Corn is so ubiquitous in the US food chain that Americans unexpectedly consume it in nearly every meal in the form of beef, chicken or pork, ‘since corn is what these animals are now fed’, or drink corn as high-fructose corn syrup usually found in soft drinks. As Elizabeth Fitting states in The Struggle for Maize, if we are indeed what we eat, ‘then North Americans are now people of corn’ (p. 46). Of this corn, 85 per cent is genetically modified to be pest-resistant or herbicide-tolerant. Given these stunning numbers, all of us should be having a conversation about genetically modified (GM) maize. That, I believe, is the subtle message in Fitting's book. The explicit point is the example she uses in the introduction to her book: in 2001 transgenes were found in Mexican corn varieties.
The 2001 case set off a series of national debates about the impact of genetically modified varietals and the threats they posed to native crops. Though GM corn is prohibited in Mexico, most corn imported from the United States was in fact genetically modified. In Mexico, where corn is historically, nationalistically and culturally synonymous with the Mexican nation, the fact that corn was, first, imported and, second, ‘tainted’ led to a series of scientific and cultural debates. If, the argument went, corn was fouled then Mexico's staple food, the tortilla, was also contaminated. Using these analogies a handful of NGOs were formed to combat the cultural and biological impact of GM corn.
Some organisations warned that the contamination of corn in its country of origin could have drastic consequences for the entire globe. One such organisation, En Defensa del Maíz (In Defence of Maize), with support from concerned scientists, attempted to publish results revealing that GM corn had been found in Oaxaca and Puebla. On the grounds of allegedly dubious research methods and, Fitting implies, under pressure from transnational companies, the veracity of domestic findings conducted by Mexican scientists was challenged. In a rare reversal, the editorial board of Nature withdrew its support from the peer-reviewed article in 2002 (p. 50), raising questions about who has the right to conduct research and what, in fact, constitutes scientific claims.
Curiously, the En Defensa del Maíz network also shifted the argument away from science, and instead made it about the cultural survival of Mexican campesinos' identity. Fitting shows that these ‘national’ debates over corn took on very local meanings depending, surprisingly, on what type of corn was produced and, not so surprisingly, on how well organised a community was around agricultural issues.
The book is divided into two parts. The first introduces the national GM debates and the political history of the Mexican countryside. The second section expands on the lives of the campesinos from the Valley of Tehuacán to illustrate that maize production has multiple and contrasting meanings at the most local level. Fitting uses the GM corn debate as the means to ask broader and more complex questions about ongoing change in the Mexican countryside. For example, Fitting is interested in exploring what happens to the Mexican men and women who work the land when the primary crop, corn, is now one of the nation's leading imports. This ‘neoliberal corn regime’ speaks to the dislocation of traditional farmers and their incorporation into practices that, she argues, ultimately end or severely alter a traditional farming way of life.
Focusing on the central Mexican community of San José de Miahuatlán, Fitting relied on interviews with campesinos to illustrate how corn production in one community is affected by often violent struggles over water rights, the building of a nearby jeans maquiladora, and even a younger generation's preference for an hourly wage (learned, most likely, during their time working the fields of the United States). While the GM corn debate might have pitted Mexican scientists, activists and politicians against transnational corporations, Fitting found it difficult to find anyone in the locality who was engaged with, or even aware of, the debates. This difficulty is in fact a key contribution, for it succinctly lays out how national debates are distilled, understood or wholly disregarded by the local people whom the debates supposedly represent.
Non-specialists will find chapter 2, with its short but well-informed historical overview of rural policy between the 1930s and 1990s, particularly helpful. In it, Fitting underscores how food subsidies became a staple political currency for the ruling party both in the countryside, by providing credit, and in urban spaces, by, for example, keeping tortilla prices low. Furthermore, Fitting traces the multiple cultural meanings that corn and its producers have faced in the official narrative: from ‘backward’ peasants to symbols of a hybrid nation. Finally, the chapter gives a short but provocative nod to the ‘agrarian question’ of the 1970s, in which scholars and politicians debated over the value of, and strategies for, modernising the countryside.
Fitting shows that the debaters, quite simply, got it wrong by focusing on the purity of maize as the centre of the national campaign against GM corn. This was not about maize production, but rather about the difficulties experienced by small landholders that preclude them cultivating maize. The book shows how campesinos have left their fields to find work in the United States, or in many cases have become maquiladora workers. It is, however, the older generation, too old to migrate, who continue to turn to corn as a safety net.
Fitting has written an insightful book that urges us to ponder the future of farming in and beyond Mexico. Its fresh take on getting to the background history of the food on our plates will be of use to those interested in food safety, food policy and food security, as well as to scholars of labour, peasant studies and the history of Mexico.
