In Post-Westerns: Cinema, Region, West, Neil Campbell offers an engaging and timely analysis of post-World War II transformations in Hollywood film and independent cinema. The book serves as the last volume in his well-received trilogy that began with The Cultures of the American New West (2000) and was followed by The Rhizomatic West: Representing the American West in a Transnational, Global, Media Age (2008). With this final installment, Campbell extends discussions in his previous work regarding critical regionalism, transnational studies, and the American West as a non-exceptional globalized space. In doing so, he joins a leading group of non-US critics whose distance, perhaps, from the national mythology has enabled them to expand studies of the western in striking and notable ways. The list includes Jenni Calder, Kim Newman, Christopher Frayling, Edward Buscombe, Christine Bold, Victoria Lamont, Jack Halberstam, John Saunders, Andrew Patrick Nelson, and many others whose work in postcolonial criticism, queer theory, feminism and gender studies, race and ethnicity, as well as the New American Studies, has enabled more complicated and nuanced understandings of the western.
In this well-argued study, Campbell notes an important rupture in the genre that marks the appearance of what he calls the “post-Western,” a type of cinema often centered on silences and disavowals in US history. Refusing to “dwell in the nineteenth-century moment of the classic Western” in order to explore more “divergent histories … across unexpected, uncanny landscapes,” these films operate as “ghost stories” that unsettle the dominant national imaginary (2). Campbell's careful attention to the spectral hauntings shaping the form is a response to the larger history of commentary about the genre. Almost from its very beginnings, the western has been described as a dying cultural narrative that cannot withstand the social, geographical, and historical changes brought by hyper-modernization. As he demonstrates, the western in fact has not retreated or died off, but remains very much alive, often taking on new life outside the traditional frames associated with the genre. While death is a concern of the post-western, it operates as more than just another postmortem pronouncement, becoming instead part of the larger critical apparatus shaping the ghost narratives addressed here. Post-westerns are “troubled and troubling texts” that feature “awkward meanderings into a layered, scarred region” (15). These texts “mobilize a more varied vision of the West” (11), redirecting their stories “across generic boundaries, poaching and borrowing from many different earlier traditions, while contributing to the innovation of the genre” (20). Thus “the post- in post-Western has a self-conscious reference to and echo of the word posthumous,” as something “that continues to live on beyond its apparent death or exhaustion” (37, original emphasis).
Campbell's analysis offers a detailed genealogy of “post-western” as a concept used in a number of academic fields. Just as the term has developed in a fluid manner throughout cross-disciplinary spaces, so the cinema he studies arises out of thoroughly globalized and transnational efforts. Many directors associated with the post-western are British or European filmmakers, and often their work has been influenced as much by the French New Wave, Italian spaghetti westerns, New German Cinema, or even the narcocorridos of the US–Mexico borderlands as by the traditional western itself. As Campbell notes, Wim Wenders continues to be haunted by the West because it offers a “powerful condensation of affect” that allows “complex human narratives to unfold” in a space of “immense beauty and mythic intensity” (242). The filmmaker argues that for Karl May or the “young boy in Japan” who likewise never visited the region, the larger tradition enabled by these spaces is so powerful and appealing that it ultimately “belongs to everybody” (242). In Campbell's study, post-western filmmakers are indeed a varied group of directors that includes Nicholas Ray, John Sturges, John Huston, Dennis Hopper, Kent MacKenzie, John Sayles, Wim Wenders, Donna Deitch, Allison Anders, David Jacobson, and the Coen brothers.
In opening up key issues about the form, Campbell often centers on films that may be new to readers, because they either were developed by independent filmmakers, were made by directors not typically associated with the genre, or are lesser-known works by directors whose other westerns may overshadow these texts. Because the western is a mutable form that can accommodate tremendous change, one wonders if at some point these post-western films will end up carrying such power that their critiques become incorporated into the genre itself. The “Indian sympathy film,” influenced by the civil rights and antiwar movements, introduced elements that have now been thoroughly absorbed into the genre. As a result, the term is no longer used to describe westerns that offer a particular take on race, power, and nation. Time will tell if the post-westerns examined here will become central and paradigmatic to the tradition itself, their critiques successfully transforming the genre in ways that fully alter the types of story we will eventually come to associate with the western.
