Long ago, when I was a graduate student, historians were discovering the importance of the life sciences during the Enlightenment. Not only did this give rise to a number of important and interesting studies, it was also part of a broader reassessment of what Andrew Cunningham and Perry Williams so nicely call the ‘old big picture’: a picture in which mathematical physics and astronomy held pride of place. As someone who was becoming increasingly convinced that attention to the history of chemistry was equally (or more) crucial to furthering our understanding of (pardon the anachronism) ‘scientific’ development, I felt triply isolated. Not only did ‘mainstream’ historians seem to have little interest in the ‘arcane’ knowledge and practices of pre-Lavoisian chemistry, but I could ride this historiographical wave only by focusing on the possible links between vitalism and chemistry. Even within the community of historians of chemistry, the primary questions being asked of the eighteenth century were oriented around the chemical revolution.
It is thus with great pleasure, and a little nostalgia, that I read Matthew Eddy's polemically (semi-)biographical study of John Walker, professor of natural history at the University of Edinburgh's medical school from 1779 to 1803. While most of Eddy's book reads quite easily, his argument is complex in terms of both its historiographical import and the many facets of its composition and historical implications. Historiographically, he takes aim at a variety of other historians: those who continue to miss the significant roles played by eighteenth-century chemistry in natural inquiry and the ways in which recognizing its historical presence can help us better understand the productive interactions between natural inquiry and industrial production; those who are interested in eighteenth-century chemistry, but organize their studies around the chemical revolution; those who have jumped on the bandwagon of substituting natural history for the mathematical sciences, as early modern Europe's ‘big science’, but overplay the importance of Linnaeus or let the telos of Darwinism or other nineteenth-century developments in the fields of natural history creep into their studies of the eighteenth century. Historically, Eddy uses aspects of Walker's career to develop a sophisticated picture of chemistry-based education at the University of Edinburgh's medical faculty during the last decades of the eighteenth century. To give his story more specific focus, he zeroes in on the classification system that Walker developed and used to organize the courses he taught, with special attention to mineralogy. Readers thus make the acquaintance of a highly intelligent and ambitious man, who built a productive network of patrons, colleagues, correspondents and students in the context of Enlightenment Edinburgh and the world of which it was a part. So too can they follow the path paved by Walker's education (both formal and autodidactical) and teaching career, along which he developed a nomenclatural mode of expression and organization to discipline the contents of the subjects he taught.
Some of this book – especially the detailed description of Walker's mineralogical classification system – will be of most interest to historians of chemistry; but many elements should be of more general interest. It is important to know, for example, that Scottish chemistry during the last three decades of the century fed into and fed off interaction with Swedish and German communities. The more that historians are aware of such connections, the easier it will be to replace standard narratives that structure the history of chemistry around the origins of and reactions to a Paris-centred chemical revolution. This will also help draw wider attention to the importance of the Baltic trade, along whose routes many important material and intellectual resources were transported. So too is it generally salutary to appreciate that, though university chemistry education might be housed in the medical faculty during the eighteenth century, its content was often of interest to a broad range of students, including apothecaries, naturalists and various sorts of manufacturers. It is also good to reflect on the limited impact of and contemporary reservations about the applicability of Linnaeus's classification system and the theoretical views of natural historians such as Buffon. Especially regarding the first, Eddy importantly explicates the development of mineralogy as based not only on external characteristics, but also on the classificatory examination of a substance's internal, chemical characteristics.
Finally, as Eddy shows in depth, it is always a good thing to think carefully about issues of language and classification. And it is in relation to this point that this review ends by posing questions for further consideration. First, what function(s) did nomenclature play in the history of eighteenth-century chemistry and its pedagogy? Was it directed towards expressing the (cumulative) findings of observation and experiment – towards capturing nature's truth (whatever that means) – or should nomenclatural systems instead be seen as conventional means of organizing teaching, and so heuristically directed towards aiding learning? I would like to have seen this question addressed more explicitly. Since the answer is obviously not a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’, it would also have been helpful to know what Eddy thinks about the connections between the different arenas in which nomenclatural development and reform took place. And in the light of the role played by experimental and specimen demonstration in the courses taught by Walker, it would likewise have been good to learn more about the relation between language and classification, on the one hand, and, on the other, experimental practices and the training and use of the senses. Was chemistry-based education really only about organizing and imparting ‘scientific’ knowledge? Without putting words into Eddy's mouth, this is an implication that could be read into his narrative.
I take it as a sign of a good book that at the end the reader wishes to pursue its inquiries further. In The Language of Mineralogy, Eddy – so generous here with creative ideas for future research – has given us just this kind of book.
