Those interested in Ezekiel – indisputably the strangest and most enigmatic of prophets – have benefited in recent years from the publication of several worthy commentaries, including Odell (Smith and Helwys, 2006), and most recently Tuell (Hendrickson, 2009) and Jenson (Brazos, 2009). Paul Joyce's 2007 contribution to this group is a most welcome addition.
Joyce is traditional in his methods, using textual, historical and literary criticism to tease out the theology of the book, but leaving ‘constructive appropriation’ to the reader. After dealing with initial questions of unity, authorship and redaction, Joyce continues the introduction with helpful summaries of the major theological themes in the book. Those looking for an up-to-date orientation to the book as a whole will benefit greatly from this section.
In general, one finds Joyce's perspectives and insights throughout the commentary to be solid, but not ground-breaking. Nonetheless, of the recent commentaries mentioned above, Joyce's commentary offers the most balanced, judicious perspective in the traditional commentary genre (as opposed, for example, to Jenson's distinctively Christian interpretation). The single greatest contribution that this commentary offers is bibliographic: Joyce provides a plethora of references to the abundant secondary literature – a treasure to anyone engaged in the research and interpretation of Ezekiel.
The commentary is arranged according to the chapter divisions in Ezekiel, which is sometimes frustrating as the chapter divisions do not always correspond to discernibly meaningful units. And while substantive in terms of content, the commentary feels short (no doubt a result of publishing constraints); because many of Joyce's reflections on the text are thoughtful, they leave one wanting to hear more.
A more expansive interpretation of the larger sense units would have been especially welcome. Apart from the introductory chapters that are helpfully synthetic, it sometimes seems that attention to individual verses comes at a cost to attention to the meaning of the larger whole. Yet at the same time some verses cry out for additional comment, such as Ezekiel 20:25, the infamous claim that God gave Israel laws that were not good, and by which they could not live. Joyce rightly notes that this bizarre statement, contrasted as it is with the previous affirmations that God gave life-giving laws, is a ‘shocking paradox’, and he notes the similarity to the theological cruxes of the hardening of Pharaoh's heart in Exodus and Isaiah's call to make the mind of the people dull. A discussion of child sacrifice, alluded to in the following verse, follows with Joyce concluding, following Patton, that God gives the evil law in order to guarantee the ultimate destruction of the people. Even without engaging in any constructive theological ‘appropriation’, one might hope here for some further reflection on how such a ghastly idea functions in Ezekiel's overall theology; after all, Ezekiel also asserts that God ‘takes no pleasure in the death of anyone’ (18:31).
Joyce's vast knowledge of Ezekiel studies, reflected throughout the commentary, is not to be taken for granted – this is the most useful traditional commentary currently available. For teaching, I find the commentary particularly useful when paired with Jenson's self-consciously theological interpretation.
