Participants in the independent film world in the US today draw upon a familiar language of art versus commerce to position independent films on the side of art, as the socially engaged and/or formally experimental alternative to mass-marketed, profit-oriented Hollywood studio films. What is new about contemporary American independent film is not its rhetoric but the cultural prominence and commercial value it has achieved in comparison with previous alternative cinemas. In Not Hollywood, anthropologist Sherry Ortner seeks to explain how and why the indie movement has emerged and flourished since the 1990s. Ortner acknowledges the role played by industrial changes in the process. She considers how the specialty divisions established by conglomerate-owned studios have encouraged independent filmmaking, while complicating its claims to “outsider” status. But she argues that independent film can also be understood at another level, as a product of and critical response to “profound changes wrought in American society under the regime of neoliberal capitalism” (3). She foregrounds changes that have increased class inequality and eroded expectations among what was once a relatively comfortable middle class.
In her previous book, New Jersey Dreaming (2003), Ortner studied rising middle-class baby boomers whose economic mobility validated their faith in the American Dream. The new book, in many ways a companion piece, is focussed on the young middle-class adults who became known in the media as “Generation X” as they negotiate what Ortner calls the “Twilight of the American Dream.” Ortner treats Generation X as “an open-ended and ongoing generational entity” rather than a finite cohort: middle-class youth born after the baby boom who come of age in a world reordered by neoliberalism, a world they see as in many respects harsher than the world which the boomers confronted (22). The immediate relevance of this category to indie cinema is that it includes many of the filmmakers, whose “generational positioning” Ortner sees as the source of the dark realism by which she characterizes indie cinema (59). She argues that indie filmmakers channel the “generational anxieties” into dark, difficult, and disturbing films that are proffered as vehicles of “truth” in opposition to Hollywood's “lies” (69).
But if the films express the “dark worldview” she attributes to Generation X, Ortner recognizes that the indie film movement also depends on middle-class affluence (66). Here she introduces the category of the professional–managerial class or PMC – salaried mental workers, in the Ehrenreichs' formulation – whose class position depends on educational capital. Over the 1990s, even as the long economic downturn generated mounting anxiety, many PMC people thrived economically, while retaining liberal attitudes; some of them invested in independent films, while other highly educated if less wealthy PMC people became indie producers. Ortner adds that PMC people (including boomers as well as X-ers) are also the main audience for indie films, thus effectively crediting the “expansion and reconfiguration of the PMC” with the new cinema's commercial viability (101). She presents PMC involvement in independent film production as motivated primarily by “passion” rather than commercial interest; that investors and producers may also pursue economic profits is not denied, but how they balance cultural and economic motivations is not addressed.
Ortner displays a cautious attitude toward Bourdieu's model of art as a “restricted field,” referring to it at one point as “too thin,” overly focussed on “prestige effects” (53), and suggesting that the concept of an “interest in disinterest” reduces artistic production to “the empty play of cultural capital” (169). Although space does not permit, I would argue that this is a misrepresentation of Bourdieu's model. Be that as it may, I think Ortner underemphasizes the contradiction between critique and distinction in the operation of alternative cultural formations such as indie film. The audience for indie film initially appears in her account within the class-generational frame that includes the filmmakers, as anxious, disillusioned X-ers, bearers of a darkly critical “worldview.”
The category of PMC is withheld until the discussion of investors and producers, when the audience is characterized, almost in passing, as a cross-generational class elite, whose receptivity to indie cinema would seem to depend not only on socially conditioned “generational anxieties” but also on possession of what indie cinema constructs as a superior aesthetic taste. Ortner equates the indie aesthetic with realist storytelling, and when she analyzes individual films she focusses on the stories they tell, which she argues are “most directly relatable to the social issues at stake” (280). Realism, however, is only one strain of indie cinema; many films, including some of the best known, emphasize formal experimentation and narrative play; prominence of form encourages and rewards particular kinds of viewing practice that do not necessarily demand reflection on a represented social world.
A more nuanced view of indie aesthetics arguably complicates an account of the movement's emergence. Thus it seems to me that Ortner assigns too much causal force to “neoliberal capitalism,” to the neglect of more specifically cultural institutions through which some PMC people have learned to appreciate films as art, including university film societies and programs, as well as new sites of film viewing such as festivals and urban art house chains that get only brief mention in the book. Ortner has cogently and persuasively connected indie cinema to the dispositions of what I would call the “knowledge class.” Although I think the attitudes and tastes of this class formation are less unified than in her portrayal, her ethnography makes a major contribution to the study of culture and social class.
