This volume contains the conference proceedings of the 20th Franco-Italian Meeting (Rencontre) on the epigraphy of the Roman world, which took place in Poitiers on 18–19 September 2014. The thread that binds the volume together is how epigraphy reflects slave-master relationships. The introduction by F. Chausson (3–10) briefly discusses the scale of Roman slavery and how the epigraphic record might reflect the relationships between masters and at least some of their closest slaves. Unfortunately, this introduction does not provide much information about the contents of the volume, nor indications of the theoretical premises which underpin the selection and organisation of contributions.
The first section, dedicated to slavery and the law, is in fact heavily slanted towards manumission. Drawing upon contracts of manumission from Delphi, D. Mulliez (13–30) assesses the survival of the pre-Roman legal framework in the aftermath of Roman imperial expansion in the eastern Mediterranean, and the extent to which everyday practice adjusted to it. A brief mention (16) of how the transition from capture to breeding in the slave supply may have affected the probability of manumission directs the reader all the way back to Rostovtzeff's monumental work, while barely mentioning more recent scholarship on slave supply and demographics, a trait not unique to this contribution. E. Incelli (31–43) aims at using epigraphy and papyri to identify what he claims were the two most widespread modes of manumission in the Roman world: testamento and inter amicos. The resulting picture is far less gruesome than the typical tale of authority and domination enforced by the whip. Incelli argues that the evidence confirms that not all Roman masters regarded slaves as empsycha organa (43). This is unsurprising, however, as this Aristotelian notion was alien to the Romans, who saw slavery as the mere product of chance. F. Luciani (45–64) analyses how private patron-freedman relationships were reproduced in the rapport between public freedmen and the cities whose slaves they formerly were. However, his claim that new discoveries and the re-examination of inscriptions overlooked by A. Weiss, Sklave der Stadt (2009) would shed new light on Roman public slavery is unaccompanied by detailed discussion of new material. Finally, N. Laubry (65–79) explores the meaning and implications of the formula libertis libertabusque. The discussion focuses on both the legal and the symbolic value of a formula which prolonged the freedmen-patron reciprocal obligations long after the demise of the latter.
The overarching theme of the second section, on ‘Le monde servile face aux hommes, aux dieux, à la mort’, is less easy to pin down, which is not unusual in conference proceedings. C. Hamdoune (83–96) proposes a new reading of CIL VIII 21303, a versified inscription of a slave of King Juba II. The inscription is presented as a good illustration of the adoption of Roman usages by the Mauritanian royal family. This contribution has little connection with the next four and I wonder whether it would have been better placed in the regional studies section. C. Landrea's survey of the epigraphic material left by the familia of the Valerii Messallae (97–111) shows that this household was quite unexceptional. More interesting is the brief last section on the epitaph of Zosimus, a freedman of M. Aurelius Cotta Maximus (cos. a.d. 20), which illustrates the role Roman nobiles had in the social promotion of former slaves.
The interaction of slaves with the supernatural is introduced by A. Alvar Nuño's study of the defixio of Politoria (113–27), a rare example of a slave having her master as the target of a curse. The discussion is introduced by an attempt to theorise on magic, which draws upon authors like Wilamowitz-Moellendorff and Weber, but overlooks more recent developments on the subject. The reader is warned against seeing magic as ‘mambo jambo’ (sic), which I presume is a phonetic error. S. Antolini and S. M. Marengo (129–40) analyse dedications of slaves and freedmen to the genius of not only their masters and patrons, but — more interestingly — of non-personal and abstract entities such as vici, pagi, collegia, etc. The expansion of such practices is seen as an Augustan innovation which mirrors the cult of the genius of the emperor and which allegedly shows a more humane side of slave-master relationships. Finally, G. L. Gregori and G. Bianchini (141–59) discuss two unpublished funerary carmina inscribed on an ash container found near Rome in 2013. The poems contain an unusual number of conventional no-thought-for-the-morrow Epicurean maxims.
The last section is dedicated to regional studies which vary in length, depth and scope. Only two contain new material. M. Silvestrini (279–96) presents some unpublished inscriptions from the National Archaeological Museum of Taranto. G. L. Gregori (243–52) draws upon an unpublished inscription dedicated to an alumnus and domnulus (little master) to reassess the role of tatae, i.e. lower-class male child minders. Surprisingly, K. Bradley's contribution to this subject remains unacknowledged (in Discovering the Roman Family (1991), 76–102). Other contributors instead work with published material. A. Buonopane and G. Cresci Marrone (163–84) draw upon 341 inscriptions from the Padanian plain to study the relationship between female patrons (patronae) and their freedmen. The discussion is fairly descriptive and ends rather abruptly without general conclusions. C. Zaccaria (185–213) performs an exhaustive survey of inscriptions from Aquileia. He claims that the material reflects a gradual acknowledgement of slaves’ human dignity which led to the mitigation of their condition. That this could stem from the intrinsic bias of epigraphic sources is not considered. G. Mennella (215–25) offers a new reading of CIL V 6785, based on autopsy performed after the inscription was removed from its location and transferred to a local museum. F. Cenerini (227–41) focuses on a small selection of stelae from Aemilia which commemorate child slaves. She argues that the material reflects the humane spirit of Seneca's Ep. 47, but acknowledges that her selection has an over-representation of privileged slaves. M. L. Caldelli's discussion of 80 epigraphs from Ostia (253–67) reaches similar conclusions to the extent that she sees that master-slave relationships were not necessarily predicated on conflict and violence. L. Chioffi (269–77) attempts to establish a typology of domini in Capuan inscriptions. Her selection shows slaves owned both by individuals and cities, corporations, collegia, etc. She claims without much elaboration that the material testifies to a thriving and well-administered community. The volume is closed by a fairly detailed discussion by M. B. Cocco (297–318) of the epigraphic testimonies to slavery in Sardinia from the Late Republic to Late Antiquity.
The contribution of epigraphy to our understanding of Roman slavery has been invaluable. I felt, however, that this volume did not fulfil its potential. The more theoretical sections often overlook some significant recent scholarship and do not always sufficiently discuss the problems posed by epigraphic evidence. Undoubtedly, historians of slavery will find here some interesting epigraphic material in a self-contained volume, but the selection is far from thorough, the material is unevenly distributed and the focus is somewhat skewed towards the less unpleasant aspects of slavery. I entirely understand that this stems from the nature of the sources analysed. But while epigraphy exposes a more multi-faceted portrayal of slavery, we should never forget that the institution was sustained by violence, brutality and arbitrariness. More importantly, the differential treatment of the slaves which figure prominently in our epigraphic record is the embodiment of that arbitrariness, something which is not highlighted sufficiently by some of the contributions to this volume.
