The Nation and its “New” Women details societal, cultural, and political changes that took place in Palestinian society during the British Mandate through the lens of Palestinian women and the women's movement. This well-researched book is divided into two sections. The first three chapters provide the background out of which the Palestinian women's movement arose, the major issues faced by women in Palestinian society and politics, and the major debates in Palestinian society about women and nationalism, veiling, education, and work. The second section charts the development of the women's movements by examining different forms of women's activism: charity, women's organizations, politics, feminism, and Pan-Arabism.
Fleischmann situates her work within three major tropes that defined Palestinian society and women's activism at the time, as well as in contemporary academia: nationalism, feminism, and colonialism. Nationalism was the dominant force in Palestinian life during the period of study and thus forms the major influence shaping Palestinian women's lives and directing their activism. Fleischmann charts the “women question” as it appears in the Arabic press and creates a fascinating study of Palestinian women and men debating publicly many of the issues of the day, which included the veil, the marriage crisis, women's rights, and woman as the savior of the nation. These debates centered around ideas of tradition and modernity that did not so much clash but rather were used to promote competing ideas of progress for the nation, thus “demonstrating the extent to which almost all Palestinians began to conceive of so many aspects of their lives in nationalist terms” (p. 82).
The overlap between nationalism and feminism appears throughout the book but perhaps most clearly in Chapter 4, which focuses on charitable organizations. Here, the emphasis on preserving Palestinian society, which oftentimes meant uncritical support for patriarchal social and cultural institutions, grew out of the overriding nationalist concerns facing Palestinians during this period. In fact, these organizations developed out of the absence of social welfare provided by the state and also provided an arena for educated and active women to focus their energies. However, “their linking of socioeconomic issues solely to the national issue ultimately limited their ability to develop a critical understanding of some of the sources of internal problems in Palestinian society while at the same time, their focus on the national situation provided an opening for their more overt political involvement” (p. 114).
In analyzing the women's movement, Fleischmann describes the limits of feminism as a scholarly framework for histories of people and places that did not develop within the same context as that which provided for Western feminist history. Instead, she argues for understanding Palestinian women's voices and actions that showed a “female consciousness” and forms that could be described as indigenous, nationalist feminisms. To this end, Chapters 5 through 7 provide the details of women's activism from the charitable work of the late Ottoman period to the inception of the women's movement in 1929 and the maturation of women's political consciousness in the 1930s and 1940s. There was a good deal of ambivalence in the early years about the women's movement (by middle-class and elite women who made up the ranks)—about the role of women in the nation and the contradictory push of modernity (as defined by the colonial power) and indigenous reform movements that women embraced on occasion and renegotiated on others. The women, however, always prioritized a clear Palestinian nationalist position. Because, unlike the male-led nationalist movement, there was almost no infighting among the women's organizations, the women's groups formed a consistently strong and militant force opposing British policies. By the 1940s the women's movements shifted from informal organizational structures based on friendship and kinship that had earlier defined their groups to democratic structures of elections, committees, and mass-oriented political techniques, which again set them apart from their male counterparts who led the Palestinian national movements.
The third pole of the book focuses on colonialism. To understand the rise of women's activism, Fleischmann documents attitudes in British official and missionary discourse toward Arab and Muslim women. These attitudes declared women to be oppressed and degraded and in need of a civilizing mission to save them, attitudes that Fleischmann shows middle-class Palestinian women both adopted and resisted. Fleischmann reveals, however, how little the British accorded to women and girls despite the rhetoric. For example, boys' schools outnumbered girls' schools at a ratio of ten to one, and the only governmental girls' secondary school, the Women's Training College, charged fees. It was the private and missionary schools instead that educated the vast majority of secondary school-aged girls. Furthermore, government policies toward girls and women focused on creating good wives and mothers; this was achieved by restricting the educational curriculum to subjects such as embroidery, housewifely skills, and hygiene, as well as by conducting hygiene campaigns throughout the villages and cities of Palestine. Fleischmann makes clear that in teaching individuals to be cleaner and healthier, the government failed to address infrastructural limits such as running water, sewage facilities, and health clinics—all of which it failed to provide—in addition to the economic inequalities created by the unequal pay regulations that the government enforced for both women and Arabs.
Fleischmann's scholarship is solid and innovative in her approach to the sources and the subject; her manuscript is a significant and noteworthy contribution to 20th-century Middle Eastern history, literature on women in the Arab world, and Mandatory Palestine. Because women active in the women's movement dominate the narrative, the more common experiences and lives of contemporary women do not come out very strongly in this text. Therefore, readers should not overlook that at this time there was almost no social mixing of the sexes, urban women would not leave the house without a male relative, and there were extremely limited educational and work opportunities for girls and women, both poor and rich. Fleischmann is careful to always forefront class within her discussion, nonetheless acknowledging that her sources are almost entirely from urban, middle- and upper-class women and men. These women felt that, despite their education and economic well-being, they were more restricted than their rural counterparts, whom they saw as simple and hardworking, more free to move around, and, in some ways, more independent than the closely watched and sheltered urban woman.
Despite this, the text is an excellent one for teaching advanced undergraduates or graduate students. Fleischmann's work exemplifies the historian's craft. She discusses her methods and the sources she uses—newspapers, correspondence, oral histories, autobiographies—and the advantages and limits of each. The strengths of The Nation and its “New” Women are in the detailed research, extensive use of a broad range of sources, and careful analysis of women's lives placed within the larger context of Palestinian nationalism, British colonialism, 20th-century modernity, educational reform, and charitable and political movements.
