnaires that restricted the range of commentable issues, actor self-identification was partly unavailable, and results of consultations were partly not made public (pp 94–120). As for output legitimacy, ie accountability, Ehnert discerns reluctant use of Parliament’s oversight powers. Non-bindingness of administrative measures in question has them mostly elude judicial review as well, de facto bindingness notwithstanding. The European Ombudsman fares somewhat better in Ehnert’s view (pp 118–43).
The case study on the chemicals sector (chapter 5) again catches the Commission shying away from legislative revision and resorting to implementing acts and ECHA guidance documents. Ehnert points out that from the outset the latter measures are not suited to fix issues in REACH itself. Among these are the tonnage thresholds for the requirement of registration/preparation of a Chemical Safety Report, which have bulk material in mind. Nanomaterial is generally produced in much smaller quantity, making REACH largely inapplicable as a result (pp 148–66).
As for “mastering knowledge”, Ehnert welcomes the launch of an impact assessment for some proposed REACH implementing acts,Footnote 4 however she suspects dubious political reasons at work: the impact assessment may only be directed at easing some of the turmoil caused by foregoing legislative revision (pp 168, 202). The section also discusses the updating process of some of the ECHA guidance documents. Though ECHA has an updating procedure in place, including consultative steps, this procedure was circumvented in favour of a “fast-track update”. Consultation was deemed unnecessary, as it had allegedly already taken place within the Commission’s adjacent REACH Implementation Project on Nanomaterials (RIPoN) (pp 178–79). This is rejected on the grounds that the RIPoN process lacks transparency and provides only for a shortened consultation period, as compared to the genuine ECHA procedure (pp 186–87).
The section on input legitimacy decries lacking or rudimentary consultation standards, an erratic applicability of the standards existing and the Parliament not exercising its participation right in the preparation of some of the administrative measures (pp 180–89). As for accountability, parliamentary oversight and judicial review are again shown to be extremely limited (pp 210–19).
Ehnert concludes her case studies, finding that “controversial issues [are] shifted to the EU administration, which, largely shielded from the public eye, works out substantive rules in collaboration with a selected number of stakeholders and, thereby, remains largely beyond the control of the pertinent accountability fora” (p 198). The richness of the empirical material and the careful analysis thereof do sustain this assessment.
V Overall result
Ehnert concedes some amount of proceduralisation on the books, which, however, is largely voided in nano practice. The executive branch made sure to be “bound” by participatory provisions largely only at will (pp 206–07). Suggestions for reform include a justification requirement in case no impact assessment is performed. The Better Regulation Package of 2015 is deemed largely insufficient. In addition, at least rudimentary adoption procedures for guidance documents should be laid down in EU Agencies’ founding regulations. The latter would also facilitate judicial review (pp 213–15). Ehnert calls for a further disclosure of the political nature of what seem to be merely “scientific” assessments (pp 220–22).
VI Conclusions
Ehnert’s study is a demanding yet rewarding read. The interwovenness of a great number of theoretical and empirical threads commands undiminishing attention. Ehnert accomplishes holding all these threads coherently together throughout her study. She nicely assists the reader in keeping track by providing regular written-out and tabular recaps of preceding sections. The thoroughness of the empirical research deserves particular praise, too.
Ehnert’s reasoning as to the inevitability of a subjective take on nano regulation and, subsequently, of an inclusive regulatory approach, is compelling. This, however, raises the question of whether and how EU Fundamental Rights and Single Market Freedoms can still retain some legal impact. These rights and freedoms are meant as substantive boundaries of democratic decision-making, protecting business companies as well as consumers from over- and under-regulation. Sure enough, this desideratum does not reflect some shortcoming of Ehnert’s considerations, but rather an inherent deadlock of the subject matter itself, which, by all means, has always been the central predicament of risk regulation. In light of that, Ehnert appears justified in maintaining her specific focus on empirico-theoretical analysis of regulatory legitimacy and in handing primary EU law’s continued grip to future research. Only some elaboration on the constitutional relationship between the Executive, the Parliament and the Judiciary would have been in order. Parliament’s lack of relevant knowledge and political participation, as well as judicial self-restraint, are lamented throughout the book. However, further examination is warranted as to what extent the limited role of Parliament and Judiciary in nano regulation merely follows the lines of responsibility drawn by the principle of institutional balance, which in its own right is a means of establishing output legitimacy by conferring to an EU body (only) those powers that it is best equipped to handle.
I recommend the book to academics in the fields of law and social sciences as well as to practitioners with an interest in EU’s handling of new technologies and in EU policy design in general. Specifically, the book presents an abundant source of case material highlighting the desirability of a single legal framework for EU administrative procedure as is proposed, for instance, by the European Parliament and the Research Network on EU Administrative Law (ReNEUAL).
