
That State sovereignty would be a barrier to any broad judicial role was evident during the drafting of the Geneva Conventions – States would not agree to a proposal to grant compulsory jurisdiction to the ICC. The Plenary Assembly of the 1949 Diplomatic Conference heard that:
To deplore the inadequacy of the procedure for settling disputes under international law is almost a commonplace. Whereas national legislations generally provide for the repression of any infringement of their rules, and whereas all legal disputes are settled by the national courts of justice, the dogma of State sovereignty in international law has proved an insurmountable obstacle to any generalization of a system of compulsory international jurisdiction.Footnote 3
The deliberately limited part played by international courts in this context, as Sharon Weill observes, “reinforces the important responsibility carried by national jurisdictions”.Footnote 4 Yet, as she discusses and analyzes at length in The Role of National Courts in Applying International Humanitarian Law, domestic judicial bodies are also subject to certain restrictions when addressing wartime conduct.
It was apparent during the preparation of the Geneva Conventions that States considered national courts the more appropriate venue for judicial consideration, if any, of matters relating to conduct during armed conflict. The judicial enforcement of IHL, Weill points out, “relies primarily on domestic courts”.Footnote 5 As the first detailed treatment of this subject, this book is a welcome and long overdue contribution to the existing literature on international law and IHL, which has not previously provided such a comparative analysis of the national application of IHL.Footnote 6 Against the backdrop of an increased number of national cases concerning IHL, Weill's book provides “a theoretical framework for the analysis of national jurisprudence in the field of IHL”.Footnote 7 National courts do not enjoy the same degree of detachment that international tribunals have from domestic politics and pressures, and this invariably impacts on the national application of IHL. It is these dynamics and influences which are at the heart of Weill's book. She focuses on the “functional role” of national courts, and the book has as one of its primary aims the deconstruction of the “contradictory and often incoherent positions in which national courts place themselves when applying IHL”.Footnote 8 Weill proposes a methodology for understanding court decisions “in order to decipher properly their functional role”.Footnote 9 According to the spectrum of roles she identifies, courts might:
serve as a legitimating agency of the state; avoid exercising jurisdiction for extra-legal considerations; defer the matter back to the other branches of government; enforce the law as required by the rule of law; or, develop the law and introduce ethical judgment beyond the positive application of the law.Footnote 10
These various roles are analyzed in turn in the individual chapters of the book, which provide a thorough and critical demonstration as to why the domestic application of IHL is neither “predictable nor consistent”.Footnote 11
At the outset of the study, Weill observes how the unique context of armed conflict serves to place obstacles in the path of national courts that may seek to “oversee the state's exercise of its war time power”.Footnote 12 She elaborates:
The conduct of wars has traditionally been left to the discretion of the executive and its professional agencies. Their information is generally kept out of the public domain. This concealment prevents the effective crystallization of public opinion, impairs public ability to influence decision-making, and weakens the demand for judicial scrutiny over armed conflict issues. These and other socio-pyschological factors that favour unity and support for the state (all of which typically emerge in times of crisis and violence) lead to a weakening of the checks and balances of the democratic system, not least its oversight by the judiciary.Footnote 13
Even where in a position to exercise such oversight, judges have shown a tendency to defer to military decisions taken on the battlefield, except perhaps in especially egregious cases. This judicial approach is apparent in a couple of cases which are not explicitly mentioned by the author, but which can be seen to confirm her analysis. In a 2013 case concerning British soldiers in Iraq, the UK Supreme Court expressed the view that a court should be “very slow indeed to question operational decisions made on the ground by commanders”.Footnote 14 A UK–US Claims Arbitral Tribunal sitting over a century earlier, in 1910, also preferred to defer to those in the field on questions of military necessity:
The determination of these necessities ought to be left in a large measure to the very persons who are called upon to act in difficult situations, as well as to their military commanders. A non-military tribunal, and above all an international tribunal, could not intervene in the field save in case of manifest abuse of this freedom of judgment.Footnote 15
Such deference is but one manifestation of the complex relationship between judicial bodies and State actions during situations of armed conflict. Weill's study helps the reader to make sense of these interactions, with its in-depth and thought-provoking analysis of national jurisprudence on IHL.
The book's structure is based on the spectrum of judicial roles put forward by the author, beginning with apologist in Chapter 1 and ending with utopian in Chapter 4. This schema obviously borrows from the work of Martti Koskenniemi in part,Footnote 16 and although the author does not explain the rationale for drawing on Koskenniemi in this way, the approach provides a useful means of characterizing the varying judicial approaches to the application of IHL. The reader is faced in Chapter 1 with the author's sternest criticism of the national application of the laws of armed conflict. Focusing on Israel and Serbia, Weill portrays the relevant courts as apologists for State wrongdoing. She shows that in certain instances judicial bodies are used to give legitimacy to governments and their policies by way of judicial review, given that such a process tends to lead to only the most serious of illegal acts being overruled.Footnote 17 Courts in this apologist category have tended to give a judicial imprimateur to wrongful activity, while demonstrating their independence “through the rare landmark cases in which they rule against the interests of the state”.Footnote 18 In this chapter, Weill looks at the “hidden politics of the law”, arguing that judicial interpretation allows for the making of policy choices, and that when making decisions, national courts “choose the most politically convenient option”.Footnote 19
In Weill's well-argued opinion, the Israel High Court of Justice, sitting in judicial review of the acts of military commanders, has largely acted as an apologist for Israeli military actions. Through its questionable treatment of the law of occupation, she starkly concludes, the Court has “not only legitimatized the creation of a segregation regime in the [Occupied Palestinian Territories], but has actively contributed to its formation by providing the state with the necessary legal tools required to design and implement it”.Footnote 20 Its approach has been one marked by selectivity, excessive deference to military opinion, and a failure to look at policies in their broader context.Footnote 21 The chapter also provides a consideration of the record of the Belgrade War Crimes Chamber, which stands as a rare example of a domestic court which has prosecuted its own nationals for crimes associated with a recent conflict.Footnote 22 Although created under international pressure, the Chamber is a domestic judicial body without international staff or judges, and lacking in sufficient expertise on IHL. As examples of its apologist approach, Weill highlights how the prominent Scorpions ruling was “in line with the political interest of the state”, while similarly the prosecutor refused to apply command responsibility and prosecute high-ranking commanders.Footnote 23 The focus on lower-level accused, she finds, was the result of either “political pressures or self-imposed restraints”.Footnote 24 The chapter provides an important reminder of the undoubted propensity for a regressive application of IHL by national judicial bodies.
In Chapter 2, Weill turns to the avoiding role played by domestic courts, whereby doctrines such as act of State, political question, forum non conveniens and combat immunity result in States being “shielded” from judicial scrutiny.Footnote 25 The chapter focuses principally on the United States and United Kingdom, where higher courts have avoided “politically sensitive cases through the application of self developed doctrines”.Footnote 26 Alien Tort Statute decisions, for example, have tended to reflect the State Department's position on whether to allow or deny jurisdiction, with courts mostly, but not always, seeking to avoid interfering in political questions and foreign affairs. Weill finds that US courts can “rely on convenient jurisprudence to decide on a state by state basis whether it is appropriate to adjudicate and apply IHL or whether it is appropriate to avoid rendering justice”.Footnote 27 She usefully contrasts the US and Israeli courts’ approach to justiciability in the context of targeted killings.Footnote 28 The chapter concludes by suggesting that an international court's intervention may be desirable where the oversight provided by national courts proves unsatisfactory.Footnote 29
The subsequent chapter addresses the normative role of national courts, and provides a more positive account of the part played by judicial bodies in limiting the conduct of States during armed conflicts. Weill finds that domestic courts are showing “a growing determination and willingness to exercise their role of ‘law enforcer’ for violations of IHL during armed conflict”.Footnote 30 The influence of human rights law is also addressed in Chapter 3, with courts more likely to tackle individual rights violations rather than matters pertaining to conduct of hostilities.Footnote 31 The same can be said for international courts applying IHL, whereby “Geneva” law addressing the protection of civilians, detainees and prisoners of war has and continues to receive far more attention than “Hague” law applicable to the conduct of hostilities.
The final substantive chapter looks at the “utopian role” played by judges when they engage in activism and the development of the law. The latter occurs, Weill argues, where national courts interpret treaty rules beyond acceptable limits, perhaps “in the name of ethical values”, or where they identify a new rule of customary international law without sufficient evidence. Such occurrences are not unknown in the international jurisprudence on IHL,Footnote 32 and indeed judge-made law has been a feature of common-law legal systems. However, this is problematic for the international legal order:
When adjudicating between two parties, if the court chooses to develop the law rather than just applying the law appropriate to that particular case, unforeseen consequences may result. It is questionable whether a national court has the ability, or the willingness, to take into consideration the global consequences of its ruling, which may go beyond the particular interests of the litigating parties.Footnote 33
The chapter reveals that in national jurisprudence applying the laws of armed conflict, such decisions are “extremely rare”, with the Ferrini case in Italy, involving the lifting of State immunity for jus cogens crimes, standing apart.Footnote 34 Weill notes that the case went against settled practice on the matter, as the International Court of Justice confirmed, and that the Italian courts were in fact guilty of double standards.Footnote 35 While accepting that judges have some discretion in choosing between claims of varying legal merits, she considers that when they enter “the twilight zone of utopia, that choice is no longer an implementation of a legal rule, but the execution of a moral value”.Footnote 36 It can be difficult, of course, to draw fine lines here, especially if unwritten customary international law is being applied by the courts.
The concluding chapter provides an assessment of the different roles accorded to national courts by the author over the preceding pages with regard to various rule of law principles. The rule of law requires that the judiciary be “independent, impartial [and] accessible” and that it provide “an effective and equal enforcement of the law”.Footnote 37 For Weill, the record of national courts in this regard has proven deficient; she considers there to be a demonstrable structural bias in favour of the State during adjudication, which at its worst reveals “judicial practice based on double standards, bias and impartiality”.Footnote 38 She provides a very valuable section at the end of the book entitled “Looking Forward” which usefully summarizes the factors that influence the performance of national judiciaries addressing the laws of armed conflict.
The book demonstrates a healthy scepticism towards judicial bodies and presents a strong critique at times of the record of national bodies, motivated by the author's desire for “the optimal fulfilment of the international rule of law”.Footnote 39 The book is thoroughly researched and unquestionably timely, and will appeal to scholars of IHL and international law, as well as those with an interest in the judicial function and the interaction of different legal regimes. Military lawyers, international and domestic judges, and the legal advisers of non-governmental and inter-governmental organizations will also be richly rewarded by reading this book. The critique presented by Weill contributes significantly to our understanding of how judicial bodies apply IHL and the motivations and dynamics underlying such application. The book also acts as a counterpoint to an emerging discourse which claims that military activities are becoming increasingly and indeed overly restricted by the expansion of applicable legal rules and the growing reach of judicial bodies, particularly with regard to developments in international human rights law.Footnote 40 Weill's analysis demonstrates that there remains considerable scope for enhancing judicial oversight of the activities of parties to armed conflict.
