The cathedrals of the English-speaking world will be in celebratory mourning on Saturday, the centenary of the birth of the man who was effectively their house composer. Herbert Howells has probably touched more lives more deeply than any composer with twice his standing in the hierarchies of modern music.Footnote 1
Writing on the hundredth anniversary of Howells's birth in 1892 and barely a decade after his death in 1983, the critic Michael White identified an issue familiar in twentieth-century music (and to a lesser extent in the other arts), and one which has been particularly acute for British music of this period. While much of the most conspicuously innovative and mould-breaking art music of the first half of the twentieth century, and almost all of that produced by the post-1945 avant-garde, has struggled to find an audience beyond an elite circle of connoisseurs, plenty of other music written during this time by composers such as Rachmaninov, Sibelius and Vaughan Williams, to name just a few, has long been admired and indeed loved by large numbers of performers and listeners. Yet until relatively recently it was the music of high modernism that received all the prestige, dominating classroom textbooks and academic journals to the almost entire exclusion of music deemed largely irrelevant to a narrative of technical and aesthetic revolution. We continue to struggle mightily with modernism in all the arts – not only with the creations of those who claimed to be modernists, or on whose behalf others have made such claims, but also with the very concept itself and its history. It is obvious that radical and rapid scientific and technological development around the turn of the twentieth century generated profound upheavals in concepts of space, time, perception, consciousness and the nature of humanity itself (although some of these developments may arguably be traced much earlier, for instance to the advent of railway travel or telegraph communication in the mid-nineteenth century or of new kinds of urban experience in the eighteenth-century metropolis). But did such upheavals demand from all creative artists the kind of root-and-branch rethinking of the fundamentals of their art forms that we find in a Joyce, a Picasso or a Schoenberg, or at least that contemporaries of such pioneers fall into step so that their work would be deemed authentically modern, and would be valued and taken seriously as such? Was to do otherwise to be merely conservative or, worse, reactionary, cut off from the inevitable tide of history and thus somehow largely irrelevant? Or can different levels and kinds of response to the conditions of modern life, in different places and situations, still be deemed credible and ‘modernist’ in their own ways, without the risk of diluting the term to the point of becoming almost meaningless?Footnote 2
To many readers, all this will no doubt seem a very old – and increasingly tired – story. This again? Yet aspects of the particular place of British music within the story may bear some brief review. Modernism and the historical narratives traditionally built around it have been under attack or at least revisionist interrogation for a long time now, and from multiple directions. Although initially the musical arena lagged behind, since the rise in the 1990s of postmodernist criticism, gender studies, popular-music scholarship and other related developments, musical modernism has taken quite a beating – so much so that there has been some significant pushback in the last decade.Footnote 3 As in other fields, some critics came to see modernism as fatally tainted by authoritarianism, racism and even misogyny, and such accusations, along with more historiographical objections to grand teleological narratives and notions of decisive historical rupture, have taken a heavy toll. Whether or not the pendulum has been swinging too far and too wildly, British twentieth-century music, particularly from the first half of the century, has undoubtedly benefited in many ways from these more sceptical attitudes, to the extent that it was almost entirely shut out of the high-modernism-or-nothing account of twentieth-century music that prevailed from the 1940s to the late 1980s. This dismissed virtually all composers before Britten and the nation's broader musical culture as hopelessly isolated, parochial and hostile to atonality, serialism and radical technical and stylistic innovation in general. In the academic domain, in particular, this discouraged new research in the field, particularly among young scholars: how were you going to get a job and a prestigious book contract with a dissertation on British music? But since the 1990s there has been an explosion of work in this area, which has both drawn strength from and contributed to the erosion of traditional hierarchies. Much of this research, on institutions such as the Proms and the BBC, has largely debunked glib assumptions about British ignorance of or indifference to cutting-edge developments elsewhere, even if not all these developments were warmly embraced (although, of course, such reticence was hardly restricted to Britain).Footnote 4 It has also emphasized the sheer extent and variety of compositional productivity in Britain during this period, particularly by previously neglected composers considered ‘minor’ in relation to the ‘major’ pre-Britten figures of Delius, Elgar, Holst, Vaughan Williams and Walton (major within British music – international ranking at this level has proved more elusive).Footnote 5 Perhaps reflecting the British fascination with underdogs and lost causes, many of these minor composers had for many years maintained small but devoted followings, with societies, newsletters and so on, some of which sponsored performances and LP recordings; but it was really the CD boom of the 1980s and 1990s, followed by the era of downloads and YouTube, that opened up vast swathes of hitherto lost music to a wide public.
Yet this latter development has exacerbated questions of categorization and hierarchy, and with them the issue of modernism, which – whatever our current attitudes towards it – was a topic hotly and publicly debated by composers, critics and others at the time the music in question was being composed. Among those who value British music of this period, there have been a variety of approaches to advocating for it. Early on in the recent wave of reassessment, it seemed as if it might be enough to show that, as with the broader musical culture, many British composers were in fact more receptive to Continental modernism than had previously been supposed, and that their music often revealed significant influence from such sources – perhaps this could secure at least affiliate membership of the high-modernist club, as it were. But running alongside this, and in time intensified by the broader questioning of modernism, have been attempts to expand the definition of the term to include developments common among British composers that might offer more abstract parallels to modernism elsewhere (for example, the new and relatively systematic use of diatonic modal materials), and even to argue for distinctively British varieties of modernism, including the kind of ‘conservative modernism’ that has gained traction of late in studies of English literature. More radically, J. P. E. Harper-Scott's 2012 book The Quilting Points of Musical Modernism, going well beyond his provocatively entitled Edward Elgar: Modernist, makes an imaginative engagement with such ‘conservative’ British music the basis for rediscovering in modernism, broadly conceived, a progressive social and political potential denied or obscured by its recent detractors.Footnote 6 Harper-Scott's main target is Richard Taruskin, who in his 2005 Oxford History of Western Music attempted thoroughly to dismantle a traditional understanding of high musical modernism, yet still saw fit to ignore all British twentieth-century music before Britten.Footnote 7 While Taruskin undoubtedly manifests an exceptionally opaque blind spot in this regard, the similar neglect of most British music in Alex Ross's The Rest Is Noise,Footnote 8 another revisionist survey of this territory by an American writer published in the mid-2000s, reinforced the reminder that old habits and prejudices die hard: even in the USA, an environment that has often been more hospitable to it than most, British music from the first half of the twentieth century still faces a struggle to sustain a solid footing outside its geographical borders. (When, for instance, will more non-British conductors decide that a new cycle of Vaughan Williams symphonies might be preferable to yet another set of Shostakovich or Mahler?) While expansions of the concept of modernism in British music have been questioned (vigorously at times), the debate has generated some of the most stimulating and thoughtful recent writing on musical modernism – a paradox at first sight, perhaps, given the historiographical background, yet a vivid illustration of how the belated inclusion of Britain in the narrative(s) of twentieth-century music has much to offer the field as a whole.
The recent books on Howells and Bridge under consideration here make important contributions to the re-evaluation of British twentieth-century music and to debates about its relationship to modernism (although in the latter case they exhibit some of the tensions and fault-lines within this broader discussion). Modernism looms large in both volumes (literally so in the Howells book, where it is capitalized throughout), but for almost diametrically opposite reasons. In Howells we have a composer routinely viewed, at least since the 1960s, as staunchly conservative, a minor pastoralist distant from any notion of modernism and known mostly for his contributions to church music, especially an Oxbridge and cathedral choral culture of candle-lit evensong, tainted for some (not necessarily fairly) with notions of an unbearably comfortable Anglican religiosity, insular and elitist.Footnote 9 In contrast, the revival of Bridge since the 1970s has depended heavily upon the idea that his later, ‘progressive’ music represented the only serious British attempt to engage with Continental modernism, especially the music of the Second Viennese School, during the 1920s and 1930s, and that this prepared him, as formative teacher of the young Britten, to save his protégé from the parochial amateurism of the ‘English Musical Renaissance’ as represented by Vaughan Williams and his circle. (This was essentially the way that Britten saw it, anyway.) Both books argue, in one way or another, that critical judgments of their subject's relationship to modernism have distorted and oversimplified their compositional achievements and contributed to their neglect. While many critics and musicologists turned up their noses at Howells from the 1960s onwards, some of his output, most notably the church music, remained popular with a wider musical public; Bridge, by contrast, has been more admired by composers and critics than by audiences at large. Earlier neglect has in the last 25 years or so been substantially set right in the record catalogue, with extensive surveys of both composers’ output now available, even if live performances are still infrequent, with the exception of Howells's liturgical music and his Hymnus Paradisi (Bridge remains a relative rarity). Though broad-blanket rankings are always suspect without extensive qualification, it would probably be fair to say that their current standing within British music is that of what one might call – inelegantly, it must said – major minor composers: while never likely to be ranked by most alongside Elgar, Vaughan Williams and others, they nevertheless appear of more lasting significance than the majority of their contemporaries among the serried ranks of British composers below the very top tier. Yet scholarly studies have for the most part been very slow in coming, even in Bridge's case. The fact that almost by their very existence the two books under review are so groundbreaking speaks volumes, as it were, about the past history of research into British twentieth-century music.
The essays in The Music of Herbert Howells, edited by Phillip A. Cooke and David Maw, address a number of such issues directly, and constitute a major advance towards a fuller and more balanced understanding of the composer. There has been little previous published work on Howells, with no book-length studies since Paul Spicer's 1998 biography and no substantial examination of the music since Christopher Palmer's short (fewer than 100 pages) account from 20 years before that;Footnote 10 even theses and dissertations have been few and far between. It is appropriate, then, that the music should be the primary focus here, despite some important biographical contributions. At over 300 pages, with some 140 music examples, the volume is substantial and for the most part handsomely produced by Boydell. The generous provision of music examples is important, because with the exception of Hymnus Paradisi and a few other works, scores are not easily come by in most libraries. The book also includes an annotated catalogue of Howells's oeuvre, including unfinished projects, adapted by Paul Andrews from his 1999 dissertation.Footnote 11 A foreword by John Rutter and an introduction by Maw are followed by 15 essays divided equally into five sections: Howells the Stylist, Howells the Vocal Composer, Howells the Instrumental Composer, Howells the Modern and Howells in Mourning. Although a few chapters offer broad accounts of Howells's approach to a particular genre or compositional domain, most are more narrowly focused, and there is no attempt at a comprehensive survey of the composer's music. Although some senior academic musicologists are included (including Jeremy Dibble and Byron Adams), the majority of the 13 contributors work primarily as organists, choral conductors, librarians and composers. Reflecting the low status once occupied by the study of post-Baroque British music in academia, early work on Elgar, Vaughan Williams and others was dominated by independent scholars, such as Michael Kennedy and Jerrold Northrop Moore; although the situation has changed for major composers, the personnel of this volume probably offers a representative picture of Howells's current constituencies and his only gradual acceptance within the academy. This certainly brings benefits, in terms of different facets of intimate knowledge and appreciation, but also at times a lack of methodological self-awareness and consistency. A number of contributions refer to recent developments in the field, such as disability studies in Cooke's essay on the composer's late style and hermeneutics in Jonathan Clinch's chapter on the unfinished Cello Concerto, but others could easily have been written several decades ago. This observation implies no across-the-board value judgments of current as opposed to older approaches, but it does respond to an unevenness in tone that goes beyond that almost inevitably encountered in all multi-author volumes.
Maw's ‘Introduction: Paradox of an Establishment Composer’ faces head-on the issues that have held back Howells's reputation. Primary among these is the composer's almost exclusive identification until recently with the ‘relatively peripheral’ spheres of church and organ music, as Maw puts it (p. 2); given that Howells's contributions in these domains constitute only about a third of his output, such a focus is almost bound to distort his achievement, and church and organ music largely take a back seat in this book. But, as Maw points out, church music is part of a larger cluster of associations, not so easily set aside, which generated an acute tension between the image of Howells as a pillar of the establishment (not only in church circles but also as a teacher at the Royal College of Music, a competition adjudicator and so on) and crucial aspects of his social background, psychological make-up and compositional persona. Most notable among these were his provincial and lower-class origins, a passionately sensual and sexual nature, and the ecstatic strain that characterizes so much of his music, even when allied with fastidious technique and formal control. A number of other related themes are introduced here and developed in the chapters that follow: Howells's claim to be a modernist composer, his literary sensibility, an intense spatial and spiritual sense of place (particularly landscapes), the tendency across his career to subject many major works to extended revision and reworking, and (because it became a driving force in his creativity in the second half of his career) the character of his grief and extended mourning for his son Michael, who in 1935, at the age of nine, died of polio in exceptionally harrowing circumstances.
The most substantial engagement with this last topic is Adams's impressive essay ‘Musical Cenotaph: Howells's Hymnus Paradisi and Sites of Mourning’, which brings the book to a close; it shares this final section with Graham Barber's chapter on the composer's elegiac use of the sarabande and Clinch's perceptive study linking the multiple phases of work on the unfinished Cello Concerto with different stages of Howells's grieving process. Adams's essay is characteristically sensitive and wide-ranging, invoking the psychological literature on parental bereavement and cultural analyses of the rituals of collective mourning in the aftermath of the First World War to offer fresh insights into Hymnus Paradisi and other works. But although the shattering death of his young son and his particular response to that loss almost inevitably tends to dominate any account of Howells's life and career, it is not allowed in this collection to obscure the other most striking feature of his career arc, which has distorted both his reputation in general and his relation to innovative developments in modern music in particular. This was the essential bifurcation of his compositional output and its reception. Early success and acclaim as a primarily instrumental composer, setting him up as a (for some, the) leading figure of the generation emerging after the First World War, largely fizzled out by the later 1920s. A number of these early works, particularly in the orchestral domain, clearly reflected the influence of Bartók, Ravel and Stravinsky. It must have been extremely painful for Howells to see this early fame ebbing away in his mid-thirties, and to see the younger Walton – who had deliberately modelled his early Piano Quartet on Howells's own work in this medium – overtake him in critical acclaim and become the heir apparent. Only some years after his son's death and Howells's subsequent immersion in sacred music during the 1940s (almost by accident, as a wartime replacement organist at King's College, Cambridge) did his star begin to rise again, though by that time in a very different environment, and with no hope of reclaiming the mantle of a cutting-edge figure that had been within his reach in the early 1920s. This peculiar shape to Howells's career was exacerbated by the fact that most of his orchestral music and much of his chamber output (he continued to produce keyboard music throughout this life) was written before 1925 and largely forgotten by the 1950s, when his late resurgence was dominated by choral music; a further complication was the composer's tendency easily to be discouraged by criticism, and to withdraw and rework pieces, sometimes over many years.
Clinch's essay ‘“Tunes All the Way”? Romantic Modernism and the Piano Concertos of Herbert Howells’ goes to the crux of this issue. Clinch examines in detail Howells's deliberate but ultimately unsuccessful attempts to navigate the slow acceptance of modernism in British music criticism and audiences in the early 1920s, specifically in relation to the large public forum of orchestral music and the key role that the reception of the Second Concerto played in his virtual abandonment of this arena. Between 1914 and 1925, Howells wrote more than a dozen or so orchestral works, some including vocal forces, and this period was framed by the premières of the two piano concertos, both of which were subsequently withdrawn by the composer and not performed again until after his death. (Lewis Foreman offers a compact survey of all the early orchestral works in his chapter.Footnote 12) The second was pulled at the proof stage of publication, after a turbulent first performance that elicited strongly negative critical reactions, despite the support of Vaughan Williams and others. Other composers have weathered such setbacks, of course, or even managed to turn them into a succès de scandale, but Howells was traumatized and largely retreated from the public glare of the orchestral domain. Before this débâcle Howells had shown a bold and ambitious approach to orchestral writing, in both formal scale and instrumental technique, confidently adapting to his own purposes some of the innovations of Ravel and Stravinsky, among others. Clinch argues thoughtfully that a concatenation of unfortunate performance and reception problems, including Howells's own attempt to downplay the modernist elements (for example, relatively harsh and sometimes percussive piano sonorities) in the concerto, deprived the musical world for 75 years of a work that successfully combined traditional and modern elements in a distinctively British fusion.Footnote 13
But the contributors’ identification of modernist traits in Howells's music is not limited to the works of the 1920s. The term is used frequently throughout the book, with varying degrees of specificity and persuasiveness. No single consistent definition is advanced, which is perhaps hardly surprising, given the variety of meanings typically associated with it. Adams locates it in the abstract formal intricacy that he uncovers in Hymnus Paradisi, for instance, composed in the late 1930s and 1940s, while for Cooke it is embodied in the introspection, austerity and general ‘difficulty’ that he finds in the church music of the 1960s. Yet Cooke links these traits to recent work by Joseph Straus and others on the phenomenon of ‘late’ style in general in the musical domain, which draws parallels between composers from very different historical periods, thus drawing attention to the difficulty of establishing a specifically twentieth-century frame of reference for such general attributes. One recurring theme across multiple contributors is that of formal and technical ingenuity, albeit of a kind generally abstracted and hidden well below the surface. Once again it is debatable how far this may be considered a specifically modernist trait – one thinks immediately of Mozart and Brahms, for instance (without muddying the waters by reaching back to the Baroque and Renaissance models that inspired Schoenberg, Webern and others). And the surface of most of Howells's music does remain relatively conservative, for want of a better word (we are in no danger of mistaking one of his church works of the 1960s for the music of Birtwistle or Maxwell Davies, for instance, or even late Stravinsky), and so the modernism argument, at least as it is generally understood in terms of style, can seem forced if sufficent qualifications are not entered. There is the implication at times, furthermore, that it is being deployed not just to place Howells more accurately in the context of his time, but to confer reflected prestige – in other words, to validate him through the old narratives of high modernism. While understandable given the historiographical background, this seems somewhat regressive in the current climate.
This is not to deny the value of identifying in Howells's music the compositional features in question, nor the richness and complexity to which they attest, not least because they have so often been neglected, along with his broader awareness of the music of contemporaries in Continental Europe. That Howells was interested in (and wrote perceptively and vividly about) the modern musical scene does come across clearly in a number of his writings quoted here, in which he stresses the diversity of musical modernism as he saw it, and the space it allowed for individual offshoots. Maw, in an excellent essay on Howells and the ‘phantasy’ genre (a staple of British music by the 1920s), stresses the composer's explicit interest in establishing himself as a ‘modern’. Howells seemed to equate this modernity, among other things, with experiments in form and with complexity of mood (concerns that were more important to him than cultivating an overtly English musical identity, for all his sense of landscape and place). New forms were needed to represent the complexities of his experience as a modern artist, and must allow for fragmentary, even hallucinatory states, which the one-movement phantasy scheme could at one level integrate. Maw's essay, and those by Clinch on the piano concertos and by Fabian Huss on the oboe and clarinet sonatas, offer the most nuanced, and therefore the most convincing, invocations of modernism in the book. Both Clinch and Huss also draw on recent work in literary criticism, Clinch invoking Alexandra Harris's formulation of a distinctively English ‘conservative modernism’ in the work of Virginia Woolf and others, Huss linking British trends of the period to Jed Esty's analysis of the interwar literary scene in the context of imperial decline.Footnote 14
Modernism is certainly not the only or necessarily dominant theme in the book: the under-appreciated range of Howells's work in general, for instance, and the psychological contradictions that it often embodies are eloquently explored. While a number of the book's themes, such as the importance for Howells of particular geographical locations and of his deep affinity for Tudor music, accrue significance by their frequent reappearance as subsidiary themes across multiple contributions, others are concentrated largely in a single chapter, as in Dibble's deft analysis of the musico-literary sensibility reflected in Howells's choice and treatment of song texts, and in Andrews's chapter,‘Lost, Remembered, Mislaid, Rewritten: A Documentary Study of In Gloucestershire’, which takes us deep into the composer's often convoluted revisions and reworkings, in this case of the third of his string quartets – so extensive here that Andrews plausibly concludes that the quartet should be known as two distinct works. Several chapters effectively bring broader issues of style into focus through the lens of specific works or technical features, as in Diane Nolan Cooke's chapter on the Six Pieces for Organ, or Spicer's consideration of Howells's use of the melisma, which (along with an original treatment of plain triads and of cadences) is such a distinctive feature of the composer's expressive ethos. For all the desire to diversify our appreciation of Howells's multifaceted oeuvre, the church music must be given its due, and the two contributions by Phillip Cooke do this handsomely, with the chapter on the late choral works complemented by a broader survey of Howells's contributions to English church music, ‘A “Wholly New Chapter” in Service Music: Collegium regale and the Gloucester Service’. The latter essay underlines the importance of Howells – building on vital but sporadic earlier contributions by Holst, Vaughan Williams and others – in revitalizing Anglican church music in the post-1945 era. Indeed, one might push the point rather further than Cooke does. Howells was central in acclimatizing choristers and congregations to some core elements of twentieth-century ‘advanced’ music (advanced in terms of the kind of service music familiar up to that point), and this was surely critical to creating the pluralistic environment that has evolved since the 1960s; this has been both attractive and open to a wide range of contemporary composers, not only in the annual commission of new carols for the Nine Lessons and Carols service at King's College, Cambridge, with its extraordinary global reach, but arguably also in the broader contributions to sacred music of Jonathan Harvey, James Macmillan, John Tavener and others. Indeed, however necessary and valuable the recent advocacy by performers and scholars for Howells's other music, it is likely that his church music, and in particular the example that it set, will remain his most enduring contributions to twentieth-century music as a whole – a paradox, perhaps, in view of the role played by Howells's ecclesiastical associations in excluding him for so long from the hallowed halls of modernism.
Like the Howells volume, Huss's book on Bridge represents a major landmark, and for similar reasons: this is the first full-length study to appear since Anthony Payne's, published originally in the mid-1980s and then in a revised version in the late 1990s, and Huss is the first to offer a sustained analytical engagement with the music.Footnote 15 While Huss makes clear that he is not attempting a comprehensive survey, he does provide a solid basis for understanding the composer's musical language as a whole, and in particular the continuity of certain issues, most notably a preoccupation with form. These career-spanning concerns, he argues, allow for the reconciliation of what may otherwise appear to be the conflicts in terms of style between the composer's early, ‘transitional’ and late works (conflicts that affect so many composers of this period, of course), and the contrasts between the earlier ‘salon’ pieces that largely made the composer's name in his day and the challenging later works on which his reputation as a modernist is based. Bridge, born in 1879, was closer to the generation of Holst and Vaughan Williams than to that of Howells. Huss divides the composer's career into six phases, devoting a substantial chapter to each: early works; first maturity (1906–12, beginning with String Quartet no. 1); transitional period (c.1913–c.1920); post-tonal later works (c.1921-c.1927, from the Piano Sonata to String Quartet no. 3); progressive later works (c.1927–c.1932); and works from the last years, up to the composer's death in 1941. The emphasis is on large-scale works because this was Bridge's own, certainly in the later periods; many of his small-scale pieces were aimed at the popular market, and unlike, say, the composers of the Second Viennese School or Stravinsky, he rarely used such works as a laboratory in which to experiment with advanced techniques that would later be developed on a larger canvas. In addition to the analytical chapters, Huss offers two brief biographical ‘interludes’ (not numbered as chapters), one exploring the crucial patronage that the composer received from Elizabeth Sprague Coolidge in the 1920s and 1930s, the other focusing on Bridge's relationship with Britten. The text is supported by copious music examples, which as in the Howells volume are crucial because of the relative scarcity of scores, even for the published works. The examples are for the most part well produced and presented.Footnote 16
Huss charts an illuminating course through Bridge's compositional preoccupations and the expressive world that they embody, characterized by complex interactions between a classically infused Romanticism (Brahmsian in origin, absorbed during his education at the RCM as yet another Stanford pupil), newer currents from French music (Fauré as much as Debussy) and, later, the expressionist dimensions of the Second Viennese School. Huss's main contention is that despite Bridge's much-vaunted engagement with Berg and Schoenberg, the underlying structures of his music remained fundamentally conservative and never developed a consistent synthesis of surface harmonic features and underlying tonal or otherwise centric structure. Huss's analytical methods are relatively ad hoc, and he does not for the most part articulate the theoretical assumptions on which they stand; set-theory terminology is used in relation to Bridge's later music, in order to deal with octatonic, whole-tone and extended tonal elements, but in the earlier works there is no reference to neo-Riemannian approaches, which have proved fruitful with a good deal of early twentieth-century music, or to extensions of Schenkerian methods that address similar repertory. There is certainly no ‘magic bullet’ for such music, and British composers of this period have proved unusually resistant to the consistent application of established analytical methods; it does seem surprising, however, to find so little acknowledgement of this theoretical background here. Similarly surprising, in view of the focus on Bridge's interest in large-scale form throughout his career, is the lack of any reference to the now well-established concepts and terminology of James Hepokoski and Warren Darcy, even though Elements of Sonata Theory is included in the bibliography (there are, in fact, only a handful of form charts of any kind).Footnote 17 While the author may not have found these concepts useful in relation to Bridge, given their broad application in the field one might have expected at least a brief explanation of their absence here. That said, the analyses are generally convincing in their own terms, particularly in demonstrating how complex contrasting pitch collections and thematic materials delineate and impart direction to Bridge's forms, finding the thread of which becomes increasingly challenging as the composer moves away from more traditional tonal materials. Huss's definition and deployment of stylistic terms such as ‘impressionist’ and ‘expressionist’ to characterize broader contrasts between different kinds of material is in general judiciously handled, although a degree of reification at times is almost inevitable, and his own discussion of the emergence of such concepts underlines how easily they could blur together at the level of musical technique.
Despite the analytical focus of the book, it by no means neglects the wider context of Bridge's compositional preoccupations within both British and Continental European musical culture of the time, as, for instance, in Huss's nuanced discussions of the gendered language surrounding modern music and of the complicated relationship of national trends and identities with modernism at the beginning of the chapter on the ‘progressive’ works. And although they are not his primary focus, Huss does engage from the outset with aspects of Bridge's reputation and reception. In the introduction he addresses directly the notion that the emphasis of writers before him on Bridge's later works was maintained ‘perhaps in order to establish suitable modernist credentials – and hence artistic status’ (p. 1) and as a corrective to the popularity during the composer's lifetime of the early, more obviously accessible music, including some unabashedly ‘salon’ pieces. It is, of course, the later works that served initially to revive Bridge's reputation in the 1970s, particularly the idea that he (almost alone among British composers of the 1920s) was responsive to developments in central Europe. Yet despite this sensitivity to the potential pitfalls in championing neglected (particularly ‘minor’) composers and to the complications created in Bridge's case by the assimilation of some early works, most notably The Sea (1910–11), into the popular pastoral (or at least nature-orientated) trope of the ‘English Musical Renaissance’, the well-trodden path of validation-by-Continental-modernism is simply too strong at times to resist. Having affirmed his intention early on to follow a different course, there are times when Huss does fall back into old patterns, particularly in his discussion of Bridge's later music. He accepts too readily, for instance, a simplistic characterization, advanced by some contemporary British critics in the mid-1930s, of Vaughan Williams's Fourth Symphony as a work of ‘healthy’ modernism untroubled by moral or other kinds of ambiguity, which he sets against Bridge's supposedly more complex, ‘continental’ vision during this period, with the strong implication that this comparison should now be viewed to Bridge's advantage.Footnote 18 Huss's success in freeing himself from this kind of binary equation, and from a one-dimensional view of mainstream interwar British music as a parochial backwater, is thus somewhat qualified.
The wider contextual discussions, including the two short but telling purely biographical sections, offer some valuable correctives to received wisdom. Although Coolidge's generous financial patronage and encouragement in the 1920s and 1930s afforded Bridge extraordinary freedom in terms of choosing which compositional projects to undertake and how long to spend on them, Bridge had in fact secured for himself a very comfortable lifestyle long before Coolidge entered the picture.Footnote 19 To be sure, this was dependent to a large extent on performance (primarily as a viol player but also as a violinist), conducting and instrumental teaching (Britten was his only significant composition pupil), and Coolidge greatly eased the pressures of such an existence, familiar to any freelance musician. Nevertheless, it does complicate the picture which has often been presented of Bridge, based partly on his own expressed frustrations, as the downtrodden victim of a conservative British musical establishment (and even in the compositional arena he was hardly ignored, for all that his later works met with widespread hostility). In the Britten chapter, Huss argues that the younger composer exaggerated in retrospect Bridge's very qualified pacifist leanings and their impact on his music in order to support his own more extreme position – a position, indeed, over which the two (and Bridge's wife) had bitter struggles, as the pupil came under the influence of Auden and his circle and began to grow away from his teacher. More broadly, Huss not only emphasizes the extent to which Bridge has lived in his pupil's shadow, but also questions, for all that Britten's devotion was crucial in keeping alive his teacher's legacy, how far the younger composer's rather slanted advocacy actually helped the move towards a balanced appreciation of Bridge's music.
Both of the books reviewed here clearly represent major contributions to the literature on twentieth-century British music. In conceptual and historiographical terms, neither will sharply alter the course of existing debates on musical modernism or its role in British twentieth-century music – that is not in any case their purpose. Yet they offer something which is probably more valuable at this point: wide-ranging and relatively comprehensive reassessments of two highly significant figures who until recently were woefully under-represented in the scholarly literature and whose reputations have been strongly shaped by overly simplified and value-laden notions of modernism. By extension, they offer fresh case studies of the ways in which British composers were able to engage distinctively with developments in early twentieth-century music that originated elsewhere for the most part, but which proved able to be brought into meaningful dialogue with recognizably native elements and attitudes or with more personally individualized constructions of identity. They add texture and detail to the emerging picture of a wide range of such dialogues and of the exceptional variety of imaginative responses that British composers gave to this turbulent environment; and they help consolidate the process of bringing the study of British music into the musicological mainstream – belatedly perhaps, yet still timely in its own modest way, as at a broader level Britain's profoundly conflicted relationship with Continental Europe (whatever that may now be taken to mean) heads deep into new and uncharted waters.
