A self-conscious work of political science, Land, Protest and Politics offers a concise and systematic analysis of the recent history of agrarian reform in Brazil. For those interested in the agrarian question, author Gabriel Ondetti offers precise arguments for the rise and fall and rise again of land distribution policy from the 1980s to the present. While a variety of hypotheses are taken into account, Ondetti emphasises ‘political opportunity’ as the best way to understand the policy's fortunes. The leading protagonists taking advantage of these opportunities are social movements organised to help the poor secure land. Thus, Ondetti's book pursues the objective of evaluating the ups and downs of public policy and the role of social movements as a cause and consequence of these trajectories.
While the subject of the book is Brazil's agrarian reform policy, its central character is the Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra (Landless Workers' Movement, MST). Along with other factors, the MST is credited with reviving agrarian reform as a national priority. After a review of the strengths and weaknesses of various explanatory theories – principally grievance/discontent, organisational capacity, activist strategy and political opportunity – the author analyses the subject chronologically, dedicating a chapter to each of a series of crucial transitions in the relationship between the policy and fortunes of the MST. Thus, the book reads like a political history of the movement as Ondetti seeks to explain five key moments in the process of land struggle.
These critical moments are summarised in the chapter headings as ‘Emergence, 1978–1984’, ‘Growth amid Decline, 1985–1994’, ‘Takeoff, 1995–1999’, ‘Decline, 2000–2002’ and ‘Resurgence, 2003–2006’. The first period coincides with the ‘political opening’ that the dictatorship promoted in order to prepare for the restoration of civilian rule after the military took power in a 1964 golpe. Ondetti argues that numerous industrial strikes, the return of competitive politics and the organisation of political parties and independent trade unions all contributed toward the emergence of peasant movements and agrarian reform as a political issue.
What fascinates Ondetti is the fact that the MST continued to grow when so many other civil society organisations had ceased to exist, despite their emergence in the same context of political opportunities created by the military-to-civilian transition. To explain this, Ondetti depends on an innovative reading of Mansur Olson's theory of collective action. According to Olson and in contradistinction to Marx's theory of class struggle, it is irrational rather than natural for people with common interests to join together. Most see little benefit in collective action as the ‘public good’ that may result, such as an eight-hour work day, will be available to all whether or not they participated in the strikes. Thus, the majority of people are not joiners but ‘free riders’, Olson argues.
Ondetti inverts Olson's logic to argue that the MST prospered in the post-dictatorship period by fighting for private rather than public goods. For those who follow the landless movement, Ondetti's argument comes as a provocative but disturbing insight. On the one hand, the MST defends agrarian reform as a public good. Through agrarian reform, land concentration will be reduced, allowing Brazilians to finally root out concentrated power and open the field to true democracy. Liberated from the oppression of large landowners and greedy monopolists, movement theorists speculate, Brazilians will naturally support socialism. But, as Ondetti rightly notes, successive civilian governments have interpreted agrarian reform not as a public good but as a private benefit or handout. Land is distributed to those who fight for it, and they are allowed to negotiate land usage on their lots as if they were indeed rentiers. Thus, argues Ondetti, what has kept the movement alive in the re-democratisation period has not been its collectivist but its individualist nature. People become public militants in order to establish private farms.
Ondetti explains this, as well as the four other transitions specified, by filtering historical data through the causation hypotheses listed above, demonstrating why one or the other theory might be lacking in explanatory power. For example, the ‘grievance/discontent’ theory is consistently considered important but inadequate given the near constant state of material misery that the landless tolerate. On the other hand, theories emphasising ‘organizational capacity’ and ‘activist strategy’ almost always play significant roles as Ondetti analyses the MST's creativity and perseverance.
Ondetti argues, in fact, that MST leaders caused the decline of the movement in favour of agrarian reform when they overreached in the late 1990s. Assuming public support would keep growing after the El Dorado de Carajas massacre of 1996 and the ensuing upsurge of public sympathy, MST coordinators decided to broaden the movement to include direct action mobilisations against neoliberal reforms such as the selling of state highway concessions to private corporations. Militants occupied toll booths and tied up traffic; they also moved the focus of occupations from the land in question to the buildings of the government agencies tasked with implementing agrarian reform. Ondetti argues that these urban, non-agricultural targets actually cost the movement support and created opportunities for conservatives to shift the narrative from advancing reform to controlling civil unrest. The government rather than the movement gained a ‘political opportunity’ to impose new repressive measures that crippled the MST by outlawing its principal weapon, the land occupation.
Political opportunities for the movement were revived following the 2002 presidential election of Luis Lula Inácio da Silva, a long-time supporter of the MST. During the campaign, movement activists strategised to guarantee that agrarian reform remained an issue and that Lula's election would improve the chances for its consolidation. The movement demonstrated significant organisational capacity in capitalising on the moment. The Lula administration faced considerable opposition in implementing its agrarian reform plans, but created favourable conditions – political opportunities – for another movement take-off.
Ondetti's approach is methodical, and while this could be grounds for criticising the book for reading too much like the University of North Carolina dissertation it once was, the explicit structure and consistent reinforcement of the argument enhance its utility. The book is one of the few studies to scientifically demonstrate the links between social movements and public policy, an extremely valuable level of analysis. One could criticise it for failing to capture more social, personal and emotional factors, as it almost entirely ignores anthropological and literary theoretical fashions, but as it makes no pretence to engage postmodern approaches, such criticism is simply descriptive; taken on its own terms, the book is essential reading for those interested in the agrarian question, social movements, economic development, public policy and contemporary Latin America.
