No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
How does one represent the diversity of Muslim communities in Europe while also highlighting the commonalities brought about by Islam? Philip Lewis attempts to answer this question through a case study of South Asian Muslims in Bradford, Britain. Despite the book's limited focus on Bradford, Lewis not only contributes to a more nuanced understanding of Muslim experiences in Britain but also brings valuable insights into appreciating the diversity of Islam across Europe.
The book was originally written in the immediate aftermath of the Satanic Verses controversy. Lewis was worried at the time that “the habit of describing British Muslims as ‘fundamentalist’” (p. 5) was obscuring and misrepresenting the diversity and dynamism of Muslim communities. Through an empirical study of Bradford's Muslims, the author was hoping to challenge the ongoing demonization of Muslims in Britain. The revised edition of the book, which has a fifteen-page postscript covering the developments of the past decade, appeared shortly after the summer 2001 riots in Britain and the events of 11 September. The continuing dehumanization of Muslim groups and individuals and the undiminishing popularity of the term “fundamentalist” in the media and among policy circles make Lewis's study relevant once again. As the author states in the Preface to the revised edition, his main goal is simply to contribute to an informed understanding of British Muslims.
Islamic Britain is based on the author's Ph.D. thesis and ongoing engagement with different Muslim groups. Lewis studied in Pakistan for six years and worked in Bradford for ten years. He is currently the adviser to the Bishop of Bradford on interfaith issues. Lewis's long years of participant observation has provided him with a detailed and intimate grasp of the inner workings of South Asian Muslim life in Bradford. His hands-on knowledge enables him to present a more informed reading of the data he gathered from archival research, interviews, and observation. Moreover, Lewis's long-term exposure to the intricacies of religious life at Bradford allows him to identify continuities and discontinuities in a rapidly changing field.
After presenting a brief history of Muslims in Britain in Chapter 1, the author proceeds to discuss South Asia's Islamic traditions—namely, the Deobandis, Tablighi Jama

at, the Barelwis, and the Jama

at-i Islami—and their responses to colonialism and modernity in South Asia. Chapter 3, titled “Bradford: Britain's ‘Islamabad,’” introduces readers to the research site with the help of informative maps that show the distribution of mosques belonging to different sects and the regional groups controlling mosque committees. Through his holistic perspective, Lewis aims to complement anthropological monographs that are often limited to certain ethnic groups or city quarters. Chapter 4 offers an impressive account of the Islamic organizational life in Bradford. One of the interesting findings is that in Bradford Islamic traditions tend to “maintain strong links with their parent organizations in South Asia” (p. 112). In the next chapter the author provides a sympathetic portrayal of the South Asian ulema. In addition to pointing out the cultural and linguistic marginality of religious scholars and functionaries, Lewis also presents a vivid description of the economic hardships they endure. Chapter 6 has a historical account of the transformation of the Bradford Council for Mosques. The author also draws attention to the growing public role of Muslim businesspeople and politicians vis-à-vis the Council for Mosques. The predicament of Muslim youth in handling their multiple identities in Britain is discussed in Chapter 7. Here Lewis is particularly attentive to the struggles of Muslim women, who are increasingly visible in the public domain. The few interviews presented by the author give an intimate portrayal of women's multiple and changing identities. In the Conclusion, after praising the Muslims' successful use of local organizations to influence local governments, Lewis identifies the development of inclusive national organizations as the main challenge facing Muslims, because the Parliament has become the main arena to push for Muslim demands.
Islamic Britain deserves praise for presenting a multi-layered account of Bradford's Muslim communities through various disciplinary lenses, ranging from history to anthropology. An interdisciplinary approach is particularly apt in demonstrating that neither Islam nor the Muslim community in Britain is monolithic. When it comes to discovering “the commonalities across ethnic boundaries generated by belonging to a shared religious tradition” (p. 7), Lewis identifies the religious studies perspective as being the dominant lens. The data on “shared religious tradition” (p. 7) uniting various Muslim communities in Britain are not as comprehensive as the abundant examples illustrating the diversity of Muslim communities in Bradford. Although Lewis is quite successful in demonstrating the commonalities among various Muslims of South Asian origin in Bradford, he fails to present significant material on other Muslim groups, which make up 20 percent of British Muslims. In the absence of such data, it is not clear whether the commonalities he is referring to stem from “shared religious tradition” of Islam or from South Asian culture.
Although the book benefits immensely from Lewis's anthropological sensibilities, there is a conspicuous absence of reflexivity. The author refrains from discussing his ongoing involvement with the Muslims of Bradford and its significance in the nature of the data he collected. Moreover, Lewis fails to acknowledge his subjective and normative position even when he is judgmental in condemning a Muslim scholar as “a writer and polemicist who contributes nothing to a serious Islamic engagement with modern science or non–Islamic religious traditions” (p. 194).
Islamic Britain would be of interest to academics, intellectuals, and policy-makers. Although this informative book, which contains a short glossary of Islamic terms, is also accessible to undergraduates, the details and minutiae on Bradford could be confusing for non-specialists. The spelling mistakes are distracting (pp. 35, 157), and the endnotes are not practical, especially in the absence of a bibliography. The detailed index, however, is handy both for students and scholars.