Book reviews often begin with praise of the ambitious nature of the work. On the contrary, the strength of Zeynep Çelik's About Antiquities is its modesty. Rather than focusing on the works excavated, as in art history, or in the history of the excavations, as in the history of archaeology, Çelik looks outside of the multiple frames that make meaning out of antiquities in the context of the Ottoman Empire. Through a fresh look at old sources and in engagement with recent scholarship, About Antiquities looks to context over content from international to local perspectives.
The introduction begins with the deceptively simple question of who owns antiquities. It points to the hierarchies of ownership discussed in the rest of the text: identification through modern cultural production and the European enterprise of archaeology; issues of class distinction in the Ottoman Empire as affiliated with European cultural practices; the experiences of travelers to archaeological sites in the empire, both foreign and regional; and the experiences of communities living near and/or working on site excavations. Moving from transcontinental to local contextualizations, Çelik uses unusual comparisons and a detailed reading of archival materials to integrate recent observations about the archaeological enterprise into the Ottoman context.
A central assumption in the ideology of development is that institutions developed first in the West and then were emulated in the East. Examining the cotemporal institution and investments in the Istanbul Archaeology Museum and the Metropolitan Museum in New York, Çelik subtly undermines such assumptions. Yet far from presenting an oppositional, defensive stance implying that the two institutions were competing on equal ground, Çelik points out how the ideology of antiquities and ownership and the relationships between state and private investment played out in each context. By pointing to outsider nations on either side of Europe, she examines discourses of ownership through cultural affiliation and through territorialism played out as an expression of the right to own and the needs to invest in ownership and public education. One might assume that the better outcome of the Metropolitan Museum reflects a relative lack of interest in antiquities in the Ottoman Empire. Rather, Çelik makes clear that it is the lack of investment in public education rather than an absence of cultural identification.
The second chapter examines how racial discourses colored debates about the rightful ownership of antiquities in Europe and the United States. Although theoretically, archaeologists, scholars, and others engaging in the debate could see value in leaving antiquities in place, they interpreted the failure of locals to care for the works as ample ground to remove them to European museums, regardless of the efforts of Ottoman elites. As discussed in the conclusion, the baldly expressed racial expression of such ideas may ruffle contemporary feathers, but their clear echoes in contemporary discourses underscore the sublimated racial discourses that continue to underlie global cultural hierarchies.
The third chapter takes on the painstaking effort of finding references to the Ottoman Imperial Museum in fiction, travel guides, and reports about visits to Istanbul. The chapter begins by framing documentary reports with fictional accounts by the French author Emile Zola, the American Edith Wharton, and the Turkish Kemal Tahir in order to reflect on the potential foreignness and emotional inaccessibility of the museum in many contexts. Rather than imagining a contrast between Euro-American audiences who readily accept the educational value of museums and Ottoman/Turkish audiences who do not appreciate their worth, these quotations introduce a leveling effect that questions the presumption of the museum as a space of transparent knowledge production that reaffirms a globally differential hierarchy of cultural capital. This context allows an examination of how similarly alien institutions in Paris and New York flourished, while that in Istanbul remained relatively poorly attended. Rather than naturalizing this in the culture of origin with clear racialist implications, the work looks to histories of development.
Chapter 4 offers a counterpart to European traveler reports through an examination of Ottoman engagements with antiquities. A comparison between Lord Byron's play Sardanapale (1921) and a version by the Ottoman author Abdülhak Hamid (written in 1876 but published in 1919), the work again uses cross-cultural comparison to frame documentary evidence. Reading of many relatively difficult-to-access late Ottoman journals allows for a subtle interpretation of how Ottomans framed their relationship to antiquities. Focusing on discussions of Baalbeck, Ninevah, and Palmyra, with descriptions of contemporary habitation and access to the sites, the work offers food for thought about sites that have become focal points in many contemporary discussions of heritage preservation.
This emphasis on the local addressed in the last two chapters of the book offer the most original and refreshing perspective on the history of Ottoman archaeology. Whereas earlier chapters addressed topics that have been taken up by others in new and more detailed ways, these chapters bring forth an emphasis on local labor and habitation that has not been central to discourses on Ottoman archaeology. Chapter 5 establishes the diversity of labor practices at various sites in the empire, each run by individual archaeologists responding to varying local conditions with different budgets, cultural expectations and presumptions, and relationships with the excavations. Rather than imputing an overarching imperial perspective to the excavations, the chapter suggests that a close reading of the scant information that we have about them suggests a wide variety of motivations and experiences at the sites. Chapter 6 continues with this localization by comparing existing settlements, particularly at Palmyra, with the varieties of temporary habitation needed by archaeologists and laborers at archaeological sites. Interpreting the spatial relationships between upper-class Ottoman and European archaeologists with local laborers in relation to colonial urbanism, it suggests fault lines between the us and them of empire less along lines of race and nation than along those of class. With ample and fascinating illustrations of life conditions at excavation sites, these final chapters expose sites often imagined as a direct link to the ancient past as living spaces in which the death of the past had to be reconstructed through archaeology.
The conclusion touches briefly on the types of controversies that have been raised through the rise of the so-called Islamic State and the vast destruction of antiquities as well as the growth of the illegal antiques trade in recent years. Acknowledging these current repercussions, Çelik recognizes these as complex topics unto themselves and leaves comparisons with our own times largely to the reader.
With a detailed presentation of textual and visual examples that go beyond current publications in the field, About Antiquities touches lightly upon the complex debates intrinsic to the critical study of archaeology and heritage, complimenting and making important methodological contributions to the rapidly developing and increasingly relevant historiographic field.
