The historical origins of bureaucracy in China have long been unclear. As Li Feng notes in the Introduction to Bureaucracy and the State in Early China: Governing the Western Zhou, that was due in part to the ancient traditions of classical and historical scholarship in China. Classical texts—above all Zhouli (Zhou Rituals), a putative description of Western Zhou government—contain vitiated accounts of the early Chinese state. These provided a ready-made framework for research, into which new information has all too often been forced. In Bureaucracy and the State, Li examines the roots of bureaucracy in China in the Western Zhou period (1045–771 bce). Confining himself nearly exclusively to information derived from inscriptions on Zhou bronzes, Li outlines the structure and function of the bureaucratic Western Zhou state. Li's approach allows him to sidestep many of the problems inherent in relying on the textual tradition and to reach new conclusions about the state in early China. This project is exciting and has great importance for the study of state development in pre-imperial China for its conclusions and translations, and as a model for future research.
Li's Introduction notes that, in addition to the textual tradition, research on pre-imperial governmental structures in China has also been hampered by a lack of theory. Li orients himself on the work of Max Weber and his interpreters, arguing that Western Zhou government was a bureaucracy as Weber defined it. The Introduction also discusses the context and characteristics of Li's primary sources: bronze inscriptions, particularly those created as part of rituals linked to the bureaucracy. Li argues that these inscriptions can serve as historical sources, despite their potential bias.
Chapter One presents a historical overview of the Shang and Western Zhou periods. Li concentrates on those aspects of Shang history that led up to the Western Zhou government, locating the predecessors of Zhou bureaucracy in the duties of Shang religious practitioners. Li sketches Western Zhou history through its early, middle, and late periods, incorporating the progressively increasing quantity of available information. Chapter Two traces the emergence and development of governmental organisation as part in these three periods. Li puts special weight on the “bifurcated structure” (p. 44) of the Zhou state, under which the Zhou king ruled the western part while others governed the east. Due to a paucity of source material, the early period is less amenable to analysis than the others. But Li traces the emergence of non-religious offices to this time, a development he says made Western Zhou governance more effective than its predecessor. The middle period saw the “separation of the Royal Household” (p. 70) from the rest of the bureaucracy, and growth and expansion in both civil and military systems of official service, with increasing clarification of roles and relative authority. According to Li, “These developments gave the Mid-Western Zhou government the clear organizational characteristics of a bureaucracy” (p. 83), which continued in the late period.
Chapter Three deals with “The actual administrative process of the Western Zhou government” (p. 96). Much of this chapter concerns the rituals for installing officials and the emergence of “professional groups” (p. 133) based on personal associations instantiated in those ceremonies. In Li's presentation, the king, at the top of the bureaucracy, had direct contact with both the bureaucratic apparatus and his subordinates. Chapter Four examines “local society and local administration in the royal domain” (p. 149), although the scope of this consideration is limited by the lack of sources. Li proposes that lands in these areas were of three kinds: the possessions of the king, property allotted to noble houses, and lands managed by the bureaucracy. This chapter also covers the administration of cities, primarily a group of five that the central government controlled through bureaucratic structures.
Chapter Five treats how men came to be members of the Western Zhou bureaucracy. Here Li challenges the notion of straightforward hereditary succession in official posts. He examines relevant inscription texts and shows that while offices were sometimes granted because of family connections, the majority of official candidates did not come into their official positions in that way. Li says that high social status and a degree of learning were required, but beyond these things, individual ability and qualifications determined who received office. And once in the bureaucracy, even those of relatively low status could potentially advance to high positions.
In Chapter Six Li turns to the “regional states” that lay in the east, outside the Zhou royal demesnes. Li says that each of these states formed around “a cluster of yi settlements” and had a populace that was “diversified and typically stratified” (p. 243), comprising both autochthonic peoples and an imported Zhou upper class. Li considers the characteristics of these states’ governance, especially the high degree to which they reproduced the central government. He also looks at how the Zhou maintained connections with local governments through ritual, meetings, and cooperation in martial activities.
Finally, in Chapter Seven, Li outlines five models of early states that previous researchers have applied in the study of China and—to varying degrees—in cross-cultural research. While acknowledging the utility of such models for comparing different societies, Li criticises previous models on different grounds. In the end, he endorses a “settlement state” model which holds that the state was arranged around population centres. He modifies this to propose his “delegatory kin-ordered settlement state” (p. 294) model, concentrating on the central Zhou authorities’ grant of the power to rule to members of the king's lineage.
The core of Li's project is the description of early government in China based predominantly on archaeologically recovered source materials, avoiding the problems of a historiography based on questionable received texts, above all Zhouli. This is an ambitious, important and difficult undertaking, and its success deserves great respect. Li's conclusions about the nature of regional states explain neatly why they outlasted the Western Zhou dynasty that initially established them. He convincingly demonstrates the existence of meritocracy in Western Zhou governance. Li also gathers and translates much primary material not previously available in English, and in an Appendix he provides a useful list of Zhou offices, including translated titles and brief description of each post. His work will thus be of interest for students and scholars of early Chinese history both for its arguments and as resource. I applaud Li's decision to address competing explanations of the state directly and explain their perceived shortcomings, and to concisely and unambiguously offer his own alternative.
Ambitious work like this raises high expectations, and there are a few areas I think might have benefited from more or different treatment. The first of these is the theoretical aspect. Weber's work on bureaucracy generally and China specifically gives him immediate relevance for Bureaucracy and the State; nevertheless, I think it would have been better to concentrate on more recent research. And although I see merit in Li's criticism of the state development models that have been applied to China, I think his contribution in this respect would bear further refinement. Unless a model can be applied to multiple cases, it is not really a model: it is a schematic description of a single example. It seems to me that Li's “delegatory kin-ordered settlement state” describes early China too closely to apply elsewhere without considerable revision. I also wish Li had addressed the problems of using palaeographical sources in historical study at greater length. Such records avoid the problems inherent in textual transmission (even as they bring new difficulties), but there is little reason to think their contents are necessarily more reliable than other documents. Lothar von Falkenhausen has demonstrated that the information in at least some bronze inscriptions cannot be accurate.Footnote 1 Li acknowledges these questions without delving into them. A thorough consideration could have made a significant contribution to the ongoing, broader discussion about how to integrate palaeographical materials into historical research.
