I Introduction
National measures introducing mandatory country of origin labelling (hereinafter, COOL) for milk, foodstuffs containing milk or meat used as an ingredient, and single ingredient foodstuffs are on the rise in EU Member States. At the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council on 17–18 July 2017, at the request of the Belgian delegation, EU Member States’ ministers discussed the impact on the internal market of national rules introducing COOL of food and, in particular, for milk and foodstuffs containing milk or meat as an ingredient. While many of those measures are currently only in trial periods, the recent increase of initiatives by EU Member States, namely in Italy and France, indicates a growing interest by EU Member States and a likelihood that such measures would be implemented on a more permanent basis. Before that happens, implications for the internal market must be carefully evaluated.
II Background
Already quite a number of food products are subject to mandatory COOL throughout the EU and on the basis of EU law. This includes fruits and vegetables,Footnote 1 beef,Footnote 2 fish,Footnote 3 olive oilFootnote 4 and honey.Footnote 5 Regarding meat, COOL was made mandatory for unprocessed fresh beef and beef products in the aftermath of the mad cow disease epidemic (ie Bovine spongiform encephalopathy, or BSE).Footnote 6 It is also required for pre-packed poultry meat imported from third countries.Footnote 7
In addition, Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 on the provision of food information to consumers (hereinafter, FIR)Footnote 8 requires that unprocessed fresh, chilled or frozen meat of swine, poultry, sheep and goats be accompanied by COOL. Specific rules under this regulation are set out in European Commission Implementing Regulation No 1337/2013 of 13 December 2013.Footnote 9 Likewise, Article 26(2)(a) of the FIR requires that COOL be mandatory in instances where a failure to provide such information could mislead consumers.Footnote 10
The scope of mandatory COOL in the EU stands to be further expanded by specific provisions in the FIR that enable the European Commission (hereinafter, Commission) to table legislative proposals on mandatory COOL for, inter alia, milk, unprocessed foods and meat used as an ingredient in processed foods.Footnote 11
According to Article 39(1) of the FIR, EU Member States may, in accordance with the procedure laid down in Article 45 of the FIR, adopt measures requiring additional mandatory particulars for specific types or categories of foods, justified on grounds of at least one of the following: (a) the protection of public health; (b) the protection of consumers; (c) the prevention of fraud; (d) the protection of industrial and commercial property rights, indications of provenance, registered designations of origin and the prevention of unfair competition.
With respect to measures concerning the mandatory indication of the country of origin or place of provenance of foods, Article 39(2) of the FIR additionally requires EU Member States to establish a proven link between certain qualities of the food and its origin or provenance. Such links must be established and corroborated by the respective EU Member State with respect to every single COOL scheme. EU Member States must notify such measures to the Commission and provide credible evidence that the majority of consumers attach significant value to the provision of that information.
Ahead of the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council on 17–18 July 2017, the Belgian delegation presented a document entitled “Consequences of the mandatory labelling of the country of origin on the internal market”Footnote 12 in which it noted that the FIR introduces a set of provisions regarding origin labelling of food, while certain measures of the FIR may be supplemented by national rules (under strict conditions), as in the case for the mandatory COOL of food. Belgium noted that several EU Member States had notified national rules for milk and foodstuffs containing milk or meat as an ingredient to the Commission and that, although a strict link between the quality of the product and the origin had to be proven and several EU Member States did not agree with the notification, the Commission did not react to the notification and tacitly accepted those national measures considered as “test measures”. This document was tabled and debated before Italy, in August 2017, introduced mandatory COOL for pasta and rice products, without having notified the respective measures to the Commission. In September 2017, Italy announced the forthcoming introduction of COOL for tomato products.
In particular, France and Italy have started trial periods for COOL schemes for certain food products. On 1 January 2017, France started a two-year trial of a mandatory COOL scheme, which requires producers of milk, food containing milk products and food containing meat to provide information on the country of origin of the products. The scheme was introduced through Decree No 2016-1137 (ie Décret n° 2016-1137 du 19 août 2016 relatif à l’indication de l’origine du lait et du lait et des viandes utilisés en tant qu’ingrédient).Footnote 13 Before the end of this trial period, France has promised to provide a report to the Commission that would allow it to review consumer patterns and the potential impact on the internal market.
After being notified by France of the draft Decree, on 12 April 2016, the Commission consulted the relevant section of the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed (composed of representatives from the Commission and the EU Member States, hereinafter, SCPAFF) on the matter.Footnote 14 During the relevant section meeting of the SCPAFF, a number of EU Member States raised concerns about the negative impact of the French measure on the access of non-French ingredient suppliers, particularly on small- and medium-sized enterprises, to food production and distribution in France. Other delegations did not oppose mandatory COOL as such, but expressed a preference for a harmonised approach at EU level, while a few delegations supported the French draft Decree. The Commission reminded the SCPAFF that the FIR allowed EU Member States to adopt national measures on COOL on food under certain conditions. It also stated that “the topic was intensively debated at the co-decision stage and that the political and legal context has significantly evolved in recent years”.
Italy adopted, on 9 December 2016, a Decree requiring COOL for milk and dairy products (ie Decreto 9 dicembre 2016 Indicazione dell’origine in etichetta della materia prima per il latte e i prodotti lattieri caseari, in attuazione del regolamento (UE) n. 1169/2011, relativo alla fornitura di informazioni sugli alimenti ai consumatori), which applies for a trial period until 31 March 2019.Footnote 15
Both the French and Italian decrees provide that the indication of the origin of milk or milk used as an ingredient in dairy products must include the following information: (1) “country of collection: (name of country)”; and (2) “country of transformation: (name of country where it has been conditioned and transformed)”.Footnote 16 When milk or milk used as an ingredient in dairy products has been collected and processed in the same country, the indication of origin may appear as “origin: (name of country)”Footnote 17 . When collection and transformation are carried out on the territory of several EU Member States, the mention “EU” may be used, instead of the name of the country or countries to designate the location of the steps involved. In addition, when those steps are carried out on the territory of several countries located outside the EU, the words “Outside EU” may be used instead of the name of the country or countries to designate the location of the relevant steps. Finally, should collection and transformation be carried out in EU Member States and in countries located outside the EU, or if the origin is undetermined, the words “EU or outside EU” may be used.Footnote 18 According to mutual recognition clauses in both decrees, products lawfully produced or marketed in another EU Member State are not subject to the provisions of the Decree.Footnote 19
III Comment
The question arises as to whether Food Business Operators (hereinafter, FBO) comply with the new and burdensome COOL requirements for dairy products and whether there are sanctions enforced by the authorities in case of non-compliance. In April 2017, the French consumer organisation Que Choisir published a survey carried out on 40 products of major brands showing that, in more than 50% of the cases, “FBOs insist in maintaining opacity of the origin of the ingredients they use”. It must be noted that the survey also included products where meat is a substantial ingredient because the French COOL measure, unlike the Italian COOL measure, also applies to meat as an ingredient and not only to dairy products. There do not appear to be reports on sanctions or fines for non-compliance with the new French and Italian COOL requirements yet. However, both national measures provide for sanctions in case of non-compliance. In case of infringements, Article 8 of the French Decree No 2016-1137 foresees fines according to the 5th class of Article 131-13 of the French Penal Code (ie € 1,500, which can be raised to €3,000 in case of recidivism). The applicable fines under Article 5 of the Italian Decree of 9 December 2017 are set out in Article 4 of the Law of 3 February 2011 on labelling and quality of food products (ie Legge di 3 febbraio 2011, n. 4 Disposizioni in materia di etichettatura e di qualita’ dei prodotti alimentari) and may amount to between €1,600 and €9,500. Violations of the Decree are subject to a fine of between €2,000 and €18,000.
A number of further EU Member States have adopted (ie Finland,Footnote 20 Lithuania and Portugal) or are already in the process of adopting (ie Greece,Footnote 21 RomaniaFootnote 22 and SpainFootnote 23 ) similar COOL legislation on milk and milk used as an ingredient in dairy products. In the last few months, the SCPAFF has held exchanges of views on Italian, Lithuanian and Portuguese,Footnote 24 and GreekFootnote 25 draft measures prescribing the indication of the country of origin of milk, dairy products and, in one case, rabbit meat. After the notification of the different measures, in accordance with the notification procedure provided in Article 45 of the FIR, and debate within the SCPAFF, the Commission has tacitly given the green light to the French, Italian, Lithuanian and Portuguese schemes, given that they are temporary, include a mutual recognition clause (providing that products lawfully produced or marketed in another EU Member State are not subject to the schemes), provide for “EU” or “non-EU” labels, and that the respective EU Member States have committed to report on the impact of these schemes on the internal market.
However, these national COOL requirements may already restrict the free movement of goods, if they discriminate against businesses based in another EU Member State and thereby possibly violate Article 34 TFEU. Quantitative restrictions on imports and all measures having equivalent effect are prohibited between EU Member States. This essentially means that all trading rules that are enacted by Member States, which could hinder trade directly or indirectly, actually or potentially, fall under Article 34 and are thereby prohibited.Footnote 26 Most importantly and troublesome, the national COOL measures appear to encourage local sourcing without regard to the detrimental impact that it may have on established supply chains, which transcend national, and sometimes even EU, borders. Although the national COOL requirements do not apply to products lawfully produced or marketed in another EU Member State (ie the mutual recognition), they may still have a detrimental effect on the internal market. For example, a Belgian cheese made with Belgian milk does not need to state ‘Origin: Belgium’ when marketed in France. However, it can be easily identified as a foreign product because it does not state ‘Origin: France’ or it might not even reach the French retail stage at all because retailers no longer buy it, leading to de facto discrimination (in form of a potential de facto “boycott” by retailers in France). It must be borne in mind that, in certain cases developed by the Court of Justice of the EU, EU Member States have to respond to trade barriers resulting from actions by private individuals, for example in cases of commercial boycotts.Footnote 27 Considering those consequences for products originating from other EU Member States, the mutual recognition clause does not appear to provide similar market access.Footnote 28 Another example is the decline of liquid milk imports by France since French processors, due to pressure from retailers, appear to prefer milk of French origin in order to be able to indicate that origin on the product label according to the COOL scheme. With respect to the recent COOL trend, a spokesperson for the trade association FoodDrinkEurope reportedly said that the Commission should fight such measures because they were “slowly but surely annihilating the single market”.Footnote 29 Another effect of mandatory origin labelling on all operators that are subject to the COOL requirements is the added cost for processors, which will have consequences at all levels of the dairy supply chain, from farmers to consumers.
At the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council on 17–18 July 2017, the Belgian delegation argued that these national COOL measures are already shown to have an impact on the internal market. As an example to show the effects of these measures, Belgium highlighted the development of the trade flows from Belgium to France during the last year: the French COOL scheme was announced for the first time in the summer of 2016 and, as many contracts in the retail sector are fixed-term contracts, some were abandoned or not renewed in order to prepare for the national rules establishing COOL.Footnote 30 According to Belgium, it appears that some major multinational retail companies, with big acquisition power, had increased the pressure on the other partners of the food supply chain to adapt for these national rules. Dairy companies producing fresh milk particularly felt an immediate impact. The monitoring of the meat and dairy product volumes exported to France, which were closely checked by the sector, and the figures of the Belgian National Bank also showed decreasing exports. Belgium states that the first “hint of trouble” came with the announcement of the sector in the spring of 2016 that there was a decline of 17% for milk compared to the same period in 2015. A further decline was attributed to the actual start of the measure at the end of 2016 and appears to be continuing. According to Belgium, these sectoral figures show that the internal market is under pressure because of the French COOL Decree. By comparison, the export of dairy from Belgium to other EU markets without COOL schemes in force (eg Germany, the Netherlands) remained stable over the same period.
Therefore, Belgium urged the Commission to take action, requesting an intermediate impact evaluation of the effects of the different national measures on the internal market after one year, as of the implementation of the first national decree. The Commission invited other EU Member States to also gather market figures on the evolution of the different trade flows.
It is important to note that not all trade diversions will be visible in the statistics. For instance, it is likely that, because of its COOL scheme, France now imports less consumer butter (ie retail butter for direct consumption). However, because France structurally requires more butter than it produces, it will have to continue importing. The possible decrease in consumer butter imports would then have to be compensated by an increase in the imports of butter for bakery and other food industry applications, where the origin considerations might play less of a role. The French Customs import figures of milk and cream so far in 2017 (January–May) show a clear decrease of the imports from Belgium and Germany in comparison with the two previous years.
In the debate at the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council on 17–18 July 2017, some ministers warned against mandatory origin labelling which would, in their opinion, not only be costly and burdensome, but also detrimental to the internal market and the free movement of goods. Several ministers supported the Belgian request to conduct an impact assessment on the national COOL schemes for food. Other delegations put emphasis on transparency, the right of the consumer to be correctly informed, and the growing societal demand to know the origin of food, in order to support the idea of an EU-wide mandatory labelling of origin.
If, after the conclusion of the test phases and the different impact assessments, the Commission decided to act on national COOL schemes, it might decide to send a reasoned opinion to the respective EU Member States, urging them to remove the discriminatory practices affecting the marketing of dairy products. The Commission may consider that the national requirements do, in fact, restrict the free movement of goods, as they appear to discriminate against businesses based in other EU Member States. The respective countries may then have two months to notify the Commission of measures taken to remedy the situation. Otherwise, the Commission may decide to refer the case to the Court of Justice of the EU for infringement proceedings. Indeed, not too long ago, in February 2017, the Commission initiated infringement proceedings against Romania and Hungary over laws promoting domestic food over imports.Footnote 31 While the respective Hungarian and Romanian laws were arguably more protectionist in nature (requiring, eg, a certain percentage of products to be sourced by retailers from short, ie regional or national, supply chains), they demonstrate the Commission’s overall willingness to act on behalf of a functioning internal market.
Challenging eventual sanctions imposed by national authorities for non-compliance with the new national COOL schemes might be another way to address them. However, as noted above, operators legally marketing their products in other EU Member States, do not need to comply with the French COOL requirements when placing them on the French market. The “sanction” may indeed be that the products do not reach the French retail market because of not being “local” and attractive and, therefore, being avoided by French retailers.
The next EU Member State likely to adopt a national COOL scheme for milk and dairy products appears to be Spain, where a measure is poised to be adopted shortly. The issue of a national COOL scheme was even raised in the parliamentary election campaign in Germany,Footnote 32 although an actual change in the long-standing position of Germany to now favour COOL would be surprising. In Italy, the COOL trend, however, does not appear to have come to a halt, as the recent measures for durum wheat in durum wheat flour pasta and for rice and the announcement concerning COOL for tomato products show. Despite the existing EU COOL for honey, Romania recently proposed a law introducing the “obligation for producers, processors and traders to display on the label the country of origin for honey and the country of origin or place of provenance for apiculture products”. The same law also imposed “a ban on mixing honey and apiculture products from other countries with Romanian apiculture products”.Footnote 33
IV Conclusion
The increased (regulatory) activity in EU Member States on COOL and the debate within the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council indicate that these developments are continuing to gain momentum. Considering the implications laid out above, they should be monitored and stakeholders should be prepared to participate in shaping potentially harmonised EU legislation by interacting with relevant EU institutions, trade associations and affected stakeholders. It is clear that an internal market disciplined by multiple different COOL schemes is hardly business-friendly and arguably also non conducive to consumers’ clarity and not ideal for fostering greater EU economic integration. Whatever the case, these schemes would have to be consistent with EU law and WTO obligations,Footnote 34 so as to avoid potentially costly and destabilising litigation, as well as commercial and legal uncertainty for economic operators.
Considering only the already apparent consequences in France and the growing number of COOL measures, it appears increasingly necessary that the Commission address this issue that is significantly affecting the internal market.
