Between 1239 and 1241, the military expedition commonly referred to as the Barons' Crusade took place in the Holy Land. The campaign was conducted in defiance of the orders of Pope Gregory IX, who in 1235, had exhorted the Christian nobles of Europe to change the objective of their planned expeditions from the Holy Land to Greece, where the Latin Empire of Constantinople was under threat from the rulers of Bulgaria and Nicaea, both kingdoms that the Pope saw as heretical. Nevertheless, while the Barons' Crusade was a military disaster, its armies repeatedly defeated by those of the Ayyubid rulers of the region, through careful negotiations with the Ayyubids, the crusaders were able to secure an expansion of the holdings of the Kingdom of Jerusalem of a magnitude that had not been equaled since the fall of Jerusalem to Saladin in 1187.
In his work on this crusade, Michael Lower provides a detailed account of the initial preaching of the crusade to the Holy Land by Pope Gregory; his subsequent change of its objective; the reactions that his message received in Hungary, the County of Champagne, western France, and England; and the expeditions to Constantinople and the Holy Land that were conducted as a result of his efforts. However, Lower does not seek merely to provide a narrative; he uses the Barons' Crusade as a case study to challenge some common assumptions about crusading. In particular, he proposes that the commonly accepted idea that the crusades were an expression of a unified Christian identity is an oversimplification of the true situation in the period, effectively demonstrating that the religious affiliation of the participants in the crusade was only one of several factors that affected how they approached the endeavor. This is not the only notion that Lower challenges. He also shows, for example, that the assumption that the crusades automatically had a negative impact on followers of faiths other than Catholic Christianity is also erroneous, and he urges caution in the use of such binary categories (Christians and non-Christians) when seeking to understand historical developments. By the same token, he also questions the established concept of the crusade as an effective instrument of papal control of the nobility of Europe. The Barons' expedition to the Holy Land represents the culmination of various activities undertaken by crusaders despite opposition and even the employment of punitive measures by the papacy in its efforts to redirect the crusade to Constantinople.
In discussing the responses to Pope Gregory's appeal in various regions of Europe, Lower emphasizes the study of comparative local history, as exemplified by his concentration in turn on the responses of the rulers of Hungary, the County of Champagne, western France (especially Brittany), and England. This strategy usefully enables Lower to demonstrate that the Pope's message encountered widely varying reactions and had equally varied consequences. For example, he is able to show that, although the Pope's call led to the execution of heretics and the exploitation of Jews in Champagne, at the same time it indirectly improved the position of Muslims, Jews, and other non-Christians in Hungary, where papal efforts to degrade these groups were abandoned in favor of an effort to encourage King Bela IV and his followers to crusade to Bulgaria, where, in Pope Gregory's eyes, there were more dangerous enemies of the faith to be found. Thus, we see both the mixed impact on non-Catholics as a consequence of the Pope's preaching and the establishment of a hierarchy in the level of threat that various non-Catholic groups posed to the faith that nuances the otherwise binary perception of Christian vs. non-Christian.
Lower's use of the sources is careful and thorough, and he provides an impressive bibliography of both primary and secondary sources that indicates the comprehensiveness of his research. Admittedly, he uses few Muslim sources from the period, but this finding is reasonable considering that the focus of his attention is for the most part on the response to Pope Gregory's message in Europe. Even in his account of the Barons' brief expedition to the Holy Land, his focus is above all on the Western point of view, although he does use several primary and especially secondary sources to provide a degree of balance.
The Barons' Crusade is primarily a book about Catholic Christian Europe and its response to Pope Gregory IX's call to the crusade. As a result, it is likely to seem of limited interest to most of the readership of this journal, being of most immediate use to scholars of the Western perspective on the crusades and scholars of the Eastern perspective who wish to broaden their awareness of the period. That said, Lower's challenging of existing generalizations and cautioning against the adoption of oversimplified conceptions of historical realities present an exemplar to historians of all periods and regions, making this work of wider interest than it originally appears. In addition, Lower's argumentation is clear and his writing style engaging, which will add to the book's appeal to professional scholars, students, and interested laypersons.
