The eight essays in this volume emerged from a series of conferences at the William Andrews Clark library on Explorations, Encounters, and the Circulation of Knowledge. The word ‘curious’ in the title indicates the ordinary curiosity of humans in unfamiliar territory but also (idiomatically for the eighteenth century) Dr Johnson's select company of curious men, who met once a week to exhilarate their studies, and compare their acquisitions (the satirical Rambler 177). Today's select company is busy upending the colonial certitudes of what Michael Bravo has termed ‘the encounter genre’ (p. 4). A multitude of studies in Europe and the Americas have been decentring long-accepted narratives of exploration and social contact between triumphant travellers and submissive indigenous peoples, ‘civilization’ and ‘barbarity’.
The eighteenth century is a vital period for this transformation, because of its situation between a simpler age of unquestioned conquest and the institutionalized certainties of nineteenth-century trade and imperial policy. The global scale of colonial acquisitiveness, an emerging new natural history, and strengthened technological capacity all intersected (and in some cases collided) in ways that underpin the interpretive turn of recent years. The editors have chosen essays focusing on the characteristic eighteenth-century long journey, in which sea captains, travellers, scientists, collectors and indigenous peoples, each with their own motives and cultural perspectives, interacted. In their introduction we meet John Sacheuse, an indigenous Greenlander who moved easily between studying painting in Edinburgh and sailing as an interpreter with John Ross on his failed 1819 voyage; ‘we know that the Isabella was searching for the North-West passage’, they ask, ‘but what was Sacheuse searching for?’ All of these essays illuminate that question.
Markman Ellis's chapter on tea as an object of knowledge between Britain and China sketches the little known in the West about tea before John Ovington, an East India Company chaplain, visited Surat between 1689 and 1692. Doctors investigated the supposed curative powers of tea while botanists puzzled over the fragmentary specimens available of the whole plant. Yet as Western knowledge grew, the complex Confucian culture surrounding tea was ignored. ‘Severed from this wider context, botany could “discover” tea by encountering the plant as if it was terra incognita and treating it as if it was terra nullius’ (p. 33). Two essays on collections illustrate the complicated ways such specimens were acquired and kept. Kathleen S. Murphy follows John Burnet, the surgeon of a British slave trader to Spanish America, ‘who was not supposed to be there in the first place’ (p. 140) because the Spanish protected the natural resources of their territories by forbidding entry to all foreigners. But the Spanish needed slaves, and the Asiento contracts that admitted slavers also admitted ships’ doctors. Burnet's considerable collection of specimens – medicines, dyes, plants, shells, astronomical calculations, even the human remains he sometimes gathered as a surgeon on shipboard – was given to his English correspondents, Hans Sloane, James Pettifer and James Douglas. Sloane's centrality in collecting culture is well known, and Miles Ogborn and Victoria Pickering take up a teasing reference to the great man's ‘nicknackatory’ to examine the almost chaotic variety of objects he collected, moved to Chelsea, and moved back to London before he died. Even in the ongoing cataloguing and boxing up of specimens, they identify something new: ‘the collection's organization was … always a matter of local forms of order, interesting juxtapositions, and an effect of abundance and particularized curiosity’ (p. 133).
Two essays draw particular attention to the history of writing and the book. Matthew Goldmark's briskly argued ‘Formal encounters: education, evangelization, and the reproduction of custom in seventeenth-century Peru’ describes the treatment by Spanish officials of indigenous customs as ‘a deviant inheritance that defined New World populations’ (p. 190). Their response was rigid: petitioners seeking to certify their good standing as Christians presented their case using an identical form for everyone; the only criterion was obedience to its rhetorical and syntactical rules. Good Christian standing ‘could in fact be made true by being properly registered in form’ (p. 197, emphasis added). Elsewhere deep-rooted practices of gift exchange modulated relationships but were not understood as such. Billie Lythberg studies how books of Pacific barkcloth samples, published from 1787 by London bookseller Alexander Shaw, seeded knowledge of Polynesia in Britain. But they represent a collision of cosmologies: intensely ceremonial objects of exchange at their origins, the cloths were explicated by Shaw in technical terms and with travellers’ accounts of their manufacture.
Three essays stand out in this stimulating company. Donna Landry writes about Evilya Çelebi, a seventeenth-century Ottoman who travelled on horseback for most of his life across the Ottoman Empire ‘from Tabriz to Vienna, from the Sea of Azov to the Sudan’ (p. 45), writing ten volumes about what he had seen, the Sayahatname or ‘Book of Travels’. Çelebi was a citizen of a vast empire very different from those in the West. Ottoman lands ‘were not conceived in Western terms of imperium, but as … a place of safety as well as toleration for all subjects’ (p. 44). This is a fascinating exploration not only of Ottoman dominion, but also of its remarkable horse culture, in which Çelebi was an experienced participant. ‘The Ottomans’, writes Landry, ‘were privileged to have immediate access to the best horses in the world, and they were equine multiculturalists’ (p. 52). The only place where Çelebi feels estrangement is in his account of Vienna, where he finally senses that the infidels who are his boon companions are also imperial rivals. Landry's expert account of Çelebi and his world makes the reader eager for more. Michael Bravo's densely documented ‘Indigenous voyaging, authorship, and discovery’ avoids any simple contrast between European and indigenous practices in identifying indigenous expertise; as he points out, ‘this is itself a trope of imperial encounter’ (p. 75). Instead, answering to the ‘making knowledge’ of the collection's title, he examines an 1810 voyage along the Labrador coast by Moravian missionaries with one of their Inuit converts and his extended family. The ostensible aim was to seek out Inuit people and places, the ultimate goal to convert the shamanist Inuit of Ungava to Christianity. The result is an anxious confrontation between indigenous and European imaginations. The Moravians sought a transcendental life-commitment from their converts, one that abjured the devilish practices of shamanism and settled Christians in one place where they could practise together. The Inuit relied on kinship networks, social traditions of hunting and feasting, and the certainty that life on the trail was home. The account of their uneasy interactions as they passed the evil spirits of the Torngat mountains and returned to the world of Christian observance and print publication offers a remarkable portrait of cultures in mystified confrontation. In the concluding essay Noah Heringman considers George and John Forster's response to changing concepts of the stages of historical and geological time. Should their ethnography depict primitive peoples as the decayed relics of once-proud races? How, then, to interpret the advanced civilization on Tahiti, especially given the tension between European sexual morality and Tahitian freedom? In their attempts to fathom the stages of human history, while at the same time absorbing the data from a new ethnography, we can see the shadowy beginnings of the interpretive transformation that would bring this excellent collection about.
