Speaking out in Vietnam examines the landscape of protests and state responses in Vietnam spanning the period 1995–2015. Benedict Kerkvliet's overall premise is that Vietnam's political system cannot be considered as purely authoritarian. Instead, he shows that public criticism and dissent are met with a range of responses including toleration, concession, intimidation and repression, which leads him to describe Vietnam's political system as a ‘repressive-responsive party-state’. In other words, he recognises that both the forms of public criticism as well as the ways in which the state responds deserve nuanced analysis. Here, he closely examines four oppositional themes: labour protests demanding better wages, rural resistance against land appropriation and corruption, nationalist demonstrations criticising China–Vietnam relations and pro-democracy activism.
Kerkvliet's findings make an important empirical contribution to the fields of Southeast Asian studies and social movement studies because this is the first book that details the varied forms of public protest and state reactions in Vietnam, and it supports what social movement scholar Charles Tilly formulated in 1978. Tilly argued that a state's response to collective action ‘always consists of some combination of repression, toleration, and facilitation’, that is, state responses depend on political structures as well as the forms of collective actions used (From mobilisation to revolution, 1978, pp. 106–7). Kerkvliet's work confirms this hypothesis and provides evidence from the perspective of Vietnam.
Kerkvliet also provides explanations for why the Vietnamese state reacts with tolerance and facilitation in certain areas such as labour struggles, and why some democracy activists are subject to police harassment ‘only’, while others are sentenced to years of imprisonment (chapter 5). According to him, the dominant factors that lead to less repressive state reactions are: the actors’ (former or current) ties to the Communist Party of Vietnam, whether a non-confrontational approach is used (p. 129), and the existence of domestic and international pressures such as international trade agreements that could lead the party-state to make concessions.
Despite the book's impressive empirical data (hundreds of online newsletters and newspapers, video clips, recordings, blogs, social media and secondary interview material), with which Kerkvliet is certainly able to explain some individual cases of state reactions towards different forms of dissent, it leaves one question open: How can the state–protest nexus be explained at a structural level?
Given that there are already several reviews for Kerkvliet's book, I will take the liberty here to focus on some of its theoretical shortcomings and their implications. In so doing, the following sections draw on the findings of Jörg Wischermann, Thi Viet Phuong Dang and George Martin Sirait's latest research project, which tackles the question of ‘when, how and why’ the Vietnamese and Indonesian states respond with repression, toleration, facilitation, or coercion (‘The state in a capitalist society: Protests and state reactions in Vietnam and Indonesia’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, April 2022). Wischermann et al. found that, despite the two country's different regimes, both show significant similarities in their responses to protests. According to the authors, this can be explained in theoretical terms by bringing capital accumulation and its underlying power dynamics into the centre of analysis.
However, in line with many other studies on Vietnam, Kerkvliet focuses on the analysis of ‘state–society relations’, which implies that the state and its hybrid regime type is considered the dominating driving force behind societal developments. Although this is certainly a common and important level of analysis, it de-emphasises the macro level, that is, the global economic constraints and political opportunity structures to which both parties—citizens and state agents—are subjected. Kerkvliet exemplifies one of these structural constraints by stating: ‘Strikes cost employers more than making concessions’ and ‘strikers give up because they are desperate for income’ (pp. 26–7). This observation indicates that both the workers as well as the employers are prone to manoeuvre and strategise according to the rules of a capitalist economy. Thus, an explanatory framework that raises questions of how state actors calculate their costs and trade-offs while balancing the conflicting forces of capitalism and political legitimacy deserves more attention. Accordingly, a macro-level analysis would focus on Vietnam's increasingly free-market economy, one that is characterised by a fairly corrupt political elite with strong ties to private conglomerates. This shift towards a critical analysis of Vietnam's complicity in global capitalism and its underlying power dynamics would bring us closer to generalisable explanations on the relation between protests and state reactions.
Moreover, Kerkvliet's account of Vietnam's ‘state–society relations’ shows weaknesses in the micro-level analysis, which would investigate how emotional, ideological, and socio-psychological factors play into the choice of violent or non-violent forms of resistance or harsh repression informed by the state actors’ felt sense of fear or threat. Kerkvliet mentions several times that the force of ideologies in Vietnam (communism and nationalism) has weakened over the past decades. Needless to say, this does not mean that political ideas and ideologies have stopped influencing mindsets. On the contrary, my own research found that ideological drivers pertaining to idealised concepts of Western democracy, free-market economies, and the rule of law, but also anti-communism, Catholicism and anti-China nationalism are, in fact, exercising a strong influence on protesters’ and state agents’ practices (Pham Thi 2021, ‘Activism in Vietnam: Political practice and cognitive resistance’, PhD diss., University of Manchester). Again, future research will benefit from a closer examination of how those micro dynamics (socio-psychological factors such as emotions and ideologies) motivate different forms of public criticism and state responses.
Overall, Kerkvliet's aim was to provide a detailed picture of the landscape of public dissent in Vietnam. He has achieved his aim in a scope that could not have been better executed by anyone else.
