For the last two decades, historians have been moving away from writing Eurocentric imperial histories that focus on the rise and rivalry of European empires in Asia. Instead, they have shifted to a new kind of imperial or world history, largely maritime in orientation, which examines the rise of new global commodities, port cities, and business forms. These works also tend to highlight economic connections and interactions among a variety of actors in early modern maritime Asia. In many ways, George Bryan Souza's new collection of essays, Portuguese, Dutch and Chinese in Maritime Asia, c. 1585–1800 documents this very transition in one historian's career. Note the absence of the word “empire” from the book's title. While the Portuguese and Dutch empires and their agents are still part of the story, commodities—tobacco, opium, and cinnamon; port cities—Cochin, Melaka, and Macao; and Asian merchants—southern Indians, Hokkien Chinese, and Javanese have become central characters in Souza's work. This book collects 13 essays, most of which have been previously published. Souza has been writing about the Portuguese empire in Asia for three decades, and this collection not only conveniently compiles his work, but also demonstrates the transition to a new more global and economic approach to the history of European empires in Asia.
Souza's collection of essays is divided roughly into three overlapping thematic sections: 1. Introduction, 2. Merchants, and 3. Commodities and Commerce. The first essay, “Maritime Trade and Politics in China and the South China Sea,” serves as an introduction to the entire collection of essays. Written before 1987, the essay presents the state of the field at the time “regarding the history of maritime trade in political and economic development of late Ming and Qing China and its commercial and cultural exchanges with parts of East Asia (Japan.)” The other sections include essays on a wide variety of topics including the business of Portuguese country traders, a microhistory of a Portuguese colonial administrator, imperial finance on the periphery of the Portuguese empire, commodity prices in the Dutch empire, cross-cultural trade in Batavia, the consumption and trade in opium, and trade in a variety of other commodities, such as tobacco, cinnamon, alum, zinc, and sugar.
While Souza advocates for a less Eurocentric bias in the field, he recognizes this tendency in his own work. There is good reason for this, he explains. When he began his career as a researcher, earlier studies of the Portuguese empire had focused on the Portuguese metropolitan center and its failure to run the empire effectively. Souza, instead, sought to shift attention to the empire's colonies in Asia, such as Macao, for example, where “Portuguese commercial activities were more deeply involved than we have previously understood…” This was the motivation for his 1986 monograph, The Survival of Empire: Portuguese Trade and Society in China and the South China Sea 1630–1754.
In the volume now being reviewed, many of Souza's essays also focus on Portuguese and Dutch actors in Asia, but some of his more recent essays take a markedly different approach. In several of his more recent works, Souza examines the rise of global commodities in the early modern period such as opium, cinnamon, and tobacco. For example, in his 2008 essay, “Agency, Monopoly, and Commerce: The Administrators of the Junto do Tobaco in Asia and the Atlantic, Indian, Ocean, and Global Economies, 1674–1774,” Souza challenges the “narrow quantitative focus on economics and econometrics” which has led to a definition of globalization—“integration of markets across space”—that excludes early modern global commodities and economic practices from the story of globalization. In Souza's view, tobacco “demonstrates how the economies of the Atlantic and Indian Ocean worlds were interconnected in the early modern period.”
One of Souza's most innovative contributions in this collection is his essay, “Anatomy of Commerce and Consumption: Opium and Merchants at Batavia over the Long Eighteenth Century.” In it, Souza connects the social, cultural, and economic biography of opium and follows the drug “through its commercial intermediaries to its final consumers via a chain analysis.” Souza demonstrates how Dutch and Asian merchants participated in the opium trade together. The records of the Dutch Opium Society and later, the Opium Directorate, reveal that Chinese, Dutch, Muslim, Indian, Chinese, Balinese, Javanese, and Malay merchants purchased opium from the Dutch in Batavia. Because the Opium Society sold on extended credit, purchasers were required to provide two or three guarantors; their names, ethnicities, and in some cases, professions have also been recorded. Most of the opium purchasers and guarantors were Hokkien Chinese and, incredibly, their names can be found on a 1697 stele from the Ci Ji temple near Xiamen in Fujian province. Apparently, while in Batavia, they were patrons of the temple. This essay draws from rich primary source material and points to many intriguing directions for further research on the opium trade, overseas Chinese, cross-cultural trade, and business history.
In sum, this is a valuable collection of essays. Unfortunately, several typos and editing errors occasionally impede the reader's progress, the most serious of which is found at the top of page 338, essay IV. In addition, this collection of essays could have benefited from another broader introductory essay reviewing the secondary literature written after 1987 on the Portuguese and Dutch in Asia. That said, Souza's new book will be useful to historians of China, European empires, and economic history.
