In this book Paulo Drinot offers a new look at the labour history of twentieth-century Peru, especially during the 1920s and 1930s, when Peru had what he calls a ‘labor state’. The 1920s and 1930s were indeed an era of rapid modernisation and industrialisation throughout most of Latin America, which saw the emergence of new political forces and social groups: an emerging middle class, mainly due to the expansion of the state and the professions, an increasingly better organised group of workers, and new political parties (Socialist, Communist, APRA), whose voices became louder in defence of workers' rights. It was a period when the Peruvian state was competing for votes with these more left-oriented political parties, and a time when Peruvian elites were eager to show the world how progressively modern Peru was.
The Peruvian state made many efforts to create a modern, clean and disciplined industrial workforce. Drinot analyses several of the main venues through which the workers were meant to be absorbed into the state's intentions (governability): the Labour Section of the Ministerio de Fomento (institutionalising and arbitrating conflicts between labour and capital), the barrios obreros (workers' districts), the restaurantes populares (state-funded eateries), and the Seguro Social Obrero (comprehensive social insurance and free hospitalisation). Policies issued through these entities and programmes were a prolongation of the arm of the Peruvian state, with seemingly little leeway of their own. Drinot's book weaves around official and celebratory narratives and critical counternarratives, including such well-known ones as those by José Carlos Mariátegui, the founder of the Socialist Party.
There was, Drinot argues, a perspective of governmentality, or a project of rule, which was not based mainly on disciplining the labour force, but was above all a project to manage the population, that is, ways of operationalising rationalities of government. Elites were mostly opposed to labour demands, seeing them as a threat to social order; but elites also understood that reforms were necessary to achieve their civilising goals. Workers viewed the ‘labour state’ as the expression of their own aspirations, but also used project failures as a critique of the state and the elites. It was the continued ‘sort of dialogue’ between workers, the state and the elites that is represented as the making of the Peruvian state in this volume.
In the wake of this process, the Indian majority of the country was excluded from becoming workers, and hence from access to insurance, to health care and to state-offered food, unless they left their Indianness behind and turned into immaculate mestizo, salaried workers. The historical foundation of this kind of narrative is a certain image of what it meant to be ‘an Indian’ in the eyes of the political, economic and intellectual elites. As it stood, this image was part and parcel of the ‘colonial heritage’, which had little to do with the real participation of the indigenous peoples in the economy, with their actual political participation as ‘Indians’ in the making of the Peruvian state, or with the cultural apportionments (food, music, communal organisation, and so on). In Drinot's analysis, the ‘Indian’ remains as a generic personage to whom others referred, not a differentiated, acting group of people. I found myself wondering whether in all the documentation Drinot reviewed there were any ‘Indians’ mentioned beyond derogatory references. There was a large indigenous, salaried labour force in Peru's mines. Did they have any access to what the Peruvian state was willing to offer? What was the level of discussion concerning labour and labour demands between the Peruvian state and foreign capital, particularly in mining activities? How did workers' salaries compare, say, between Indian mine workers in Cerro de Pasco and textile workers on the coast? Or maybe it would be worth asking ourselves how much the ‘labor state’ actually knew about labour and labour conditions. If most projects failed miserably (or at least did not benefit the targeted social group), can it be assumed that the state's knowledge before creating the workers' districts or establishing the eateries or the Seguro Social was close to nil? Or that it did not really care, in spite of its rhetoric and civilising anxieties?
Maybe all these questions could be summarised in one critique of the book, namely the absence of a definition of who the ‘workers’ actually were. Aside from being ‘state-defined dependent manual labor in given locations', we learn very little about who they were, what they did, or even how they reacted to the labour state's intentions and actions. I almost feel there is a second part of the book missing, but maybe Drinot has a second volume in mind, in which the words ‘race’ and ‘workers’ in his title get full-fledged attention. Peru's working class was relatively small, but, for instance, would evidence from 81 families be representative of the workers' housing conditions in 1940 (p. 156)?
As a brief side note, ‘The Making of the Peruvian State’ has become such an overarching concept/title that it is beginning to lose its historical meaning. It seems that now we can use the concept to describe any time period we choose. It is, for sure, an ongoing process; however, each ‘making of a state’ encompasses very distinct phases but is not the making of the state. Drinot's would be the ‘phase of the labour state’, other authors' would be the ‘phase of the independent state’, or the ‘phase of the warrior state’ … the ‘making of the state’ should not look only at labour relations, or a war scenario, or a guerrilla movement, and, most certainly, it should not be a top-down reading of the historical record. Where has this cherished ‘everyday state formation’ idea gone?
Overall, Paulo Drinot's book is a fine contribution on a period of Peruvian history that we still know too little about; it is also a nice read, although it could be an even better read if the reiterations had been fewer.
