Two centuries after the shuעūbiyya movement was active in the East, the Arab–mawālī dispute was replicated in al-Andalus. The only extant manifesto of Andalusi shuעūbiyya is the Risala (Epistle) of Abu עAmir ibn García al-Bashkunsi (11th century). Studies on this work are scarce. After the pioneering work of I. Goldziher on the shuעūbiyya in al-Andalus (“Die Shuעūbiyya unter den Muhammedanern in Spanien,” 1899), which included extracts of the Risala, two editions of the text were produced by al-עAbbadi (Madrid, 1953) and A. Harun (Cairo, 1951–55). The text has been translated into English and analyzed, along with five refutations to Ibn García, by J.T. Monroe (The Shuעūbiyya in al-Andalus, 1970).
A few investigations on this topic have been carried out recently, but the volume under review (Larsson's doctoral dissertation, translated from Swedish into English) constitutes the most extensive work to date devoted to the Risala of Ibn García and the shuעūbiyya in al-Andalus. The book comprises six main sections: “Introduction,” “The formative period of al-Andalus,” “The symbolic articulation of power,” “Dissidents during the caliphate period,” “Ibn García and the context of his time,” and “The reading of Ibn García.” Finally, there are a conclusion, bibliography, and index of proper names.
In the introduction, Larsson briefly discusses a variety of topics illustrative of the author's approach to the subject, general issues related to the history and historiography of al-Andalus, and specific issues related to the reading of Ibn García's Risala, structured as follows: (A) objectives, (B) sources, (C) theoretical setting, (D) Ibn García and heresy, (E) methodological setting, (F) previous research, and (G) historical background. However, in this introduction, the reader receives a somewhat confusing impression of the book's contents, which mirrors the confusing structure of the chapter. In addition, Larsson goes far beyond the analysis of Ibn García's letter and the shuעūbiyya movement by discussing issues with little or no relation to the book's focus. This is the case in the section on previous research, where Larsson speaks of the early 20th-century historiographical debate between Américo Castro and Claudio Sánchez Albornoz on whether Spain resulted from a mixed Semitic and Latin heritage or was built on a Latin/Christian foundation (pp. 33–34), followed by a summary of scholarship on the history of al-Andalus (pp. 34–36) that includes works as general as the Cambridge History of Arabic Literature, Encyclopaedia of Islam, and Cambridge History of Africa.
Chapter 2 deals with the history of al-Andalus from the conquest in 711 CE to the proclamation of the independent caliphate in 929 CE, paying special attention to the social conflicts of Andalusi society, including those of a religious, ethnic, and political nature. Larsson adroitly links theology and political power in his analysis of social tensions. In chapter 3, the focus of attention is the structure and articulation of power during the caliphate period (929–1031 CE), through the analysis of two specific manifestations of power and legitimacy: the adoption of the title of caliph and the architectural language of the mosque of Córdoba. Chapter 4 summarizes different sources of social conflict at the end of the caliphate period.
Chapter 5 brings us closer to the meat of the matter. It gives a general overview of the Taifa period and the more specific historical and intellectual context of Ibn García's Risala. Larsson summarizes and discusses previous scholarship on the corresponding issues. Finally, chapter 6 is a detailed survey of the contents of the Risala. The core of Larsson's reading of the letter is its interpretation as a means of legitimizing a non-Arab alternative to Arab rule. This will be, of course, the most interesting chapter for those who desire a novel and up-to-the-minute discussion of Ibn García's work and the shuעūbiyya in al-Andalus.
It must be said, however, that one drawback of Larsson's study is the often erratic organization of the material and the presentation of the different topics. It is difficult for the reader to follow the thread of the different chapters. Furthermore, the putative theme of each section feels diluted by the variety of information, regardless of its relevance to the main subject. There are also numerous typographical and some grammatical errors in the text and in the bibliography. By way of example: “Iberio” instead of “Ibero” (p. viii), “Ibn al- al-” (p. 7), “Ménendes” instead of “Menéndez” (p. 18), “Espagne Musulman” instead of “Espagne Musulmane” (p. 34), “it does not expresses [sic]” (p. 52), “differ-ences” (p. 61), “that were to influenced [sic]” (p. 71), “From an [sic] mālikī” (p. 84), “opra” instead of “por” (p. 215), “Espaāa” instead of “España” (p. 220), “Hespéres” instead of “Hespéris” (p. 220), “pólitico” instead of “político” (p. 220), etc.
The scholar of Arabic and Islamic history will recognize this book as an “introduction and update” to a topic of Andalusi history rather than as an “in-depth study.” This is particularly the case given the author's reliance on secondary sources. Yet, one of the highlights of the study is its emphasis on methodological and theoretical issues. Larsson has most adroitly situated each topic within a broad theoretical setting, using modern sociological methodology and language.
