No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
According to the early Sufi

Ali ibn Ahmad Bushanji, as quoted by the towering scholar of Sufism William Chittick, “Today … Sufism is a name without a reality, but it used to be a reality without a name” (p. 1). Chittick begins and ends Sufism: A Short Introduction with Bushanji's saying, attempting to evoke something of this “reality” of Sufism throughout the work. Chittick faults much of previous academic scholarship on Sufism in the West for ignoring Sufism's reality by being overly preoccupied with its “name”: its origins, schools, luminaries, histories, and definitions. He likewise faults modern devotional works on Sufism for their promotion of a single contemporary branch of the movement as representing Sufism's essence. Chittick thus strives to bridge the gap between purely academic and purely devotional approaches to Sufism by translating extensively from pre-modern Arabic and Persian primary sources, largely letting the early texts “speak for themselves.” He arranges these translations, along with his accompanying introductions and commentaries, into ten thematic chapters.
Each of the ten central chapters of Sufism: A Short Introduction can stand alone as an independent essay, a point underscored by the fact that each is a revised and rewritten version of Chittick's earlier work (p. viii, fn. 1). Chapter 1, “The Sufi Path,” lays the basic groundwork for the rest of the book, explaining the fundamental connection between Sufism and shari

a-based Islam. It contains a nice section on God's mercy and wrath, employing the yin-and-yang symbol to explore subtleties in this dichotomy. The chapter also introduces the recurring idea that all things have two faces: eastern and western. Chapter 2, “The Sufi Tradition,” begins with the crucial point that in essence Sufism has nothing to do with the Sunni–Shi

i split, with the various theological schools, with the different schools of law, or with particular geographies, a point that readers new to Islamic studies sometimes have difficulty grasping. The chapter introduces the distinction between sober and intoxicated approaches to Sufism, and it ends with a somewhat selective but nevertheless useful survey of Sufism in the modern world. Chapter 3, “Name and Reality,” explores the reality of Sufism through a discussion of key dichotomies and paradoxes, through the concept of love (introducing ḥadīth al-nawāfil), and through a discourse on divine names. Strangely, there are no footnotes in this chapter, but the reason perhaps lies in Chittick's privileging of oral teachings. Significantly, he asserts that “the literary output [of Sufis] represents only the name of a much deeper and broader reality that by nature cannot be known from the outside” (p. 33). Chapter 4, “Self-Help,” offers a nuanced presentation of the concept of the nafs and the importance of prophetic guidance to self-purification. Chapter 5, “The Remembrance of God,” presents one of the best discussions of the meaning and practice of dhikr that I have seen in an introductory work. Chapter 6, “The Way of Love,” focuses on the teachings of two of the most famous Sufis, Rumi and Ibn

Arabi. Chittick's translations of ghazals from Rumi's Kulliyyat are lyrical and lovely, and he lets the poetry speak for itself with few explanatory notes. Chapter 7, “The Never-Ending Dance,” again emphasizes Rumi and Ibn

Arabi in its elucidation of samā

and the stages of the soul's growth and return to God. Chapter 8, “Images of Beatitude,” draws on selections from Baha Walad's Ma

arif to examine the idea of the vision of God. Chapter 9, “The Fall of Adam,” offers the interpretation of that event by Ahmad Sam

ani in Rawh al-arwah, illustrating how Adam serves as a paradigm for humanity. In the final chapter, “The Paradise of the Veil,” Chittick explores the notion of the veiling and unveiling of reality as described by diverse Sufi authors. In line with his didactic purpose of introducing the reader to a Sufi perspective, Chittick concludes his text with a paradoxical twist on Bushanji's insight: “[P]eople will always remain ignorant of the reality, and they will always know only the name. Yet, the veil is the same as the face, and the name is identical with the reality” (p. 153). This ultimate turn toward paradox demonstrates how the work attempts to offer a broad-based insider's perspective while simultaneously nodding to the conventions of contemporary Western scholarship.
Chittick's essentializing approach to Sufism walks a fine line between devotional and academic discourse. He speaks at times for “what Sufis believe,” as if that univocal articulation could be isolated from the background noise of particular historical contexts. He defends “authentic” Sufism from its critics, alleging that true Sufis understand Sufism to presume an uncompromising adherence to Qur

an, sunna, and shari

a, implicitly disparaging those Sufis who have a different understanding of their tradition. That is, he identifies the self-understanding of some early Sufi theoreticians, who portray Sufism as the living spirit of “authentic” shari

a-based Islam, with the essence of Sufism's reality. Readers unfamiliar with the history of Sufism may not be aware that this position is a polemical one, challenged by some Sufis and non–Sufis alike.
This issue raises the question of how successful Chittick's Sufism: A Short Introduction can be considered as an introductory text. Despite a few difficult passages, the work is more accessible than Annemarie Schimmel's classic Mystical Dimensions of Islam (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1975). Furthermore, Chittick's work complements Carl Ernst's outstanding Shambhala Guide to Sufism (Boston, 1997), differing from the latter in the way that it downplays historical development and specific context in favor of emphasizing timeless Sufi ideas and practices. Chittick's ten chapters succeed in concisely introducing a wealth of central Sufi ideas. This formidable and valuable work will therefore serve as a useful text in an undergraduate course on Sufism, especially when supplemented with primary and secondary texts that offer a more historical and contextual approach to the subject.