In Making Marriage Work, Kristin Celello covers territory that historian Rebecca L. Davis also recently explored in More Perfect Unions: The American Search for Marital Bliss (2010). Like Davis, Celello examines trends in American marriage advice over the course of the twentieth century. She does so, however, within the context of American exceptionalism. As members of a society whose national myth proclaimed that anyone who worked hard and played by the rules could achieve success, Americans of the last century inevitably came to the conclusion that their work ethic should be applied to marriage. In the face of a rising divorce rate – the highest in the industrialized world – Americans adopted the can-do attitude that had conquered a continent and built a wealthy and powerful nation. With ingenuity, pluck, and diligence, Americans believed that they could overcome the dismal divorce statistics and increase the number of stable marriages. The prescriptive literature that encouraged this way of thinking frequently resembled the rags-to-riches fables of an earlier era, but the protagonists of these modern American success stories were not the eager young men of nineteenth-century Horatio Alger tales. Instead, as Celello persuasively demonstrates, marriage advisers consistently portrayed American women as the hardworking strivers who should aspire to marital success.
Employing evidence from advice manuals, women's magazines, and a variety of popular-culture sources, Celello finds that psychologists, sociologists, clergy members, and other shapers of opinion placed the burden of marital success largely on the shoulders of American wives. When the first significant rise in divorce statistics occurred after World War I, the advice givers saw wives as the logical partners to monitor the health of their marriages. After all, unlike their husbands, women relied on marriage as their primary route to economic stability and social identity. Even as the century progressed and women increased their participation in the labor force and other public activities, their continued role as family caregivers guaranteed that women remained the focus of marital advice. The marriage advice industry constructed its prescriptions around the gender-role customs of its initial clientele – the white middle class – and rarely revised the basic script as its customer base expanded. With the growth of the African American middle class, for instance, writers for Ebony and other black periodicals increasingly discussed achievement of a successful marriage as women's work. The arrival of second-wave feminism and its critique of gender-role-based marriage likewise did little to dissuade most marriage advisers from focussing primarily on wives. In fact, as Celello notes, the feminist movement of the 1960s and 1970s inadvertently spurred publication of one of the most wife-centered – and popular – marital advice manuals of the century. In her runaway bestseller The Total Woman (1973), conservative author Marabel Morgan argued that feminists had it all wrong and that a subservient wife who catered to her husband's every desire was the key to a successful American marriage.
Among the fascinating gems that Calello uncovers in her exploration of marital work is the Divorcees Anonymous movement of the 1950s, in which divorced women served as sponsors to women contemplating divorce and counseled them to learn from the divorcees' mistakes. Modeling their program on Alcoholics Anonymous and identifying one another by first names only, divorcees advised other women to forgive adulterous husbands, improve their hairstyles and wardrobes, and labor in other ways to keep their marriages intact. Within seven years of its founding in 1949, Divorcees Anonymous (or DA) claimed to have saved three thousand marriages. Widespread television and popular press coverage of DA activities, however, guaranteed that its anti-divorce message reached well beyond those who directly participated in the program.
One of the major strengths of Celello's study is her attention to American popular culture and the ways in which it reinforced the notion that marriage was primarily women's work. Magazine cartoons, big-screen movies, and television programs – including a 1950s television series entitled Divorce Hearing – frequently delivered the same message: women should take heroic measures to preserve their marriages. As Celello notes, this theme reached its “logical, if extreme, conclusion” (148) in the 1987 blockbuster Fatal Attraction, in which a forgiving wife saves her marriage and the life of her adulterous husband by killing his psychotic lover. Celello's treatment of this film and other popular-culture sources makes her book a particularly engaging and accessible study.
