The relocation of relatively affluent individuals from well developed countries in the global North to less economically developed countries in the global South is an emerging phenomenon, and also an unacknowledged or under-analysed international migration trend. Many of these migrants are retirees, as well as younger adventure seekers, but the volume of this migratory flow is admittedly smaller than that of more familiar South–North flows of labour migrants. In this context, many US nationals have moved to low-cost destinations in South America, in the last decades but mainly after the 2008 economic crisis, and Ecuador has embraced several thousand of them. Matthew Hayes’ book focuses on US nationals relocating to Cuenca, Ecuador, the country's third-largest city and a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
This book analyses how this move enabled migrants who felt stuck in an urban environment that diminished their opportunities for sociability to live more fulfilling lives. It narrates the experiences of these lifestyle migrants in Ecuador in terms of an adventure and fits the cultural idea of a generation that seeks to define its ageing by emphasising continued activity and consumer identities. The study begins with the motivations, imaginaries and experiences of US nationals living in Cuenca; most are self-professed ‘economic refugees’ who seek offshore retirement, affordable medical care and/or a lower-cost location, so many are pursuing economic opportunity in a global marketplace. Others seek adventure by relocating to an unfamiliar cultural environment and experiencing personal growth through travel, illustrative of contemporary cultures of ageing. Normally, these life projects are often motivated by a desire to escape from the economic and political conditions in the United States. The transnational relocation to a lower-income country enables them to attain their lifestyle ideals and also benefit from economic and territorial imbalances.
The research is based on data collected throughout 34 weeks of fieldwork conducted between 2011 and 2016, using ethnographic methods such as semi-structured qualitative interviews. The study is not intended to be representative of the population of migrants in Cuenca as a whole, but reflective of the ways US nationals talk about their lives and their community in Ecuador and aimed at gathering socially significant narratives rather than merely representative ones.
The book analyses lifestyle migration, but also its relationship to global inequality, focusing on the ways that global inequality is reproduced through the unequal experiences of global mobility of North–South migrants. Thus, it provides a look at today's ‘reverse’ migration of white, middle-class expats from North to South through the perspective of Cuenca. The ethnographic approach to lifestyle migration in southern Ecuador draws our attention to migrant imaginaries, racial identity formation and the complexity of the global social inequalities and social relations generated between the new migrants and the local population.
This book is in dialogue with the colonial continuities of global society that shape contemporary forms of inequality, especially in transnational contexts. Hayes argues that transnational migration clearly illustrates global structures of coloniality, especially with the relocation of US nationals to Latin American countries, so this migration reproduces colonial patterns of domination in the absence of concerted and collective responses to them. These unequal global social relations are evident in the disparity of income and wealth between US nationals migrating to Ecuador, on one hand, and the migrations of Ecuadoreans and other Latin Americans moving north, on the other. This book also draws attention to how a stratified global society reproduces spatial and social injustices, building on the reflections of white, mostly middle-class US nationals who occupy relatively privileged global social positions.
Hayes explores the repercussions for the host country – from rising land and rent prices to the reproduction of colonial patterns of domination and subordination, in the geographic expression of global inequalities in the global South; the author also identifies the coloniality of urban ‘revitalisation’ and heritage restoration, especially in this context of transnational mobility from the global North. Heritage preservation and tourism development reflect the interests and culture of European-descent landowning elites, who have most to benefit from the new North–South migration. In the process, the US migrants participate in transnational gentrification that marginalises popular traditions and non-white mestizo and indigenous informal workers. These US migrants say that, being migrants in Ecuador, they usually want to find ways to bridge inequalities and shun ethnocentric displays of superiority.
Hayes’ argument is that the global division of labour is marked by a history of colonial domination that centred social processes of accumulation, and the existence of high- and low-cost regions is a product of an unequal political economy that stratifies regions and labour forces along territorial lines. In this sense, Hayes thinks about these territorial inequalities as a consequence of a global division of labour and as a product of an exploitative and often violent appropriation of wealth in the colonies. The exploitative practices of colonialism that led to an unequal global economy seem a long way from the present experiences of US nationals living in Ecuador, but they are entangled in many ways. What Hayes currently calls ‘globalisation’ is a product of a colonial integration of the globe and a process that includes slavery, violent appropriation of land, and exploitation of colonised people.
This book maybe focuses too much on the explanation of this international migration based on oppressors and the oppressed, deepening the inequalities and the dichotomy between North and South, which gives the book a postmodern vision of lifestyle migration. However, Gringolandia is definitely the first book to consider the phenomenon of mostly white, middle-class people moving from the global North to the global South, but also one of the few that analyses this subject under this postmodern approach.
