In a 1927 lecture the Director of the British Museum Sir Frederic Kenyon countered the futurist leader F. T. Marinetti's calls for the destruction of museums by arguing that “in times of upheaval . . . salvation is to be found in adherence to tradition” rather than in “break[ing] loose from” it. Kenyon explained the museum's role in promoting this salvation:
A visit to a museum will not by itself quench a revolution. It would have been useless to invite the pétroleuses of the Commune to an official lecture in the Egyptian Gallery at the Louvre; but if they had been brought up to respect the past, there might have been a revolution without pétroleuses. Every form of instruction or experience which teaches men to link their lives with the past makes for stability and ordered progress. Hence the value of history and hence also the value of those institutions which teach history informally and without tears. (24–25)
This is perhaps the most explicit statement of the British Museum's ideological function in early twentieth-century museum discourse. The museum acts as an ideological state apparatus that calls out to museum-goers to identify with, rather than agitate against, the social order symbolized in the “examples of great men” and the “monuments of the past” (23–24). Though not without critics, much of the new museology since the 1980s draws on this historical record and poststructuralist theory to argue that the modern museum operates as a site for the reflection or reinforcement of existing power relations.Footnote 1 Critics have associated the museum, for example, with racism and sexism (Haraway), with classism (Bourdieu and Darbel), with imperialism and colonialism (Barringer and Flynn), with mechanisms of social control (Sherman and Rogoff), and with the consecration of state authority (Duncan and Wallach).Footnote 2 Whereas Kenyon's defense of the museum suggests a reactionary position, the cultural destruction he combats amounts to a revolutionary act, whether accomplished by the “gay incendiaries with charred fingers” exhorted by Marinetti in his movement-founding manifesto of 1909 or the communardes accused of torching the French capital during the semaine sanglante in 1871 (43). For cultural destruction is inescapably political, as Antonio Gramsci argued in “Marinetti the Revolutionary” (1916). The Italian theorist and political activist identified the futurist discourse against the museum and the aesthetic tradition it perpetuates with the Marxist task of destroying “spiritual hierarchies, prejudices, idols and ossified traditions” to make way for the creation of a new, proletarian civilization (Gramsci 215).
It would be tempting to take Kenyon's quarrel with communards and futurists as emblematic of the binary parameters governing museum discourse in the modern period: modernity versus museum, avant-garde versus tradition, democracy versus elitism, life versus art. It would be tempting but also erroneous, for Kenyon's justification of the museum, while openly grounded in its support for the state, ultimately rests on its service to the people. As he put it, “Museums have ceased to be merely the arsenals of students engaged in research; they are beginning to offer themselves to the public as a means of recreation and an instrument of education” (12). This shift in the museum's mission toward serving a popular as well as a professional audience dates from 1864, when John Edward Gray, Keeper of Zoology at the British Museum, first proposed to a scientific association “the new museum idea” (Flower 37–38). At the same time, the defensive character of Kenyon's remarks reflects the basic challenge that the modern museum has confronted in various forms since its origins in the eighteenth century and continues to reckon with today: how to reconcile art (or artifact or specimen) with life, the “palace of the muses” with the uninstructed masses. British museums had to resolve this predicament if they were to achieve what Kenyon defined as their “ultimate purpose” – “to help the nation to save its soul” (25).
In Henry James's social realist novel The Princess Casamassima (1886), repeated visits to British (and French and Italian) museums not only dissuade the novel's hero, or anti-hero, from becoming a pétroleur, they also quench his revolutionary fervor altogether. Yet the museum does not quite help him to save his soul – or body. Torn between a desire to overthrow the social order and a growing attachment to the cultural achievements it makes possible, Hyacinth Robinson takes his life at the end of the novel. I argue that Hyacinth's dilemma is the museum's dilemma, that his conflict emblematizes the museum's tension between the competing demands of art and life, the elite and the general public. The museum's attempts to satisfy the two derive from the widespread cultural assumption that the mission of the arts was to improve people morally, spiritually, intellectually, and aesthetically, and more particularly from the liberal doctrine that expanding public access to them was the most effective means of doing so.Footnote 3 Ultimately, James uses Hyacinth's suicide to illustrate the danger inherent in this doctrine: too much refinement too fast could spoil the working class. The museum's efforts to transform itself from a mausoleum or temple into an educational instrument vital to the public and relevant to the age, as documented in the museum literature of the day, provide the main context for my analysis. Another point of reference comes from William Morris, whose radical ideas on the union of art and life under socialism and their divorce under capitalism provide a subtextual foil for Hyacinth's cautious liberal attitude toward the museum.
Much criticism of the novel has centered on determining the reasons for Hyacinth's suicide and assessing their moral validity. Lionel Trilling, for example, considers Hyacinth a hero for taking upon himself the guilt of the two irreconcilable ideals of equality and culture. Christopher Stuart takes issue with such critics, “who describe Hyacinth's dilemma as an inability to reconcile the claims of politics with the claims of art,” arguing that “James’ hero unflinchingly embraces the conservative political implications of his aesthetic ideals” (23). Margaret Scanlan agrees that Hyacinth – and in back of him, James – chooses art over revolution, arguing that James “fails even to consider the possibility of synthesizing” the two (393). In contrast, James Seaton contends that Hyacinth does not oppose art to life but instead comes to believe that art improves life. I agree with Seaton that art is represented in the novel as having the potential to benefit everyone, but, unlike this critic, I analyze how art actually benefits the characters – and destroys one of them. I analyze this theme in the context of the great Victorian “culture debate,” and more particularly the debate over the museum, which assumed – falsely, as it turns out in the novel – that art and life could indeed be synthesized. My recovery of a key historical context links my approach to some more recent criticism of the novel, which situates it in relation to contemporary interclass friendship (Betensky) and sensationalist media accounts of political violence (DeVine).Footnote 4
The novel takes its title from the character of Christina Light, the mademoiselle fatale of Roderick Hudson (1876), who was married off by her mother at the end of that novel to the Italian Prince Casamassima. She reappears some ten years later, estranged from her husband, living in London and taking an interest in radical politics and the destitute poor. There she meets Hyacinth, who, like the Princess, has a vexed relationship with the idea of aristocracy. True to the naturalism that informs the work, Hyacinth's divided loyalties to the abolition of privileges and the preservation of culture derive from his mixed heredity. He is the illegitimate offspring of an English peer and the French seamstress who killed the Lord following his denial of paternity. A fellow dressmaker, Amanda Pynsent, takes Hyacinth into her home and raises him with the help of her friend and neighbor, Anastasius Vetch, a staunch republican. Hyacinth's maternal grandfather, a clockmaker by trade, died on a barricade during the 1848 Revolution. Another French radical figures in the novel; namely, Hyacinth's co-worker Eustache Poupin, who came to England after the insurrection to escape government reprisals. Motivated by a class resentment bred by his sense of disinheritance, Hyacinth pledges his life to the revolutionary cause and its underground leader Diedrich Hoffendahl.
Hyacinth's problem begins when his deepening exposure to the monuments of civilization diminishes his support for the cause. This exposure had always been limited by his humble origins, which forced him to maximize his minimal opportunities for gaining culture. He takes advantage of museums, for example, to develop morally, spiritually, intellectually, and aesthetically. At her art-filled estate in Medley, the Princess asks him “if he were fond of works of art; adding, however, immediately that she was afraid he had not many opportunities of seeing them, though of course there were public collections, open to all. Hyacinth said, with perfect veracity, that some of the happiest moments of his life had been spent at the British Museum and the National Gallery” (1: 286). The two contrastive adverbs (“however,” “though”) underscore the obstacles to lower-class cultural advancement – obstacles of which the Princess, given her station, is but vaguely aware. Technically, museums were indeed open to all, but the British Museum was closed on the only day the working classes were free to visit it, and access to it was as socially as it was temporally exclusive. As late as The American Scene (1907), James observed that “The British Museum, the Louvre, the Bibliotheque Nationale, the treasures of South Kensington, are assuredly, under forms, at the disposal of the people; but it is to be observed, I think, that the people walk there more or less under the shadow of the right waited for and conceded” (Collected Travel Writings 560).
“[T]he absence of any direct contact with a library” likewise limits Hyacinth's access to books (1: 101). He makes use of the Reading Room at the British Museum – it is there that he discovers the truth of his mother's crime passionel in contemporary newspaper accounts – but admittance at the time (the novel is set in 1871, 1881, and 1884) was by recommendation only, adding material barriers to the aura of selectivity and exclusiveness that, as James observed, characterized the whole of the museum. It can be assumed that Hyacinth's visit was an exception. Admission to the Reading Room was restricted because it served the function of a national archive, not a people's library. The British Public Libraries Act had been passed in 1850, empowering municipal authorities to provide for the accommodation and maintenance of a museum and/or library. But it was not until the 1870s, after the passage of the Education Act, that municipalities began to levy ratepayers for rate-supported libraries. By 1886, as many as 125 local authorities had begun the process of library provision (Northey). These numbers were still woefully inadequate, according to the economist and philosopher William Stanley Jevons, who reserved his greatest condemnation for London, which had only one small rate-supported library. “To show the extent of the deficiency in London it is enough to mention that the 86 provincial towns possessing Free Libraries have an aggregate population (in 1871) of not quite 6,000,000 persons; while London, with its one small rate-supported library, has a population of 3,620,000 persons” (42).
The novel draws attention, then, to contemporary limitations on working-class access to culture. Yet it also suggests that they are in the process of being removed, as indeed they were at the time. Free libraries and museums kept going up. After years of debate, the British Museum opened on Sunday afternoons in 1896. The admission fee for the Burlington House exhibition was affordable, and Hyacinth pays his shilling to see it. Also within his means – and those of “that superior part of the public for which a penny is not prohibitive” – is the price of renting lawn chairs in Kensington Gardens, and Hyacinth and his childhood friend Millicent Henning “take possession” of a couple of them (2: 335). James consistently specifies prices in the novel: Hyacinth pays a shilling for his French dictionary and five pennies for old books on the quays of Paris; the ornaments in his friend Rosy's room cost a penny; her counterpane, the price of a raffle ticket, or sixpence; Hyacinth and his co-conspirator Paul take a penny-steamer to Greenwich and sit in a six-penny gallery at Astley's. Such details, together with James's word choice (“take possession”), suggest that despite the unequal distribution of wealth and privilege in society, the lower classes still enjoy opportunities for culture and recreation – and so ought to be contented with them.
These scenes of access help to motivate the transfer in Hyacinth's sympathies. The shift begins when Hyacinth, through an introduction to the Princess at the theater, gains entry into a world of culture hitherto beyond his sphere. This world first takes the shape of the residences of his upper-crust friends, such as the Marylebone rooms of Captain Sholto. There the costly accoutrements give Hyacinth a glimpse of the “thousands of things . . . [that] make a civilized being” (1: 264). The furniture, miniatures, and bibelots adorning the Princess’ Mayfair mansion unveil “whole provinces of art” (1: 285). On a visit to the Princess’ country house, where he samples the refinements of “high civilisation,” he begins to pity the rich who will suffer their loss under socialism (1: 170). The final change comes on his travel to the Continent. In Paris, rather than calling on the communard veterans to whom Poupin had given him written introductions, he makes the most of the city's cultural and historical attractions. He roams through all the museums, galleries, gardens, and theaters, and in another scene of access that belies James's observation of the Louvre's exclusive aura, takes “the same satisfaction in the Louvre as if he had been invited there” (2: 123). Free for the first time to immerse himself in culture, what strikes him most in Paris is “not the idea of how the society that surrounded him should be destroyed; it was much more the sense of the wonderful precious things it had produced, of the fabric of beauty and power it had raised” (2: 124–25). From Venice Hyacinth writes to the Princess of his increased sense “that want and toil and suffering are the constant lot of the immense majority of the human race.” But he confesses that he has not “minded them.” For he has grown convinced that the world is “less of a ‘bloody sell’ and life more of a lark” as a result of “the splendid accumulations of the happier few, to which doubtless the miserable many have also in their degree contributed” (2: 145).
The installment of socialism, he now perceives, would result in the loss of art. Hoffendahl, he tells her, “wouldn't have the least feeling for this incomparable abominable old Venice. He would cut up the ceilings of the Veronese into strips, so that everyone might have a little piece. I don't want every one to have a little piece of anything and I've a great horror of that kind of invidious jealousy which is at the bottom of the idea of a redistribution” (2: 145–46). This vision of cultural vandalism in times of insurrection has a historical basis. French revolutionaries destroyed religious and secular monuments and artworks, seeing in them embodiments of the ancien régime they sought to overthrow. The 1848 Revolution led to a mob attempt to burn down the Louvre. “We shall never get rid of kings until we pull down the palaces,” they cried (qtd. in Nochlin 14). Press reports and political bulletins following the siege of the Commune of 1871 alleged the existence of some 8,000 petroleuses supposed to have set fire to the city's monuments and buildings. Although these allegations have largely been exposed as myths, the communards did set fire to the Tuileries Palace, City Hall, and the Palace of Justice. They also pulled down the Vendôme column, which as an emblem of imperialism (it was made from the bronze of captured cannons and originally had a statue of Napoleon on the top) formed a natural target.
Contrary to these attempts to destroy the monuments of the past, another strain of radicalism, also dating from the French Revolution, sought to make them available to the public by means of the museum. According to this tradition, the museum is an instrument of democracy rather than a temple of elitism. Edifying the public was the aim of the foundation of the Musée des Monuments Français in 1795 and the Musée National, or Louvre, in 1793. In Linda Nochlin's words, “through the alchemy of the museum,” this former palace of the kings, together with confiscated royal collections and ecclesiastical property, was “transformed into the National Heritage, the most precious possession of the people.” The notion that museums belong to the people took sufficient root in France to persuade some radicals to organize protection for public monuments and artworks during the insurrections of 1848 and 1871 (15). Hyacinth's prediction of the post-revolutionary fate of existing art thus has its roots in both traditions of radicalism: cultural destruction (“He would cut up the ceilings of the Veronese into strips”) and cultural redistribution (“so that everyone might have a little piece”).
His opposition to both options suggests that he favors its monopoly by the elite, those whose gentle birth endows them with refined taste. Hyacinth belongs to this privileged class by virtue of his aristocratic pedigree. In contrast to him stands Millicent, whose admiration for cheap manufactures in shop windows prompts him to assure her that she has “the worst taste of any girl in the place.” Low-born, she is debarred from entering into the mysteries of art appreciation. When Hyacinth points out a commodity that he condescends to like, and she asks him “to be so good as to explain to her in what its superiority consisted,” he replies that it is “no use attempting to tell her; she wouldn't understand and had better to continue to admire the insipid productions of an age that had lost the sense of fineness” (1: 166–67). Presumably, the article is unique and handcrafted as opposed to machine-made and mass-produced. Hyacinth's training as a bookbinder, combined with frequent trips to the museum, helps him to distinguish between the two, but it is the noble “blood in his veins” that he expressly credits for his “fine sensibilities” (1: 177). Hyacinth thus locates the disparity between his possession of culture and Millicent's cultural dispossession – which results from a difference in education – in a difference in nature. For him the general public lacks a sense of what is beautiful. Since only the high-born possess this discriminative faculty, only they should have access to art. Such is his conviction that, in discussing with his friend Lady Aurora the question of opening the museums on Sunday, he remarks on “the danger of too much coddling legislation on behalf of the working classes” (2: 355). Yet elitism does not alone explain his reservations about social-welfare legislation; by the end of the novel, and this article, two additional, more important reasons will emerge.
Hyacinth believes that socialism would not only disable the elite's enjoyment of art – through its destruction or redistribution – but also dismantle the necessary conditions for art's creation, which he identifies with the present social order. In broader historical terms, he sees that “The monuments and treasures of art, the great palaces and properties, the conquests of learning and taste, the general fabric of civilisation as we know it, [are] based . . . upon all the despotisms, the cruelties, the exclusions, the monopolies and the rapacities of the past” (2: 145). Hyacinth's admission of the inequities and iniquities that permit the production, transmission, and reception of cultural treasures resembles the seventh of Walter Benjamin's “Theses on the Philosophy of History”: “There is no document of civilization which is not at the same time a document of barbarism. And just as a document is not free of barbarism, barbarism taints also the manner in which it was transmitted from one owner to another.” Benjamin critiques the representation of history as a “triumphal procession” of “spoils” from the past down to the present. The problem is that these “cultural treasures” “owe their existence not only to the efforts of the great minds and talents who have created them, but also to the anonymous toil of their contemporaries” (256). Hyacinth thus shares the historical materialist's insight that objects owe their life and afterlife to human agents and concrete circumstances.Footnote 5 Yet, unlike Benjamin, Hyacinth draws from this premise the conclusion that the social order is an essential condition for the making of art and culture. He so values the benefits of high civilization that he grows convinced they “redeem” the Benjaminian barbarism that sustains them (2: 217).Footnote 6
He expresses this view most bluntly in the following dialogue. Upon learning that the Princess has sold all her possessions for the benefit of the poor (her conversion to radicalism provides an ironic foil to Hyacinth's turn away from it), Lady Aurora asks her:
“But don't you think we ought to make the world more beautiful?”
––
“The world will be beautiful enough when it becomes good enough,” the Princess resumed. “Is there anything so ugly as unjust distinctions, as the privileges of the few contrasted with the degradation of the many? When we want to beautify we must begin at the right end.”
––
“I think there can't be too many pictures and statues and works of art,” Hyacinth broke out. “The more the better, whether people are hungry or not. In the way of ameliorating influences are not those the most definite?” (2: 169–70)
The trio's competing views on which is the right end or the most definite influence points up the larger “social question” – how to improve the laborers’ lot – that forms this working-class novel's true fulcrum (2: 105). Each of the characters argues for and acts out the contradictions of a different Victorian position, so that The Princess Casamassima reads like a thrashing-out, testing, and assessing of the various proposed solutions to the problem of the poor. Vetch begins as an “old-fashioned, constitutional, milk-and-water, jog-trot sort” of radical – a gradualist and reformist, not a revolutionary, or “exterminator,” as he considers Hoffendahl and his co-conspirators to be – grows convinced of the impossibility of transforming the social order without giving rise to new problems, and ends by accepting the world as it is (1: 182). Poupin remains “a Republican of the old-fashioned sort, of the note of 1848, humanitary and idealistic, infinitely addicted to fraternity and equality,” ardent of socialist revolution yet, grown older, less given to action than to utopian rhetoric (1: 93). Granted amnesty by the French government whose post-Commune reprisals he fled, he chooses to continue the petit-bourgeois life he has built for himself in England rather than return to the scene of his earlier struggles. A humanitarian, Lady Aurora prefers to engage in individual acts of charity, such as visiting the sick and poor at the hospital and in the home – a solution whose wider efficacy Hyacinth and the Princess dismiss in calling her an exceptional “saint” (2: 271). Paul and the Princess (however dubious her conviction) support revolution as the shortest possible route to socialism.Footnote 7 Art has no place in their immediate schemes. The Princess’ statements suggest the radical notion that the private possession of artistic treasures runs counter to democratic ideals. But their public exhibition is no dearer to her, for the sale of her belongings reads less like a figure for cultural redistribution than for cultural renunciation.
But this was not the only radical position current at the time. The artist and socialist Morris advocated his own solution to the workers’ plight. Morris' figure looms large in the novel, especially amid all this talk of making the world both better and more beautiful. Such rhetoric, combined with Hyacinth's denunciation of modernity's degraded taste and of the inferior productions that swarm the market, recalls Morris' instigation of a Ruskinian revival of the decorative arts tradition to combat the ugliness of the Industrial Age. Hyacinth's work in bookbindery and view of it as “quite one of the fine arts” recall Morris' devotion to the crafts and restoration of them to the status of art (1: 67). The Princess’ renunciation of her privileges, as well as her and Hyacinth's (early) commitment to class struggle, connect the pair to Morris the revolutionary. But Morris differed from both of these characters in uniting his political and artistic concerns: for Morris, art was life, and socialism was essential to both. His conversion to socialism can be charted through a series of lectures on art, beginning with “The Lesser Arts” (1877) and culminating in “Art and Plutocracy” (1883). In the first lecture, Morris expresses his fear that the ornamental arts will die and his hope that they will revive and thereby effect a reconciliation of art with life. These two were sundered, he argues, at the onset of the Industrial Age, when standardized, mechanized production sent the tradition of beautiful yet useful works of art into decay. For the decorative arts to regain popularity and for people to recover their sense of beauty, a new order founded on social equality and freedom from toil must replace the present one based on profit and privilege. Only then can art recover from the Middle Ages its true character as an “art made by the people for the people as a joy for the maker and the user” (Collected Works: 73). Socialism, Morris grew convinced, bore the promise of this new order.
But until socialism triumphed, he admitted, museums would remain necessary for the restoration of artistic sensibility. In spite of the city's unattractiveness, “London,” he says, “is good for this, that it is well off for museums” (Hopes and Fears: 21). Indeed, museum-building was the Victorian Age's great enterprise, realized in the opening of the South Kensington Museum in 1852, the National Portrait Gallery in 1859, the Natural History Museum in 1881, and the Tate Gallery in 1897 (Black 4). Recognition of the museum's value in promoting the culture of the masses led the British Parliament to pass a series of statutes, beginning with the Museums Act of 1845, providing for the foundation and maintenance of local museums. The idea that public collections should aim not just at the advancement but also the diffusion of knowledge gained ground in the late nineteenth century, triggering a shift in museological emphasis from acquisition and preservation to organization and development. In 1889 the Museums Association was founded in England for the purpose of determining the best methods of arranging exhibits with a view to instruction. Curators sought by scientific means to transform museums into “powerful educational agencies, in which by object lessons the most important truths of science (and art) were capable of being pleasantly imparted to the multitudes.” Early museums were criticized for their jumbled character. According to Lord Balcarres, trustee of the National Portrait Gallery, “The modern museum of art differs essentially from its earlier prototypes. The aimless collection of curiosities and bric-à-brac, brought together without method or system, was the feature of certain famous collections in by-gone days.” For the modern museum to be of didactic value, “Acquisitions must be added to their proper sections; random purchase of ‘curios’ must be avoided. Attention must be given to the proper display and cataloguing of the exhibits, to their housing and preservation, to the lighting, comfort and ventilation of the galleries” (Encyclopedia Britannica 19: 66, 60). With the new mission and management came a new emphasis on public outreach. The museum movement increasingly recognized that “museums must not merely exist passively for the benefit of those who choose to profit by them, but must be active in propaganda, must go out into the highways and hedges and compel men to come in” (Kenyon 30).
Morris recognized the educational value of museums and championed their role in the dissemination or redistribution of culture. He “heartily wish[ed]” that museums “were to be got at . . . on the only day on which an ordinarily busy man, one of the taxpayers who support them, can as a rule see them quietly” (Hopes and Fears: 21). Yet Morris' attitude toward museums was mixed. He believed that the contemporary enthusiasm for museum-building and arts education indicated a profound disconnect between art and life. According to him, the lack of quality works in their own time leads artists to the museum to study the examples of past art. The public goes to the museum to feed on beauty, which can no longer be found in their cities, homes, and places of work. Until socialism does away with the system of competitive commerce that ushered in these conditions, museums will be needed. But the job they do in the meantime is inadequate and possibly injurious. For a museum truly to have educational value, he argued, it must combine traditional arts instruction with political consciousness-raising. He elaborated his ideas for activist museum theory and practice in “At a Picture Show” (1884), a lecture delivered at the opening of a Manchester art exhibition for working men. Exhibitors, he said, should make clear that the difference between their knowledge of art and the audience's ignorance of it results from artificial class distinctions. They should point out that a difference in the economic basis of society is responsible for the superiority of the art of the past over that produced and producible in the present. Finally, they should seek through their exhibitions to kindle in the audience a desire for change, one that would lead to a revival of the arts and of the working man's role in their production. These changes would counter what Morris identifies as the museum's reigning ideology, what may be called the “museum effect,” whereby museums raise to the status of wonderful rarities articles that were actually ordinary at the time of their creation – and can be ordinary again, provided the necessary transformation in the social order. Left as they are, exhibitions as well as public libraries and museums risk becoming “substitutes” for real change, “dangerous snares” to political liberals and middle-class philanthropists who could come to believe that the museum's improvement of the masses rendered a radical transformation in the social order unnecessary.Footnote 8
Such was precisely the view animating the museum movement. In 1848, the year the Chartist movement came to a head and burst, Charles Kingsley published three papers in the socialist periodical Politics for the People explaining the good for London working-men of looking at pictures in public galleries. Picture-galleries, he believed, reconcile workers to their lot by lifting their thoughts above the ugliness of their lives to the beauty on display, and thence to the beauty of the world hereafter:
Believe it, toil-worn worker, in spite of thy foul alley, thy crowded lodging, thy grimed clothing, thy ill-fed children, thy thin, pale wife – believe it, thou too and thine, will some day have your share of beauty. God made you love beautiful things only because He intends hereafter to give you your fill of them. That pictured face on the wall is lovely, but lovelier still may the wife of thy bosom be when she meets thee on the resurrection morn! Those baby cherubs in the old Italian painting – how gracefully they flutter and sport among the soft clouds, full of rich young life and baby joy! Yes, beautiful indeed, but just such a one at this very moment is that once pining, deformed child of thine, over whose death-cradle thou wast weeping a month ago; now a child-angel, whom thou shalt meet again, never to part! (232)
The museum further obviates the need for wholesale social change by cementing the bonds between rich and poor, and it does so more effectively than other means currently proposed. “Believe me, my friends, . . . that men will never be joined in true brotherhood by mere plans to give them a self-interest in common, as the Socialists have tried to do. No: to feel for each other, they must first feel with each other” (245). The museum helps men to this end by being one of the only places where the poor and rich may meet together on equal footing, as English citizens, as men capable of admiring beautiful things, things created by artists who worked their way up not by birth but by worth, things that testify to the glory of their ultimate maker, God, before whom all men are brothers. “National property will always be respected,” Kingsley stresses, so long as all feel that they have their rights, including the right to share in the cultural treasures exhibited in the museum. In short, “The British Museum is a truly equalising place, in the deepest and most spiritual sense” (242).Footnote 9
An emphasis on people's spiritual improvement, brought about through art, over their material advancement, carried out through politics, also characterizes the thought of Matthew Arnold, who placed culture above what he saw as the traditional English preference for wealth and freedom, individualism and industrialism. In Culture and Anarchy (1869) he defines culture as the pursuit of perfection, which consists in “an inward condition of the mind and spirit,” and posits it as the supreme end in life for all social strata (62). As well as the end, culture is the means, and if culture is to be attained by all, it follows that the means must also be universally accessible. Indeed, culture for Arnold is both democratic and democratizing. It “seeks to do away with classes; to make the best that has been thought and known in the world current everywhere . . . This is the social idea; and the men of culture are the true apostles of equality” (79). Such equality is spiritual, in contrast to the political equality promoted by the Reform League, whom he identified as the false apostles of equality. It is marked by the moral and intellectual virtues of the individual rather than the right of the working class to vote (gained two years before) or the collective ownership of property and the means of production (championed by the Socialist League a decade and a half later). Ultimately, it leads people to rise beyond these narrow class or party interests and repose authority in the state, to the greater interest of all. Thus would culture counteract what Arnold saw as the prevailing trend toward anarchy in England, lately epitomized by the Hyde Park Riots. Culture functioned similarly, then, for Arnold and Kingsley: both reformers saw it as a way to induce the working class to moderate or renounce their political demands and entrust their welfare to the state, according to the first, or to heaven, according to the second.
If in Arnold's view Morris was a false apostle for advocating social instead of spiritual equality, from Morris' perspective Arnold was a liberal dupe for believing that spiritual equality could be achieved in the absence of social equality. As he said in “How I Became a Socialist” (1894), “Surely any one who professes to think that the question of art and cultivation must go before that of the knife and fork (and there are some who do propose that)” – here he has the likes of Arnold in mind, and we may think of Hyacinth too – “does not understand what art means, or how that its roots must have a soil of a thriving and unanxious life.”Footnote 10 Arnold's priority – to elevate the workers’ culture through the spread of the arts – assumed that doing so would lead to an improvement in their material conditions. Conversely, Paul's priority – to ameliorate the workers’ physical situation through revolution – presupposed that doing so would conduce to their spiritual uplift. As he put it, “The low tone of our fellow-mortals is a result of bad conditions; it is the conditions I want to alter. When those that have no start to speak of have a good one, it is but fair to infer that they will go further” (2: 216). Morris rejected this assumption as well, arguing that the workman “scarcely knows how to frame a desire for any life much better than that which he now endures perforce. It is the province of art to set the true ideal of a full and reasonable life before him, a life to which the perception and creation of beauty, the enjoyment of real pleasure that is, shall be felt to be as necessary to man as his daily bread.” Morris instead staked a middle ground between what may be called the idealist and materialist positions, promoting art and life equally on the grounds that they were interdependent and in the belief that their joint fruition could only come about through socialism.
Hyacinth sides with the liberal reformers on the social question, holding that the spread of culture is the most effective means of improving the people. At the same time, he harbors reservations about opening museums to the working class on Sundays, which leaves him open to the charge of elitism. There are two reasons for these reservations that should serve both to mitigate the charge and to differentiate him from his fellow advocates of culture. First, in Hyacinth's view the service art renders life proceeds more by indirect means (raising the level of civilization) than by direct means (redistributing art through the museum). This perspective admits the power of private, and not just public, collections of art to have an effect on the wider society. As Hyacinth says, the splendid accumulations of the happier few enhance the quality of life for all. In the 1909 New York Edition James emended the prosaic phrase that these accumulations make the world “less impracticable and more tolerable” to the more colloquial “less of a ‘bloody sell’ and life more of a lark” precisely to underscore Hyacinth's belief in the inclusive benefits of the arts, however exclusive these may be. In paralleling, as we saw above, “The monuments and treasures of art, the great palaces and properties,” in the same sentence with “the general fabric of civilisation as we know it,” Hyacinth similarly emphasizes their common benefit to people high and low. How exactly does this trickle-down theory of art work?
The notion that the fine arts spread beauty to all of society through their influence upon the decorative arts was a staple of Victorian thought. In a Royal Academy lecture early in the century Henry Fuseli had already argued, “Whatever is commodious, amene, or useful, depends in a great measure on the arts: dress, furniture, and habitation owe to their breath what they can boast of grace, propriety, or shape: they teach elegance to finish what necessity invented, and make us enamoured of our wants” (550). Speaking in 1846 of the Society of Arts, Prince Albert said that the department “most likely to prove immediately beneficial to the public, was that which encouraged, most efficiently, the application of the Fine Arts to the veracious manufactures of the country” (qtd. in Mayhew and Cruikshank 131). The idea of improving the quality of commodities by wedding mechanical skill with high art motivated the Great Exhibition of 1851 and the founding of the South Kensington Museum. The diffusion of beauty is manifest in the novel's elaborate descriptions of the domestic interiors of the lower classes. Poupin's salon and boudoir, for example, boast, among many other things, a great many mirrors, prints of revolutionary heroes, magnificent red drapery, rugs and mats of various shapes and sizes, and “a wonderful gilt clock of the Empire, surmounted with a ‘subject’ representing Virtue receiving a crown of laurel from the hands of Faith” (1: 104). That his intérieur can be so pleasingly if not richly appointed underscores the irony of a communard fighting for the redistribution of cultural goods. That the Empire clock originates in the same regime whose overthrow he seeks only adds to the irony. In fact, Poupin's rooms so well recreate the Paris he fled that they evoke for Hyacinth visions of that celebrated capital. Similarly, Paul's quarters in Audley Court, while shabbier and duller than the Lomax Place where Hyacinth resides, nonetheless feature from the back windows a view of the dome of Saint Paul's. The poor chemist's flat displays a wealth of “relics, treasured and polished” and in spite of the brown walls presents, “thanks to a multitude of small prints, both plain and coloured, fastened all over the walls, a highly-decorated appearance” (1: 120, 140). Indeed, the place has the air of a “picture-gallery” (1: 122). Meanwhile, Paul's invalid sister Rosy enjoys a “beautiful counterpane of every colour of the rainbow” (1: 239). Even Miss Pynsent's meager artistic furnishings provide her with some small measure of pulchritude. Thus do Medley, Marylebone, and Mayfair, and in back of them the museum and art gallery, radiate their refining influence to Lomax Place, Lisson Grove, and Audley Court: by disseminating a model of beauty, exemplified in the comely arrangement of objects both ornamental and artistic, into the everyday world of the less privileged classes. Audley Court's “pretty name” itself owes its inspiration in a way to the first three locales, deriving as it does from the title of a Tennyson poem (1: 120). Art's beneficent power reaches as far as Captain Sholto's coiffure, which, parted at the side and coming forward on either temple in a well-brushed lock, emulates the fashion of the portraits of 1820. The novel thus endorses Hyacinth's brand of meliorism, which falls in line with the broader nineteenth-century faith in progress. In proof of this progress, “Lomax Place has improved” from the “beastly hole” Hyacinth once considered it to be (2: 57, 1: 78). Such a lift in living conditions – presumably another example of the edifying influence of high art – further supports the liberal argument that a radical transformation of the social order is unnecessary to improve the workers’ lot.
A subtle appreciation for art's life-enhancing effects is, then, one factor that distinguishes Hyacinth from his fellow advocates of culture. The second factor, which also explains his misgivings over expanding public access to museums, consists in Hyacinth's perception of “the danger of too much coddling legislation on behalf of the working classes.” The danger lies in the possibility that giving the working class a taste of high culture will spoil them for their station. Hyacinth's own case illustrates this danger, making him all too aware of it. His glimpse into the world of high civilization, afforded by his contact with the Princess and his travel to the Continent, does not just lead to his ceasing to care for the revolutionary cause. It also sets the stage for the demoralization that inevitably ensues upon his return to his humble sphere. As he writes to the Princess from Venice, where he can hardly believe it is he who is enjoying the city's cultural fare, “a short time hence, . . . I shall have proof enough that it has been my very self: I shall know this by the terrible grind of the life and the penance to come” (2: 144). Indeed, back in London he must “pull himself together for the business of his livelihood, an effort he found by no means easy or agreeable” (2: 147). Madame Grandoni had already warned Hyacinth of the peril posed by his budding intimacy with the Princess.
“Don't give up anything.”
“What can I give up?”
“Don't give up yourself. I say that to you in your interest. I think you have some little trade – I forget what; but whatever it may be, remember that to do it well is the best thing; better than paying visits, better even than being liked by Princesses!” (1: 282)
James was not alone in realizing that too strong a dose of culture can put workers out of joint with their class. In The Crown of Wild Olive (1866), John Ruskin considers the same problem, led thereto while drawing out the implications of his claim that to teach taste is to form character:
As I was thinking over this, in walking up Fleet Street the other day, my eye caught the title of a book standing open in a bookseller's window. It was – On the Necessity of the Diffusion of Taste among all Classes. “Ah,” I thought to myself, “my classifying friend, when you have diffused your taste, where will your classes be? The man who likes what you like, belongs to the same class with you, I think. Inevitably so. You may put him to other work if you choose; but, by the condition you have brought him into, he will dislike the other work as much as you would yourself. You get hold of a scavenger, or a costermonger, who enjoyed the Newgate Calendar for literature, and “Pop goes the Weasel” for music. You think you can make him like Dante and Beethoven? I wish you joy of your lessons; but if you do, you have made a gentleman of him. (54–55)
Ruskin points up not just the risks involved in elevating taste but also the limits to its success. The passage serves as a caution to liberals – especially Arnold – overly zealous of the power of art to improve society. The Princess Casamassima serves up the same warning, whereof Hyacinth is long heedless at the cost of his life. For the problem, it turns out, is not that culture comes to him too little too late but that it comes too much too soon.
At the same time, Hyacinth hardly has a rank for which he can be ruined; hence his puzzlement at Madame Grandoni's advice. In ignorance of his origins, she assumes an identity between his self – the emphasis is her own – and his trade. “‘Ah yes, I see what you mean!’ Hyacinth exclaimed, exaggerating a little. ‘I am very fond of my trade, I assure you’” (1: 282). Hyacinth does not see clearly what she means because he has never clearly seen who he is. Of hybrid parentage, he is neither lower- nor upper-class, neither French nor English, neither cultured nor uncultured, neither merely a mechanic nor wholly an artist – or rather, he is all of these things. He was spoiled at birth, as it were, and throughout childhood, when his foster mother hinted to him about his noble ancestry, giving him a lofty self-image that clashed with his lowly surroundings and humble prospects. The spoiling deepened when she took him to meet his biological mother in prison, which awakened him to the reality of the class-structure at the cost of embittering him toward society. The irony is that she did so on the recommendation of Mr. Vetch, who intended to enlighten Hyacinth as to “the state of the account between society and himself” so that he “can then conduct himself accordingly,” meaning use his natural resentment constructively, to champion change, like Mr. Vetch himself. Little did Mr. Vetch foresee that Hyacinth's agitation would take a destructive turn instead, leading the pupil to go beyond his mentor's gradualism and take up arms against the state. Thus, rather than saying that Hyacinth's precipitant entry into the world of high culture spoiled him for his station, it is more appropriate to say that it completed a process begun at birth.
In Morris' view, the museum at its worst delayed the inevitable revolution. According to Kenyon, not even at its best could the museum stave off revolution but it did have the power to prevent would-be pétroleurs. The museum, in fact, comes close to achieving both objectives in The Princess Casamassima, where the monuments of culture win Hyacinth's sympathies away from both the socialist movement and the incendiary zeal he perceives in it. Yet the museum's social utility – the very mark of its modernity – does not prove as great as that with which Kenyon and his nineteenth-century forbears credit it. Near the end of the novel, Hyacinth receives a pistol and orders from Hoffendahl to assassinate a duke and thereby to start the revolution. On the one hand, Hyacinth wishes to preserve art, which he considers essential to life, from the flames or partition to which his erstwhile coreligionists would consign it. On the other hand, the tutelage of his taste, in reforming his character, has not only rescued him from the cause but also ruined him for a station that was never quite his to begin with. However much the museum helps him to save his soul by cultivating his sense of beauty, it neither saves his body by improving conditions rapidly enough nor – pace Kingsley – reconciles him to his lot, and Hyacinth is driven to despair by the contradiction. What Benjamin said of conventional historiography may be extended to the museum: it “may augment the weight of the treasure accumulating on the back of humanity, but it does not provide the strength to shake off this burden so as to take control of it” (“Edward Fuchs”: 268). Caught in the conflict between art and life, Hyacinth turns the pistol on himself.
